News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by RealGeek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:55PM (#10852678)
93 victims were unarmed, 33 were armed with a toy, and 27 unknown.

That is a lot more than Americans killed by terrorists in US.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by notatoad on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:41PM (#10853090)
I've seen police shoot and kill a man "armed with a toy" and it's very, very hard for me to fault them for it. It sounds bad when you say it, but armed with a toy and armed should be treated as the same thing. When a man being chased by police stops his car, gets out, takes cover behind the door and starts pointing something that looks remarkably like a gun at police, he should be shot.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gherkin0 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:45PM (#10853615)
> When a man being chased by police stops his car, gets out, takes cover behind the door and starts pointing something that looks remarkably like a gun at police, he should be shot.

I disagree, especially in your outlined scenario, for a couple of reasons:

1) First and foremost: the police are professionals whose job should be to protect the public, even if that means they put themselves in harm's way. The person with the toy gun (or wallet, cell phone, etc) is still a member of the public.

2) After a car chase, the police have the ability to position themselves defensively until the situation becomes clearer (e.g. shots are actually fired at them). They also could be wearing unusual protective gear like body armor, which would further reduce their personal danger.

Now, if the person was actively threatening an innocent third party with a realistic toy gun in some way, then I think it would be much more justifiable for the police to shoot. Ditto if a person brandishes something clearly gun-like at an officer at close range.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gozur88 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:08PM (#10853785)
I don't think it's reasonable to expect cops to allow criminals to take the first shot in case the gun might be a toy. Even if you're "positioned defensively" you can still be killed by someone who's lucky or skilled.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by sliverstorm on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:52PM (#10854102)
There seems to be a cohort of people who believe that policemen's lives are essentially forfeit, and thus any level of mortal risk to them is reasonable.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gherkin0 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:05PM (#10854621)
I don't think that policemen's lives are "forfeit," but that it's their duty to not have self-defense as their very top priority, which entails taking risks in some situations that we wouldn't expect of other people.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gozur88 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:41PM (#10854838)
Clearly the cop doesn't have self-defense as his top priority, or he wouldn't be in that situation at all. He'd make sure he was somewhere else when the possibility of violence manifested itself. Like, say, I would.

Police officers shouldn't be shooting people on the off chance that a suspicious bulge might be a gun, but it seems pretty unreasonable to expect police officers to put their self-defense as the very lowest priority and wait until bullets actually come out of a gun-like-object being pointed at them before shooting.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gherkin0 on Thursday January 07, 2016 @10:24AM (#10858368)
But what I'm saying isn't putting their self-defense at "the very lowest priority," it's just putting it after correctly determining the suspect is an imminent mortal threat before deciding to kill them.

The police are after all are the ones with the experience and training: they shouldn't ever be killing kids with toy guns or people with wallets, which they in fact are. The thinking that enables that needs to change.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gozur88 on Thursday January 07, 2016 @04:19PM (#10860868)
>...they shouldn't ever be killing kids with toy guns or people with wallets, which they in fact are. The thinking that enables that needs to change.

I disagree. That's not an achievable standard without putting officers' lives at undue risk. Cops can not tell the difference between toy guns and real guns without a close inspection.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by talmand on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:03PM (#10854168)
So, we should just hope that innocent bystanders are not hit by that first shot at police as the they hide behind their defensive positions and superior equipment?
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gherkin0 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:14PM (#10854680)
> So, we should just hope that innocent bystanders are not hit by that first shot at police as the they hide behind their defensive positions and superior equipment?

The scenario outlined did not involve an actual gun that could harm anyone.

If a car chase ends the suspect hiding behind a door with a "gun" in their hand, there are actually many possible scenarios, for instance:

1. The "gun" is not actually a gun, and was misidentified.

2. The gun is fake or a toy.

3. The gun is a real gun and the suspect will not shoot at anyone.

4. The gun is a real gun and the suspect will shoot at the police or others.

Some people say the suspect should be shot in all four scenarios (after all, he might shoot!). I disagree.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by talmand on Thursday January 07, 2016 @10:10AM (#10858277)
> The scenario outlined did not involve an actual gun that could harm anyone.

It did not involve an actual gun in that particular instance. I would like you to explain exactly how the police may identify whether the object that appears to be a weapon is an actual weapon other than waiting for the suspect to fire first.

Again, we should just hope that innocent bystanders are not hit by that first shot at police as they hide behind their defensive positions and superior equipment? Police officers and innocent bystanders don't always fare too well when the police are obligated to follow stupid rules of engagement.

> Some people say the suspect should be shot in all four scenarios (after all, he might shoot!). I disagree.

