News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by youngian on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @12:53PM (#1095483)
Bold. This makes me really happy. Comments sections are the cesspools of the Internet, so it's great to see someone say "This is going away until you think about what you did wrong."

P.S. Yes, I'm aware of the irony in that I'm commenting on a comment-centric site about how much I hate comments. Let's just say HN is the least cesspoolish place I've found so far.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by pg on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:43PM (#1095659)
Comments really are a hard problem. 90% of the thought I expend on HN is devoted to saving the site from bad comments. Spammers and overt trolls are easy. The really hard problems are fluff comments and subtle trolls (people who are fundamentally nasty, but who are sophisticated enough to stop short of name calling).
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jmtulloss on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:48PM (#1095862)
I think it's especially hard on HN due to the nature of the site. Since HN is a site dedicated to discussion, it becomes important to ensure that open conversations are happening. Strong opinions shouldn't be banned just because they get a little hostile, and weak opinions shouldn't be banned just because they're a little fluffy. There's such a huge gray area that it's an impossibly difficult problem.

Contrast this with Engadget, who can enforce discussion that aligns with whatever site policies they choose to adapt. Or you can take this even further, like on my blog, where openness means nothing and I can just delete anything that's not a question or an anecdote that adds to what I've written.

In an open discussion forum, your biggest problem will be always be open discussion.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jodrellblank on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @03:25PM (#1095971)
I wish more blogs would take your view. People go to all the trouble of writing articles carefully, putting them on a dedicated domain with a nice design or template, and then I scroll down and there are:

"nice article I wrote one like it at http://buyviagra-cheap.example.org

and "HOW TO INSTALL THIS???!!!!!?!!! IT DOES NOT WORK!??"

Invite readers in, tempt them with an interesting article and then leave them in some internet shady backstreet area. It doesn't need free speech, delete the tripe, edit the rest mercilessly (but note that they have been 'edited').

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by RiderOfGiraffes on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:47PM (#1096251)

  > It doesn't need free speech, delete the tripe,
  > edit the rest mercilessly (but note that they
  > have been 'edited').
Can you suggest a way of doing that without don it all "by hand"? What you suggest is what I'd like to do, but it doesn't scale. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts as to a system like yours that does.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jodrellblank on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @07:17PM (#1096659)
I hadn't really considered that it should scale, anymore than you would ask how to write the articles themselves without doing it all by hand.

Comments close after a period of time, so it shouldn't scale temporally, comments for a large site with lots of authors, well, they have lots of authors.

If you want commentors to be able to suggest corrections indefinitely, then either a wiki is a more suitable medium, or an "email me" link. Depending on what you want to achieve - a communally edited document or a personal reply.

As far as newspaper sites go, they go beyond 'comments'; hundreds of comments is in the realm of a forum and deserves some kind of moderators and so on.

You want to publish to the world and have the world able to reply to you while you aren't paying attention? That's not going to work. If you want to publish to the world and have the world reply to each other, well that's what people have their own blogs for, surely; why would you want to host that indefinitely?

And if you are going to have an abandoned corner of the internet where nobody 'in authority' checks what happens, then you need to rely on the passerby, hopefully give them some tools to step in and help, e.g. several downvotes over several days from different sources = autodelete. I doubt that's a solution; if you could automatically tell who to trust in the first place you wouldn't let the spammy comments be submitted.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by Perceval on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @02:33PM (#1098608)
The xkcd IRC channel instituted the Robot 9000, which mute-bans anyone making an unoriginal comment. Obviously this does not prevent trolling, but it does reduce some of the more low-hanging fruit of retardation: http://blag.xkcd.com/2008/01/14/robot9000-and-xkcd-signal-at...

4chan also implemented Robot 9000 on one of their boards: http://boards.4chan.org/r9k/

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jmtulloss on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @06:19PM (#1096513)
My blog is very low traffic, so it's not that big of a deal, but using disqus allows me to go through and respond with "delete" in the body when I get a spammy message. Takes about 10 seconds and I can do it from my phone.

Of course, I always end up missing some, so I tend to go through every few weeks and prune those that I missed. What we really need is gmail-esque spam filtering in disqus.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by prawn on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @07:25PM (#1096678)
Or leave off comments altogether (Kottke is an example of a successful blog without comments) and put other interesting entries in the article tail instead to keep people moving around the site.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by prawn on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @08:48PM (#1096828)
"Comments really are a hard problem."

Bit tangential, but has anyone (e.g., start-up) solved the problem of massive discussions? Anything over a hundred or two hundred comments becomes unmanageable in a hurry. Some of the larger sites (e.g., Huff Post) routinely have 2000-comment threads that would take days to plow through.

