The "yoghurt" you can buy in supermarkets here is sugared milk with artificial thickeners, it's madness.
No, it hasn't, because you can still get other-than-nonfat yogurt, both full fat (sometimes labeled as 4% fat, which is certainly a response to the anti-fat movement) and low-fat (2%); I have yet to see even a poor-quality supermarket that doesn't have full-fat yogurts (though the most common offering and the one with the greatest variety of choices seems to be low-fat, but still not non-fat.)
As for yogurt I pretty much do not buy supermarket brands anymore. There's a European imported food store in town that sells some fresh items, among them Greek yogurt. The stuff is like paste, and it's fantastic.
Organic is basically irrelevant as far as I can tell. The type of the cow and how it's handled makes a huge difference, though.
Have you tried St. Benoît milk? It's available at a bunch of farmer's markets in the bay area, and most Whole Foods and well as a handful of other stores carry it. It's 4% milkfat (it's from actual Jersey cows!) and rivals any milk I've tasted abroad for flavor.
The point of "local" is "shippable from harvest to store in 24 hours" instead of "put into the food distribution chain for 2 weeks".
I don't know about 'much much better'...maybe just one 'much'.
As long as you stay out of Walmart and Costco. Trying to find full fat yogurt in those stores in Montana is a futile effort.
Edit: I'm in SF and routinely buy local, organic, blahblahblah. I've still had better dairy elsewhere.