News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rayiner on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:05AM (#10875319)
> The chart-topping office rents in San Francisco are also a testament to the city’s geographic constraints, crammed as it is into 47 square miles at the top of a peninsula

It's more of a testament to the city's anti-development attitude. Manhattan has twice the people with half the land area, on an island.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by eweitz on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:49AM (#10875936)
> Manhattan has twice the people with half the land area, on an island.

Manhattan has twice the residents based on U.S. Census population data, but actual daytime population is more than just residents. A more important statistic is commuter-adjusted population [1], i.e. number of people in an area during normal business hours, including workers. That's where Manhattan and San Francisco really diverge.

The commuter-adjusted population of Manhattan is 3.1 M [2], compared to 1.6 M residents [3]. San Francisco has a commuter-adjusted population of 1.0 M [4, 5], compared to 0.8 M residents [5]. In other words, Manhattan's population booms almost 200% during normal business hours, while San Francisco's increases a modest 25%. Manhattan may have 2x more residents, but it has 3x more daytime population than San Francisco.

Given it has about half the land area, Manhattan's daytime population density is thus 6x that of San Francisco.

Attitudes on development -- namely transportation infrastructure and building construction -- certainly contribute to that difference.

1. http://www.census.gov/hhes/commuting/data/daytimepop.html

2. http://www.citylab.com/commute/2013/05/most-important-popula...

3. http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/36/36061.html

4. http://ww2.kqed.org/lowdown/2014/01/10/how-city-populations-...

5. http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/p...

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by siculars on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:25PM (#10876091)
Everything eweitz mentions is spot on. I'll just note what my sister said not two moments ago when reading some of these comments. "San Francisco is a baby town, a joke, compared to what's going on in Manhattan." And I kinda have to agree. San Francisco's current issues are entirely of their own making. I have no sympathy. I grew up in Queens, lived in Manhattan for 16 years and moved to Dallas a year ago (cause someone paid me.) I've been to SF more times than I can count over the last 10 years for computer related work and conference, etc. You couldn't pay me to live there.

No other place in the country has the kind of network effect that NYC does. It is entirely due to density and density is a direct result of NYC's subway system. As much as New Yorkers love to complain about the subway, and believe me it's a sport out here, we would not be able to accommodate the masses we accommodate without it. Transportation and, of course, vertical space is the way we do it. I really don't know why this is such a mystery to so many not from here. It's kind of glaringly obvious to the most casual of observers.

San Franciscans need to stop navel gazing and look up to the sky. Go up, my friends, go up.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rsync on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:00PM (#10876282)
"I grew up in Queens, lived in Manhattan for 16 years and moved to Dallas a year ago (cause someone paid me.) I've been to SF more times than I can count over the last 10 years for computer related work and conference, etc. You couldn't pay me to live there."

Wait, so I could pay you to live in Dallas, but I couldn't pay you to live in SF ?

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by siculars on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:28PM (#10876413)
California's rules, regulations, tone and general outlook on most things irk me, and even more so SF as the epicenter of such things in California. So, no, I don't think one could pay me to live in San Francisco.

It doesn't need to be said here but I'll go ahead and say it anyway - Texas has no state income tax. Sure, they have no mass transit to speak of, but then again, in truth, they don't need it. (Outside of the philosophical view that all metropoli need mass transit, which I agree with.)

Edit: the fact that SF, a city with arguably a third the population of NYC has rents more than NYC is exactly the kind of "thing" that irks me about SF. It's the kind of social dysfunction that's intolerable - for me.

Another is the Bay Bridge. When standing in Marin north of the Golden Gate, there are a number of plaques describing the building of the GGB. A picturesque view with the BB in the background. Guess what? It turns out the GGB was built ahead of schedule and under budget - with no computers! I don't even need to go into the failings of the BB. You get my point.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by mrgordon on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:29PM (#10876744)
Ahh I see, you hate regulation, taxes, and don't think a city the size of Dallas really needs mass transit in practice. So this isn't really about San Francisco at all. The only thing that really surprises me now is that you speak highly of New York.

