News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by exolymph on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @05:58PM (#10934760)
This is flogging an old argument, but shouldn't users' choices be respected? They (we) don't seem to want freedom.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:08PM (#10934818)
Users want freedom to not be forced to use just free stuff, which is quite different. In a hypothetical country, one could be forced just to use proper GPL'd open source software. It wouldn't be a free country, even if the software itself was free.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by thatcat on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:22PM (#10934902)
>it wouldn't be a free country

Arguing that the freedom to restrictively licensing your software is more freedom than using GPL because it requires unrestricted future access is analogous to arguing that one should be tolerant of intolerance because that is the more tolerant action.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by meric on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:59PM (#10935074)
Yes and being intolerant of intolerance is to become intolerant ourselves. I have a strong distaste for those who are intolerant of the intolerant, even more so than those who are merely intolerant, but I tolerate them.

It's analogous to saying people who murder murderers are murderers. Which is true.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by JadeNB on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @08:24PM (#10935419)
> I have a strong distaste for those who are intolerant of the intolerant, even more so than those who are merely intolerant

Wait, seriously? So, if someone says "I don't want my kids ever to meet gay people", and I say "I don't want my kids ever to meet that guy", then you feel that I'm more in the wrong?

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by meric on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @08:41PM (#10935489)
Yes. The first person is showing prejudice with an exclusionary attitude. The second person is showing exactly the same while being self-righteous about it. The first person is prejudiced against gays based on his own experience growing up as well as his ignorance. The first person is being who they are. The second person is doing what they are doing because that's what society is telling them to do. (Of course if the second person is the gay person the first person is prejudiced against, then I would sympathise with them instead because they was the target of the first person's prejudice). And to think you're good when you're judging people with the same attitude to align with society's prevailing morals is distasteful to me. But I understand it and I will still let my kids meet you. It's human nature to follow the crowd.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by JadeNB on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @10:44PM (#10935931)
> The second person is doing what they are doing because that's what society is telling them to do.

I have a suspicion that we have totally different ways of thinking about this, so our disagreement might be about the axioms rather than their consequences, in which case it's probably useless on both sides for us to argue; but I would like to have one more go, to see if our disagreement is really so fundamental.

Why is it valid to say automatically that someone who is intolerant of homophobia is just doing what society is telling him or her to do? Indeed I'd say to the contrary that there are many societies where homophobia is the normal attitude, so that being intolerant of it is very much going against societal norms.

Even if I'm in a society where homosexuals are (correctly) treated as equals, then describing as simple conformity my revulsion at an attempt to treat them unequally seems to be extremely uncharitable. Why not simply say that I, too, am "being who I am", because of my upbringing or any other reason?

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by meric on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @11:15PM (#10936056)
I have a suspicion that we have totally different ways of thinking about this, so our disagreement might be about the axioms rather than their consequences, in which case it's probably useless on both sides for us to argue; but I would like to have one more go, to see if our disagreement is really so fundamental.

Okay. Let's try that.

Why is it valid to say automatically that someone who is intolerant of homophobia is just doing what society is telling him or her to do? Indeed I'd say to the contrary that there are many societies where homophobia is the normal attitude, so that being intolerant of it is very much going against societal norms.

That's a good question. If we were in such a society, the annoyance I have for people who follows the crowd and do not think for themselves would not apply to you.

Even if I'm in a society where homosexuals are (correctly) treated as equals, then describing as simple conformity my revulsion at an attempt to treat them unequally seems to be extremely uncharitable. Why not simply say that I, too, am "being who I am", because of my upbringing or any other reason?

I have distaste for the intolerant of the intolerant, because on one hand, they know the harm intolerance can cause in society, and on the other, they engage in the very same intolerance they know causes harm, and then they have the gall to tell people they are morally superior. That is knowingly causing harm, and then tricking people into thinking they're tolerating - all it provokes is the very same intolerance in other people, and the very same impulse to disguise this intolerance in others. The intolerant have a passive effect of reducing society's tolerance, which have the consequence of suffering in individuals. The intolerant of the intolerant have the same passive effect, except they're now knowingly partaking in this activity.

The intolerance of the intolerant makes the following situation possible: "Don't talk to that man, he is a misogynist! Oh by the way I hate misogynists. :)". Intolerance in society allows possible situations where simple label will smear the reputation of someone in other's minds for life, before people get to really know who the person is.

