News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by balls187 on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:19PM (#10913038)
John Oliver had a great piece on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks

In the US, where the constitution expressly prohibits it: that your property is seized w/o due process is complete and utter garbage.

By no means am I a right-wing/vigilante militia supporter, but this type of behavior from the police makes me support having a heavily armed citizenry.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by timonovici on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:45PM (#10913205)
How would heavily armed citizenry help solve the problem? Are you going to put a hole in the head of the officer who takes your cash out of your car? Won't that lead to anarchy or civil war, eventually? Maybe...consider changing the law, eh?
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by such_a_casual on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:08PM (#10913327)
>Won't that lead to anarchy or civil war, eventually?

Yes, hopefully (though hopefully not at the scale you may be imagining). Cops have turned into thugs in this country and something needs to be done about it. Maybe legalizing drugs would fix everything. I don't know. But cops in this country aren't even accountable for the people that they kill. There are no logs on how many murders are carried out by police.

Yes, they can take our property, including cash, for no reason (something like 90% of dollar bills test positive for traces of cocaine). And in this case all the officers had to do was say they smelled weed. I have been a victim of this "smell like weed" abuse myself, in which everyone in my vehicle was pulled out and searched. My vehicle was then searched without my permission. They found nothing and gave me a speeding ticket for going 5 miles over the speed limit.

But seizing our property means nothing when they can take our lives without the public knowing about it.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by d_t_w on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:37PM (#10913477)
Being heavily armed (and also being white) alters how the police treat you, the Oregon stand-off demonstrates as much.

There would likely also be a presumption, as a heavily armed white person, that you're extremely confident in your ability to recite the constitution, quite possibly spoiling for a fight to defend particular rights that you see enshrined in the constitution, that you will not submit to a warrantless search, and are even less likely to allow the police to steal your money.

You don't need to put holes in the police officers, they would profile you from a mile off and assume you're a red-neck nutbag who is potentially going to put holes in them, move along citizen there's nothing to see here.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:36PM (#10913739)
The Oregon stand-off just demonstrates that if you "occupy" buildings out in the middle of nowhere in the winter off-season the cops are going to ignore you and see if the cold convinces you to leave.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by pdkl95 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @06:40AM (#10915040)
Winter is the excuse, not the cause.

The situation in Oregon is larger than just this single incident. I recommend reading the report[1] put together by the SPLC on the previous incidents.

Page 9 of the report has photos of these militia scofflaws pointing rifles at federal and local law enforcement[2]. That show of force did get law enforcement to back off at the time. As for why the people involved still haven't been charged with - at a minimum - assault with a deadly weapon is another matter entirely that really needs to be remedied before those militia nutjobs escalate their tactics into a a reenactment of the Whiskey Rebellion..

When you strip away the usual political rhetoric an other distractions, the primary reason the Oregon stand-off didn't turn into a (possibly Waco-style) raid immediately is because the militia members are both white and conservative. We saw what happened to unarmed non-conservatives when the police started using CS gas on various Occupy Wall Street groups (e.g. the battles in Oakland). If the militia members were black or Muslim, the media would be calling them "terrorists" and the swat teams would have gone in shooting within the first day or two.

[1] https://www.splcenter.org/sites/default/files/d6_legacy_file...

[2] http://cdn.theatlantic.com/assets/media/img/mt/2014/04/RTR3L...

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:26PM (#10918273)
>When you strip away the usual political rhetoric an other distractions, the primary reason the Oregon stand-off didn't turn into a (possibly Waco-style) raid immediately is because the militia members are both white and conservative.

I don't believe that for a second. The government certainly didn't hold back at Waco or Ruby Ridge.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by pdkl95 on Sunday January 17, 2016 @02:42AM (#10918715)
> Waco

I should have included "mainstream xian" in that list.

> didn't hold back

I don't mean to imply that it's a perfect shield. There are numerous cases where the government has gone after more or less every subgroup. The point is that framing affects how people perceive a situation, which in turn affects how they respond.

What framing? Just look at the media. An example from today:

http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-oregon-mil...

    "The armed activists occupying a national wildlife refuge ..."
               ^^^^^^^^^

    "... took over the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge to protest ..."
                                                           ^^^^^^^
Do you really the same framing would be used if the people involved were black? If liberals took over a similar federal building as with firearms, do you really think they would still be called "activists" by the media? If they were Muslim, do you really think they would be getting the same low-key treatment by the FBI?
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Sunday January 17, 2016 @01:40PM (#10920399)
>Do you really the same framing would be used if the people involved were black? If liberals took over a similar federal building as with firearms, do you really think they would still be called "activists" by the media?

Yes, I do. Are you seriously going to pretend the press is more sympathetic to Christians?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by newjersey on Sunday January 17, 2016 @06:12PM (#10921552)
Are you seriously going to pretend that we're not? Come on man. We can't win this one. I mean we have a presidential candidate on stage defending bringing in only Xians as refugees.

