I am assuming SF considers a bike a vehicle so fair game I guess. But you cannot just beat up or arrest someone just because they refuse to show their ID. You cannot assume suspicion because they won't tell you who they are. You're essentially saying if you got nothing to hide, you shouldn't worry about telling police who you are.
One time I found a wallet on a sidewalk, I picked it up, saw there was ID. The police station was nearby so I drove to turn it in. When a cop showed up (the station was closed for the night), I explained to him that I found a wallet and was turning it in. He asked me a couple questions and asked me if I wanted to leave contact information, I hesitated, and eventually after the officer assured me he didn't care, I said, "no." But during that moment I seriously considered whether or not I had to assert my right to remain anonymous/not show ID, especially since I was just trying to be a good Samaritan, and didn't want to deal with any possible accusation of stealing money from the wallet (it was empty).
That's the real law everywhere in the world. It's the law in China and it's the law in the US.
Can you refuse to show your ID to the cops? Can you say to the officer, "Am I being detained?" Don't just regard what the letter of some document says. Regard the subtle law with the subtle calculus.
Probably no (in practice), if you're black or Latino or lower class white. Or anybody, in a drug-dealing neighborhood.
Can you refuse to show your ID to the cops?
Outside of cause supported by reasonable suspicion OR driving a vehicle, yes (under case law). But your average beat cop may not know that (or care). "Am I being detained?"
To avoid certain ambiguities, instead ask, "am I free to go?"This varies state to state. In many states you must identify yourself at the level of providing your name and address, but you are not required to produce any documentation.
The only exceptions are if you're in a vehicle
That's why he was stopped in the first place, for (allegedly) talking on his phone while riding. Doing so is a Vehicle Code violation. In CA, a bicycle on a public road is a vehicle subject to most provisions of the Vehicle Code.There's a saying about how bad the german cops got in the nazi era that you may have heard "papers please"-- this is literally asking for someone's id, usually without cause.
It's a sign of a police state-- a classic one.
http://www.bicyclelaw.com/road-rights/a.cfm/road-rights-iden...
In any case, this is all beside the point. No matter how much you think people should carry ID, it's not a legal requirement and certainly not a justification to beat someone so badly you put them in the hospital.
In fact, BART sought, and was allocated, funds specifically for security cameras... not unlike how PG&E charged ratepayers in San Mateo County for gas pipeline testing and replacement that never happened.
Everyone wants more body cams. let's get them to stop the speculation all the time.
on the police side though, more people need to understand that the cops ask people all the time for ID and they say they don't have it. In WAY TOO MANY cases they don't want to produce it because they have warrants for other things. Cops get people night after night on small offenses and they have warrants for bigger ones. Constantly. That's why he called in, because his experience is the guy is likely hiding something.
I can't imagine not carrying my ID around if I'm an adult. I have to produce it to make transactions.