Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by motters on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:24PM
(#1092823)
Obama deserves kudos for this. Lowering the cost of access to space by introducing commercial rocketry is a step in the right direction, which will facilitate many other things in future. Going back to the moon in a craft almost identical to Apollo would have represented neither a science nor an engineering advance.
This could be the beginning of the end of grandstanding "national prestige" space projects, and the start of an expansion in human activities in space.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by Empact on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:09PM
(#1092972)
We're just as well without it. Absent accountability via serious attention from higher-ups or the constituents themselves, bureaucracies tend to devolve into inefficient, unproductive jobs programs, and NASA is no exception: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=770268
The future of space travel will come from organizations with the accountability to properly motivate them to succeed. I, for one, welcome a future of private space flight.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by sketerpot on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:37PM
(#1093044)
The budget is also increasing NASA support for (or dependence on) private spaceflight companies for their rocketry needs. SpaceX's Dragon space capsule has a manned configuration, and the Falcon 9 rocket is due to make its first orbital launch in the next one to three months. Manned spaceflight is not dying.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by thegrossman on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:40PM
(#1093240)
Actually, Lockheed is the company that is designing and building the Orion spacecraft. Which is why this whole thing is slightly confusing... NASA does very little design and construction of their own hardware. At least on paper, our manned space program is privatized.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by maxklein on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:49PM
(#1092908)
Humans should not be going to the moon at this point in time for exploration. We should focus on robots going to the moon - spending that money on developing robots will have a much larger benefit than spending the money trying to keep a human safe. We'll develop advanced controlling and communication systems for this.
You can send a robot to the moon and leave him there - a human has to come back. That's an uneccessary expense.
When we have enough robots on the moon they can build the structures neccessary to support human life there.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by ErrantX on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:40PM
(#1093052)
Indeed this is the logical choice.
But the beauty of humanity is we prefer to reach for extraordinary things. I bet a large number of people would still love to send manned missions to the Moon.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by waterlesscloud on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:09PM
(#1093145)
If we'd had a human on Mars for the last 5 years, they would have covered many, many, many times as much territory as the robots have, and in far more detail.
Yes, it would have been incredibly expensive, but it would have been infinitely better from a science perspective. Which is my point.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by ricree on Monday February 01, 2010 @02:25PM
(#1093187)
A human on mars could certainly have covered more territory than the robots did, but the expense would have been several orders of magnitude more.
Had those billions been spent on robotic explorers, they would also have outperformed the relatively cheap robots that we actually have on the surface.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by designtofly on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:13PM
(#1092989)
I certainly consider this bad news. I know there's a lot of people on here who poo-poo manned spaceflight as needlessly expensive and unnecessary. But let me say this, manned flight (both air and space) as inspiration is the number one reason that I'm an aerospace engineer today. I know I'm not alone in this. While moves like these make economic sense in the short term, I have no doubt that in the long term, they will rob this industry of talented and inspired people... in some ways, the lack of progress in aerospace in the last 30 years already has shown this to be true.
I'd rather the administration issue grand challenges in all fields (especially aerospace) in order to inspire us today and future generations. Having an inspired workforce is the most critical challenge and essential to continued success and growth in any field.
edited to add: In case it wasn't clear, my point is that there is no way I'd be an aerospace engineer today if the aerospace vehicles and missions in my youth were unmanned/robotic. Yes, robotics is "cool"... but it's not even in the same league as manned flight when it comes to inspiration for me.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by ajross on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:56PM
(#1092930)
Because they're cutting something dumb in favor of funding good science?
FWIW, from numbers (the stuff you skipped, I suspect) in the article: a $6B increase over a $19B budget over 5 years comes to about a 5.6% increase per year. That's just barely above the overall (typical) yearly change in federal revenue.
All budgets increase over time, because federal revenue increases due to inflation and GDP growth (itself due to fundamental population increase). So increasing funding by itself is never news; the news is about changes in what kinds of things are funded. Thus the headline.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by seldo on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:14PM
(#1092793)
As a pretty die-hard Obama supporter and also a huge geek, this is a tough one for me. The change in funding priorities gives us another 5 years of funding for the ISS of course, which is by far the greater achievement than landing on the mood yet again. And the greater funding for private space flight is also an excellent idea.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by DannoHung on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:25PM
(#1092830)
Maybe this is just me, but I was never terribly keen on another Moon landing. In general, I'm not interested in further manned space exploration unless it contributes to establishing an industrial presence in space.
Probes and robots are doing a pretty damned good job at exploratory science.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by gamble on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:52PM
(#1092919)
The moon has never made any sense as a stepping stone to Mars. Why truck fuel and materiel down a gravity well, only to bring it right back out again? Nor would the Apollo-redux spacecraft suitable to a moon mission be useful for a trip to Mars.
