News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by tokenadult on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:22PM (#10963375)
I feared that many participants here would react to this interesting article's headline rather than to its content, and it appears that that fear is warranted. But, seriously, this is a thoughtful article and well worth reading for better understanding of debilitating phobias and how they are currently treated. It is also good to read the whole fine article to see what the medical doctor author has to say about the trade-offs of the proposed drug treatment suggested as an addition to the currently standard exposure therapy. I don't know anyone among my close friends who has a phobia as disabling as those described in the article. There is a big difference between such phobias and the everyday caution and avoidance of rash behavior that helps keep us all safe.

AFTER EDIT, AFTER OTHER COMMENTS TO THE THREAD: I remember that back in the 1980s propranolol (a beta-blocker originally prescribed to prevent heart disease) was investigated for anxiety conditions like stage fright. (The cases of stage fright among performers I know best largely resolved as the performers gain in performance competence from more coaching and practice and reduced fear of performing by performing in public more often.) So this line of research about propranolol has been going on for a long time.

Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by nathanb on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:10PM (#10964024)
A fair comment.

I think it's important to note that a fear or anxiety reaction may not, as you say, keep us safe. When I'm calm and rational, I make better decisions than when I'm gripped by fear.

As an avid hiker and explorer, occasionally my fear of heights interferes with my enjoyment of my hobby. I try to push past it as much as possible, but when my heart is racing and my legs are shaking, a situation which would otherwise be safe can become dangerous.

Also, unlike you, I do have two friends who suffer from PTSD (it's common enough that one may be surprised to find that a friend one has known for years wrestles with PTSD in some aspect of life but doesn't advertise that fact). One of those friends has gotten off an elevator early because being in an enclosed situation with a stranger gave her a panic attack. Another called me on the phone nearly in tears because she had to stay late at work and walking across the deserted, dark carpark to her car was almost more than she could handle.

I think it would be great if a drug could help people like these two friends of mine go through life without feeling controlled by anxiety in situations like these. I also think it would be great if people like me whose day-to-day lives are unmarred by fear can do more things -- safely; the drug does not impair reason -- through this therapy. The tradeoffs are important to know (and as you say, the article does a great job exploring them), but to me this sounds really promising.

Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by category on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:09PM (#10963564)
If there are more than 3 negative reactions to an article I definitely go read it because at this point it's hugely probable that the backlash is mainly cultural/traditional rather than logical.
Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by facetube on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:03PM (#10963538)
Yeah, I get that feeling too.

The idea that someone exposed to a traumatic event (e.g. rape, child abuse) could immediately given a single dose of a drug that would prevent a possible 30-40 years of painful PTSD is, honestly, pretty compelling.

Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by spangry on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:00AM (#10966246)
This article seems a little inaccurate to me, or at least incomplete.

On phobias, it's not quite as simple as a 'fear memory', although certainly a part of it when we're discussing 'conditioned fear' (e.g. PTSD). There's a part of your brain called the amygdala that is implicated in modulation of memory formation and emotional processing. It's part of the limbic system, which is tied in to the body's autonomic nervous system. This controls your 'fight or flight' response, essentially a sudden release of adrenaline into your system which causes 'anxiety symptoms': increased heart rate, increased perspiration, butterflies in stomach (due to diversion of blood flow to large muscles in your limbs).

The amygdala is sort of like a 'heuristic co-processor' that receives sensory input earlier than other parts of the brain. If the input matches a heuristic, the body's fight or flight response is activated. If the amygdala is dysfunctional, is 'pre-programmed' with heuristics now considered maladaptive, or you've had experiences that have 'programmed' inappropriate heuristics, it will activate your fight or flight response in response to non-threatening stimuli.

Drugs like propranolol, which I take daily for a panic disorder, antagonise (i.e. block) beta-adrendergic receptors, blocking the action of adrenaline and noradrenaline, which dampens the fight or flight response. This reduces or eliminates panic/anxiety like symptoms, and alters how memories are encoded while under its effects (however I'm not clear on whether this interferes with memory formation, or whether it causes the memories to be encoded in a different way).

The part I find most interesting is the 'pre-programmed maladaptive heuristics' still present in our heuristic database. Evolution is a slow process, and has not caught up to our rapidly changing context. For instance, if you've ever given a public speech, you've probably experienced a 'fight-or-flight' response. It's not because you've had some bad past experience with public speaking that has conditioned a 'fear response'; it's because of a left over heuristic in your amygdala that may have been adaptive a thousands of years ago.

Humans used to live in small tribes or groups with maybe a dozen other humans, and the only other humans they might have contact with in their life would be when fighting other groups for resources. If you publicly humiliated yourself in this context, it would have likely meant elimination from the gene pool or possibly even death. In a modern context, where you're giving a speech to a room full of people in another country, this isn't even mildly the case. But evolution is a slow process, so many of us still experience a fight or flight response anyway, which is maladaptive.

Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by sridca on Monday January 25, 2016 @11:48AM (#10968201)
In your experience taking this drug, does propranolol have any effect on 'pre-programmed maladaptive heuristics'?
Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by spangry on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:32PM (#10968513)
I'm not 100% sure. I think so, possibly in the same way that exposure therapy can be helpful.

On rare occasions when I've forgotten to take my propranolol dose, I think I experienced less severe panic reactions to provoking stimuli compared to in the past. This might be due to higher levels of 'exposure' when taking propranolol without a concurrent onset of panic symptoms, leading to a partial reversal of 'fear conditioning' (perhaps better characterised as 're-conditioning'?)

In my case I've found it to be very effective at treating the symptoms of my panic disorder, which are mostly physical/autonomic nervous system mediated. I think beta-blockers wouldn't be as effective for anxiety disorders where the symptoms are mostly 'mental' (e.g. catastrophic thinking, irrational anxious beliefs etc.).

tl;dr - Propranolol is great for 'physical' anxiety, possibly not as effective for 'mental' anxiety

Re:A Drug to Cure Fear by taurath on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:49PM (#10976865)
Wonderful description - thank you very much. Sounds very promising as a treatment for post-CBT resistant anxiety, which is a simple word for what I have. I can feel a physical fear response coming on and a large drain in my willpower resources based on very small stimuli that aren't cognatively fear-inducing. Sounds like this could help calm my overactive fight or flight system - its been on my list to try for a long while.