News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by dsacco on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:35AM (#10945025)
As an angel investor, I can anecdotally confirm that I've become more cautious recently (in the last year, really). However, I'm not at all concerned about the stock market. That has never influenced my decision to fund a company. My belief is that a strong company can weather a bear market.

I'm concerned with the current state of valuations - I enjoy giving investments to companies on the order of five figures or so each with the hope that they make something meaningfully impactful. I don't necessarily look for them to become moonshot successful; a win can be much smaller than that. Developing incrementally impressive technology that effects change is also a win.

But valuations are so frothy right now that it's difficult to tell the strong companies from the ones that won't survive "when the tide goes out." It all seems very clear in hindsight, but it's hard to know right now, even moreso than usual. This is always very difficult, but the market for ideas has become somewhat "congested."

There has been a flood of folks entering the "startup game" who seem to be planning for their IPO before they've even gotten a product off the ground. Again, anecdotally, I'm observing a noticeable increase in fraud among founders who are trying to raise money unscrupulously, especially with novice investors.

I don't like to use the word bubble because I think it's lazy analysis, but I do strongly believe valuations are in the beginning of a market correction. At the very least, I think there will be a higher bar for invested money to indicate a legitimate valuation instead of a loan.

I do think that there will still be plenty of capital ready to be given to companies, investors are just going to be more selective (read: cautious) about it, which may very well change the growth and success potential of certain more dubious business models in the valley.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by roymurdock on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:08AM (#10945200)
> However, I'm not at all concerned about the stock market. That has never influenced my decision to fund a company.

It probably will as things start to slow down.

During the growth phase of the business cycle, many companies do well. Even some with poor fundamentals that shouldn't. This is the danger of stimulus - it promotes an inefficient and wasteful allocation of resources. But it makes investing easier as a larger pool of companies are succeeding and finding exits for their founders and investors through IPOs and acquisitions, which are both very closely correlated with the health of the stock market.

During the contraction phase, the companies with poor fundamentals are exposed. Ok, no loss there, they were struggling and nobody really believed in their potential anyways. But contractions can also bring down good, solid companies who were just caught unaware and were not holding enough liquid assets to pay their employees and the interest on their debts. Some non-negligible percentage will not make it through a rocky period while liquidity dries up and relatively cheap funding/investing slows down.

I think it's smart to not read too much into the stock market as it can be distracting and noisy, but I think its trajectory and what it indicates about the phase and timing of the next business peak/trough cycle is extremely important and should not be discounted.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by dsacco on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:19AM (#10945277)
You have a very good point, in that the stock market's current phase ultimately affects the health of all its constituent companies (in both a symbiotic and parasitic relationship).

But like you said, I don't consider it helpful to pay attention on a day to day basis, and I find it to be a more useful indicator for macrotrends than microtrends. In other words, my understanding of the stock market will influence my opinions about the angel investing and startup market en masse, but it would not be anything more than one factor in my opinion about a single company I could invest in.

While it's true that companies with strong fundamentals do fail in a downturn, companies with strong fundamentals can fail for any number of reasons. Just as I'm not all that concerned with my Vanguard funds going down for a while because they'll be back up in 10 years, I'm not too worried about a single company with strong fundamentals getting caught with its shorts down when the tide goes out. If it happens, it happens; in the absence of other poignant data, however, I find it much more important to focus on the company itself and pay attention to macrotrends more infrequently.

Besides, a market downturn is an excellent time to hedge long bets with shorts :)

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by haxeny1 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:31AM (#10945809)
> hedge long bets with shorts I am curious, without sharing details obviously, have you actually been able to successfully pull it off or do you expect to see some hits due to changes in direction?
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:16PM (#10947548)
> There has been a flood of folks entering the "startup game" who seem to be planning for their IPO before they've even gotten a product off the ground. Again, anecdotally, I'm observing a noticeable increase in fraud among founders who are trying to raise money unscrupulously, especially with novice investors.

FWIW I'll back you up on this, definitely a complicating factor for novice investors.

Free tip to novice investors: If someone approaches you with a request for funding, if it is still 'just an idea' and if the idea will surely deliver billions and if the funding required is < $50K then you're being fed a line of bull-shit.

Anything that will grow to turnovers that high will surely require a little bit of traction after implementation before any figures can be projected at all and anything that hasn't been implemented yet doesn't even qualify to be discussed in other terms than hypotheticals.