A realistic Mars mission would consist of a spacecraft assembled in earth orbit, then flown directly to Mars. However, the technology required to get a human crew to Mars and bring them back alive is so far beyond what we have now that the moon-as-a-stepping-stone plan is more of a way to avoid confronting the problems than a way to solve them.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by ajross on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:50PM
(#1092911)
You have a cite for that decade number? Seems silly to me, given that we've already been to the moon, and over 40 years ago at that. Surely we should be at Neptune at least by now, no? :)
More seriously: what is the value of a Mars mission that we should be paying for it? There's no meaningful science to be done there (vs. what can be done via much cheaper means, anyway), just lots of eye candy and fantasy material for wannabe astronauts.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by briansmith on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:39PM
(#1092876)
We shouldn't be wasting $3 billion a week in Iraq. But, we shouldn't be wasting $2 billion a year to go to the moon either. AFAICT, there's no significant scientific justification for people to go to the moon or to Mars at this time. Robots can go instead. Previous robot-based Mars missions have been very successful--except for the ones that would have killed everybody on board if they were manned.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by ajross on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:46PM
(#1092897)
Absolutely. This was dumb, and quite frankly a cynical bread-and-circus idea in the first place. There was never any meaningful scientific justification for the project (nor the Mars one that was announced simultaneously).
Although the grandparent post is right: relative to other wastes in our government (the Iraq war being by far the biggest discretionary one), this is small potatoes. But $8B is $8B, and it means it doesn't have to be cut elsewhere.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by DannoHung on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:12PM
(#1092982)
GAH, why does Hacker News cut off replies at certain points?
This is a response to the child of this post talking about Chinese moon missions:
My thoughts will entirely depend on just what space development we have done in the intervening years. If some company is beginning an asteroid surveying mission or there is an orbital construction platform, I'm not going to give two damns about what the Chinese are doing with flags. Good for them!
If we are going to spend money on space we should stop thinking in terms of spectacle.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by sailormoon on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:34PM
(#1093035)
Here's a trick: if you click the direct link to the post, you can reply there without any cutoffs :D
And hey, I agree. If Team USA is building orbital platforms and doing asteroid surveys by then, then I will be utterly delighted.
If, however, because of our lack of long-term vision and misplaced priorities, the space exploration arena comes to be utterly dominated by India, Russia, China, the EU and Japan, then I think I will be justified in lamenting the failings of leadership in my own country I perceive today. Well, I'm not even American actually (though I have family who are), but y'know, I feel a sort of inter-westerner kinship ...
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by sailormoon on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:08PM
(#1092963)
quite frankly a cynical bread-and-circus idea
That may well be the truth. But at least it's a circus founded on science and engineering.
The Chinese will be on the moon in a decade minimum, two maximum. When you're sitting at home with the rest of the world watching a large chinese flag being placed on the moon in hi-def colour, what thoughts do you think will be going through your head? I bet it's not "boy, I'm glad we didn't waste that $8 billion back in the day!".
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by sailormoon on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:54PM
(#1092925)
The original space program paid for itself many times over with multiple technological and engineering advances which benefited the larger economy. One study I saw estimated the dividend as seven-fold, but that seems very low to me.
Money spent in technological and engineering development is rarely wasted. And frankly I reckon $8b is worth it in PR benefit alone.
Robots don't cut it. There's an irreplaceable excitement in seeing actual living breathing humans doing something incredible. At a time where inspiration and hope is sorely needed - and especially in the fields of science, technology and engineering - cutting the space program seems extraordinarily short-sighted.
You could make a valid point that NASA is not the agency for the job, but since the USG seems intent on pissing away every borrowed yuan it can find as fast as possible, I guess I just wish they'd piss it into something I can believe in once in a while.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by briansmith on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:10PM
(#1092975)
I don't want government to turn a profit. And, government shouldn't be in the excitement/inspiration/hope business.
When NASA started, private space exploration was unimaginable. Now, it seems very realistic. It's time to free the engineers at NASA from government bureaucracy by moving them to private industry. The profits/advances from space exploration can stand or fall on their own merit.
Re:Obama axes NASA moon plan in new budget
by sailormoon on Monday February 01, 2010 @01:20PM
(#1093003)
I don't want government to turn a profit.
If the purpose of government isn't to guide a nation to increased prosperity, what is it?
Every activity the government undertakes should be with an eye to creating the conditions for future prosperity. Public schooling. Secure borders. Fair and equitable laws. And investment, on a grand scale, in technological progress, like the internet we're using right now.
If anything I get wary when the government deviates from that goal. But never fear - if there's one thing the US Government is not doing right now, it's turning a profit.
This could be the beginning of the end of grandstanding "national prestige" space projects, and the start of an expansion in human activities in space.
In other words, after the last few shuttle missions this year, the United States will no longer have a manned space program.
Right or wrong, this is devastating news to me.
The future of space travel will come from organizations with the accountability to properly motivate them to succeed. I, for one, welcome a future of private space flight.
History indicates it's the Lockheeds of the country that NASA will turning to.
I'd agree that recent history has shown they turn to the Lockheeds
You can send a robot to the moon and leave him there - a human has to come back. That's an uneccessary expense.