I am as much intolerant of Muslims as anyone (PC be damned) but I don't think we have a leg to stand on here.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Monday January 18, 2016 @01:45AM (#10922940)
>Are you seriously going to pretend that we're not?

Remember Obama's remark about people "clinging to their guns and religion"? That's pretty insulting if you're a Christian (or a gun owner). He was still elected president. Twice.

Sure, numerically speaking there are a lot of Christians in the US. But they're not a majority and they don't control any part of the press, academia, or the government. The people running the executive branch (including Obama) are downright hostile to both whites and Christians.

Come springtime if those guys are still there ATF or the FBI will take the gloves off.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by newjersey on Monday January 18, 2016 @09:54AM (#10924669)
I wouldn't say these things. I'd like more blindness with regards to gender and race when it comes to government policies but I'm optimistic overall. I get that the candidates need to pander to minorities. That is OK. As the honorable mayor of new york will learn in a hard way, even a 90% approval rating among minorities is not enough to carry an election without support from whites.

I hate this fear you've succumbed to because I'm afraid it will be a self-fulfilling prophesy. We are destroying ourselves. Fear hurts us because it makes us follow lunatics and insincere people like Ted Cruz and Jeb Bush.

We need to take a step back and stop listening to fear mongerers. Of course, our work never ends. Of course, we need to push back to defend our rights. However, I don't see us pushing back. When we support antics like occupying a park office, we are not reaching out. We are withdrawing further. We are showing that we are afraid. Some dude not getting to graze his cattle in federal land is not a constitutional crisis much less a moral or religious one.

I equate it to me going to the NSA and demanding them that I be given a free vps on their servers. I mean clearly my taxes paid for the data centers...

I guess my point is if we stopped fearing and withdrawing into ourselves but rather tries to reach out then we will find a lot of the others will see what we really want isn't bad. However, we must discard the craziness and the insincerity. I think it will be a little easier to do that if we stop being afraid.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @05:02AM (#10929674)
>I hate this fear you've succumbed to...

You're reading something into my post that isn't there. What in the world are you talking about?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by newjersey on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @01:14PM (#10932578)
I may have been projecting. I apologize.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by bitwize on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:47PM (#10913531)
A growing number of police chiefs are starting to like armed citizens. Because if there's an active shooter like Colorado, San Bernardino, or Sandy Hook, armed citizens mean the guy is more likely to get popped before the police get in the line of fire.

Some officers are starting to embrace drug legalization too. This apparent upsurge in libertarian views among cops is almost enough to make me consider becoming a libertarian again. Cops adopt these stances because they think it makes their lives easier and safer. A stressed fearful cop is like a cornered animal: far more likely to lash out. So, more relaxed police = less police violence, better relations between the police and the citizenry.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Grishnakh on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:56AM (#10914433)
I really wonder if this isn't a case of people in different places being really different.

For instance, people here in the US say particular generalizations about "the Europeans" all the time, but there's a world of difference between the cultures of Spain, England, Sweden, Latvia, Greece, and Moldova (and Russia, which is part of Europe geographically).

So when you say some police chiefs like armed citizens, I really wonder where those chiefs are. I'm willing to bet good money the chiefs of NYPD, Chicago PD, LAPD, etc. are not among those chiefs. However, I can certainly see some police chief in some pop. 30k city being like that; I can also see the police in a random small city like that not having any real problems with police misbehavior; we're likely judging ALL police nationwide for actions of a lot of police who seem to mostly be in cities. Are the cops in rural North Dakota known by the people there to shoot unarmed people or beat people or steal from them?

Note also that I'm not claiming that it's only a small number of police that are bad cops; I think it varies by jurisdiction, and I think they stick up for each other and that a few obviously bad ones in a department probably indicate the entire department is bad (much like the old saying, "one bad apple spoils the entire bunch"). But not all police departments are the same, and again it seems we usually hear about problems in cities.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by bitwize on Saturday January 16, 2016 @06:23PM (#10917360)
One of the armed-citizen supporters is the chief of the Detroit PD.

Another is a former Cincinnati chief.

I dunno, make up your own mind.

And I was certainly not blaming all cops for police violence committed in the inner cities. The evidence we have to date suggests a pattern consistent with my statements that stressed out police officers who expect shit to go down at any minute are more likely to react with excessive violence. That's far more likely to be the situation in a major city. Police in rural and low-density areas are less likely to react this way.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by triplesec on Monday January 18, 2016 @11:18PM (#10928847)
This is fair and good, but not the whole story. Recruitment has emphasized the macho and gun aspects of policing in many jurisdictions, abetted by the provision of military equipment to PDs (including grenades and rocket launchers to LA school district FFS). There is a significant socialisation and culture problem within many PDs, due to lack of effective feedback mechanisms against such abuses of power. Add that to the inevitable draw of PDs to psychopaths (*notallcops ;) and the problems get out of hand, as we have now.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by baddox on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:05PM (#10914030)
It's pretty clear how a heavily armed citizenry would disincentivize cops from this sort of thing. It's because the cops would be afraid that if they rob someone they will be met with a violent response, as they well should.