Another free tip for novice investors: pair up with a more experienced investor to vastly reduce your chances of being ripped off on your first investment(s).

This is also not a guarantee but it will increase your odds considerably, it also requires you to convince another, hopefully more skeptical party that what you've found is really worth an investment.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by bsder on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:11PM (#10948391)
> anything that hasn't been implemented yet doesn't even qualify to be discussed in other terms than hypotheticals.

Except that once you implement it, investors start anchoring to how small your numbers are. Catch 22.

I work with an actual IoT startup. Hardware--implemented. Backend and frontend--up and running on Azure migration to AWS ongoing. Customers who pay? Yep--and they love it.

So, investors?

"Ick, haaaardwaaaaare? But ... but ... but ... that's going to take actual moooooney." (yeah--well, so did Nest, thanks)

"Your numbers are too small to be meaningful" (no duh--does the word "startup" actually mean anything to you)

"This isn't going to scale." (translation--it takes money and marketing to acquire customers--welcome to a business with actual value and customer lockin).

"Big data is uninteresting to us now." (translation--"actuarials" and "business process" are only profitable--not wildly profitable and flippable)

To a certain extent, I'm looking forward to these unicorns winding up on the butcher block and being discovered to have no meat. The lead VC's of these unicorns are going to give a bunch of the initial investors a huge haircut via preferences (don't get me started ranting on the stupidity of that). Suddenly, initial investors are going to have to start looking at "sustainable" rather than "flippable".

Those of us with actual profit will be waiting.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by stcredzero on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:22PM (#10948966)
I'm looking forward to these unicorns winding up on the butcher block and being discovered to have no meat.

http://amzn.com/B00EWZCTD0

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by bsder on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:26PM (#10949383)
I love the Stross "Laundry" novels. Added to my reading list.

Thanks.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by roymurdock on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:00PM (#10950244)
Have you looked at more conventional forms of funding? If you already have meaningful revenues, why not just get a small business loan from a commercial bank? I've never done it, but I expect the interest rates are laughably low at the moment if you have decent credit and some assets (hardware, so yes) to back the loan. Plus, you wouldn't have to give up any equity.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by bsder on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:50AM (#10951015)
> Have you looked at more conventional forms of funding?

We have, but hardware doesn't lend itself to small amounts of money. And there are different trajectories depending upon whether you can get 500 thousand, 2 million, or 5 million.

The folks I work with are religious about maintaining a low burn rate. Hardware has a LOT of NRE, and you can get in deep trouble very quickly.

We actually had to be very hard-nosed with customer which we expected to be profitable with about 100K volume (actually kind of the Valley of Death in electronics volume--100K has all the NRE of huge volume without the profitability) because we simply couldn't take the risk with cash we had in reserve. If the customer didn't follow through, the NRE would have killed the company. This is a very different discussion if you have 5 million in the bank.

In addition, while I can't prove it, I suspect that we lost some funding because we're religious about burn rate management. VC's want "Go big or go home" and someone who is managing burn rate well is anathema to this.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by kokey on Friday January 22, 2016 @05:41AM (#10951963)
I can see how hardware would benefit from someone taking a risk with investment. It's better to sell hardware at the price point it would be at if you are doing it large scale to test the market, even if you are selling it at a loss. However, it sounds like you are almost beyond that point and know there is a demand and at what price, but it was probably hard to compete for investment (and talent) when investors were willing to throw money at zany schemes with hopes of unicorns. I hope for you, once investors become more careful again, that a business with something more proven and where the cash was managed sensibly will be exactly the type of company that most investors will be keen on. This was roughly the situation after the dotcom boom, except investors were poorer and less confident (well, I hope). I also think investors will have to increase their appetite for hardware, because IoT and autonomous vehicles are showing a lot of promise. I also think money that would normally go to unconventional oil and gas projects would be seeking something new. Good luck!
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by api on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:19PM (#10948935)
> Except that once you implement it, investors start anchoring to how small your numbers are. Catch 22.

Are investors really that irrational?

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by bsder on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:24PM (#10949370)
Now that I stopped laughing, I can give you a reasonable answer.

Yes, they are. But, then, handing someone a couple million dollars in the hope that it will turn into 50 or 100 million is an irrational act, too. So, it's hard to get too upset over them being purely irrational.