When we have enough robots on the moon they can build the structures neccessary to support human life there.
But the beauty of humanity is we prefer to reach for extraordinary things. I bet a large number of people would still love to send manned missions to the Moon.
Yes, it would have been incredibly expensive, but it would have been infinitely better from a science perspective. Which is my point.
Had those billions been spent on robotic explorers, they would also have outperformed the relatively cheap robots that we actually have on the surface.
I'd rather the administration issue grand challenges in all fields (especially aerospace) in order to inspire us today and future generations. Having an inspired workforce is the most critical challenge and essential to continued success and growth in any field.
edited to add: In case it wasn't clear, my point is that there is no way I'd be an aerospace engineer today if the aerospace vehicles and missions in my youth were unmanned/robotic. Yes, robotics is "cool"... but it's not even in the same league as manned flight when it comes to inspiration for me.
FWIW, from numbers (the stuff you skipped, I suspect) in the article: a $6B increase over a $19B budget over 5 years comes to about a 5.6% increase per year. That's just barely above the overall (typical) yearly change in federal revenue.
All budgets increase over time, because federal revenue increases due to inflation and GDP growth (itself due to fundamental population increase). So increasing funding by itself is never news; the news is about changes in what kinds of things are funded. Thus the headline.
Still: it would have been nice to go to the moon.
Probes and robots are doing a pretty damned good job at exploratory science.
A realistic Mars mission would consist of a spacecraft assembled in earth orbit, then flown directly to Mars. However, the technology required to get a human crew to Mars and bring them back alive is so far beyond what we have now that the moon-as-a-stepping-stone plan is more of a way to avoid confronting the problems than a way to solve them.
More seriously: what is the value of a Mars mission that we should be paying for it? There's no meaningful science to be done there (vs. what can be done via much cheaper means, anyway), just lots of eye candy and fantasy material for wannabe astronauts.
The orion crew capsule was part of the Constellation program. Same technology and innovations to bring the astronauts to the moon.
$8 billion over four years to go to the frickin' moon - too expensive!
Go figure.
Although the grandparent post is right: relative to other wastes in our government (the Iraq war being by far the biggest discretionary one), this is small potatoes. But $8B is $8B, and it means it doesn't have to be cut elsewhere.
This is a response to the child of this post talking about Chinese moon missions:
My thoughts will entirely depend on just what space development we have done in the intervening years. If some company is beginning an asteroid surveying mission or there is an orbital construction platform, I'm not going to give two damns about what the Chinese are doing with flags. Good for them!
If we are going to spend money on space we should stop thinking in terms of spectacle.
And hey, I agree. If Team USA is building orbital platforms and doing asteroid surveys by then, then I will be utterly delighted.
If, however, because of our lack of long-term vision and misplaced priorities, the space exploration arena comes to be utterly dominated by India, Russia, China, the EU and Japan, then I think I will be justified in lamenting the failings of leadership in my own country I perceive today. Well, I'm not even American actually (though I have family who are), but y'know, I feel a sort of inter-westerner kinship ...
That may well be the truth. But at least it's a circus founded on science and engineering.
The Chinese will be on the moon in a decade minimum, two maximum. When you're sitting at home with the rest of the world watching a large chinese flag being placed on the moon in hi-def colour, what thoughts do you think will be going through your head? I bet it's not "boy, I'm glad we didn't waste that $8 billion back in the day!".
Maybe instead of thinking "Damn, there's a Chinese person on the moon!" we should think "Wow, there's a person on the moon!" and then maybe "But why?"
What will dismay me is the short-term thinking that led us to squander our lead in the first place.
And as for "why" .. why do anything? "Because it's there".
Money spent in technological and engineering development is rarely wasted. And frankly I reckon $8b is worth it in PR benefit alone.
Robots don't cut it. There's an irreplaceable excitement in seeing actual living breathing humans doing something incredible. At a time where inspiration and hope is sorely needed - and especially in the fields of science, technology and engineering - cutting the space program seems extraordinarily short-sighted.
You could make a valid point that NASA is not the agency for the job, but since the USG seems intent on pissing away every borrowed yuan it can find as fast as possible, I guess I just wish they'd piss it into something I can believe in once in a while.
What is the dividend of leaving billions of dollars in American's pockets?
The answer is: minus six times the program cost.
When NASA started, private space exploration was unimaginable. Now, it seems very realistic. It's time to free the engineers at NASA from government bureaucracy by moving them to private industry. The profits/advances from space exploration can stand or fall on their own merit.
If the purpose of government isn't to guide a nation to increased prosperity, what is it?
Every activity the government undertakes should be with an eye to creating the conditions for future prosperity. Public schooling. Secure borders. Fair and equitable laws. And investment, on a grand scale, in technological progress, like the internet we're using right now.
If anything I get wary when the government deviates from that goal. But never fear - if there's one thing the US Government is not doing right now, it's turning a profit.