I could describe how much more "social dysfunction" there is in Texas than California at length but I sense its going to be an uphill battle. Suffice it to say that my friends just got back from Austin where they witnessed a "mock shooting" at the university in support of the new open carry gun laws. When your legislators spend time expanding gun rights after repeated mass shootings, you're looking at social dysfunction. These same legislators also found the time to carefully craft anti-abortion legislation recently in an attempt to force all abortion clinics to close until the Supreme Court can overturn the decision. Meanwhile they don't seem to mind all the fake clinics being set up which use tax money and tax benefits to confuse and lie to desperate women who are under extreme stress already. You can have your 0% income tax rate "paradise" and try to remember that Texas has among the highest property tax rates in the country to make up for it.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by siculars on Sunday January 10, 2016 @06:03PM (#10877676)
> You can have your 0% income tax rate "paradise" and try to remember that Texas has among the highest property tax rates in the country to make up for it.

Coming from NY, those property taxes don't really make me even flinch. When you combine lower cost of living, lower real estate and no income tax higher property tax doesn't even move the needle.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by mrgordon on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:02PM (#10876611)
Yeah Dallas is really the epitome of good urban planning and land use compared to San Francisco. Lets go get in our cars and drive thirty minutes to Chili's so we can have a real cultural experience </sarcasm>

Texas pretty much defines sprawl in my mind. San Francisco could be more dense but it certainly isn't sprawling.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by mvc on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:34PM (#10876766)
You'd have to pay a lot more.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by hitekker on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:30PM (#10876748)
"San Francisco is a baby town, a joke, compared to what's going on in Manhattan."

I don't particularly have a soft spot for either city, but I agree with you on the note of maturity. Manhattan has a far better idea of what it's doing compared to SF.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by nzoschke on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:19PM (#10878208)
I agree about the Manhattan to SF comparison.

But if you take a less cynical view, doesn't this mean that SF represents a remarkable opportunity?

At some point the population has to get it together, elect better reps, reject the nimbyism and build more towers and trains.

It's actually happening as we speak. New bay bridge, extensions of muni, transbay tower, Salesforce tower, ...

I'm biased living in SF, just getting married, and avoiding the current market rate rents. but I see tremendous opportunities in SF.

Which is crazy to think given all the advantages - nature, water, work, weather - SF has over most other places.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by hitekker on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:57PM (#10878495)
Agreed. That reminds of this old quote (replace france with SF):

>God just finished creating the world. He looks his creation and see France.

>"This country is to beautiful. It's unfair for the others countries."

>And so, God created the French.

On a side note, congratulations on getting married. Hope all goes well.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by donretag on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:41PM (#10876491)
This is the first time that I read Hacker News that I realized who the poster was. Hopefully Dallas is treating you well!
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by siculars on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:44PM (#10878651)
Ha! This is the first time I've been recognized by someone reading something I wrote! Dallas is actually pretty ok. Shhh... don't let my NY friends know that I said that ;)
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by swingbridge on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:00PM (#10876276)
Exactly. SF's problem is not just a lack of sensible zoning but also a lack of adequate infrastructure to handle a modern sensible environment for commerce. Manhattan not just doubles its population size each business day but the vast majority of those people use public transit to get there. SF is still far too linked to the car. In many ways NYC is a 21st century center for commerce while SF is largely stuck with a 20th century way of thinking about things.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by timr on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:00PM (#10876601)
Manhattan has twice the people with half the land area, on an island.

...that is tightly connected to 10 times that land area as the boroughs of New York City. Everybody leaves that part out. It's more convenient to live in Queens and commute to Manhattan than it is to live in the Outer Richmond and commute to SOMA.

This matters, because the part of San Francisco that people conventionally see as "San Francisco" in has little overlap with the parts of the city that are actually low density. The city north of Market and east of Divisadero is fairly high-density development, by any standard: most buildings are at least six stories, and often taller than that. But to make the other 2/3rds of San Francisco viable as high-density development, you'd need to build a ton of new mass transit. It's car country over there.

