Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit
by jey on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @12:02AM
(#1097108)
Yeah... e.g. this poor guy, who got "auto-hellbanned" and has been talking to himself because the third comment he ever made was childish: http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=efaith
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit
by jrockway on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @10:41PM
(#1096997)
FWIW, I only read AskMe.
But I agree that Metafilter handles moderation better than HN. The way voting is here, it seems like it mostly depends on the time of day as to whether a comment of mine gets -4 or +30. (Usually this works out for me pretty well... but I can't help feeling dirty when I write something that gets upmodded that high.)
Re:Engadget - We're turning comments off for a bit
by chrischen on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @12:30AM
(#1097149)
Well I also feel like a system which allows mob punishment tends to select "regulars" who are more homogenous in opinions, since they will fit into the thinking which defines the community.
But if you want a like-minded small community it's a tradeoff that's necessary.
Why do you feel dirty though?
They take great pains to avoid banning people (excepting spammers, who get their signup fee refunded!), though sometimes they dole out timeouts. The community policing means that the shitty users tend to disable their own accounts.
pg takes the opposite approach, applying a single assholish technical approach to all problems: hellbanning for everyone!