Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N....
by TillE on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @03:56PM
(#11022498)
That's really not how copyright works at all. If the NFL owns the copyright, then distributing it in any way is a blatant violation. There are no relevant fair use exemptions.
Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N....
by wyldfire on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @04:43PM
(#11022915)
No, you're mistaken. Fair Use is for precisely this kind of purpose and protects those who share copyrighted content for educational purposes.
Refer to USC, Title 17, chap 1, § 107
[1] http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#107
Note that "educational purposes" are described, but not "cultural/historical relevance". Up for debate as to whether those intersect here.
If he uploaded a copy to youtube as part of a historical article or other non-commercial use, then the fair use analysis would likely go his way. Particularly for something of such cultural and historical relevance.
That said, trying to get money for it is certainly going to count against that analysis.