There's immense hypocrisy on both sides of this discussion. I think height limits in SOMA and the Financial district and Mission Bay should be higher. But it's hard to stomach density criticisms from people who want to live in cute, victorian, single-family housing in Noe valley themselves, and re-develop the places where poor brown people live. And that's happening a lot around here.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rayiner on Sunday January 10, 2016 @04:01PM (#10877193)
Manhattan is an island. It didn't get tightly connected to a bunch of other land by refusing to let anyone build anything.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by timr on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:32PM (#10878823)
That's a fatuous response. There are many reasons why San Francisco doesn't have New York City levels of public transit, the most important of which is that it's a comparatively tiny city, approximately 1/8th the size of New York, by population. If the "bay area" were a single city with a single government, it would be much easier to build a comprehensive transit system.

Moreover, New York has been one of the world's largest cities for over a century. It's had a while to get good at things. San Francisco was a cow-town until the 1980s.

I realize it's self-satisfying to blame NIMBYs for everything, but the facts are more complicated.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by JohnTHaller on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:28AM (#10875389)
An anti-development attitude combined with a less effective and smaller mass transit system compared to NYC.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by melling on Sunday January 10, 2016 @09:20AM (#10875370)
How do people get away with making bad comparisons in major news sources? Manhattan is 34 square miles surrounded by water. It's an island! This would seem to indicate that there must be more to the problem. Better mass transit into Oakland, for example, would help. That's another 78 square miles of usable land.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rhino369 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:34AM (#10875866)
While it doesn't effect the city itself, the geography appears to constrain suburbs. The lack of nearby suburbs probably drives prices up.

New York has sprawling suburbs that go into nearby states.

The SF equivalent of a lot of those areas are mountain ranges and oceans. To be sure, SF has suburbs (or suburb equivalents): SV, Oakland, etc. But a lot of prime area for suburbs can't support one.

Draw a 30 miles radius circle from manhattan and SF, and I bet NYC has more livable land.

That said, that is all the more reason for strong development in SF. Or else you are going to end up with SF just being a rich neighborhood for millionaires in a Bay Area megacity.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by melling on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:52AM (#10875951)
How many people live in SF and Silicon Valley? 4 million people? There are 20 million people who live in the NY area?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_metropolitan_area

If you want to work in Manhattan, you need to live near mass transit (bus, train) because 30 miles in/out of the island is too painful. That greatly limits where you can live.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rayiner on Sunday January 10, 2016 @03:26PM (#10877024)
I used to live 25 miles from Manhattan. Easy 30 min commute on Metro North.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by melling on Sunday January 10, 2016 @05:46PM (#10877607)
Really? Where? No need to provide half an answer. I'm sure you meant 30 minutes on the train. I live 3 miles from Manhattan. It takes me between 20-90 minutes by bus.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by tamana on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:53PM (#10876237)
LIRR is a commuter train that serves over 30miles out.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by melling on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:09PM (#10876320)
All the commuter trains in the NY area serve over 30 miles out. NJ Transit and Metro North also serve is several directions into NJ, New York, and CT. No one claimed that they didn't.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rewqfdsa on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:28PM (#10876103)
You should apply equal skepticism to everything you see in the news. These days, news outlets are all about pushing a particular narrative, not about impartially reporting the facts.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by Tempest1981 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @03:51PM (#10877152)
So do we want San Francisco to be more like Manhattan? Is Manhattan the ideal city -- the pinnacle? I think of Manhattan as being noisy, crowded, and no where to park.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by siculars on Sunday January 10, 2016 @06:09PM (#10877692)
Yes, Manhattan is the ideal city. It's so ideal, that even people who live in the other four boroughs of New York City[0] refer to Manhattan as "the City."