There are two problems:

1) VCs/Investors are sheep.

This is the infuriating one as it makes most of the VCs/investors you deal with effectively useless. To the point that when pitching to them the goal is to trigger that behavior (the term is FOMO-"Fear of Missing Out" aka: acting like sheep). So, if everybody is investing in something, everybody will invest in something. Until it blows apart. If you just want funding, try to pitch something which runs downwind of this tendency.

2) It's really all after the fact rationalization of "I don't like/trust you."

This doesn't make me mad--I just would rather a VC/investor just say this. But they won't turn you down definitively for lots of social reasons (mostly hoping they don't turn down the next AirBnB/Uber/etc. and get laughed at at the country club). I would actually respect someone more who simply said "My astrologer says the signs aren't right. KTHXBYE." Or, even, flat out "I don't like you." I'm cool with that--my personality is straightforward--most people like it, a few call it tactless and arrogant. If you're one of those I rub the wrong way, fine, we need to find different dance partners.

The problem is that too many investors want you to jump through hoops when they're looking for reasons to turn you down. Generally, you should simply read this as "No" and move on. It's like trying to date a pretty girl--when she gives you some excuse multiple times, she's probably telling you "No" but trying to keep you in her list of options just in case.

Upshot: raising money is hard work. If you want to sit in the big chair, you had better be prepared for the slog.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:22PM (#10949727)
At the risk of upsetting those that pay my bread & butter, yes, for the most part. And then there are tons of buts.

The first one: but they're usually good at judging people.

The second: some of them do hire tech people to help improve the odds (because that's all this is, playing the odds, improve them enough and you can do very well at this).

The third: they're past masters at the other end of it, protecting the exit. This is important because without an exit there is no return worth measuring (dividends don't really count as a rule, but an IPO would be nice if the company survives the lock-up period or if the VCs get to float their shares or a large chunk of them).

Obligatory lame VC joke: Q: Why does a venture capitalist walk into the negotiation room backwards? A: So they keep sight of the exit.

The fourth: there are at least as many irrational founders as there are irrational VCs, if not many many more.

Finally: Trust is everything. Break the trust at any point and you can kiss any investment goodbye. Have broken tech, a broken business model, a good attitude and team willing to put in the time and the effort to fix the tech and the model (or even an outright pivot) and I wouldn't rule out that you get funded.

Fun fact: the one thing that keeps on being repeated back to me whenever we (one of my clients and me) go to do tech dd on any one of the companies they've signed a terms sheet with is that no matter how many other investors have already been in that position and no matter how many times that company has already seen due diligence teams it will be the very first time that they actually get to really show their tech, both the good and the bad. This never ceases to amaze me, the amount of sloppy homework on the part of VCs and the usual suspects of companies that do dd (usually the big legal and accounting firms get hired and they then farm out the bits to various parties) is scary and this costs quite a few of them many millions of dollars annually. Even so, it's good advertising for me so I really shouldn't complain.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jonnathanson on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:58PM (#10949214)
Some are. The rest aren't irrational so much as impatient. They tend to believe -- correctly or not -- that the winners and losers among their portfolio can be identified quickly, and prioritized accordingly.

They are not just thinking about your company in isolation. They are thinking about it in terms of stack-ranked IRR on a spreadsheet with other investments.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DiabloD3 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:55PM (#10949193)
Yes. I may not be apart of that highly rigged game personally, but holy goddamned yes a thousand times. The front page of HN almost always has at least one story during the day about how irrational they are.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by simonebrunozzi on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:25PM (#10950353)
Curious to hear what startup yours is. Mind to share the name?
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by bsder on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:24AM (#10950929)
> Mind to share the name?

Yeah, not right now, thanks. I'll share the name when I'm ready for a stress test. <grin>

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jonesb6 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:01PM (#10949230)
I'd counter that free tip with a dose of the real world. That less then $50,000 is rent and payroll.

If I'm a software start-up with a < 10 person team and I'm six months into a six month development cycle, and oh shit we miscalculated the significance of feature X, which has now revealed itself to be our greatest value proposition and requires 2 months more development time to be fleshed out (mini-pivot I suppose) in order to be sold to customers.. I need that 10k, 20k, 50k just to push the product out the door.

