News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by terravion on Thursday January 14, 2016 @12:41PM (#10902905)
By now everyone knows that expected payoff of working at a start-up is the same or lower than a big company, but with much higher variability. Everyone knows this.

The thing is though, no matter where you work, as a professional you'll spend 50+ hours a week working. The satisfaction you get from that time matters a lot to your happiness and sense of satisfaction. You could work at a large soul destroying company that MUST pay you more because you have to put up with their BS, or you could work at a small company where you can look the founder in the eye and tell him or her to change something you don't like (as this article disparagingly puts it, change the culture in two weeks). And the founder is going to listen because everyone on the team is dedicated to the same mission. Really where are you going to be happier?

The fact that start-up payoff is even remotely equivalent to big company salaries tells me start-ups are a great choice if you value things like your happiness, sense of accomplishment, self-esteem, impact on the world, etc.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by gearoidoc on Thursday January 14, 2016 @12:46PM (#10902943)
There are plenty of large companies where you can go to your boss, express dissatisfaction with some aspect (tech used, projects youre involved with) and get an almost immediate turn around on.

Conversely, there are startups (even ones just founded) where the CEO is inapproachable and your input wont affect culture/product/whatever one jot.

As a programmer, my satisfaction comes from writing quality code on systems that are in some way complex and commonly used. There's not a lot of satisfaction to be gleaned from writing a dozen CRUD apps.

Btw, citing 'impact on the world' as a reason to join a startup is a really good way of coming across naive imo ;)

EDIT: I also disagree with your point on 50+ hours a week. 40 hours is about right with 50+ hours during crunch periods - which should be rare (2-3 a year max).

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by sjg007 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @01:28PM (#10903297)
Agree that "impact on the world" is naive and meaningless. It's like new grad resumes that hype leadership skills.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by dang on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:46PM (#10903901)
It's a cliché, but neither naive nor meaningless when the small company you're working for is trying to do something ambitious.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by jonathankoren on Thursday January 14, 2016 @03:47PM (#10904348)
It's naive because the vast majority of small companies crash and burn, with no impact whatsoever.

Also, since we're talking about Silicon Valley, it's naive to think that Uber-for-Dog-Walking or Grindr-for-BitCoin startup is going to change the world in any meaningful way. Most business startups are playing inside-baseball games that only certain companies care about, and consumer startups tend to be trivial contrivances for people with copious amounts disposable income.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by dang on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:33PM (#10904675)
> It's naive because the vast majority of small companies crash and burn

Most ambitious projects fail, but that doesn't mean they aren't more satisfying to work on. That kind of satisfaction has to do with the work and one's team. It isn't retroactive; it doesn't flip polarity because the project succeeds or fails in the end. Such work is more deeply satisfying because of its nature, even when we know that the odds are against us. And don't forget that most projects—especially most ambitious ones—fail inside bigcorps as well.

There's a cynicism going around about about startups right now where the game is to exchange negative generalizations with other cynics, kind of like trading cards. That's understandable as a reaction in the hype cycle—the startup hype cycle has entered a downturn among the early adopter types who populate places like HN. And yes of course some startups are derivative and some are lame, though the bias to dismiss nascent things as trivial is also a huge distortion, and easy to fall prey to when you're in a cynical mood.

But any account that minimizes the joy of working on a fresh, ambitious project with a small team is clearly mistaking a baby for bathwater. Greater work satisfaction is an important reason why someone might want to work at (the right kind of) startup that has little to do with expected payout and is a form of compensation in its own right. For that type of person it can change the calculus from "meh, it's a lottery" to "the greater meaning justifies the risk".

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by sjg007 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @09:35PM (#10906728)
It's not about throwing the baby out with the bathwater. You're suppose to solve some small problem you have and then by proxy impact/solve something big because other people have a similar problem. So advertising "impact" and "change the world" is superfluous.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by Karunamon on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:15PM (#10904539)
There are a limited number of hours in the day, and the more time wasted on things you'd rather not be doing is less time you're doing things that make you (and quite possibly others) happy.

There's no moral imperative to not waste time, of course, but I'd argue that increasing happiness in the world is never as trivial as you make it out to be.

Sometimes that means something as large as giving dying kids a last wish, sometimes that means something as small as providing a better/faster way to do something we all already did. How many people wasted time and energy shitty homegrown workarounds for file syncing before Dropbox showed up? How many shitty, stressful, overpriced cab rides did people have before Uber came along? How many relationships wouldn't have formed without things like Tinder and Grindr?

All "trivial" web applications, but all increased happiness in the world, one way or another.

