I can only speak for myself here, but I noticed how after I started a professional career as a programmer and a tech-geek, I became more and more isolated; preferring alone time, and being in my head. It's just easier, to take in all the information and opinions you prefer, and ignore what you don't want. To engage in activities you want to do yourself, rather than compromising with others.
Perhaps this new society that emerges will not be WORSE than any previous one, but it will be different. I think it is important to understand those differences. I can already feel the growing pains caused by old institutions struggling to keep up with the pace of technology. We should keep an eye on those millennia old social institutions as well (like politics, community building, and voting).
And communication through phones for hours a day was normal for most people in the 90s too. Even in the 50s.
Call neighbor. 1 minute of small talk
Ask the question
Get answer
more small talk.
Say goodbye.
Today it would be (via txt): A: can i borrow a c of sugar?
B: y. come over
A: k
A lot of communication happens through text messages which dramatically reduces the number of words you say to another human being.I think what is more damaging is that most people can solve their own problems without ever having to rely on neighbors or even family. Cell phones, uber, and other services remove the need to ask for help. You don't really ask people for directions, ask the time, find out how to do something.
Yes. people still talk to neighbors, family, friends, etc. But it happens much less and in much different contexts. For instance the vast majority of people would not call their neighbor to check on their kids because they are stuck in a storm.
The text vs. call is an example of technology removing obstacles and inefficiencies. In your example, both of the conversations lead to people meeting face-to-face, but only one of them could be done while on a bus, or in between work meetings. Text-based communication enabled us to talk in situations when it wasn't possible before. I fondly remember late-night IM talks with my friends when I was in high-school. This is not something we could do on the phone, both because of stupidly high costs and because other people in our houses were sleeping.
RE most people solving their own problems, I think that's a) good, and b) not what actually happens. Good, because it means less time wasted for everyone in aggregate; not what really happens, because the world is getting more complicated and people delegate more and more understanding to third parties. Also, that we can solve some problems on our own doesn't mean there aren't other, more complicated problems - for help with which we end up calling the family or friends after all.
The world is fine, at least in this aspect.
Also, if you're arguing these devices reduce smalltalk, I'm not so sure of that. If anything, I'm more likely to idly chat to someone on IM due to increased opportunity to do so. Plus I can even put my daily life in tweets and post that reach an even greater audience than just whoever I happen to bump into.
I'm fairly convinced that when society is too comfortable (while being messier at the same time) then you see diminishing returns in people's existence.
[1] how society repeats itself, new tech bad for work, old good ways are dying; these are recurrent generational waves.
I don't think the people who leverage these 'tricks' today do this because of superior intellectual skills or understanding. They just use it for blind results.
Now, when people are bored with what you're saying, instead, of their eyes glazing over, they might start to become increasingly attentive to their phones; In other words, they now have a physical bore-shield.
I think people meet and talk as much as they did - They just don't necessarily prioritise the pleb in front of them - and for some people, who like to monopolise their audiences, this is a problem.
Personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all.
This is just demonstrably false, by a whole host of measurable metrics. For example:
Average people fly long distances dramatically more today than ever before. (And I'm not talking about just in rich countries -- regional airlines are booming in Africa and Asia too.) It's pretty hard to argue that visiting a faraway place is not a "real experience" that is more accessible than ever.
The fraction of children in the world who go to school instead of doing menial labor is the highest in history and continuing to rise.
And you can't have any "real experiences" if you're dead, so historically low global child mortality is generating an awful lot more real experiences.
> You become ever closer to a mere regurgitator of pre packaged thoughts.
It's rather rich to claim the past was better along this dimension, when most of history was dominated by orthodox religions backed by political elites, and only a tiny elite could even read. Unless you think literacy implies more regurgitation, in which case you've watered down the term enough that it loses it opprobrium.
> More kids are in school? For what? To be a white collar slave? To be a white collar slavemaster (entrepreneur)? Death in menial labor, while undesirable, at least prevents one from fattening the elites' wallets with their brains.
I'm a strong critic of schooling as its typically done, because it is indeed a conformity machine. But here's the thing: it's still better than sending all the kids to a salt mine, because that's a precondition for us to even be having this discussion. The kids who got sent to salt mines don't get to read Baudrillard and comment on HN.
> Where are the African and Asian artists?
On those continents, respectively. Racist much?
> scientists... philosophers... virtually unheard of
This has always been the human condition. I guarantee you the fraction of people who appreciated Aristotle during his life was a vanishingly small fraction of the human race.
> Similarly, low child mortality just currently means the commodification of children and childhood.
This is pretty hilarious, because high-mortality societies are the ones that have large families specifically because children are valued as sources of labor. Some societies didn't even name their infants until they got old enough to be out of the highest morality risk -- they were treated as fungible commodities before then.
> I'd also say literacy could have resulted in more healthy attitudes
It could have resulted in spontaneous world peace, too. But that kind of navel gazing is not relevant to the question of whether literacy is still better than nothing. It's clearly a precondition if you want those great scientists and philosophers to ever have a shot.
> people who think everything is great and there cannot possibly be any systemic problems
This is a giant straw man. Please find me a single person who thinks the world has no systemic problems. The presence of problems is a necessary precondition for someone like me to argue that things are getting better. "No problems" implies stasis, not improvement.
But it seems like we're on a path that makes this less and less likely, whereas the introduction of technology and so forth should have done the opposite, were we not "ethically bankrupt" as a species.
Baudrillard can be said to have identified the problems. and that more than makes up for his defeatism.
The rest of your reply is basically, now that we dont have salt mines worked by kids, everything is awesome and you cant complain.
If you really do recognize that we have the systemic problems I was talking about, perhaps we actually agree and I'm only saying things arent getting better fast enough.
Which is a real danger. There's only so much resources one can devote to not being a complete tool, and these are running down, quickly.
This is going to sound snippier than the tone it's intended in:
What's your proposed alternative? So very much human suffering is directly caused by a failure to communicate well - seems like increasing ease of communication would be the best way forward based on that alone, regardless of the growing pains and the bad actors. Manipulation has been a thing since communication has been a thing - you're simply not thinking straight if you think retarding the latter will impact the former.
What the hell is a "pre packaged thought" anyways? A synonym for unoriginal? We're products of our shared environment, the likelihood that your thoughts are entirely unique is just about nil.
Aside:
there will always be zombies like you
Could you not? Doing this, your entire opinion becomes worthless, and even uglier than it already was considering the cynicism it's practically dripping in. Snide remarks aren't necessary here. Thanks.
I'd say universities and government are actually the only institutiona left where one can really do the work you are talking about, and even that is with significant capitulation to the economy in order to continue existing.
We have a new religioua dogma now: capitalism, make more money than the next guy, everything is exchangeable, what you cannot pay for doesnt exist.
(Em mine.) I have a problem, my rig's not very powerful. Where can I vote to get a better rig? Or does my rig do the voting weighted by its power? (http://lesswrong.com/lw/jb/applause_lights/)