News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by Someone1234 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:03PM (#10949243)
Wow that was a really depressing read. I did learn several new problems that homeless people can face getting back into the working world that I wasn't aware of (e.g. night shift work isn't compatible with homeless shelters).
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by balls187 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:22PM (#10949351)
There are a number of penalties[1] that when applied to a certain demographic (read: working-poor), disproportionately and unfairly hurt those people--either intentional or otherwise. Penalties that include suspended drivers licenses, municipal fines, asset forfeiture, and even required medical screening, overly penalize poor workers.

These folks are so dependent on both the income from their jobs, and the precarious balance they maintain of income to expenses, that anything that threatens either can quickly lead to cascading and compounding problem that become insurmountable.

It's very much possible to get ahead in America[2], that's why I love this country. It's also very important to recognize that it's very much possible to create a house of cards that can come crashing down, and that to also recognize that if that has happened to someone, it's not because their unwillingness to work hard, or some other perceived flaw of their character.

As an aside, this is one of my favorite moments in US politics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=iGmY...

[1] http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/04/09/398576196/...

[2] I'm aware of the international readership of HN. However as an American, I can only speak to the opportunities I've experienced.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by thescriptkiddie on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:25PM (#10949378)
My takeaway from this is that homeless shelters don't do enough to support employment of the homeless, and that a minimum wage job is not sufficient to get you off the street. Conversations I've had with homeless people seem to corroborate this.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by Outdoorsman on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:04PM (#10949972)
Most of the homeless shelters I'm personally familiar with (have volunteered at) are not-for-profit...they have limited funding, manpower, and facilities...

On a really good day everyone gets fed, clothed, bathed and has a climate-controlled place to spend the night...most of the time its a stiff challenge to provide those basics..the wherewithal required to offer extras like counseling, job coaching, or to accommodate individual patron's schedules (coming and going--a security issue) is just not there the majority of the time...

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by derefr on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:17PM (#10950720)
I wonder if the debt-counselling advice of "tackle the worst debt first and pay it off entirely before touching your other debts" has an equivalent here? Maybe instead of sheltering and feeding 20 people, they could shelter, feed, and empower 5, enough to get those people out of the system and make room for the next 5. In the end, with several such facilities operating this way, available care slots would actually increase.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by pyre on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:32PM (#10950752)
> they could shelter, feed, and empower 5, enough to get those people out of the system and make room for the next 5

What do you do about the 15 that you left on the street in the middle of winter, and it's -40 out? Will they get by until you're ready for them?

What other prioritization will you be doing? Maybe you'll also prioritize the most hireable candidates to the top of the list to be re-groomed for the workforce. What about those that find themselves in a less hireable state? How far down the list are they, and how long do they have to wait to be helped?

What about the people that are homeless due to untreated mental health conditions? Do you just ignore them for now? Are they the "class" of homeless that gets helped last?

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dredmorbius on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:08AM (#10950874)
You've limited resources. At some point, yes, you play God.

Head off to G+ and look up Andreas Schou. He used to run a homeless shelter in Boise, Idaho. Kind of fell into the job, previous boss was incompetent. Or skimming. Or something else. But he was out and Andreas, just another volunteer, was in.

Some days he could help out. Some he couldn't. Sometimes he kept his cool. Sometimes he didn't. I'll try to find the article.

Here: https://plus.google.com/+AndreasSchou/posts/B9iRsq2kVeL

Andreas works for Google now. Writes some amazingly fucking good shit on G+ as well.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by pyre on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:44AM (#10950996)
My point was that it's not as cut-and-dry as the parent post made it (like balancing a math equation or something). The 15 that you are not helping (at the moment) don't just wait on a shelf until you're ready for another batch. There are touch decisions to make if you go down that route.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dredmorbius on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:42AM (#10951183)
Are you helping anyone by attempting and failing to help 20?

If not, then help a number you can actually help. Apply a selection process: triage, sortition, intuition. Whatever.

Someone's going to get helped, someone's not.

If you've got additional bandwidth, make loudly known that there are more people who need help, and that others should step forward.

It's rather like emergency first-responder practices. First ensure you're safe yourself. Then save who you can. Avoid wasting time on helpless cases, or those who can survive without help. Recruit others.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by derefr on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:56PM (#10950824)
Actually, going by the analogy, you'd do precisely the opposite: solve the most intractable cases first, because they're the ones that would be soaking up the most of your long-term resources. Like Murray[1].

[1] http://gladwell.com/million-dollar-murray/

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by Outdoorsman on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:42PM (#10950790)
Looking at a spreadsheet and looking into the eyes of a fellow human being are two different experiences altogether...practicality and pragmatism get left behind, quite easily...
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by samstave on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:06PM (#10949632)
I did the math previously on the numbers that SF put out on the homless support they pay out per homeless person; $25k per year / homeless...

yet the services are abysmal!

One of the things I've long thought would be three areas to address homelessness;

1. create "hygiene trucks" - they are semi trailers that are mobile that would provide showers, bathrooms, 'scrubs' style basic clothing.

2. container based micro housing, divide the containers into ~3 rooms.