See, that's where I agree with you. Because none of the scenarios in your list is a reason for police officers to fire as you list them. But tack on the end of each item that the suspect acted in a threatening manner with an object that appeared to be a weapon then the police officer may choose to fire their weapon. To be fair, if the suspect tried to run down other people or cops during the chase to show that he was a threat then just getting out of the car with an object that appeared to be a weapon will get him shot. It's all about context.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gherkin0 on Thursday January 07, 2016 @11:52AM (#10859000)
I agree the context is important, and it may sometimes provide reasonable justification for the police to shoot first, like if there's a crowd behind the officer. Generally, I think the officers should minimize the probability that 1) innocent bystanders get shot, 2) unarmed suspects get shot, and 3) the officer gets shot; in that order. Some people seem to put 3) in front of 2), and I think that's wrong.

However, a in lot of recent videotaped incidents, it's been shown that many police officers are shooting and often killing people merely because the officer falsely "thought" they had a real gun. That behavior is unacceptable and needs to stop, even if that means police have to take more personal risks themselves.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by talmand on Thursday January 07, 2016 @02:19PM (#10860046)
I agree, to a point, because most of the unjustified police shootings I'm aware of, that we have video for, did not show any direct threat to the officer or any bystanders. In almost all those cases the victim did not even have an object that could be mistaken as a weapon. I personally don't see those as police shootings but as murder, manslaughter at best.

But I still have problems with your wording. In your examples above you feel 2 is more important than 3 and you disagree with people that reverse it. I agree with you. The difference is I see the possibility that the police may think the unarmed suspect is armed and is a direct threat to the officer or bystanders. By your wording you seem to suggest that scenario is not possible, and just in case the officer should wait until fired upon to determine whether the suspect is armed or not. That's a bad rule of engagement.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by melted on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:34PM (#10853967)
I take it you're not a cop, and don't have any cops in your family. The rule is very simple: unless you want to get shot, don't fuck with police. Pointing a toy weapon at an officer counts as fucking with police in my book.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by DanBC on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:38PM (#10853996)
It's not surprising when people describe the police as a fascistic brutal regime.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:50PM (#10854519)
I'm not sure how you can extrapolate that from one person's insensitive comment about the police.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by DanBC on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:22PM (#10855039)
Because it's not just one person's insensitive comment, is it? It's a pattern of repeated behaviour. "I am the law, don't fuck with me".
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:47PM (#10855140)
Clearly every police who believes "I'm the law don't fuck with me" fits the bill you describe, but I don't think we're close to establishing that every police believes that.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by melted on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:49PM (#10855151)
Yes, that's how things are done in this country. You can fuck with them afterwards, in the court of law. When they're enforcing the law, fucking with police is the stupidest thing you can do. They have families to come back home to as well. I don't see what's so "insensitive" about that.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by DanBC on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @08:05PM (#10855215)
> When they're enforcing the law, fucking with police is the stupidest thing you can do

...in the US. In other countries you can fuck with the police and not get killed.

And, for the sake of clarity here, "fucking with the police" is for example asking if you're being detained or if you're free to go, or asking what grounds they have for a stop and search. It's baffling to me why asking police to obey the law is described, by police, as fucking with them.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by melted on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @09:46PM (#10855631)
No, I'm not talking about stop and frisk or "am I free to go". I'm talking about pointing a toy weapon at an officer when he/she can't tell if the weapon is real or not. Or reaching into the police cruiser, punching the officer in the face and attempting to grab his gun. Stuff like that.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by DanBC on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @10:01PM (#10855682)
Sure, but in this little sub-thread I'm talking about the thug officers who think that polite refusal to answer their questions is justification for police harassment.

It's far too common in the US.

And while it's stupid to point a gun (toy or not) at police (I agree that death is a likely result, because you should never point a gun at someone unless you intend to kill them) that doesn't excuse all the people who had cell phones in their hands, or the people shot within six seconds of a police officer arriving on the scene, or the people with no weapon and their back turned.

Yet in many of these cases we see officers closing ranks and claiming the victim somehow deserved it, and was somehow responsible for their death because they were arguing with police.

The US is unique in first world nations in murdering its citizens. It's an abuse of human rights when it happens after lengthy court cases; I can't imagine why it's okay before an arrest is made.

(Unless someone's life is in real and immediate danger).

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by logfromblammo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:49PM (#10854504)
Given that people in the U.S. have the right to be armed, with anything from nail clippers to 18-wheelers, I demand a bit more justification for a violent intervention than simply carrying or controlling a weapon.