What's your motivation for making this comment? Is it to increase happiness, knowledge, understanding, or any positive aspect of any piece of humanity? Or is it to take cheap potshots at people who aren't working on what you've arbitrarily decided is the base level of importance?

(And lest you ask: My motivation for this comment is to increase understanding - hopefully I can change your mind)

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by kamaal on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:10PM (#10905536)
>>It's naive because the vast majority of small companies crash and burn, with no impact whatsoever.

Let me tell you a lot of people prefer to be the participant and fail disastrously than being audience all their lives and clapping/cheering for others.

If you take a moonshot aim and fail, you are going to end up far higher than the anybody else who is doing the normal routine.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by freshhawk on Thursday January 14, 2016 @03:40PM (#10904305)
But you are talking about <1% of the companies making that claim.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by ojbyrne on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:06PM (#10904474)
I recently read an MIT career guide that said you should work 60 hours a week always, but 40 hours for your employer, 20 hours for your "career."
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by jhchen on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:14PM (#10904528)
Sense of purpose is a real sources of satisfaction and happiness. If you work on something that you believe will impact the world, you will be happier, regardless of the actual odds.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by Silhouette on Thursday January 14, 2016 @01:11PM (#10903152)
By now everyone knows that expected payoff of working at a start-up is the same or lower than a big company, but with much higher variability.

If that were true, places like Silicon Valley would be smaller, I think.

The thing is though, no matter where you work, as a professional you'll spend 50+ hours a week working.

Nonsense. I've been doing this stuff for decades and in my entire career I have never worked for anyone who expected or received 50+ hours per week routinely. If this is your norm, you need better employers/clients.

Particularly in creative fields like the software or Web work we usually discuss around here, I would even say that most people can't sustain 50+ productive hours per week for an extended period.

You could work at a large soul destroying company that MUST pay you more because you have to put up with their BS, or you could work at a small company where you can look the founder in the eye and tell him or her to change something you don't like

You imply a false dichotomy. There is a vast range of employers and many other ways of working that do not involve either working in a dead end job for a faceless corporate giant or working in a small start-up.

I have nothing against start-ups. I have started my own companies, which I run to this day, and the majority of my earlier career as an employee was working for smaller businesses. But I do think articles like this are useful from time to time, because a lot of relatively inexperienced people do get taken in by the start-up culture and, in some cases, I would even say abused by it. If the start-ups are as attractive as their advocates would have the newbies believe -- and again, I'm not saying they don't have some big plus points -- then it won't do any harm to offer a more realistic look at the rest of the picture, will it?

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by potatolicious on Thursday January 14, 2016 @03:19PM (#10904124)
Agree with all points - and to add, part of the problem with all this is that developer pay has incredibly high variance and in general knowledge of salaries is poor.

It's not that many people choose lower-paying startups for the enjoyment, satisfaction, etc, while fully aware of how much more BigCo pays - many simply aren't aware of how much more BigCo pays. Many are not even well informed on how much startups pay.

Many are also not aware of the proper math around their startup equity, which results in a large overestimation of its value even in the case of success - I'd say it's not uncommon to see startup employees overestimate the value of their equity by ~10x. Most haven't seen the cap table at all, which means they don't have the ability to estimate the value of their equity at all.

I've seen this in real life where people - not new grads either, experienced industry folk - express shock at the sizes of offers Google, Facebook, et al are throwing around.

We've seen this here, where revelation about how much many engineers make routinely elicit shock - and even hostility - and this is a demographic that particularly cares.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by freshhawk on Thursday January 14, 2016 @03:46PM (#10904342)
> I would even say that most people can't sustain 50+ productive hours per week for an extended period.

I'm not sure, I've noticed that people can sustain it for indefinite periods. What happens is pretty massive drop in quality of work output, massive (negative) lifestyle changes, health problems, social isolation, depression / general dissatisfaction with life.

I find it really interesting just how often these changes go either completely unnoticed or are noticed but not connected to the cause. It seems to be a particularly harmful emergent property of some combination of some types of human irrationality.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by jmspring on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:10PM (#10904505)
The thing about larger companies, some parts could be soul crushing and others can be quite amazing.

I've experienced such at the two larger companies I've worked at.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by drumdance on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:15PM (#10905094)
Sometimes even in the same company. After the NY Times story on Amazon, a lot of Amazonians here posted that they had both really good experiences and really terrible ones.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by JDiculous on Thursday January 14, 2016 @03:59PM (#10904442)
> no matter where you work, as a professional you'll spend 50+ hours a week working

This is false. There are plenty of companies that respect the 40 hour work week (and many where you can get away with less).