3. "standard pantry" -- give them a basic standard pantry which has the ingredients or basic meals (a step up from MREs)

4. basic min-wage jobs with initiatives like this with Amazon where the co gets a tax break - but must provide basic skills like cleaning, organizing etc.

Then -- FOCUS ON MENTAL HEALTH

Mental health degenerates REALLY fast for those that dont have the above basics.

NO PETS.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by resu_nimda on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:43PM (#10949852)
1. create "hygiene trucks" - they are semi trailers that are mobile that would provide showers, bathrooms, 'scrubs' style basic clothing.

There is a startup in SF doing exactly this. I've seen their trucks around the Tenderloin. http://lavamae.org/

[replying to dpark's child comment here] How is this better than a permanent facility? It's got to be way more expensive to build this into a truck.

One reason is that the public bathrooms around the Tenderloin/Civic Center are just constantly fucked up with needles stuck in the drains and other issues, requiring constant maintenance. Most of the time I walk by one it's closed or actively being worked on. With the truck they can probably manage and control it a lot better.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by derefr on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:21PM (#10950724)
You could get most of that benefit from just having a guard posted inside a permanent/stationary public bathroom. Heck, that guard could be homeless themselves, paid a bit, and people would jump to take the job. (Vancouver's public bathrooms near the homeless area on Hastings & Main have exactly this setup.)
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by lflux on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:33AM (#10951317)
This exists in SF, it's called called "Pit Stop SF": http://sfdpw.org/index.aspx?page=1805 and costs over $1mm a year according to the Chron: http://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/matier-ross/article/City-...
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dpark on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:20PM (#10949717)
> 1. create "hygiene trucks" - they are semi trailers that are mobile that would provide showers, bathrooms, 'scrubs' style basic clothing.

How is this better than a permanent facility? It's got to be way more expensive to build this into a truck.

> 2. container based micro housing, divide the containers into ~3 rooms.

Containers are not an affordable way to build housing. Shipping containers converted into housing is a fetish for rich people with architects.

> FOCUS ON MENTAL HEALTH

Yep. Mental health problems are highly correlated with homelessness. Everything from depression to schizophrenia to substance abuse. Often multiple issues combined.

> NO PETS.

This eliminates a huge number of homeless. Many homeless desperately cling to their pets because they have no one else.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by cbhl on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:10AM (#10950884)
It's super expensive -- IIRC, Lava Mae was quoting $1 million to convert one bus into a bathroom and run it for a year. That said, getting approvals in SF to build a permanent facility is non-trivial and expensive in its own right, and it would only serve homeless in the immediate area (one of the features of Lava Mae's approach is that they put the truck in different parts of the city on different days of the week).
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by placeybordeaux on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:36PM (#10949816)
You might get beyond not in my backyard with a truck.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dpark on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:46PM (#10949873)
Maybe, but if you can build container housing in someone's backyard, I'm pretty sure you can get a washroom in there, too.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by barsonme on Friday January 22, 2016 @03:08AM (#10951427)
I think the previous poster was referring to NIMBYs[1] (people who oppose something because of its proximity to them, even if it's a necessity).

A fair amount of people wouldn't want a homeless shelter or washroom next to their house, but a mobile truck could have the same benefit while placating the NIMBYs.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NIMBY

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dpark on Friday January 22, 2016 @06:29AM (#10952123)
I understand that. Item 2 on the list was container-based micro housing units, though, which are going to have to be built/installed somewhere. If you can get the permits and land to install micro housing units, you can most certainly get permits to install shower and was facilities. In fact you are required to do so. You cannot housing housing without plumbing.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by josinalvo on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:14AM (#10951086)
No pets = no homeless in your program.

People like respect and affection much more than they like food and heat.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by pas on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:26PM (#10949754)
Why no pets?
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by Outdoorsman on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:35PM (#10950124)
Agreed...

I'd go further, especially in the case of a company scaling in the billions:...provide basic housing near order processing centers, or any other place where unskilled labor is needed, or semi-skilled labor can be offered training...with whatever amenities are necessary for employees to be productive--transportation and a reliable phone are huge deals for a homeless person...

It's not enough to say "I'll hire the homeless, give them a chance" just to make the news...it's much better to say "I'm committed to doing whatever it really takes to put someone back on their feet, provided they are willing to work "

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by 13thLetter on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:59PM (#10950236)
> It's not enough to say "I'll hire the homeless, give them a chance" just to make the news...it's much better to say "I'm committed to doing whatever it really takes to put someone back on their feet, provided they are willing to work "

If that's the price of admission, Amazon will probably decide it's not worth the trouble and abandon the project, and the homeless people you're concerned about will have even fewer opportunities.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by Outdoorsman on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:56PM (#10950823)
That is the true price of admission...a company, scaling in the billions, can opt out if they think their initial efforts were not productive...

If you are in a position to help others and you do not that says something very profound about you...effective benevolence is hard work...always has been...

