News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:48PM (#11015768)
Paid clicks up 31% overall, on Google’s own sites, up 40%. That's a bit concerning to me, especially when you consider:

a) That growth is outpacing internet traffic growth, and has for many years now. Internet traffic CAGR is 23%[1]

b) The shift from desktop to mobile should have the effect of reducing clicks.

c) Since some of the growth is video, I would expect a decrease in click growth related to this as well. Video adds to bandwidth growth pretty directly. Click growth would be less direct.

Sergey and Larry, at least at one time, might have expressed concern:

"The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users"[2]

[1] http://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/solutions/collateral/service-pr...

[2] http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by SerLava on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:17PM (#11016013)
>the shift from desktop to mobile should reduce clicks

We're not shifting from desktop to mobile. Mobile is increasing while desktop stays about the same.

We are shifting from print media, TV, excercise, talking, driving, academic studies and paid labor... To mobile.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by fixermark on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:21PM (#11016046)
Exactly. And possibly not even that---there are quite a few of those activities that can operate in conjunction with mobile. Exercise, talking, and TV for starters.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:20PM (#11016040)
Semantics. The context is that the growth is higher in the area that has a naturally lower CTR.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by Lewisham on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:54PM (#11015813)
...or Google is just getting better at serving the right advertisement at the right time?
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:07PM (#11015931)
They are getting better, every single year, over more than a decade, in a way that click growth outpaces traffic growth. Despite circumstances that would counter the effort. It seems unlikely it's just targeting, without spilling over into something that's bad for consumers.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by AnthonyMouse on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:44PM (#11016222)
> They are getting better, every single year, over more than a decade, in a way that click growth outpaces traffic growth.

That they're getting better at it is why click growth outpaces traffic growth. If they stayed the same at it then click growth would equal traffic growth.

> It seems unlikely it's just targeting, without spilling over into something that's bad for consumers.

It could be one or the other or both. Care to present any evidence or reasoning as to why we should make one conclusion or the other?

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:50PM (#11016272)
>> Care to present any evidence

They certainly do things today that they did not do 5 years ago. Like specific query results where everything above the fold on desktop is an ad.

I personally do not think that's good for consumers. I suspect, though, that you disagree.

On your other point, they are getting better every year as measured by a YoY comparison...not just plain growth. Double-digit percentage YoY improvement. That's hard to do.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by Phlarp on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:13PM (#11016425)
>Like specific query results where everything above the fold on desktop is an ad.

Do you have an non-anecdotal evidence to present? A few advertisement laden queries and a "funny feeling" is rarely a sound investment strategy.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by magicalist on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:22PM (#11016485)
It depends on how you defined "above the fold", but I have seen this on occasion. It's hard to replicate, though. For instance "credit card" is a search terms often overflowing with ads, but it's only giving a few to me right now.

Where GP is wrong is that this is something "they did not do 5 years ago". There were a ton of articles complaining about it in 2008/2009. Unless it is happening on many times more search terms than it was back then, it wouldn't explain the increased click rate at all. The fact that the increase was YoY makes it even more dubious.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:48PM (#11016948)
>>The fact that the increase was YoY makes it even more dubious.

YoY click growth percentage has been higher than traffic growth for years and years for Google. I suspect there are a number of reasons for it.

The 100% ads above the fold did get a lot of complaints in 2014, specifically because Google announced it would penalize sites that did that. Quite a few examples of Google doing this were subsequently pointed out, due to the irony.

You are correct in that I don't have an itemized, timestamped list of the things they've done over the years to either push organics down the fold, or expose ads further down the fold.

There are many things they've done that are pretty subtle as well.

- The wikipedia information in the sidebar when you do informational searches used to have links to wikipedia...leading you away from google. They now keep you within Google, and include links to ads: http://i.imgur.com/j3w9LbP.png

- Various widgets push organics down pretty far: http://i.imgur.com/VwYH7mY.png

- There are queries that became 100% above the folds ads within the last 1 or 2 years. Travel is especially aggressive: http://i.imgur.com/89iYCmc.png

- Other widgets that aren't ads per se, but serve to keep you on Google's site as you drill down to pages that will have ads: http://i.imgur.com/v1urMBm.png

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by magicalist on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:58PM (#11017225)
> There are many things they've done that are pretty subtle as well.