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by guelo on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:21PM (#10904581)
Wake up, get ready, commute both ways, lunch, happy hours, etc. 50 hours is on the low side.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by cobaltblue on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:34PM (#10904680)
If you include thinking about work, then even work-from-home people could reach the 50+ figure relatively easily since you include weekends and trying to get to sleep. But then you might easily get into low numbers of hours per week, 15-30, if you subtract things like spending some large % of your time doing non-productive non-work (happy hours, lunches not at your desk, watercooler talk, browsing HN) even though you're at work.

Work time should generally only be the time between clock-in and clock-out. For professionals that are freed from clock-in-clock-out, I think they would still clump around that 40 hour figure if you made them clock-in-clock-out for the data rather than for the pay.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by Apylon777 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @10:32PM (#10906977)
I manage a software team at a Fortune 20 company, and my developers have a ton of freedom. They can work from home any day they please, and I'm honestly surprised when I tell them, "You don't have any meetings for the rest of the day, go home." By no means am I an exceptional manager, but that statement is taken as suspect by most of my staff. Good software can't be coerced.

They also own houses instead of renting flats in SF with roommates.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by softawre on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:45PM (#10904769)
I work 9-5 M-F, live 5 minutes away, and love my job. Keep looking, they are out there.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by vonmoltke on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:26PM (#10904614)
Sure, if you include all that I've been working 50+ hours a week for virtually my entire career. I don't generally count all that other stuff as "working", though, because I have some control over how much or little of that I have to deal with.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by Armisael16 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:24PM (#10904600)
Are you seriously considering waking up and putting on pants to be working?
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by seivan on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:37PM (#10904705)
Job requires pants, it should be included, but you're obviously not paid for it.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by seivan on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:35PM (#10904685)
Those jobs are few, not plenty. They also tend not to be tech companies unless they are bodyshop/ad-agencies in which case you'll find 60 hour work weeks.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by viscanti on Thursday January 14, 2016 @01:16PM (#10903189)
Also, it's unclear that big companies would be willing to hire 100% of the people who want to work in tech. For some, working at a startup might be the best way to learn and improve. Google might not blindly extend 100k+ more offers, above market rate, just to cover everyone who wants to be a programmer. So for the (likely majority of) people who can't realistically get into Google, a startup might be one of the best ways to learn and make money.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by fweespeech on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:06PM (#10904479)
> The fact that start-up payoff is even remotely equivalent to big company salaries tells me start-ups are a great choice if you value things like your happiness, sense of accomplishment, self-esteem, impact on the world, etc.

I can tell the CTO I'd like something to change and one of these things happens:

1) I'll get a pay raise and/or more PTO.

2) What I'm not happy about will change.

> The thing is though, no matter where you work, as a professional you'll spend 50+ hours a week working.

I work 40 hours a week. I get paid more than a startup would pay me.

> You could work at a large soul destroying company that MUST pay you more because you have to put up with their BS, or you could work at a small company where you can look the founder in the eye and tell him or her to change something you don't like.

That is true of small-to-medium sized businesses with a reasonable C-Suite. This has nothing to do with startups and pretending it does perpetuates the myth that startups are different in ways they are completely identical to other businesses.

> The fact that start-up payoff is even remotely equivalent to big company salaries tells me start-ups are a great choice if you value things like your happiness, sense of accomplishment, self-esteem, impact on the world, etc.

I've designed and built systems that I'm as happy with as I would be at literally any other business.

Really all of you've done is generalized a "bad employer" into "all large companies". This simply isn't true.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by seivan on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:41PM (#10905734)
I hope you understand how lucky you've been. Would you say majority of devs have it like you? Because I've experienced the working hour issue. And that's not even at a startup.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by fweespeech on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:55PM (#10905843)
> I hope you understand how lucky you've been.

Tbh, I maintain a several-million-dollar-a-year project with essentially no IT resources besides myself and my requests are reasonable.

At this point, three developers [including someone my boss really, really was hoping would replace me on this] have failed to handle this project effectively.

So it isn't just luck.

> Would you say majority of devs have it like you?

The Devs I know personally do but they are largely my coworkers or my coworkers at previous employers.

> Because I've experienced the working hour issue. And that's not even at a startup.

Yeah, its probably because I've been largely self-managing with hard deadlines really only when we have contractual changes.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by seivan on Friday January 15, 2016 @01:45AM (#10907654)
Thanks for answering, appreciate it.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by fweespeech on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:56AM (#10909630)
Maybe you are right and all luck. :) Idk.

Best of luck to you.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by svimma23 on Friday January 15, 2016 @12:08PM (#10910557)
"By now everyone knows that expected payoff of working at a start-up is the same or lower than a big company, but with much higher variability. Everyone knows this."