Sure I'm going to tell you all about our sales projections, remember when you asked to hear them in the meeting, and yes the projections will be optimistic (but still fundamentally sound). No I will not go into too much depth about all the reasons we pushed launch back two months (the meeting would go past the ~30 minutes allotted and you would likely feel bored towards the end of the meeting.. not good).

I think both investors and founders are products of our current environment. We both ride the roller coaster, yet I feel like founders often get portrayed as the dishonest ones (I'm guessing it's because we don't hold the money). Maybe I would just like to feel more representation in this thread.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:30PM (#10949781)
10 to 250k is what a single angel will invest. Usually these team up for a larger seed round depending on their ability to fund.

Sure, $50K is peanuts, but then again, compare it to what YC offers and it's actually not all that weird. Usually seed funds do not get you enough money to go on a hiring spree and collect your favorite list of valley talent. But it might just be enough to get you to the point where you can demo your stuff and get a larger round. Essentially that's all that seed funding is, a way to get in front of a group of larger investors after doing some more product development.

There are dishonest people both on the founders side and on the investors side, no exclusivity there for either group.

Rare to see a career based on dishonesty last very long, word definitely gets around.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by hiddencost on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:09PM (#10949279)
Cheap engineers you've got there.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jonesb6 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @06:14PM (#10949310)
Yup, it sucks. And it's become par for the course. My biggest fear is that a downturn in VC will only cause more of it.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by ryporter on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:16PM (#10948439)
Pairing up with a more experienced investor is a great idea. The easiest way for an outsider to do this is to join an angel group. When I first started angel investing, I joined the Seattle Angel Conference [1], and I learned a lot from the more experienced members.

[1] http://www.seattleangelconference.com/

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DenisM on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:07AM (#10946123)
An unrelated question, if I may...

When evaluating a startup in a given area, how do you bridge the gap between your expertise in that area, and that which is required to assess the opportunity?

Obviously the startup founders will always project the fields of gold ripe for the taking, so you can't blindly trust that. Do you only invest in the field you know well? Do you look for behavioral clues? Do you look for your or their peers' decision? Do you look for what's in trend, or counter trend?

It seems like a super tough problem, yet it hardly ever gets discussed...

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:17PM (#10947552)
Hire an expert. This is routinely done during any kind of due-diligence, if you don't know the field find someone who does, get them to sign an NDA and start picking the proposition apart.

Make sure there is absolutely no conflict of interest, make sure the expert will be told up front they will not be able to participate in any kind of deal and will only be paid an agreed-up-front hourly rate for their participation in the due-diligence process.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by mbesto on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:33PM (#10947667)
Unfortunately angels rarely do due-diligence. The fees to do this for a portfolio approach (which VC's model is) are much too high.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:36PM (#10947681)
The amount of money you spend on a due diligence should be related to the size of the investment. Under 100K investment 5 to 10% should be enough to keep you out of trouble. A couple of hours (or a full day) of an expert in the field that you're going for would amount to maybe $1K to $3K depending on the field. Easy money for the expert and a very cheap insurance for someone putting down 20 to 100K of their hard earned money.

The funny thing is they don't bat an eye at spending that kind of money on a lawyer but to actually get a good look at the material it is suddenly 'a lot of money'.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by shin_lao on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:50PM (#10948680)
That's because they know they can't do the lawyer job but believe they are inteligent enough to understand the field without the help of an expert.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by mbesto on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:30PM (#10949779)
I don't disagree, but there aren't enough "experts in the field" to supply your proposed demand. In a typical diligence round, you usually have financial/accounting, legal, commercial and ops/tech diligence. Are you suggesting they find a finance expert, a ops/tech, and commercial expert and pay them $1-3k each and on each investment?
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:45PM (#10949864)
Assuming the angel has at least one of those skills will save some money and assuming that it's not a single person funding the round yes, that's precisely it, whatever skills the group of angels does not bring to the table they'll have to farm out.

Otherwise you might as well go to the casino and put all your money on 'black'. Better odds that way.

I used to work quite a bit for angels (I'm priced out of their range now I guess) and contrary to A rounds the number of bad deals proposed to angel investors is substantially higher. By the time you get to an A round there has already been a significant shake-out, all of which means some angel or group of them have lost a bunch of money.