So you are correct when you say armed with a toy and armed with a functional weapon should be treated in the same way. But I don't think possessing an object that may or may not be a weapon is sufficient justification in itself for the use of lethal force. I think police need to exercise every available opportunity to de-escalate conflicts, with the goal being to deliver the suspects alive and unharmed to the courts for arraignment. That may actually mean that the cops have to let the suspect fire a shot before he gets a lead shower. That would leave no doubt that yes, it is a real weapon, and yes, the suspect is willing to use it inappropriately.

I don't want 750k Judge Dredds on the street, acting as judge, jury, and executioner.

When a man takes cover and points a gun, he should be ordered to "show me empty hands" [0], then given a reasonable opportunity to assess his situation and comply. If he even fires the gun, and injures a cop, he should still be given an opportunity to surrender and make it to the courtroom alive.

[0] As "drop the weapon" is confusing to a person not actually carrying one.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by enraged_camel on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:13PM (#10853377)
>>When a man being chased by police stops his car, gets out, takes cover behind the door and starts pointing something that looks remarkably like a gun at police, he should be shot.

How often does this happen?

A much more common occurrence is when someone sees a suspicious-looking dude walking down the street, calls the cops and says "I think he is armed!" and the cops arrive and shoot him without first verifying if he's actually armed with a real weapon.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by notdonspaulding on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:23PM (#10853451)
First: citation needed.

Second: In almost the entire US, being armed is not against the law.

Third: If it's as much of a "common occurrence" as you claim, please paste here one example from the list of shootings on the article's main page where an officer shoots a civilian without any provocation.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by LordKano on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:42PM (#10853600)
Admittedly, I don't think it's on the article's main page but if you were paying attention, you'd know about this one.

http://www.cnn.com/2014/12/16/justice/walmart-shooting-john-...

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by thaumasiotes on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:42PM (#10853602)
> In almost the entire US, being armed is not against the law.

So what? Cops don't know the law and aren't expected to know the law. The fact that a cop didn't know the law is a legal defense if you accuse him of messing up.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by raarts on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:11PM (#10853803)
Cops aren't expected to know the law? Does that hold for civilians as well?

As a comparison, here in The Netherlands, all citizens are expected to know the law. Not knowing it is never an argument as far as I know.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by wolf550e on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:51PM (#10854091)
Not knowing that what you are doing is illegal is not a defense for you, true. But when a cop arrests you for doing something they believe is illegal but in fact is legal, you are not allowed to resists arrest. You must allow yourself to get arrested (and searched) and then explain later, at the precinct. You'll lose a few hours, people will be worried about you, you might lose your job, and the police don't owe you anything, because cops do not have to know the law. Only prosecutors are supposed to know the law, and then only if a judge is willing to shame the prosecutor (not a given).
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by notdonspaulding on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @11:46PM (#10856040)
Yes, cops in the US are expected to have an above-average working knowledge of the law. If you have a question about the legality of something, you're more likely to get the correct answer asking a random cop than a random civilian.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by afarrell on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:19PM (#10853856)
Where are you are taking this from? There is a recent Supreme Court opinion (the name of which I forget) relating to the 4th amendment that I recall touches on this, but the exclusionary rule of evidence isn't what we are talking about here.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by bobwaycott on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:25PM (#10853894)
To your third:

How exactly do you define "provocation"? I'm curious because you seem to have a very lenient definition when talking about police using deadly force. This is remarkable to me when there have been a number of highly reported incidents involving police shooting a civilian without provocation that warrants deadly force (by my definition and video evidence). Here are a few to consider:

1. Tamir Rice

2. John Crawford III

3. Levar Jones

4. Laquan McDonald

Seriously, I could go on. It happens far too frequently that Americans are killed by police firearms when they are not posing an immediate and credible mortal threat. Sadly, there are too many high-profile cases in which cops fire before even bothering to assess the situation. Videos of these incidents abound.

Now, I assume we all agree that police are charged with serving and protecting their communities, right? I believe that also includes suspects and criminals. The bar for determining provocation that warrants deadly force should be very high.

If we are being rational and reasonable, I think there are behaviors that we can agree are not provocations of mortal danger. A few such behaviors:

1. Running away from police

2. Verbal altercations

3. Suspicious behaviors of any kind that are not posing credible mortal threat to other persons or officers

4. Reaching for waistbands (of what are too often excessively sagging pants that frequently need to be pulled up)

I think it is reasonable to have a civil, national conversation about better training for police, and a national charge and expectation to keep every potential suspect alive until a situation is properly assessed and resolved.

If ranchers in a standoff, or bikers in a gun battle, can make it out alive, I think many more can, too.