> The wikipedia information in the sidebar when you do informational searches used to have links to wikipedia...leading you away from google. They now keep you within Google, and include links to ads http://i.imgur.com/j3w9LbP.png

That still has a link to wikipedia

> Various widgets push organics down pretty far: http://i.imgur.com/VwYH7mY.png

That second box isn't an ad, it's just a called out search result.

> There are queries that became 100% above the folds ads within the last 1 or 2 years. Travel is especially aggressive: http://i.imgur.com/89iYCmc.png

As I said, this has been a thing for more than 5 or 6 years:

http://www.seobook.com/excuse-me-where-did-googles-organic-s... (from 2009)

> Other widgets that aren't ads per se, but serve to keep you on Google's site as you drill down to pages that will have ads: http://i.imgur.com/v1urMBm.png

They aren't ads per se...so would have at most a secondary effect on ad click through rates. It's also hard to argue that this (and the other) examples would be the cause of user harm as you argued above.

> YoY click growth percentage has been higher than traffic growth for years and years for Google.

You're missing my point because that's exactly it. Unless things have changed substantially in the last year, and every year before that, these things wouldn't explain the growth in click rates.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:30PM (#11017317)
>>That still has a link to wikipedia The sidebar wikipedia info used to have all links that went to wikipedia. The one I posted isn't the best example for hat, but it is the best example of one with a directly monetized link.

>>That second box isn't an ad, it's just a called out search result.

It also consumes vertical space, pushing the organics down. The relevance is also quite low, being a link to a discontinued product.

>>You're missing my point because that's exactly it.

Not missing your point. I'm not saying the few examples I gave are everything they've done. I think they've been doing things like, for several years, this to sustain the expected growth. Lacking a dividend, the pressure to sustain growth rates is pretty high.

Edit: It's also likely that for other purposes (testing/deployment/whatever), these things (and similar ones I haven't noticed) have dials for where/when/how often they are exposed, either by geography, search terms, demographic, or some other criteria. A bunch of dials would also allow you to smooth growth if you wanted.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @07:53PM (#11016969)
I didn't say anything about investment advice. My concern was from a consumer point of view.

You also put "funny feeling" in quotes, as if I'd said that.

In short, the repeated pattern of click growth outpacing traffic growth has me concerned that they are achieving that, in part, with strategies that are bad for the end user. Google says they care about such things. https://www.google.com/about/company/philosophy/

Non-anecdotal evidence is hard to collect, since Google doesn't release statistics like "organic click growth" or "real estate devoted to organic vs ads".

I can certainly post screenshots of queries that are 100% ads above the fold, but lacking the kind of information only Google has, they are, by definition, anecdotal.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by metaphorm on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:19PM (#11016032)
I think your concerns raise an interesting point but I would like to know what, specifically, is "something that's bad for consumers."

There might be something to dig into here. I'd like to learn more. Can you expand on your previous point?

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by dynofuz on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:42PM (#11016211)
Previously google used to organically list products in their "froogle" search. now all product listings are ads. Therefore it's not surfacing content from the entire web which almost always has products for cheaper prices.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by metaphorm on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:51PM (#11016279)
are there no organic listings at all? or is it just that there are now way more paid listings so the first page is entirely paid placements? thats a pretty big difference.

I recall that when froogle/google-shopping first launched they were just filling in content from search results because they didn't have very much direct engagement by vendors. maybe that's changed now so the search results were just scaled back because not necessary.

I dunno. I'm willing to accept non-nefarious explanations for this. That doesn't mean it isn't on the whole better for google and their paid advertisers. Whether or not that also means its worse for consumers is an open question.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by dangrossman on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:20PM (#11016467)
There are no organic listings at all. The only way into Shopping results is via AdWords' Product Listing Ads.

http://googlecommerce.blogspot.com/2012/05/building-better-s...