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by 13thLetter on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:14AM (#10951088)
That's nice, but it's not going to convince Amazon to turn itself into a full-bore social services agency. It's job offers or nothing; which do you pick?
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by bloaf on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:11PM (#10950706)
You mean like the dorms foxconn provides?
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by alexandrerond on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:37PM (#10949455)
My takeaway is that Amazon doesn't give a shit about homeless people issues and is just looking for seasonal cheap labor.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by axlprose on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:42PM (#10950421)
I always wonder why people want everything helpful to be the result of some purely altruistic action, when there's at least as much help to be gained from mutually beneficial partnerships. Symbiotic relationships not only require less friction to implement, but they're also a lot more sustainable in the long run, since both parties get something out of it as opposed to just one.

Yes, amazon obviously benefits from having a larger labor pool to chose from when hiring the poor, but why is this a bad thing?

If you had the opportunity to go make Warren Buffett an extra $1 Billion, but you'd only get a 1% cut of it, would you say that's a bad deal? I would hope not, because 1% of $1,000,000,000 is still $10 Million. You'd have to be either crazy or filthy rich already to turn that down just because it'd make a wealthy person wealthier.

A seasonal amazon warehouse job might not be the most luxurious, but it still has an unusually low barrier to entry, and is likely to be sustainable for amazon to provide it regularly. Even most of the wealthiest billionaires had to start out by doing annoying grunt-work at some point in their careers.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by jonesb6 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:16PM (#10949693)
Their a corporation of course they don't care about the issues.

My guess is that it cost Amazon more money (opportunity cost had they hired a more fit individual) and that they were actually looking for cheap PR not cheap labor.

However Amazon doesn't give a fuck about their minimum-wage employees anywhere, especially in their warehouses.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by s0rce on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:21PM (#10949349)
The incompatibility of shift work with a homeless shelter was very surprising. Wouldn't 'hot racking' like on a submarine increase the capacity of the shelter and the homeless could get shift jobs that might be easier to find.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by rtkwe on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:42PM (#10950159)
Shelters can also use the time during the day to clean up and do any maintenance that you couldn't really do with people trying to sleep. Also if the workers are volunteers it'll be way easier to get enough during the evening than any other time.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by ZanyProgrammer on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:46PM (#10949506)
That would imply homeless shelters give a shit about the homeless.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dpark on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:47PM (#10949878)
Are they in it for the money? I don't think running a homeless shelter is actually that lucrative.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by thaumasiotes on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:53PM (#10949909)
They're in it for the prestige. Showing people that you care about the homeless is a sign of moral virtue, regardless of whether you're actually trying to help.

Consider what the jealous groupies sing about Captain Hammer's girlfriend in Dr. Horrible's Singalong Blog:

    So they say he saved her life
    They say she works with the homeless, and doesn't eat meat
    We have a problem with her!
Why equate working with the homeless with not eating meat? Those are both displays of feminine caring.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by tracker1 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:28PM (#10949398)
It seems to me that part of these job fairs should include some funding to help homeless shelters keep daytime operations in place... I'm not sure about the logistics vs. other conventions, but it could/should be similar that part of the fees are operational costs behind the location.

Alternatively, how hard would it be for an employer to provide barracks, or other housing options for seasonal employees?

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by aharonovich on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:02PM (#10949607)
Sadly I think that if a company supplied housing for temp employees the media would shout slavery.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by true_religion on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:30PM (#10949777)
Perhaps the shelter who is hosting the fair could agree that workers that take night-shift jobs from the fair will temporarily be allowed to sleep in the shelter during the day.

Are they not best positioned, and inclined to help?

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by tracker1 on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:24PM (#10954968)
The problem is, who pays for the extra daytime staff at said shelter... that cost is above and beyond the night staff that the shelter already has... This cost could/should be part of the job fair fees, if the positions are for night staff... so that the shelter can afford to stay open during the day.
Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by parennoob on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:54PM (#10949560)
Yeah. Maybe I'm having a stupid moment, but could someone ELI5 this to me?

> most homeless shelters close during the day and have strict curfews that don’t allow people to arrive in the night

I thought homeless shelters had some sort of semi-permanent living arrangement. Does this mean that they essentially drive everyone out during the day? Otherwise, how does it affect work on a night shift?

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by Naritai on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:49PM (#10949888)
The semi-permanent arrangements are usually a small number of apartments for which there are months-long waiting lists. It's considered to be like a halfway house, or a dry run for having an actual apartment, and the shelter frequently charges a nominal rent + utils, just to get the tenant into the habit of dealing with monthly bills.

But this is a tiny fraction of the total quantity of shelter beds - most are mattresses that are laid out on a gymnasium floor at 8pm (first come first served, so yes the lines form much earlier), then collected and stacked at 7am the next morning when everyone is given a quick breakfast and turfed out onto the street.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by dpark on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:16PM (#10949695)
> Does this mean that they essentially drive everyone out during the day?

Yes. Many (most?) homeless shelters are like this. Semi-permanent housing is less common, and it's very difficult to get into due to the limited number of beds. Most semi-permanent housing also has curfew, and might still interfere with night shift work.

Re:Amazon Hires Homeless Workers, and Everyone Ends Up Disap... by normand1 on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:32AM (#10951149)
Did you read to the end? It's not a depressing read.