I actually happen to agree with the statement but 1) I think the author doesn't understand the mathematical meaning of his statement (or he would have put an AND not a BUT) and 2) It is definitely not possibly true that "Everyone knows this"

In pure probability / economics terms, if I have three payoffs:

a) 50% probability of +1, 50% probability of -1; expected value = 0

b) 50% probability of +5, 50% probability of -5; expected value = 0

c) 25% probability of +5, 75% probability of -5; expected value = -2.5

a) and b) have the same expected value, so:

-- I am "risk neutral" if I am indifferent between the a & b

-- I am "risk averse" if I prefer a) over b (lower variance)

-- I am "risk loving" if I prefer b) over a (higher variance - a gambler)

In financial terms, any investor would absolutely prefer a) over b) [the lower variance bet]. c) is obviously worse than both b/c it has a lower expected value (and it's "doubly" worse than a) b/c it has a higher variance AND a lower expected value).

If now, the argument is that startups have both a lower expected value AND a higher variability than established companies (i.e. they are like bet c)), then, if everyone knew this, the startup community would not exist not least because investors wouldn't be willing to fund it, but also b/c no one should be willing to work there.

What are the caveats?

1) People's behavior isn't always rationale (people pick c) over a) --> for example, the lottery

2) There is a fair amount of evidence that most VC's don't make any real return at all (That putting your money in stocks is on average a way better investment.) Hence, perhaps it is true that startups are like bet c).

3) That the payoff of a VC is different (and better) than that of an employee who suffers from asymmetric information (VC's get access to the "best" companies to invest in whereas workers may not), lack of diversification, being screwed on equity structure, etc. So, it is possible that for a VC, there is expected value equal to that of comparable investors, but that for an employee, on average it is worse in all ways (lower expected value AND higher variability) to work at a startup as an employee than for a larger company.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by gaius on Thursday January 14, 2016 @01:51PM (#10903460)
y now everyone knows that expected payoff of working at a start-up is the same or lower than a big company, but with much higher variability. Everyone knows this.

Not everyone or the VC business model would have imploded.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by terravion on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:44PM (#10903881)
Actually it wouldn't. Most professions with high variability pay lower average wages than more stable alternative industries, this is a basic, well documented principle of hits businesses like the VC industry, upstream oil & gas, movies, and even drug gangs.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by mcguire on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:41PM (#10906146)
You sure about that? My experience working as a government employee (i.e. about as low-variability as it gets), with corresponding low pay, and as a corporate contractor (high-variability in the sense that you may not be needed tomorrow), for higher pay, argues otherwise.

Heck: drug gangs.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by dang on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:34PM (#10903809)
It has certainly become a well-worn meme on HN, so much that it's probably past its best-before date. Once things get repeated too often, the discussions around them stop being vibrant.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by gaius on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:38PM (#10904713)
It needs to keep on being repeated until 20-somethings aren't getting chewed up and spat out by the startup machine anymore.
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by dang on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:13PM (#10905071)
It sounds like you might have had some bad experiences. If so, I'm sorry that happened.

From a discussion-quality point of view, though, your comment seems an example of what I'm talking about. Hype inevitably leads to cynicism, but neither gives a balanced view and neither is good for curiosity.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by gaius on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:38PM (#10905308)
Fair enough! :-)
Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by sageabilly on Thursday January 14, 2016 @01:29PM (#10903312)
You could work at a large soul destroying company Yes, you could.

You could also work at a medium-sized soul destroying company with a totally dysfunctional culture. Or you could work for a 5 person start up with a founder who was only able to function if he had multiple grams of cocaine in his system. Or an up-and-coming, making the transition from startup company who used to have a dysfunctional culture but who fired the perpetrators and who is focused on strategic hiring during a period of heavy growth. Or you could work for a US-based branch of a global company where things were pretty good except for that one co-worker who'd been there 15 years who threatened violence every day and suicide at least once a week and who worked at a snail's pace, yet who was still there the day you got fired because the new boss was younger and saw your college degree as a threat to his position. Or you could work at a 3000+ software company on a product that was used by almost the entirety of the Fortune 2000 and have the direct ear of the CIO even though you're 4 levels below him (as a result of the company culture, not because you're special) and have direct influence on the company direction because of it.

Point being, "startup" != happiness or quality of life, no more than "established company" = stability or a big paycheck. Again and again, it all boils down to company culture, and that's entirely independent of company size, and often it will vary greatly from group to group within the same company.

Re:Beware of the Silicon Valley cult by dang on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:38PM (#10903835)
Company culture is not independent of company size. Bureaucracy grows inexorably with size, probably super-linearly. Smaller organizations and teams are under fewer constraints.

That doesn't guarantee that a small team or company will have a fine culture, but the option is so much more available that the odds are higher.