Contrary to what people believe angel investments are a lot harder to get right than later rounds. There are many more start-ups that die prior to receiving an A round than afterwards and the amounts are low enough that doing proper due diligence is not in the cards. But an abbreviated dd is (much) better than none at all.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DenisM on Thursday January 21, 2016 @02:59PM (#10947862)
Enginers like you and I may have the same idea of what's right, but I'd rather see an actual investor describe how it's actually happening.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:04PM (#10947902)
I'm also an actual investor (but on a very small scale, I'm pretty careful) and that's how it is actually happening.

Except when it isn't and there will be blood (investor blood).

I make a living like doing tech dd, and when a due-diligence needs other expertise I'll be the first to point it out. This works pretty good for investors and technology people alike.

Investors that don't do due diligence at all end up losing their shirt, so that's a pretty good starting point. Just abbreviate the process relative to the amount of money involved, after all, it is a risk mitigation strategy, not a risk erasure strategy (if you don't want risk: don't invest anything just sit on your money and watch it evaporate, every other kind of investment strategy will carry risk to some degree).

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DenisM on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:16AM (#10951093)
So due diligence is happening after they decided to invest, right?

What about before? There is a number of startups that are pitching you (the generalized investor you), and for most of them you wouldn't know enough about target market to judge one way or another. Like, you don't know about wholesale distribution of manufactured goods from mid sized companies, how can you assess if the founders are onto something?

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Friday January 22, 2016 @06:37AM (#10952145)
> So due diligence is happening after they decided to invest, right?

Yes, usually this happens after the terms sheet is signed (and for smaller investments after a letter of intent is signed or a handshake deal is agreed upon). Up to that point it is read as true that everything the founder says will check out.

The due-diligence process is there for two reasons: to fulfill the 'duty to research' for a VC to cover their backs in case a deal goes bad after investment and LPs wonder how the hell they got suckered in like that as well as to simply protect the funds.

For angels the situation is worse here because they don't have the funds or the organization to do this properly.

> What about before?

Typically a VC has a number of analyists that assess the companies that pitch them to see how solid the various commercial claims are. The accent there is usually on the numbers and the commercial side of things, which is reflected in the education of the associates (typically: finance, accounting and/or a bit of legal and commercial).

Angels tend to do this part by themselves.

Angels and VCs do roughly the same thing, only angels do it earlier on (when the risk is higher, companies are cheaper and the deals are much smaller so they can still participate), the biggest difference is dictated by the size of the deals, it limits the amount of money you can spend in order to determine if you spend it wisely.

To make an extreme example: a full legal/commercial/technical/financial dd would cost approximately 100K or so. The bulk of that will be eaten up by the legal portion, the remainder is roughly equally split between the other parts.

If you're looking to plunk down 100K as an angel if you actually did a full DD you'd be out 200K if the deal goes through or 100K if it doesn't, so then there is no point in doing DD at all. Hence my advice to do an abbreviated one scaled down to a portion of the size of the investment, but to definitely look at all these aspects of the company, if possible through the eyes of an outsider.

The other important thing to remember is that doing DD puts a strain on the company you invest in, and if every angel would do a full DD on a company before investing then the company would grind to a halt during their seed round.

Yet another note: for seed investments there usually isn't a whole lot to verify anyway, the company is still tiny, probably has no turnover (so financial dd becomes: look at the model), has very little technology (so tech becomes: look at the proof of concept) and so on. So everything becomes a lot simpler anyway, it wouldn't be possible to do a full process DD on a start-up that has only just become real enough to look for seed funding.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DenisM on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:18AM (#10953578)
Thank you for taking the time to answer my question!

The reason I'm asking is that I keep imagining this picture: suppose there are 20 areas of economy(there are more but bear with me), and each angel knows one area well. Startups come at random from all 20 areas, so for 1 in 20 pitches the investor hears about something he understands deeply, can ask good questions and question assumptions. And so he can make an educated decision. What about the other 19? He can't judge the financials because it's too early. He has to rely on various proxies, such as interest from others (not necessarily any more qualified), the quality of the deck, the looks or pedigree of the founders (PhDs and professors are like really sexy as I found out), and so on. The likely rejection reason then comes out arbitrary, and obfuscated. Few people just say "not my area" before you even start. The startup founders are now wasting their time in 95% of the cases, unless they come with a sexy background and then investors are just piling up.

Wouldn't that be a lot more efficient if investors just referred unknown companies to a buddy who knows the domain area? I don't see it happening. Am I looking in the wrong place?