[0] New York City is comprised of five boroughs (aka. counties): 1. Manhattan (officially known as New York County) 2. The Bronx (yes, "The Bronx." No one says "Bronx.") 3. Queens 4. Brooklyn (officially known as Kings County) 5. Staten Island

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by ropiku on Sunday January 10, 2016 @06:05PM (#10877680)
If you have a good transit system you don't need parking.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by Tempest1981 on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @02:42AM (#10892877)
So basically you work in Manhattan, and live elsewhere. I was thinking of living in Manhattan, and having a car for weekend getaways -- is that possible?
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by Spooky23 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:29PM (#10876424)
Plus the decline of NYC.

Manhattan is increasingly a financial services company town, and many parts of that industry are drifting to Jersey.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by codyb on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:53PM (#10876552)
I'm not sure what sort of decline is happening here. Silicon alley is booming. The city is a cultural smogasboard. Hundreds (maybe thousands) of large corporations are centered and based here. Construction is rampant. And the city is likely one of the safest metropolis's in the world.

But maybe you could prove me wrong... I'm not sure, just noting what I see.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by Spooky23 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @08:11PM (#10878188)
The economy of NYC is much less diversified than it was say 20 years ago or in the postwar period.

Those corporate HQs used to come with thousands of workers -- now more likely a couple floors of folks supporting the CEO. A lot of residential construction is funded by capital flight and shady political lobbying that helped get 2/3 top state leaders convicted of corruption charges.

Still a great city, but not the economic behemoth that it was.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by hellofunk on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:24AM (#10875815)
I don't know what the underlying geography of SF is like, but in case you have ever wondered why Manhattan is only vertically developed in two areas of the island where there are tall skylines (with a lot of low-lying areas in between, i.e. the Village, Chelsea, Chinatown, Little Italy, etc), it is because those are the only two areas on the island where the bedrock can support that type of development. I don't know if this factors into SF development options, but just an FYI.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by coderzach on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:35AM (#10875871)
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by hellofunk on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:07PM (#10876016)
This is rather interesting. I took a course many years ago at NYU on the history of the city, and my parent comment was taught to us in the class by none other than the Dean of the actual school. Fascinating.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by potatolicious on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:26PM (#10876096)
It's an incredibly common urban legend even in the city itself - fortunately with no basis in reality.

As an example the Metropolitan Life North Building right next to Madison Square Park was originally designed in the 20s to beat the Empire State for height (but sadly, the Depression happened), and that plot of land is firmly on the "soft" ground "unsuitable" for tall skyscrapers.

Not only do we not need the bedrock now, it appears we never needed it - and the engineers of the early 20th century knew this as well as we do.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by HillaryBriss on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:58PM (#10876889)
Yes. And any tall building in SF's Embarcadero stands in defiance of the need for bedrock. A lot of the land there is just old, accidental landfill.

Also, I think, but, I'm not sure, that they built this extremely large, heavy structure right over the bay itself a few years back, something about helping cars get from Oakland to SF and back. I don't know how much bedrock they found underneath the supports for that thing, whatever it's called. Can't seem to remember its name ...

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rhino369 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:38AM (#10875885)
Bedrock is not needed to build a sky scraper. It was just natural trends, not enforced with zoning laws.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by avn2109 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:20PM (#10876070)
>> "Bedrock is not needed to build a sky scraper..."

True, but that's because of comparatively recent developments in geotechnical engineering. They needed it during the first wave of skyscraper development.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by rhino369 on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:03PM (#10876292)
The first NYC ones certainly used bedrock. But floating raft system was invented in Chicago in 1882. So I wouldn't say recent.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by dantheman on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:32AM (#10875856)
That's historical and enforced by zoning. Large buildings can now be built anywhere.
Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by pstrateman on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:31AM (#10875850)
There are a bunch of very tall buildings in SF built on landfill.

The issue is entirely politics not engineering.

Re:San Francisco Office Rents Pass Manhattan as Most Expensi... by raldi on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:44AM (#10875909)
They're building the new Transbay Tower in SF on soft ground. It just means they had to put in a bunch of very deep piles and a foundation that constituted one of the largest concrete pours of all time. But the real estate market is such that they were happy to do it, in exchange for permission to build the tallest building in the city.