As for leading to anarchy (let's save discussing whether that would be a good thing for another time) or civil war, I don't see why it would.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by dragonwriter on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:15AM (#10914486)
No, its pretty clear that a heavily-armed citizenry would not disincentivize this, since the portion of the citizenry targetted by the powers at issue is alreadY heavily armed compared to the citizenry at large.

> It's because the cops would be afraid that if they rob someone they will be met with a violent response, as they well should.

The cops already are afraid that if they exercise seizure or arrest powers they will be met with a violent response, and conduct such operations based on the assumption of a violent response (often with tragic results.)

This manifestly does not prevent them from executing these powers.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by thescriptkiddie on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:06PM (#10913320)
The police are breaking the law.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by finid on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:28PM (#10913428)
> The police are breaking the law.

No, they're not breaking the law. They're just taking advantage of laws your elected officials wrote.

So if you want to stop the cops from stealing from you, get your elected official to change the law, or threaten to _vote_ him/her out of office.

That's how it's supposed to be, but citizens keep voting the same politicians into office that vote against their interests.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:16PM (#10913654)
...citizens keep voting the same...

It's almost as if the voting process itself is part of the system, rather than being separate somehow? If we examined that process as a part of that system, we might conclude that it always produces the same results for durable structural reasons rather than because voters always fuck up in special contingent ways.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Nutmog on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:51PM (#10913551)
Absolutely. I live in an authoritarian country and people would love to be able to vote politicians out. Americans really can but they just complain then vote for the same two parties every time.

Clinton caused some of these tough on crime and drugs laws. So if you voted for his party (Obama), then you voted for this.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by such_a_casual on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:00PM (#10913588)
According to Howard Zinn in "A People's History of the United States", the political party and electoral system was created as a facade to placate the poor from revolting against the wealthy. It worries me how much of this may still be true today: https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by finid on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:13PM (#10913640)
The real problem, is that shepherds (politicians) know how to play the game, while the sheep (citizens) are too stupid to realize that they're being played.

All the politicians do is stir up emotional issues like "they're trying to take away your guns", or abortion, to distract the sheep. It works all the time.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by krapp on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:54PM (#10914165)
Most Americans approve of the war on drugs, three strikes laws and zero-tolerance policies. Even the militarization of police after 9/11 was welcomed by a populace that was outraged such a thing could happen on US soil. If the end result has become authoritarianism, we must recognize that it exists in the US, in no small degree, because we the wanted it, not because it was forced upon us against our will.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Decade on Saturday January 16, 2016 @04:03PM (#10916832)
If there’s one useful outcome of the research of Pavlov and Freud and their peers, it’s the scientific discovery that humans are distressingly easy to manipulate into wanting things they did not want before. Ten years ago, the modern smartphone did not exist, and now I bet you don’t want to live without one.

In this case, we have the big media, big industry, and big government in a huge orgy of bribery and self-interest, that all benefit from people accepting authoritarianism. There’s a relief valve, a small minority of people getting their political analysis from Comedy Central or their security analysis from Bruce Schneier, but the vast majority get their talking points from people who are funded to act like there is still a debate about climate change.

It’s not technically against our will, but our will has been manipulated.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by finid on Saturday January 16, 2016 @04:39PM (#10916971)
> Ten years ago, the modern smartphone did not exist, and now I bet you don’t want to live without one.

The smartphone example does not fit.

Very few needed to be manipulated into buying one. You've got to have a phone, whether it's a smartphone, a feature phone, or even a land line phone. Unless extraneous circumstances dictate otherwise, a phone is a necessity.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by finid on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @08:47AM (#10930662)
> not because it was forced upon us against our will.

In a sense it was forced upon us. You see, we were whipped into a frenzy where the most likely thing to do, given our emotional states, was support whatever the perpetrators wanted in the first place.

It's a trick that works all the time.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by collyw on Saturday January 16, 2016 @03:57PM (#10916806)
I don't think that's what anyone asked for, but I think, but those in power have seized it as justification for their authoritarian policies. Orwell predicted it quite well.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by triplesec on Monday January 18, 2016 @11:21PM (#10928856)
Tell us how you can make a difference there in your country do you think?
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by bobwaycott on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:47PM (#10914148)
The opposite side of the aisle has been in no way demonstrably different.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Decade on Saturday January 16, 2016 @04:11PM (#10916854)
False dichotomy. I have never voted for a major party candidate for president.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by bobwaycott on Saturday January 16, 2016 @05:46PM (#10917233)
I'm sorry, what false dichotomy? I haven't suggested one.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Decade on Sunday January 17, 2016 @02:11AM (#10918653)
The false dichotomy is that the opposite of Democrat is Republican.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Retric on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:31PM (#10913718)
They are breaking to constitution not the law. There is a huge difference.

