Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito
by MaysonL on Saturday January 16, 2016 @07:15PM
(#10917537)
Can you refuse to show your ID to the cops?
Probably no (in practice), if you're black or Latino or lower class white. Or anybody, in a drug-dealing neighborhood.
Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito
by DrScump on Sunday January 17, 2016 @03:41AM
(#10918847)
Can you refuse to show your ID to the cops?
Outside of cause supported by reasonable suspicion OR driving a vehicle, yes (under case law). But your average beat cop may not know that (or care). "Am I being detained?"
To avoid certain ambiguities, instead ask, "am I free to go?"
That's the real law everywhere in the world. It's the law in China and it's the law in the US.
Can you refuse to show your ID to the cops? Can you say to the officer, "Am I being detained?" Don't just regard what the letter of some document says. Regard the subtle law with the subtle calculus.