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by bduerst on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @01:41AM (#11017943)
It looks like it was because of stale product data in shopping

>We believe that having a commercial relationship with merchants will encourage them to keep their product information fresh and up to date. Higher quality data—whether it’s accurate prices, the latest offers or product availability—should mean better shopping results for users, which in turn should create higher quality traffic for merchants.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by dsharlet on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @01:48AM (#11017959)
This makes sense. I stopped using google shopping a long time ago precisely because it seemed like so many of the results were junk for whatever reason (staleness is a likely reason). "Junk" meaning the search result did not lead to an option to actually buy the product I was searching for. I haven't tried it since then, so I can't comment on if it's actually better now or if it's due to these changes.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by yulaow on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:53PM (#11015801)
for b) I would say the contrary. Have you tried entering in a common website from a mobile browser without an adblocker? You get like so many ads, SO MANY, one over the other, some full-screen some that just let you see the 10% of the real site, some with a pseudo-pop-up, all with those little "x" almost unclickable to close them that force you to click on the ad in the end.

And in the "free apps with ads" of the mobile store the situation is even worse... they'll often try all possible tricks to force you to click on the ads.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by nsxwolf on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:57PM (#11015839)
Can that really go on forever? I don't know anyone that deliberately clicks on ads. Ads usually act as a "don't buy" signal to me - I assume the product is of low quality or a scam because of the skeeziness of how they tried to reach me as a customer.

Like higher education, the online ads business seems poised to collapse.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by robryan on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:25PM (#11016080)
A large part of our business is built on product listing ads and Google shopping. Regular people have no problem clicking on ads, the ads actually usually provide a much clearer path to buying they product than organic results.

In a lot of verticals without ads you would be concentrating most of the sales in the biggest players as it has become very hard to compete in organic search for anyone else.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by kbenzle on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:09PM (#11015952)
Are you Russian, this is a common sentiment there :)
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by PeCaN on Monday February 01, 2016 @06:56PM (#11016670)
I think this is a common sentiment everywhere.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by kbenzle on Thursday February 04, 2016 @10:08AM (#11034350)
If that was true the US would have A LOT fewer ads.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by JoshTriplett on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:25PM (#11016074)
> Have you tried entering in a common website from a mobile browser without an adblocker?

Not in a long time; Firefox Mobile with Adblock Plus makes the web far more usable on a phone.

The constraints of a mobile device make adblocking even more critical than on desktop systems. If a browser or mobile environment wanted to differentiate itself, it could pre-install and pre-configure an adblocker.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by lunula on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:01PM (#11017003)
You could do it with a rooted phone and adfree android, which is like adblock plus but rewrites /etc/hosts to route all ad serving domains to localhost. This one simple trick convinces even ad supported apps that they are offline, and they cease to show ads.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by JoshTriplett on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:02PM (#11017014)
I just avoid installing any apps that have ads in the first place. The only time I see ads is with the one app I use that embeds a WebView and loads webpages, many of which have ads.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by seccess on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:25PM (#11016079)
I can't comment on Google's practices, but an honest ad network can generally detect accidental clicks and won't count them towards ad budget. This can be done by, eg, looking at how long a user remains on the click-through site before coming back.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by vgeek on Monday February 01, 2016 @10:38PM (#11017521)
a) Make organic results crappier, make paid ads look more like organic results. People may be more likely to click on paid ads.

b) You'd think this. From what I've seen, mobile ads have up to 4x higher CTR with a as much as a 30% lower CVR. This is from multiple high spend accounts I have managed. Fat finger misclicks? Mobile ad "cards" also look almost identical to the organic result cards.