Sadly, the supreme court is stacked with nutjobs from both sides so issues like this are ignored.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by dragonwriter on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:17AM (#10914490)
> They are breaking to constitution not the law. There is a huge difference.

No, there isn't. The Constitution is a part of the law (and a part that constrains whether other things that purport to be law actually are.) Violating the Constitution is violating the law.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by ericcumbee on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:11PM (#10913626)
"That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, — That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government"

I would say based on the declaration of independence, if it comes to that the answer is yes.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by samstave on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:34PM (#10913465)
How would a heavily armed citizenry help solve the problem? Are you going to put a hole in the head of the carjacker who takes cash out of your care? Wont that lead to less theft and carjacking eventually? Maybe considering enforcing the legal right to do so, eh?
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by sb057 on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:09PM (#10913337)
>Maybe...consider changing the law, eh?

That's not very helpful if the people enforcing (and writing) the law are the ones who are breaking it.

>Won't that lead to civil war, eventually?

That's the idea! Or hopefully not even that, since many servicemen will revolt as well.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by balls187 on Friday January 15, 2016 @11:40PM (#10914277)
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by ryanlol on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:25PM (#10913410)
One could theoretically perform a citizens arrest? Although, non-lethal force would be preferable here.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by littletimmy on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:01PM (#10913295)
How will it lead to total civil war? All it will lead to is the police stops taking people's property without a court order or they risk getting shot.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by timonovici on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:25PM (#10913412)
That's a rather naive way of looking at the outcome. For one, do you really think a someone with the training, experience, and exposure violence of a cop could be outmatched by you?

Second, the statement above didn't say much about requiring a warrant to take people's property - how do you get to USA v2, where that law is in place? Do you shoot enough cops, so they would change the law? What kind of wild-west mentality dwells around there, anyway? How about writing a petition? How about sending (e)mails to your congressmen, or whatever people with that kind of authority you have in US?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Grishnakh on Saturday January 16, 2016 @01:11AM (#10914477)
>For one, do you really think a someone with the training, experience, and exposure violence of a cop could be outmatched by you?

Sure, why not? Most cops don't train that much with their weapons, and there's a bunch of crazy rednecks out there who train constantly with various firearms. I'll put my money on the gun nuts against the cops. Check out some YouTube videos by guys at pistol ranges. Also, cops only train at standard ranges, where you stand still and shoot at a non-moving target, and don't generally do combat training. Face it, cops aren't soldiers; they're just thugs with guns, and most are about as skilled with guns as your average ghetto thug.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by timonovici on Sunday January 17, 2016 @01:29PM (#10920354)
I'm a pretty fit guy, but I'm sure the recoil of a gun could break my wrist (well, maybe a desert eagle, I was pretty good with a kalshnikov on my military trainig). I spend more time typing on a keyboard than on a shooting range (which is kind of expected, i'm a programmer). I doubt you can apply such logic as a large scale solution. Do we begin introducing shooting classes in high school, to protect all our citizens?

As for your bet - the paradigm would shift from bullying all people to bullying frail people and avoid rednecks, as far as the violent cops go. This would hardly solve the problem.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Grishnakh on Monday January 18, 2016 @11:34AM (#10925293)
Break your wrist? WTF are you talking about? Have you ever even shot a pistol? It isn't like shooting a 12-gauge shotgun. Women with small hands shoot pistols all the time.

Most cops only train with their pistols once or twice a year.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by timonovici on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @10:00PM (#10935788)
I've only shot a small caliber pistol. Leaving poetic derailments aside, my point is - A: the solution doesn't scale B: it will lead to further discrimination, only aggravating the problem
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by NhanH on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:29PM (#10913094)
> By no means am I a right-wing/vigilante militia supporter, but this type of behavior from the police makes me support having a heavily armed citizenry.

Do you mind elaborate how firearm would help with combating civil forfeiture?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by sarciszewski on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:37PM (#10913149)
More dead police officers, and a lesser incentive for the police to rob the commoners, most likely.

EDIT: To the multitude of downvoters and angry replies: I didn't say I agreed! I'm just saying where these arguments usually logically end up.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by tehwalrus on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:44PM (#10913199)
You mean more funding for swat teams and heavier militarisation to defend themselves? Which is the only way such a move would be politically spun in this universe.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by samstave on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:46PM (#10913522)
And this is the core of the problem!!!
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by TallGuyShort on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:43PM (#10913194)
Which doesn't work until we get to the point of all-out civil rebellion. The US has a heavily armed citizenry now and this is obviously happening. And drawing a weapon on a police officer will end badly no matter what the cop was doing. And that's not for entirely unreasonable reasons.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by r00fus on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:16PM (#10913371)
You're being downvoted you because what you propose is a self-defeating policy - those who gun down cops are enemy #1 and remove themselves from the equation pretty quickly.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by sarciszewski on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:18PM (#10913386)
> because what you propose is a self-defeating policy

Once again, I'm not proposing this. I'm answering a question with the honest logical conclusion that some peoples' worldviews take them to.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by cdash on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:42PM (#10913182)
Of course, more guns does not bring that about but the willingness to kill and rebel against the government by a major part of the population.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by fuzzywalrus on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:43PM (#10913189)
... which leads more militarized policing.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:42PM (#10913187)
We'll keep that to ourselves. If you need a touchy-feely PC-approved reason why civil forfeiture leads to a more-armed populace, try this: Armed people don't need the police for immediate physical security. Unarmed people might need police for that (ignoring for a moment the fact police are actually terrible at that particular task), but because of civil forfeiture (among other reasons) they are reluctant to involve police. Therefore civil forfeiture makes unarmed people less secure, theoretically.

