News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by lugus35 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @04:17AM (#10900320)
You can't buy a hackable, open-platform tractor. What are you doing while waiting for this very hypothical tractor ? You stop working ?
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by teekert on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:46AM (#10900998)
Well, apparently you do what people on HN are suggesting here: You wait until someone else builds a hackable tractor, you buy it promising you won't hack it, then you complain about it and hope you can pressure the government into making it legal for you to hack the hackable tractor.

Why are people buying these annoying tractors anyway? The reason to me seems: They are worth the trouble.

Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by alistairSH on Thursday January 14, 2016 @09:15AM (#10901460)
Sure, but when the other option is "stop farming", what would you have them do? The typical farmer doesn't know how to build a tractor from scratch, just as the typical car-owner doesn't know how to reproduce a Honda Accord.
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by teekert on Thursday January 14, 2016 @10:05AM (#10901771)
So I buy a different brand. Or I comply with the rules I accepted at buy-time. In this tractor case I'd be mad at myself that I missed such a shitty condition of the contract, I'd write a blog post about how shitty it is. I'd try to pressure the manufacturer into giving me more rights. But not via the government, that just seems unfair. John Deere invents something, they proudly bring it to market, people (who did not have a John Deere smart-tractors before) start complaining and now that want you to alter your beautiful product? Go away! John Deere does not force anyone to buy their stuff! Why would you be allowed to force them into complying with your needs?
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by wtetzner on Thursday January 14, 2016 @12:40PM (#10902901)
> But not via the government, that just seems unfair. > Why would you be allowed to force them into complying with your needs?

Here's the thing. They should be able to lease equipment with restrictions. However, if you're going to call it a sale, then I don't see why they should have the right to restrict your ability to modify it. A sale implies a change of ownership. If they can restrict what you can do with the product after you bought it, then there wasn't really a change of ownership, was there?

Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by rakoo on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:27AM (#10900517)
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by czechdeveloper on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:52AM (#10900580)
Yea, let's go back 50 years in tech, make it by hand and call it hackable.

I guess you haven't seen John Deere tractors in a while.

Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by logfromblammo on Thursday January 14, 2016 @02:34PM (#10903813)
50 years back, to 1966, is still very much preferable to 150 years back, to 1866.

As huge a gulf in technology as that may be, retracing over ground that has already been surveyed once is much easier than blazing a trail through wilderness. It only takes 50 years to advance that far in technology the first time you try it. The second time around, it goes much faster and less expensively, especially for everything with lapsed patent protection.

That particular tractor is supposed to be a bootstrapping device, so that in the unlikely circumstance that we do lose the benefit of modern infrastructure, it can mostly be rebuilt before anybody forgets how or why.

With the benefit of the modern manufacturing infrastructure, anyone else could copy a 1995 model of Deere tractor and just leave off the trademark elements.

The LifeTrac is designed around the resources that a self-sustaining OSE community could likely produce or scavenge. It's basically what two people and a rudimentary machine shop could build in a reasonable period of time.

Again, given the run-up in prices for used, owner-repairable tractors, there may be a market for copying the most popular models for new manufacture, and leaving out anything still patented or trademarked. Serious farmers won't build their own LifeTrac unless it is impossible to get a factory-built tractor.

Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by jamespo on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:14AM (#10900482)
Maybe do what people did 10 years ago
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by smcl on Thursday January 14, 2016 @05:36AM (#10900539)
Actually this is what some farmers attempt to do - buy tractors that do not rely on complex electronics and software. However none of the major farm equipment manufacturers make such tractors anymore, so they've had to turn to the second-hand market. Consequently the prices of these second hand tractors has skyrocketed. What a strange world.
Re:Before I Can Fix This Tractor, We Have to Fix Copyright Law by wtetzner on Thursday January 14, 2016 @12:42PM (#10902909)
Yeah, my parents have a dairy farm, and they primarily buy old Oliver and White tractors, because they know how to repair them.