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:19PM (#10954935)
> Wouldn't that be a lot more efficient if investors just referred unknown companies to a buddy who knows the domain area?

That definitely happens. Most angels or VCs have a domain they are interested in and outside of that they will simply not participate or refer. Happened to me less than a week ago so definitely this occurs and fairly frequently.

> I don't see it happening.

It depends on how close to the fire you're sitting and who you are talking to I guess. In my 'backyard' it happens, frequently and the number of times that a deal is not even looked at is high enough that I never even thought this might somehow be special.

Another thing that will happen is that the party that did the referral will still take part in the round but at a much lower level.

This is a very fluid world you're trying to capture, local customers, connections and cliques will make up a lot of the background for such deals and you'd have to take all of those into account when you try to factor something like this into your worldview.

Personally I'd rather not see angels lose their shirt in areas that are not their domain,better if that money gets spent a bit wiser and on things that they understand.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DenisM on Saturday January 23, 2016 @03:03AM (#10957631)
My hunch is that most angels have random deals come to them, and most of those not being the specialty of this person, get tossed aside.

Then there is a group of angels who tag-team, and if one finds a deal he can't grasp, he would redirect to another member of the team. 12 people cold cover an area of expertise that's 12 times larger.

At least that's what I think should be happening... Does it?

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by jacquesm on Saturday January 23, 2016 @07:07PM (#10960777)
Yes, pretty much. A single angel investing without a network is in dangerous territory, but that's the exception, not the rule. Most angels do have a network, that's also how you find them in the first place.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by DenisM on Saturday January 23, 2016 @08:25PM (#10961029)
Perhaps the world is different, more optimal, in your neck of the woods. We've seen our share of angels coming up with all kinds of reasons to bail out, and never seen one saying "oh jeez, supply chain management is not my thing, let me ask Bob - he likes this stuff". I doubt they all knew the supply chain well enough to judge, but judge they did.

I hear what you're saying, it all makes sense. I just don't see it unfolding before my eyes.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by forgetsusername on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:08AM (#10946135)
>But valuations are so frothy right now that it's difficult to tell the strong companies from the ones that won't survive "when the tide goes out."

There seems to be some contradiction here: you seem to say valuations don't matter, but also that you're worried about them. How do valuations prevent you from spotting a good company?

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by rdlecler1 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:08PM (#10948828)
The more money that flows to the sector the more of a magnet it is for sociopaths and I don't think many of us are very good at dealing with sociopaths. You mentioned fraud, care to give some examples (no need to name names of course).
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by api on Thursday January 21, 2016 @05:29PM (#10949012)
I've seen some things I'd have to tone down to sell as believable fiction, and this was several years ago doing consulting for startups.

Standard issue asshattery include things like:

- Paper-thin mock up demos of a product being misrepresented as actual finished sale-able product. Sorry but the V in MVP stands for viable.

- Impressive people are touted as employees, even co-founders, and when you go talk to them it's news to them. Maybe they had a conversation with said founder once and expressed some interest and suddenly to investors and others they are the CTO. Sometimes this arises from the founder(s) being so narcissistic that they simply assume that anyone would of course feel privileged to join them. Why wouldn't they?

- Company/founder has sales/vendor relationship with other companies and misrepresents those products as "theirs," implying that they actually own them. In one case I saw rebranding without permission, which is flat out fraud.

- Signups/trials/downloads misrepresented as active continuous users or free users counted together with paid users.

- Lying about educational or work background. A skilled blowhard will do so in an ambiguous way, e.g. "went to MIT" means "attended one workshop there and read a lot of open courseware."

- Products that would violate known laws of physics or proven mathematical theorems. (Or sometimes even grade school math...)

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by anon8418 on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:01PM (#10950476)
> - Products that would violate known laws of physics or proven mathematical theorems. (Or sometimes even grade school math...)

Drop-Kicker just covered one such startup: http://drop-kicker.com/2016/01/ampy-move-teardown-and-review...

This is from three PHD engineering students from Northwestern.... over $1.5MM raised via Kickstarter and investors.

Hard to believe the founders (remember PHDs) are so naive to actually believe in their own advertising claims.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by api on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:30PM (#10954597)
Wow. After reading that I personally call fraud. Even if there is any real tech behind the scenes, these people obviously didn't ship it to their Kickstarter backers. They hoodwinked Kickstarter as a source of easy money and then immediately turned that into VC backing.