And that's the core problem of prejudice, isn't it?

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by JadeNB on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @01:23PM (#10940154)
EDIT: As I look at my closing paragraph, I see that it comes across as rather dismissive, and I apologise for that. Let me clarify up front that, though I disagree with you, I appreciate and respect your reasoned arguments, and your willingness to continue arguing civilly and rationally.

> > Indeed I'd say to the contrary that there are many societies where homophobia is the normal attitude ….

> … If we were in such a society, the annoyance I have for people who follows the crowd and do not think for themselves would not apply to you.

If you are not in such a society, then you live in a happier world, or at least society, than I do—in particular, one where Antonin Scalia is not a Supreme-Court justice.

> I have distaste for the intolerant of the intolerant, because on one hand, they know the harm intolerance can cause in society, and on the other, they engage in the very same intolerance they know causes harm, and then they have the gall to tell people they are morally superior.

I think that certainly there are people who are smug about their intolerance of intolerance, just as there are people who are smug about their intolerance of homosexuality—used as a running example just because it's what I started with, not because I think it's the only kind of intolerance. However, I don't see why it's unfair for me simply to be repulsed by intolerance, without having my repulsion automatically judged to be artificial, and in service of some ulterior motive.

I agree that the fact that I am repulsed by something that (in my opinion, to be sure!) is actually morally bankrupt, as opposed to someone else's by something that is not, doesn't make me a better person; but I don't think that it makes me worse, either. That, and possibly also what seems to be your blanket assumption that intolerance of intolerance can only be in service of some agenda (and not a genuine emotional or intellectual reaction), I think is where we do, and may simply have to agree to continue to, differ.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by meric on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:48PM (#10941986)
You can be repulsed with someone and still tolerate them. If you operate a shop, you continue to sell to them. If you're friends with their employer, don't tell your friend to fire them. If you are neighbors, you continue to acknowledge their existence when they greet you. And you let your kids play with their kids, so that your values diffuse outwards. When they try to engage you, you give them your attention. If they're homophobic but at the same time they do a good deed, you continue to praise them. When an opportunity arises for you to explain to them, with compassion and respect, their ignorance, you take it up. If you partake in these activities rather than ostracise them from your society, you are tolerating them, repulsion or no. A person who was brought up a racist, but have the attribute of tolerance, will continue to engage the target of his prejudice, and eventually learn of his own prejudice, and his repulsion would be cleared. Tolerance connects a person to reality - it gives a chance for reality to affect change in the person, and vice versa. This is how tolerance can increase society's tolerance. If you wanted to change the world for the better, I think it works better than ostracising and locking up the intolerant.

Tolerance means accepting something is part of your reality, even when you don't like it. If tolerating means accepting something only if you like it, it wouldn't be called tolerance...:)

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by thatcat on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @10:07PM (#10935812)
>The second person is showing exactly the same while being self-righteous about it

The first person is ignorant, the second person is annoyed with ignorance. Ignorance isn't the same as being in a minority group. There's no human right to remain ignorant.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by meric on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @10:13PM (#10935829)
If you were merely annoyed with someone and letting that be, then you tolerate them.

Everyone is always ignorant of something, you and I included. Human rights doesn't come into this. It's people pretending to be ignorant of nothing who I'm wary of.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by thatcat on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @11:11PM (#10936039)
The which is freeer software decision and whether to tolerate the intolerant or not are both a paradox. You can't know whether you're enabling a net increase in freedom/tolerance or decreasing it because you're doing both and won't know the result until its too late. Either decision, like choosing any value, requires a moral compromise based on the realities of the situation.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by meric on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @11:30PM (#10936089)
I agree with this statement - I don't think they're analogous because each situation has a different reality. It's like saying "As a submarine commander, you should be able to command this space shuttle because flying a shuttle is just like commanding a submarine - both vehicles are surrounded by a hostile environment." But of course we know the two environments are not analogous like that - they have different realities.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by thatcat on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @11:59PM (#10936164)
Commercial software licenses and intolerance are both a result of the self interest of the individual in society and are a defensive measure that protects individual values from community over reach. GPL and enforcing-tolerance are based on community values that protect a shared interest against the interests of individuals.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by ralmidani on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:27PM (#10934929)
Exactly. Being pro-freedom does not mean allowing someone to take away the freedoms of others.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by ralmidani on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:09PM (#10934830)
The success of GNU/Linux, Postgres, Python, Django, Ruby, Rails, Node, Wordpress, jQuery, Bootstrap, Ember, etc. suggests otherwise.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by fsloth on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @02:26AM (#10936509)
I see good non-programming specific open source tools far more unlikely than programming related ones. There are some good ones, but not many.