Is there a solution that combines karma, upvotes as a means of identifying the 'cream' as well as grouping of sub-discussions and points-counterpoints? I haven't seen any solution take a serious shot at a way of grouping sub-arguments and discussions.

The level of comments on the typical news article here in Australia is embarrassingly bad. Any discussion quickly becomes a confusing read without threading and a complete waste of time without persistent identities or moderation. Disqus has taken a crack at the basics, but is it much better for discussions over, say, 500 posts?

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by cstross on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @08:12AM (#1097647)
http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight (Making Light) is routinely in the 200-1000 comments-per-thread range. They manage okay, mostly due to have a strong sense of community and several moderators and having Teresa Nielsen Hayden to ride herd on it (one of the folks who moderated BoingBoing when they reinstated comments).

Here are her (very cogent) thoughts on how to moderate massive discussions:

http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/008856.html

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by michael_nielsen on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:29PM (#1095797)
If you ever write an essay on making online community scale, I'll certainly be an enthusiastic reader! Quite a bit has been written on the subject, but I've found surprisingly little that seems really good, despite the importance of the topic.

Two useful links on the subject are http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/006036.html and http://www.meatballwiki.org/wiki/

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by pg on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:40PM (#1095837)
One reason I don't is that it would attract attention to HN, and one of my strategies for staving off disaster has been to keep a low profile, so that most new users are people who hear about the site from friends.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by blasdel on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:50PM (#1095868)
You can't "write an essay on making online community scale" because community doesn't scale
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by Perceval on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @06:50PM (#1096595)
I wrote a long article on the subject of online community and the problems of scale: http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2009/3/12/33338/3000
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by fbailey on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @05:10PM (#1096319)
Absolutely true. Social Networks can scale but communities can't. You can scale a site with community functions, that looks like a community (youtube) but there will be no sense of community.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by blasdel on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:48PM (#1095864)
Don't take a drop of advice from Teresa Nielsen Hayden -- it's all either blatantly obvious or outrageously poisonous. She is absolutely the least-moderate moderator on the entire English-language internet, and has proven herself adept at training subordinates to follow in her footsteps.

pg is already more than capricious enough already, I shudder to think of how ridiculous things would get around here if he started taking lessons from the dark master.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by blasdel on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @03:36PM (#1096003)
A nice example would be this enormous thread (2mb of HTML), that drags on documenting the incendiary results of her 'moderation' on BoingBoing. Search for "TNH": http://www.metafilter.com/72928/Boing-Boing-Finds-21st-Centu...

A choice summary quote: "i would never never ever hire tnh as a mod ever -- an inquisitor, maybe, a chief of secret police, certainly, but a mod, no!"

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by cstross on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @08:15AM (#1097653)
If you want to run any kind of community on the web these days, you need a chief of secret police.

"Benign dictatorship" works. Anything short of it is asking to be rules-lawyered to death by trolls and griefers.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jrockway on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @06:08PM (#1096485)
Metafilter also deletes too many comments.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by blasdel on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @10:35PM (#1096986)
You'd be surprised how little comment deletion there is outside of Ask Metafilter (where all comments have to answer the damn question). Pretty much the only comments deleted from the main site are personal attacks. There's an active backchannel for discussing such things where almost nothing is deleted.

They take great pains to avoid banning people (excepting spammers, who get their signup fee refunded!), though sometimes they dole out timeouts. The community policing means that the shitty users tend to disable their own accounts.

pg takes the opposite approach, applying a single assholish technical approach to all problems: hellbanning for everyone!

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jey on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @12:02AM (#1097108)
Yeah... e.g. this poor guy, who got "auto-hellbanned" and has been talking to himself because the third comment he ever made was childish: http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=efaith
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by jrockway on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @10:41PM (#1096997)
FWIW, I only read AskMe.

But I agree that Metafilter handles moderation better than HN. The way voting is here, it seems like it mostly depends on the time of day as to whether a comment of mine gets -4 or +30. (Usually this works out for me pretty well... but I can't help feeling dirty when I write something that gets upmodded that high.)

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by chrischen on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @12:30AM (#1097149)
Well I also feel like a system which allows mob punishment tends to select "regulars" who are more homogenous in opinions, since they will fit into the thinking which defines the community.

But if you want a like-minded small community it's a tradeoff that's necessary.

Why do you feel dirty though?

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by inmygarage on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:39PM (#1096222)
And yet, as digital real estate, comment sections are among the most under-optimized sections of any content site.