Using people that way is textbook sociopathy. People are rungs on a ladder to be stomped on. Unfortunately it works. People fall for it again and again because they don't scratch the surface enough to see what's actually there.

Anyone interested in investing should take note of a few things here: highfalutin college degrees, patents (you can patent a cheese sandwich) or "patent pending" (which is trivial and meaningless), and unsupported claims of novelty are not reliable indicators of anything.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by cookiecaper on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:59PM (#10946973)
>I do think that there will still be plenty of capital ready to be given to companies, investors are just going to be more selective (read: cautious) about it, which may very well change the growth and success potential of certain more dubious business models in the valley.

With so many SV companies that have hit it big without any real idea on how they're going to make money some day, it'd be interesting to hear what passes for a "dubious business model" out there.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by paulpauper on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:44AM (#10945074)
It's easy to separate the potential winners from the losers though. Start-ups that deal with hardware and other physical stuff tend to fare much worse than apps and software.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by dsacco on Thursday January 21, 2016 @08:54AM (#10945119)
I think that analysis is too one-dimensional - it's not meaningful enough for me to simply say "hardware startups are probably bad and software startups are probably good." That's not a complete picture, even if it's true that successful startups are not evenly distributed between hardware and software, because all the other factors of startup success are not evenly co-distributed between hardware and software. It is merely one dimension of risk analysis.

In the United States, ~32,000 people die annually in car accidents. In New York, ~1200 people die annually in car accidents. I live in New York. Which statistic do I pay attention to? Does it influence my analysis of total vehicular accidents that New York has a much higher population density than most of the country? Am I more likely to die in New York or somewhere else?

What is the startup building? What is the existing market the product? What experience and domain knowledge do the founders have? How far along are they? Who are their actual and potential customers?

That's the first five minutes of a due diligence conversation. If it were so easy to divide potential winners from virtually certain losers, people would hedge so well they would lose almost nothing and most angel investors would become rich. The reality is very different.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by bsder on Thursday January 21, 2016 @04:18PM (#10948452)
> Start-ups that deal with hardware and other physical stuff tend to fare much worse than apps and software.

I'm not sure I buy this.

Maybe on Kickstarter, et al. I do, because most of the people trying to do hardware there are hobbyists who have never actually shipped a product and so have highly unrealistic expectations. My baseline for a hardware Kickstarter is "Take the Bill of Materials and Multiply by 3--if that isn't retail price they're in big trouble."

Hardware startups take quite a bit more money to get running. However, once they do, you tend to have a very strong customer base and a less assailable position. They have hardware after all--3 guys and a dog can't just clone them.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by CPLX on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:26AM (#10945771)
> However, I'm not at all concerned about the stock market. That has never influenced my decision to fund a company.

You may be the exceptional person who has no assets whatsoever tied up in the stock market, but nearly every investor who has the resources to be an angel will have money in the market.

When the market falls they have less money. They use money to invest in things. The correlation between the market and seed stage investing should be fairly direct and clear.

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by frandroid on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:45PM (#10948169)
It depends if the investor pulls their money out of the market when things start to shake down, or if they have some insights that would push them to do so ahead of a downturn. If they do, they might have _more_ money than usual to invest during a market downturn. Also, as a VC, your money is in a variety of startups that can crest even when the rest of the market goes sideways. Shopify had its IPO this year, others have been bought by the big guys, so their investors are now flush with new money. I mean if we have another big recession, there's going to be an investment chill so even an investor with cash to spare will have trouble finding partners to invest with. But we're not there yet.
Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by criddell on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:04AM (#10946101)
> The correlation between the market and seed stage investing should be fairly direct and clear.

The money can only be in one place at a time though. If you pull money out of publicly traded stocks, wouldn't that mean you have more money for angel activities? Although, when the market is way down, that's a great buying opportunity, so is that when angel investors stop putting money into startups and instead go on a stock buying spree?

Re:As Angel Investors Pull Back, Valuations Take a Hit by CPLX on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:39PM (#10946823)
You're arguing that they are substitute assets for each other that might move reciprocally, like stocks and bonds are. But equity at seed stage and public stage are the same asset class at different levels and move more in tandem.

My argument was more about the wealth effect though, which is that a crash in stocks makes Angels poorer and thus less likely to invest in risky startups.