All of those projects which you listed are more or less programming or web-content related - for which the domain knowledge is readily available among the people who enjoy working in open source. One needs domain experts in the particular domain to implement successful software.

Domain experts are motivated by money, peer reputation, and improvement in ones domain. Two of these are readily available in FOSS projects, and becoming a developer in a reputable FOSS project also improves ones career prospects financially quite considerably.

So, for a programmer, participating in a FOSS project is quite appealing.

Now take some other domain, like music. First, if ones peers are likely to be more or less ignorant of software development, they really cannot appreciate the effort an expert places on developing a software. They may find it interesting, but not as admirable as progressing in ones own domain. Secondly, while developing software may give insights in ones problem area, it's not directly related to her craft. Take a hypothetical composer - which is a more appreciated thing, him doing a composition, or testing/speccing some new compositional software. Thirdly, domain experts seldom gain any obvious financial benefit or participating in open source software (I'm talking about the dominating dynamics, not special cases).

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by ethanbond on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:18PM (#10934880)
The success of Wolfram suggests otherwise, actually.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by thatcat on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:33PM (#10934959)
what is the adoption rate of wolfram? Are there any use cases outside of demonstration/education where python wouldn't work better?
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by ethanbond on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:39PM (#10934988)
You're missing the point. If people demanded that Wolfram were open, then it would be either a) open or b) gone.

The fact that it's neither of those would suggest that people don't want it open badly enough. Listing off projects that are open to show that people like open things is absolutely irrelevant.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by yarou on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @09:58PM (#10935780)
I'm sure there are people in the past that wanted Windoze to become "open" (whatever that means, you don't specify in your argument). But Windoze is neither open nor gone.

You're forgetting the third and much more realistic option: that people will come together and create a substitute that far surpasses the original, because of the naturally collaborative nature of free software.

Wolfram the computational engine is a hosted solution, so there's very little point to "opening" that, business continuity reasons aside.

Mathematica I don't know much about, but afaik serious engineers, mathematicians and physicists use MATLAB generally. There's more of a shift to using R and Julia nowadays but academics are notoriously stubborn when it comes to using software, regardless of its quality.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by JadeNB on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @08:22PM (#10935409)
> If people demanded that Wolfram were open, then it would be either a) open or b) gone.

That seems a bit like saying that, if people demanded that North Korea were open, then it would be either (a) open or (b) gone. Of course, the lock-in to a software package is less than the lock-in to a country, but at a certain point it is not totally absurd to say that it is effectively impossible to switch.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by ethanbond on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @11:00AM (#10938954)
You mean to say the lock in of a dictatorial military state is slightly more problematic than the lock in of downloading a different piece of software?
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by JadeNB on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @01:28PM (#10940198)
I guess this is sarcasm? I didn't say 'slightly'; certainly it is much more problematic. Obviously, the comparison is hyperbolic, but I don't think so much so that it is valueless. (On an uncharitable personal note, I'm not so sure that comparing Wolfram's own ambitions directly to a dictator's is all that exaggerated.)
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by ralmidani on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @06:56PM (#10935060)
You missed my point. The argument made by exolymph was users do not want freedom. I listed projects which are among the best and most popular in their class, in no small part due to their respect of users' freedom.
Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by nickpsecurity on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @08:24PM (#10935417)
Were those Wolfram's users? And did they reject his app in favor of the free alternatives?

I think your point is missing the point. The market of people who just want a solution to work and be easy to use is much, much larger than the market that explicitly demands BSD or GPL-style freedom. Wolfram serves the former. Makes more money that way, too.

Re:Announcing Wolfram Programming Lab by thatcat on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @07:28PM (#10935182)
Right, I was trying to say that it's no more capable and seems objectively worse as a programming language. Don't get me wrong, it looks like a comprehensive learning library but why learn a language that isn't used for production software?

People don't "like open things" because of marketing hype, they just tend use the most useful things. Collaboration in programming is a feature. If no other projects on github are written in "wolfram language", then learning to program doesn't really enable you to do as much.