Google used to roll major updates all of the time, now they come within 2 weeks of earnings releases, fairly consistently. Look for them to continue manipulate their black box (quality score) to help inflate CPCs, blend paid ads into organic (a la Baidu), reduce the number of organic results per page, increase the prominence of Shopping campaigns, remove advertiser control (no true exact match, or no exact match at all?) and generally try to squeeze SMBs by reducing organic visibility and subtly suggesting to try AdWords. Google's advertising business is at odds with providing the highest quality search results. They aren't really innovating in search, they're just turning dials to increase their earnings per mille for ads displayed.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by Jabbles on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:52PM (#11015790)
Why is any of that concerning? I'm not seeing the link.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by malchow on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:01PM (#11015875)
I think he is suggesting that it is possible to drive growth in paid clicks by misdirecting organic click intenders to paid clicks.

Of course, one imagines there are many other explanations for growth, too.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:05PM (#11015912)
Sergey/Larry explain it better than I would.

http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html

Scroll down to "Appendix A: Advertising and Mixed Motives"

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by Jabbles on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:19PM (#11016029)
What does that have to do with this news though?
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:29PM (#11016111)
The news is basically that Google released their earnings today. The click growth is part of that news.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by ghayes on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:52PM (#11015794)
> b) The shift from desktop to mobile should have the effect of reducing clicks.

Can you clarify this statement?

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:01PM (#11015874)
If you're an advertiser, you've already seen this. Mobile viewers click on ads less often than desktop viewers.

So, absent any other variables...if mobile traffic is growing faster than desktop traffic, year over year, click growth would slow.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by fixermark on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:09PM (#11015951)
Unfortunately, this is almost certainly a space where "absent any other variables" is too simplifying an assumption. Some confounding factors to consider:

* Is mobile growth rate so high that it outstrips the reduced expected CTR for desktop users?

* Is mobile use not displacing desktop use, meaning desktop CTR is not falling as fast as anticipated?

* Is mobile use growing in places where there was previously no desktop use? Those users previously had a functional CTR of 0; onboarding them should increase the total clicks even if it reduces the mean CTR.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by dragonwriter on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:44PM (#11016225)
> Mobile viewers click on ads less often than desktop viewers.

> So, absent any other variables...if mobile traffic is growing faster than desktop traffic, year over year, click growth would slow.

Sure, assuming that actual total traffic growth is constant; if desktop to mobile transition accelerates overall traffic growth, the increase in mobile traffic can be enough to even at a lower click/traffic rate increase total clicks.

Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by jonknee on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:11PM (#11015966)
Mobile traffic is also exploding, there is a lot more inventory to sell against.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by josephmx on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:05PM (#11015911)
Unless ad blockers are used on a massive scale?
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tootie on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:15PM (#11015999)
Do they even measure clicks anymore? Isn't view throughs the new metric?
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by SerLava on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:20PM (#11016044)
I referenced this higher up, but here it is: we aren't shifting from desktop to mobile, because desktop has leveled off. We're taking time out of literally all the other stuff we do in life, and shifting that to mobile.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by tyingq on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:31PM (#11016129)
Yes, I get that, but the word "shift" in this context isn't all that important. The "desktop/high CTR" leveling off while "mobile/low CTR" grows was the important bit. I'm not the first person to call that a shift.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by SerLava on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:44PM (#11017357)
I thought the premise was that there would be less value to extract, not just a tiny bit more effort per value.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by Gustomaximus on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:57PM (#11016320)
I would guess this is the ever increasing paid presence on the search screen. Take a look at a screenshot from 10 years ago. Today on a smaller screen you can't even see organic results. With some shopping and maps results you don't get much organic on a larger screen. I find it amazing this is not more discussed as losing value as organic search. As a marketer I see this often forces a company to often bid for their brand name searches as competitors will hog the screen if you don't. It will be interesting to see how it develops further but I can't see Google doing anything but owning search ongoing for the short to medium term.
Re:Alphabet Becomes the Most Valuable Public Company in the ... by dragonwriter on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:41PM (#11016208)
> The shift from desktop to mobile should have the effect of reducing clicks.

Why? The shift from desktop to mobile means people spend more of their time with the opportunity to give clicks.