News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by jeffwass on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:22AM (#10953619)
You're not alone :

"I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics." Richard Feynman, The Character of Physical Law (1965)

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by lisper on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:09PM (#10953980)
Feynman was wrong. It is actually not hard to understand QM, it's just taxing on the intuition. The key insight is that measurement and entanglement are the same physical phenomenon. Once you understand this, everything else is conceptually straightforward.

See:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc

http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by jeffwass on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:30PM (#10954598)
Here's another quote. Take from it what you will.

"I can safely say that the fraction of people on Internet forums who understand as much quantum mechanics as they think they do is a non-negative number much smaller than one."

jeffwass, Hacker News (2016)

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by saganus on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:20PM (#10954534)
I'm far from understanding QM for any definition of "understanding", but from your key insight, I would interpret it as, "whenever you measure something, you are actually entangling with it".

Is this what you are trying to say, when you state they are both the same phenomenon? or what exactly does it mean for entanglement and measurement to be the same phenomenon?

It's actually a very interesting take on QM, from my limited understanding of it.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by lisper on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:38PM (#10954642)
"whenever you measure something, you are actually entangling with it"

Exactly right, but there's a little more to it than that. Because you are entangling with it, all of the "mysterious" properties of measurement (Shroedinger's cat and whatnot) can all be understood in terms of entanglement, and in particular, in terms of what happens when you get large systems of mutually entangled particles.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Saturday January 23, 2016 @09:02AM (#10958413)
Once you understand that, you've accepted MWI.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by lisper on Saturday January 23, 2016 @01:53PM (#10959476)
That's not quite true. Measuremnet=entanglement can lead to MWI, but there is at least one tenable alternative to MWI which is variously called QIT (the quantum-information-theoretic view) or the Ithaca Interpretation ("We are correlations without correlata") or, my favorite (because I invented it) the zero-worlds interpretation. Even Everett, who invented MWI didn't call it that. He called it the "relative-state" interpretation, which is actually much closer to truth than "many-worlds".

But even though MWI is "correct" in some sense, it has a similar problem with its pedagogy as the more common Copenhagen interpretation (measurement is special, wavefunction collapse is a real physical phenomenon) which causes almost as much confusion: MWI is usually presented as "When you make a measurement, what was previously one universe before the measurement splits into two universes after the measurement." That's wrong. Nothing "splits" during a measurement. There are exactly "as many universes" (I put this in scare quotes because the line between universes is not sharp and so the number of them is not well defined) before a measurement as after.

For a more detailed critique of MWI see http://blog.rongarret.info/2009/04/on-shadow-photons-and-rea...

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by s-macke on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:43AM (#10953777)
I was never happy with this statement. Because obviously we can make very accurate predictions by applying quantum mechanics.

The problem with this statement is, that the meaning of "understanding" is unclear here. When I say "I understand that, when I drop an apple it falls on the floor", What exactly do I "understand" here? Does "understanding" mean here, that our brain is trained to predict what would happen?

Actually there is a huge understanding on the mathematical level of quantum mechanics. To apply these equations to what we call "reality" is a problem. But then again, what do we mean exactly with "reality" here? If some of the effects of quantum mechanics would be visible for us somehow from birth on, would we "understand" quantum mechanics then?

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by jeffwass on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:00PM (#10953905)
FYI, I have a PhD in physics and spent many a late night hour solving theoretical quantum mechanics problems, as well as those applied to statistical mechanics and solid state physics.

And yet I'm still inclined to agree with Feynman.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by s-macke on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:16PM (#10954041)
For me quantum mechanics is something like a complex cooking receipe. We have equations, we know what we have to put into these equations to solve certain systems.

The rest is just an endless variety of coordinate transformations, model assumptions and approximations. And this is the part most physics students struggle.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by jeffwass on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:28PM (#10954150)
Feynman is not talking about just "turning the crank" as it were, but actual deep intuitive understanding of the 'why'.

I agree with you that after you know how to setup the system you want to analyse, turning the mathematical crank can be straightforward and sometimes not so interesting.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:25AM (#10953648)
And when he said it, it was true.
Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by jeffwass on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:33PM (#10954182)
Are you disputing it's not true now?

Btw, I can safely tell you that having studied QM in some depth, I usually avoid these types of HN threads.

Ie, quite often they're dominated by people who think they know what they're talking about, and throw around buzzwords and make seemingly convincing arguments based on logically or physically unsound bases.

Re:Quantum Weirdness Now a Matter of Time by spacehome on Saturday January 23, 2016 @09:00AM (#10958407)
Yes, I'm claiming that it's not true now and that MWI, while it may not be captial-T Truth, is a concise and deterministic explanation of experimental results.