A site with high-quality comments can increase the value of the existing content exponentially, but because there is a more removed connection to revenue generation it seems like the majority of comment sections (HN excluded, of course) are thrown in as an afterthought.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by mattmaroon on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:24PM (#1095776)
I think it depends on context. Some blogs, like AVC, are more of a discussion with users, so the comments are integral. Some, like Engadget or TechCrunch, are much broader-interest, news-oriented sites, and the comment sections quickly devolve into unreadability.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by cpach on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @08:07PM (#1096751)
Agreed. I think the lesson to be learned here is "feel free to disable comments". Not "you should never enable comments".
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by roc on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @12:58PM (#1095504)
There's no real irony. While anonymous-account sites can have reasonable comments, that's a function of size, really.

Back in the day slashdot was great for quality comments. Then they grew and added a karma system which... didn't really help, just buried the dreck for a time. Now it's mostly a mess.

Similarly, Engadget used to be alright, then they grew and added the voting system... etc.

Frankly, what works for smaller sites doesn't scale. At their visibility, Engadget should either go comment-less or do subscriptions for early-access and comments. Anonymous comments just don't provide enough value with that much noise.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by sjs382 on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:23PM (#1095586)
I browse slashdot at +4 and I think the comments are pretty good/insightful. They are a bit too slow on the news sometimes, though.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by JadeNB on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:52PM (#1095685)
It seems to me that this solution also “doesn't scale”, though not necessarily in the sense of the grandparent: For there to be a sufficient supply of +4 posts that you can read, someone has to be going through, reading them, and promoting them above the dreck. Thus, only a limited number of people can pursue your strategy before it stops working.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by notauser on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @05:10PM (#1096322)
I browse /. at +5 (and see only very good comments) except for the once a month or so when I get given mod points.

15 minutes a month of moderation per person seems to be sustainable/scalable, because it's been working for ages and I have noticed no real change in Slashdot's +5 comment quality.

Where that fails with HN is that we have infinite mod points all the time, which:

- Encourages point inflation as the community grows.

- Discourages people from taking moderation seriously as if it was a big deal you wouldn't be able to do it all the time.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by JadeNB on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @07:33PM (#1096696)
> Discourages people from taking moderation seriously as if it was a big deal you wouldn't be able to do it all the time.

I'm not sure I agree with this. I really like the HN system whereby upvotes are free, but downvotes are restricted. (Well, I assume that's the way it is --at least, it's easy for me to see how to do one, but not the other.)

This makes it easy for me to give a post a tiny bump up, so that I don't think much of it, but emphasises the cost of giving it the equivalent tiny bump down; and isn't that a good attitude to instill in a commenting community? Certainly I think the culture here is notably friendlier than just about anywhere public-facing site (LtU (http://lambdatheultimate.org) being perhaps a notable exception).

EDIT: I saw a mention of Metafilter elsewhere. I forgot it as an example of another site with a novel approach to the commenting problem; namely, make commenting not free by imposing a small, one-time cost.

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by AlisdairO on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:31PM (#1095805)
That's pretty much the premise that sites like reddit and HN operate on at the link level, too - most people only read the first page or two, but some people are interested/obsessed enough to go through the dreck and flag up what's interesting. It seems to scale reasonably well so far.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by count on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @11:22PM (#1097058)
s/interested\/obsessed/bored/

I get to page 5 or 6 on reddit, just because I get bored, and read fairly fast...

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by illumin8 on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:12PM (#1095740)
Easy fix for this: If you have Slashdot mod points, browse at 0; if you don't and just want to read good comments, browse at +3 or 4.
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by JadeNB on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @07:29PM (#1096690)
This is an excellent point. I gave up on Slashdot as a comment site a long time ago, and now satisfy my commenting craving on Reddit and HN, where, effectively, you always have mod points; so I forgot that it didn't work that way elsewhere. Thanks!
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by sjs382 on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:47PM (#1095858)
Agreed. What I do works for me and I'm glad there are others with the time/patience/masochistic-tendencies to view and moderate things to make them more pleasant for me. :)
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by bootload on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @01:00AM (#1097177)
"... Back in the day slashdot was great for quality comments. Then they grew and added a karma system which... didn't really help, just buried the dreck for a time. Now it's mostly a mess. .."

This tends to be perception only. I'd agree with @sjs382, a +3 browser here and I was surprised at the improvement in discussion from what I remembered. #2774

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by awa on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:48PM (#1096252)
I agree its a good move for the current situation, but just turning comments on and off won't solve the problem in the long run. When the next gizmo is launched they will face the same problem. I think they should take this time to implement a solution to the spam issue either through moderation or a voting system.

I am also not able to access old comments which if intentional doesn't seem to be a good move (imho).

Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit by mortenjorck on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @03:59PM (#1096091)
I forewent a comments section on my own blog for a philosophical reason: I feel there should be some greater investment to commenting than creating an account on a blog. To comment on anything anywhere, you're free to use the platform you feel is most appropriate for it, be it your own blog, your Twitter account... or perhaps a link submission to a news discussion site like HN.