[EDIT:] In case I wasn't clear, I'm saying:

  civil forfeiture -> armed populace
I'm not saying:

  armed populace -> less civil forfeiture
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by DanBC on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:46PM (#10913209)
You have a heavily armed population (the US has more guns per capita than anywhere else) and you still have terrible police.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by Ao7bei3s on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:52PM (#10913240)
...and less safety than in countries with better gun control.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:53PM (#10913248)
Yes we do have terrible police. Gun ownership doesn't change that, but it does mean you don't have to call the police until there are corpses to be collected. That's only the immediate benefit, because the likelihood of armed resistance to crime is a strong deterrent in the first place.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by richmarr on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:57PM (#10913272)
> Armed people don't need the police for immediate physical security

That seems contrary to evidence, surely. Looking at stats for residential shootings:

"For every time a gun in the home was used in a self-defense or legally justifiable shooting, there were four unintentional shootings, seven criminal assaults or homicides, and 11 attempted or completed suicides."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/9715182/

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:10PM (#10913340)
I note that any incident that involves a gun is assumed to be caused by the gun, as though no unarmed person ever were assaulted or committed suicide. That tells me everything I need to know about how conscientious the research is.

Don't even get me started on how suicide has been redefined as pathological, as if nothing in this shitty world could ever lead a rational person to take her own life.

If these researchers cared about public health they would have helped us end the damned drug war a decade ago. As if.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by richmarr on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:32PM (#10913447)
So there may be valid arguments in here, but you're using a bunch of flawed logic in the way you've presented them here:

> I note that any incident that involves a gun is assumed to be caused by the gun, as though no unarmed person ever were assaulted or committed suicide. That tells me everything I need to know about how conscientious the research is.

Yes, they're looking at correlation rather than causation, but looking at real world data that's usually your only option. Dismissing the research on as not 'conscientious' on that basis seems a little weak, perhaps you'd care to support it some?

> If these researchers cared about public health they would have helped us end the damned drug war a decade ago. As if.

This is entirely fallacious... the world doesn't conform to your "if X really cared about Y they would have done Z" narrative. By that same argument no president, no congress, and nobody who approves of the war on drugs, cares about human life.

Edit:

If you prefer not to talk about suicide; how about self-defence... in 2014 (according to FBI data) there were 229 cases (total) where a criminal was justifiably killed by a civilian [1]. To put that in perspective there were 281 mass shootings in 2014... 1,759 people were killed by firearms during arguments [2]... and 1,601 injured in gun-related accidents.

Similarly this study [3] found that carrying a gun increased your chance of being shot by a factor of 4.5.

The whole "armed citizens don't need police" thing may actually be fair... but you're much more likely to need an ambulance.

[1] https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2014/...

[2] https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2014/...

[3] http://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/abs/10.2105/AJPH.2008.1...

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:54PM (#10913563)
So there may be valid arguments in here...

Gee, thanks!

Ah yes, we must look under the lamppost. Sure, that's a pressing concern for "professional" "researchers" who must write grants somehow, but that doesn't oblige the rest of us to believe their tenuous constructed bullshit. Correlation might make sense, ceteris paribus, but they're comparing USA to nations of vastly different sizes, locations, and histories. Rather than, say, nations of similar sizes, locations, and histories. We are a high-population colonized nation of the Americas. We're not the only one, but we are the only one that shows up in this "research".

By that same argument...

Indeed. Normal voters have ignorance as an excuse (although that's less tenable as time passes) but every single legislator and drug warrior and surely every social scientist eventually figures out what's going on. Cops still don't join LEAP until they get their pension. Researchers continue to write grants that get funded rather than ask questions that data can possibly answer.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @09:49AM (#10915377)
I just noticed the references in your edit. About that last paper: I note that two of the four cites at your link are about the poor methodology used in the paper. Indeed reading the abstract is enough to reveal that no attempt was made to track a carefully randomized population, which is the only statistically valid way to conduct research like this. (Apparently it's not the only way to get a grant.) Rather, they selected a bunch of young dudes who had already been shot and then designated a "control" of people of all ages and genders to which to compare them. Then they made some "adjustments". As if GSW victims aren't more likely to be carrying already, do to their personal risk assessments. Good grief.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by rayiner on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:22PM (#10913399)
> Armed people don't need the police for immediate physical security.

