On rare occasions when I've forgotten to take my propranolol dose, I think I experienced less severe panic reactions to provoking stimuli compared to in the past. This might be due to higher levels of 'exposure' when taking propranolol without a concurrent onset of panic symptoms, leading to a partial reversal of 'fear conditioning' (perhaps better characterised as 're-conditioning'?)
In my case I've found it to be very effective at treating the symptoms of my panic disorder, which are mostly physical/autonomic nervous system mediated. I think beta-blockers wouldn't be as effective for anxiety disorders where the symptoms are mostly 'mental' (e.g. catastrophic thinking, irrational anxious beliefs etc.).
tl;dr - Propranolol is great for 'physical' anxiety, possibly not as effective for 'mental' anxiety