Teens: Don't have sex till later, you don't want babies yet.
Women in this country: Don't have sex till later, you don't want babies with birth defects.
Church: Don't have sex till later (marriage), you'll offend God
So what is the substantial difference between the socially accepted "don't have sex in the military, wait till you're out" and the quickly becoming socially unaccepted "don't have sex for this set period of time"? You just did it right here, characterizing it as a fight you can't win.
It seems... strange, to expect responsibility and prioritization of biological goals from people at some times and not others.
Let's just take the first example - teens who do not want to get pregnant.
I'm not sure what you find strange about this. Teenagers will feel the desire to have sex, but they (and/or their families) will be aware that having a baby at a young age can limit your freedom later in life. Thus, teenagers are told to either wait until they are older to have sex, or be sure to use contraception.
> It seems... strange, to expect responsibility and prioritization of biological goals from people at some times and not others.
Control over our base biological goals is a key part of what makes us civilised.
[1](http://www.army.mil/article/138222/Army_updates_reg_defining...)
That point being, that sexual activity in the armed forces is still controlled and sometimes that drive cannot be satisfied for relatively long periods, and this is commonly accepted.
But the kinds and degrees of control that work successfully are totally different from the kinds that you're suggesting. The "seizing on an ambiguity" is actually seizing on the fact that the policies you claim support abstinence's effectiveness are not policies of abstinence.
This is really, really simple. Are you not supposed to have sexual contact for X period of time? If yes, you are abstinent for that period. The period varies, sometimes longer, sometimes shorter, but the definition still applies.
If X period is repeating on and off on semi-regular schedule, then it's not an abstinence policy. That's just scheduling sex. If it's a single continuous period, then it might be an abstinence policy.
Or in other words, it needs to be semi permanent.
WRT socializing, we definitely have norms about controlling the drive to socialize, but I don't know many people who advocate complete isolation.
Similarly with sex. What you characterize as a "you can't control biological impulses" position usually specifically targets abstinence - that is not a fight you can win. But those same people are often totally in favor of more limited control of the sex drive. Laws against rape (statutory or otherwise), norms against romances on the workplace or military service where a power imbalance exists, norms against just plain moving too fast with someone new - these are all very broadly supported.