Police don't exist to stop the lone burglar from sneaking into your house. They exist to stop the gang of armed men driving up to your house in a bus.[1] Even small groups of organized and armed criminals can terrorize a large population, armed or not. Police exist to make it unfeasible for such groups to operate in the open.

[1] This actually happened to me, in Bangladesh.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:33PM (#10913453)
This is a good point, and that's what I was trying to indicate with the "immediate" qualifier. Armed gangs like that are not invisible in an ordered society, they do not appear overnight, and police are well suited to combat them in that context.

Were there any firearms in the house that was robbed? In that neighborhood, would criminals expect the average resident to be armed?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by yarou on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:39PM (#10913964)
Can't speak for Bangladesh, but in India there is rampant police corruption. Small groups of people gather for collective security.

It becomes dangerous when that small group becomes tainted by religion, as was the case with characters like Dawood Ibrahim.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by jessaustin on Saturday January 16, 2016 @09:52AM (#10915385)
I don't think either Bangladesh or India qualify as "ordered" in the way that I meant.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by DrScump on Saturday January 16, 2016 @08:45PM (#10917899)
Police in the U.S. have no legal duty or obligation to defend anyone from any threat.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by rayiner on Monday January 18, 2016 @12:44PM (#10925674)
"Duty" is a legal term of art which refers to the circumstances under which negligence can give rise to a tort lawsuit. Police don't have a "duty" to defend anyone from any threat in the same way that teachers don't have a "duty" to teach your kids--i.e. you can't allege they negligently failed to act and sue for damages. But the fact there is no duty for the purposes of an action in tort doesn't mean there isn't an institutional obligation and other mechanisms of accountability.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by adventured on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:42PM (#10913179)
If the police continue to escalate their militarization, and continue to ramp up their asset thievery - let's say for illustration purposes here - to a dramatically greater degree.

What other choice would the population have than to defend themselves against that kind of extreme assault on their liberty and property by what would be an obviously hostile, violent and radically unconstitutional force? The police would become little more than armed bandits at that point, modern pirates. It seems like an outlandish scenario to me, but it may not be if the police asset theft continues to soar as it has been. How about if it's ten times larger ten years from now? Latin America has had plenty of this going on, scenarios where the police have become bandits that plunder the population in numerous ways.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by manachar on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:46PM (#10913210)
The police operate at the will of the people. They are as heavily armed as they are because the political process highly rewards "tough-on-crime" politicians.

Maybe instead of buying guns we should invest more of our time and resources into the political process.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by stevendhansen on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:25PM (#10913411)
The events of the last century have all but proven, in my mind, that the political process can do very little to change the political process.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by cglace on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:19PM (#10913388)
I thought police were heavily armed for two reasons: the war on drugs and the programs put in place post 9/11.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by sneak on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:33PM (#10913943)
Widespread private firearm ownership, known to the police, cause police to be more respectful when interacting with the public.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by wahsd on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:41PM (#10913176)
It's more of a hedge in case all these ridiculous situations just go off the deep end altogether.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by balls187 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:00AM (#10914318)
If the the police believed that the average American is well armed and capable of defending their rights, that would change how Police interact with them, reducing the number of bullshit enforcements, such as civil forfeitures.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by krapp on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:03AM (#10914325)
Those police do believe the average American is possibly well armed.. they live in the same country as everyone else and know what the Second Amendment is. Why do you think they have backup and guns at the ready every time they make a traffic stop?

Why is violence an effective means of coercion by the common citizen, but an unacceptable means of coercion by the state? Surely, if fearing for their lives would keep the police honest, having the people fear for their lives would keep them honest and law abiding as well?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by dragonwriter on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:46AM (#10914406)
No, it wouldn't. Heck, firearms are a not-infrequent subject of civil forfeiture, so clearly people having firearms doesn't discourage the government from applying forfeiture.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by manachar on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:43PM (#10913196)
It does go through a process, which at this point is considered constitutional, or more properly worded, has yet to be ruled unconstitutional in court.

Civil forfeiture was a highly successful tool to combat organized crime and grew enormously in the 80s with Reagan's odious war on drugs. It basically solves the problem of illicitly used money being able to free people the government wanted wanted to stop.

As a tool for dismantling organized crime, it was effective, useful, and generally seemed basically fair and as such seemed to survive court review.

Then came the war on drugs and a dose of right-wing anti-tax thinking.

"It's now possible for a drug dealer to serve time in a forfeiture-financed prison after being arrested by agents driving a forfeiture-provided automobile while working in a forfeiture-funded sting operation." — Reagan attorney general Richard Thornburgh in 1989.

It was specifically designed to help fund agencies in a way that replaced tax revenue. Starting at roughly this same time period most government agencies at all levels became cash-strapped in various ways. This meant some agencies have turned to civil forfeiture to create revenue.

It's clearly a bad incentive and needs to be reined in and reformulated to ensure rights are being respected.

