The yacht has a captain and a crew they are responsible for managing the ship and unless Paul Allen was yelling at them threatening to fire them if they do not plow into the coral reef it's just an unfortunate event that the media likes to blow up because hey it's another rich guy with a yacht.
>> ... a legal doctrine which states that, in many circumstances, an employer is responsible for the actions of employees performed within the course of their employment.
Don't think that it really falls under this legal doctrine. I'm pretty sure he'll feel responsible non the less but doesn't it mean he's liable and it sure doesn't mean that it needs to be overblown in this manner. Cargo ships do much more damage to the environment on a daily basis. That said he most definitely owns the Yacht he owns several his biggest Yacht is often loaned to researchers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus_(yacht)
The cause for the incident is probably more interesting as if the damage was done while mooring it begs a question why is there a mooring spot so close to a coral reserve in the first place.
If the owner is not held, then the only people left are the employees. They don't earn enough to ever pay fines associated with this sort of accident. So it's either the owners or nobody.
I think you are over-representing the responsibility of the captain of a ship.
It's entirely reasonable to say that they did the job the best they could, but that circumstances were such that the ship still caused damage to the coral, through no fault of the ship's captain.
Lots of things that a captain can't take responsibility for - particularly when it doesn't involve the safety of the ship and it's passengers.
His operating costs on just the larger one are estimated at up 400k a WEEK. He spent 200m+ to build it.(1)
I admire his philanthropic efforts but buying goodwill like this is not a "carbon tax".
(1) http://www.businessinsider.com/crazy-facts-about-paul-allens...
Moving that thing's fat ass around probably uses a ton of fuel. I'm sure marine diesel spews out its share of co2, but more than a jet? I thought boats were super efficient relative to air travel.
I guess if your point is, rich guys screwing around shouldn't produce CO2, then, yeah, anything over 0 is bad. That seems unrealistic. any idea how to get a handle on how bad it is? how many cars worth of pollution it makes?
In no way does it negate his good work, and in no way does his good work negate his douchery. Trying to scientifically measure the impact of the yacht is a pointless distraction. I'm certainly not going to go around counting how many miles of gleefully fuel inefficient driving I do - which seems like a pre-requisite to judging other peoples environmental impact.
The only important question is: How do we make sure this never happens again, because it sure as hell wasn't intentional and lessons can be learned.
Last June he funded [1] a nearly $4 MM USD 5 yr project for researchers at the Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology at the University of Hawaii at Manoa (HIMB) [2] and the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS) to study assisted evolution to increase the resilience of coral species.
[1] http://www.vulcan.com/news/articles/2015/coral-reef-research...
[2] http://www.hawaii.edu/news/2015/08/04/ruth-gates-research-to...
(disclaimer: my wife works at HIMB)
edit: It looks as this comment is viewed by some as excusing the incident -- that's not the intent. I just wanted to point out that Mr. Allen was already helping to save reefs, not destroy them.