> The wikipedia information in the sidebar when you do informational searches used to have links to wikipedia...leading you away from google. They now keep you within Google, and include links to ads http://i.imgur.com/j3w9LbP.png
That still has a link to wikipedia
> Various widgets push organics down pretty far: http://i.imgur.com/VwYH7mY.png
That second box isn't an ad, it's just a called out search result.
> There are queries that became 100% above the folds ads within the last 1 or 2 years. Travel is especially aggressive: http://i.imgur.com/89iYCmc.png
As I said, this has been a thing for more than 5 or 6 years:
http://www.seobook.com/excuse-me-where-did-googles-organic-s... (from 2009)
> Other widgets that aren't ads per se, but serve to keep you on Google's site as you drill down to pages that will have ads: http://i.imgur.com/v1urMBm.png
They aren't ads per se...so would have at most a secondary effect on ad click through rates. It's also hard to argue that this (and the other) examples would be the cause of user harm as you argued above.
> YoY click growth percentage has been higher than traffic growth for years and years for Google.
You're missing my point because that's exactly it. Unless things have changed substantially in the last year, and every year before that, these things wouldn't explain the growth in click rates.
>>That second box isn't an ad, it's just a called out search result.
It also consumes vertical space, pushing the organics down. The relevance is also quite low, being a link to a discontinued product.
>>You're missing my point because that's exactly it.
Not missing your point. I'm not saying the few examples I gave are everything they've done. I think they've been doing things like, for several years, this to sustain the expected growth. Lacking a dividend, the pressure to sustain growth rates is pretty high.
Edit: It's also likely that for other purposes (testing/deployment/whatever), these things (and similar ones I haven't noticed) have dials for where/when/how often they are exposed, either by geography, search terms, demographic, or some other criteria. A bunch of dials would also allow you to smooth growth if you wanted.
YoY click growth percentage has been higher than traffic growth for years and years for Google. I suspect there are a number of reasons for it.
The 100% ads above the fold did get a lot of complaints in 2014, specifically because Google announced it would penalize sites that did that. Quite a few examples of Google doing this were subsequently pointed out, due to the irony.
You are correct in that I don't have an itemized, timestamped list of the things they've done over the years to either push organics down the fold, or expose ads further down the fold.
There are many things they've done that are pretty subtle as well.
- The wikipedia information in the sidebar when you do informational searches used to have links to wikipedia...leading you away from google. They now keep you within Google, and include links to ads: http://i.imgur.com/j3w9LbP.png
- Various widgets push organics down pretty far: http://i.imgur.com/VwYH7mY.png
- There are queries that became 100% above the folds ads within the last 1 or 2 years. Travel is especially aggressive: http://i.imgur.com/89iYCmc.png
- Other widgets that aren't ads per se, but serve to keep you on Google's site as you drill down to pages that will have ads: http://i.imgur.com/v1urMBm.png