BTW, a heavily armed citizenry is precisely why local police departments advocate for more and more militarized equipment. They'll call them gang members and drug dealers, but they are heavily armed citizenry nonetheless. Armed citizens won't solve any part of this problem.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by such_a_casual on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:17PM (#10913378)
There have been no successful tools against the war on drugs, only a tremendous violation of our constitutional rights with a few show trials to keep us all believing in the childish fantasy.

If you're going to say something is successful, be clear about it. Yes, it has been successful at locking up more people than any country in the world. Yes, it has been successful at seizing tons of property. No it hasn't been successful at putting any sort of dent into organized crime, which is fueled by the gigantic black market of drugs.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by ImTalking on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:58PM (#10913285)
It was never envisioned as a tool to dismantling organised crime. That use came later. It was originally created to allow the govt to seize assets of non-citizens where the laws of the US could not be used. For example, captured assets of foreign drug suppliers where they were unable to prosecute those people. It was never envisioned to be used on US citizens because the laws of the US can be applied to citizens as their punishment. To have assets seized AND criminal prosecution is unconstitutional.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by manachar on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:12PM (#10913352)
Wikipedia has a nice section on the history and includes this about constitutionality:

"While the 1993 Supreme Court case Austin v. United States ruled that a forfeiture could be considered as an excessive fine, the court upheld the principle of civil forfeiture generally. A 1996 Supreme Court decision ruled that prosecuting a person for a crime and seizing his or her property via civil forfeiture did not constitute double jeopardy, and therefore did not violate the Constitution. However, in 1999, the Supreme Court ruled that civil forfeiture was not permitted if the amount seized was "grossly disproportional" to the gravity of the offense."

It seems the current legal interpretations do not support considering double-dipping like this to be unconstitutional. However, it's also clear that it should be able to be argued that due process is not being followed, and the dollar value of punishment is excessive, which seems to be ACLU's stance on the matter. I hope the unconstitutional elements are removed from this tool sooner rather than later.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by mapt on Saturday January 16, 2016 @07:29AM (#10915104)
" nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation."

Seems pretty mindbogglingly clear to me. Regardless of what the present Justice Department refuses to go after, or what the present Supreme Courts choose to go after, the people practicing these policies are corrupt traitors committing literal armed robbery in defiance of their compact with the People. That sounds like a hyperbolic statement, but it's not.

I'm going to borrow xkcd's analogy at https://xkcd.com/463/

Imagine you're at a parent-teacher conference, and the teacher, out of the blue, assures you that while he doesn't wear a condom while teaching, all his STD testing is up to date and meets the state code as presently written; He has been inspected by the principal for venereal diseases on a weekly basis. He's clean, and your children are safe, no matter what their marks on the upcoming math test happen to be.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by ImTalking on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:29PM (#10914093)
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by PythonicAlpha on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:48PM (#10913222)
Even when it was successful for some things ... when it hurts innocent people, the state has to find other tools to hunt down criminals.

You can't simply drop an atomic bomb on NYC -- and justify it, by saying you killed at least 100,000 criminals ...

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by manachar on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:59PM (#10913289)
I'm not sold that civil forfeiture is an atomic bomb. It's more like guns in the hands of police. It's a very dangerous tool in the hands of people who are charged with achieving something that occasionally needs dangerous tools to solve.

Guns have obviously led to killing innocents by police, and I'd like that number to go down. Heck, I'd like most police officers to not carry guns most of the time, leaving guns to SWAT teams that can be called in when needed. In other words, I want the dangerous tool used effectively in a manner that respects everyone's rights.

Same with civil forfeiture. It's clearly being used in an abusive fashion. Innocents are losing money and property to help pay for police. It blows my mind that it's being used this way and needs to be reformed. To me it would make sense to hold the property in some form of escrow until the finding of guilt or innocence, essentially freezing assets.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by PythonicAlpha on Saturday January 16, 2016 @06:16AM (#10915004)
I did not say, that cf is an atomic bomb. I just wanted to use a picture to make it more clear, that the end does not justify all means.

I don't know, if cf can be reformed, so that it stays useful and has not such by-effects. The usefulness of cf is largely drawn from the aspect of being arbitrary.

The side effect of a constitutional state is, that some times the bad guys can use it to protect their bad ways. But the alternative would be bad for all.

cf does not only make innocent people to victims, but does change those to crooks, that should protect the innocent -- and thus an even bigger harm is done to the whole society -- with very bad consequences in the long run!

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by pstuart on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:01PM (#10913292)
Weapons aren't necessary. Ending the War On Drugs would remove the prime reasoning for this larceny. Bonus points: less people dying and going to jail, less corruption, etc.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by snsr on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:40PM (#10913170)
It's probably worth noting that you can largely thank Ronald Reagan and his handlers for this legislation.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprehensive_Crime_Control_...

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by DrScump on Saturday January 16, 2016 @08:50PM (#10917910)

  you can largely thank Ronald Reagan and his
  handlers for this legislation
except that the Democrats had solid control of the House, including control of every committee that legislation navigated.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by PythonicAlpha on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:42PM (#10913185)
And still, Ronald Reagan is one of the most popular presidents of the US in the last 100 years.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by quicklyfrozen on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:12PM (#10913354)
You have to remember what the country was like at the end of Carter's term to understand why he's so popular.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by nmlkfnelkfnew on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:50PM (#10913227)
Perhaps to people that guzzle talk radio whatever News Corp puts out. But to anyone else? Average at best.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by PythonicAlpha on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:41PM (#10913172)
The Prohibition of the state grabbing the possession of innocent people dates back to the Magna Carta and thus to the foundations of the legal systems of our civilization.

This practice simply is breaking the civil pact that holds together our countries.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by api on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:36PM (#10913147)
IMHO today cryptography and security are far more important and relevant than physical arms.

This sort of thing is why "I have nothing to hide" is not a legitimate justification for mass surveillance. Think of the abuse potential when dragnet surveillance is combined with machine learning and economic incentives for asset seizure. I can think of quite a few... umm... entrepreneurial things that might be done.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by balls187 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:18AM (#10914361)
Agreed, but security and cryptography won't protect you from the police claiming "You smell like weed." and then seizing your property.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by magicmu on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:24PM (#10913406)
Interesting that militant opposition to the police is associated with the right-wing; not trying to nitpick or condemn, in Ferguson that was absolutely true. Here in NYC it's still not, though, and generally I feel like resistance to armed government forces has generally been more left-aligned.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by yarou on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:35PM (#10913951)
Sure. Groups like the Black Panthers and various left-aligned groups tend to resist "armed government forces".

But, the counterexample to your narrative are the various militias that are slightly racist and espouse right-wing rhetoric.

Sometimes adults like to dress up in black shirts and carry weapons around, regardless of what political affiliation they have.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by whybroke on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:29PM (#10913709)
Ok, how about we set up a fund to give an AK47 and 1000 rounds of ammo to every homeless person in the country.

That people seriously consider more guns to be a solution to anything let alone this problem shows the profound level of insane indoctrination and delusion in the country more than anything else.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Friday January 15, 2016 @08:37PM (#10913744)
>That people seriously consider more guns to be a solution to anything let alone this problem shows the profound level of insane indoctrination and delusion in the country more than anything else.

I'm going to jot that sentence down in my "how to make friends and influence people" notebook.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by whybroke on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:03PM (#10913834)
>...influence people...

Is there some possibility of convincing a gun rights advocate that he is wrong? Only as much as there is to convince a climate change denier or creationist they are wrong. So for all three I'm afraid the above adjectives are accurate.

I am only guilty of the sin of posting ridicule rather than psychotherapy.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by gozur88 on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:01PM (#10914024)
>Is there some possibility of convincing a gun rights advocate that he is wrong?

When you use that kind of rhetoric there's no possibility of common ground. People who believe in gun rights, as I do, used to be much more open to restrictions on the margins - things like magazine size restrictions, say, or background checks.

But there's no better way to engender intransigence than to ridicule someone without even attempting state your own position. Given the shift in public opinion toward gun rights, you're really just marginalizing yourself and your co-restrictionists.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by whybroke on Friday January 15, 2016 @11:37PM (#10914270)
Is the gun control position unknown? It's the same as has been recited ad nuasum for 50 years: there is no right to bear arms in the same way as speech or religion and increased availability of firearms doesn't reduce violence. Only one portion of one country one earth seems to think otherwise, amounting to roughly 1% of mankind.

If two generations of discourse has had no effect then certainly nothing I could ever post will change even one member of that 1% any more than I could change a creationist's view which has been demonstrably invalid 150 years now.

But I might challenge a gun advocate's consistency this way though: why not establish a charity to hand out guns to poor inner city kids so as to reduce crime in those areas or at least give them too the opportunity to exercise that alleged fundamental human right; gun ownership?

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by balls187 on Saturday January 16, 2016 @12:16AM (#10914357)
> and increased availability of firearms doesn't reduce violence

Conversely, the decreased availability of firearms doesn't reduce violence either.

Turns out there are no hard links one-way or the other. Crime rates correlate strongly with poverty rates.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by adekok on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:41PM (#10913174)
"The weapons shops of Isher" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Weapon_Shops_of_Isher) are good in theory. They aren't very practical, though.
Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by rdtsc on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:02PM (#10913296)
> makes me support having a heavily armed citizenry.'

Well that's good for the police because now they have good reason to roll in with their SWAT wagon and get the "tactical" gear out and play GI Joe.

Re:How Police Officers Seize Cash from Innocent Americans by rayiner on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:06PM (#10913319)
The wrinkle is that the seizure of contraband has never been understood to be a seizure of property without due process, dating back to the First Congress. I think civil forfeiture is definitely bad. But it's debatable whether it's unconstitutional.