Funny story from my childhood in Southern California, around 1990:

I was playing in the yard with my toy gun. I hated the orange cap at the end of the barrel and had pulled it out with pliers. It was a metal rifle. A cop came down the neighborhood street, and I took cover behind a tree and pretended to shoot, as if he was my new imaginary enemy. He slowed down and stopped in front of the yard. I was within earshot, so he called out to me in a friendly way. Asked if I was shooting at bad guys. I nodded. He asked if I'd like to see his gun and might be interested in a trade. I thought that was cool, and ran over to his car with my metal toy rifle. He opened his car door to me and stepped out, asking if he could see my gun. I handed it right over, and he invited me to sit in the drivers seat of his squad car. Looking back, I'm sure he was checking if I had a real firearm. He then showed me the shotgun he had secured between the front seats. He talked to me about being careful with guns. Then he suggested there were some bad guys sneaking around my house, and I should go get them with my gun. And I ran off to chase them down.

I shudder to think what would happen to my 12-year-old in the same situation today.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by notdonspaulding on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @11:31PM (#10855996)
I'll agree that all 4 of your non-provocative behaviors should not escalate a situation to the level of deadly force being required. I specifically asked for examples from the list, because the list seems designed to support a very specific thesis, one that you expressed in this comment:

    > It happens far too frequently that Americans are killed 
    > by police firearms when they are not posing an immediate 
    > and credible mortal threat.
"far too frequently" is a fuzzy number, one that's hard to agree on. How many unjustifiable deaths per year is that? I believe the data in this article is intended to be used as a stand-in for that figure, and I posit that the actual number is dramatically lower than the fuzzy number everyone has in their heads.

If you want to really shut up the naysayers, try showing this data:

    Interactions between civilians and LEOs:  __________
    Of those, how many involved physical force? __________
    Of those, how many resulted in fatalities? __________
    Of those, how many were unjustifiable? __________
    Of those, how many went unpunished? __________
If that last number is more than a handful a year in the US, I'd be shocked, outraged, and offended. And certainly we should be shocked, outraged and offended for each individual incident of that last kind no matter how many others there are.

That being said, if you want to claim that we need "a civil, national conversation" about this, I think the onus should be on you to prove that the last number above has risen to a national crisis level. Maybe it has, but I don't think this article (or even your 4 examples) makes a very good case for it.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by bobwaycott on Friday January 08, 2016 @09:37AM (#10865091)
It honestly takes very little effort to find "more than a handful" of cases. I've provided four already. That's 2 short of "more than a handful". It's even easier to increase the number if we expand the parameters to citizen deaths at the hands of LEO with or without that death being from a bullet. There's a serious problem with American policing, and its behavior toward the citizenry. I have no interest in, nor am I trying to, "shut up the naysayers". I find naysayers tend to say nay as a rule, and default to any number of shifting goal posts and mental gymnastics to remain convinced there is no problem worth considering seriously. You've just done this yourself—you asked for a single example of an unprovoked death; now you've crafted a tailored list of questions meant to narrow the field of validity based on different parameters (you've now shifted to asking for deaths that are "unjustifiable", whatever that means).

When a 12-yr-old boy with a toy gun is shot by police after being on the scene for a few seconds, and the cop doesn't wind up in prison, there is a problem. And that problem extends from bad policing to the justice system as a whole.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by enraged_camel on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:56PM (#10853694)
>>Second: In almost the entire US, being armed is not against the law.

Way to miss the point. Of course being armed isn't against the law. But most states don't allow open-carry, and if someone is reporting you to the cops and saying you're armed, that means you just broke the law by failing to conceal your weapon. Furthermore, if the person reporting you says you're acting suspiciously or in a threatening manner, that's enough justification for most cops to shoot you.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by daveguy on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:30PM (#10853928)
On the contrary, in the US most states do allow open-carry. Only 9/50 states prohibit or restrict licensing to effectively prohibit open carry. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_carry_in_the_United_State...
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by talmand on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:08PM (#10854209)
Hard to believe but Texas just now joined that list. Keep waiting on the massive shoot-outs I've been told to expect. Still haven't seen someone open carry.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by djloche on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:29PM (#10853916)
Open carry is only disallowed in 5 states. That said, I agree that the police are more likely to shoot first and ask questions later no matter the situation.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by notatoad on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:18PM (#10853410)
In your scenario the victim would be classed as "unarmed", not "armed with a toy". The point i was trying to make is that people identified as "armed with a toy" in stats should be grouped along side armed people, not with unarmed ones like the person i replied to was doing. Because odds are, if you're interacting with police and carrying a replica weapon, the whole point of that weapon is to fool people into thinking you're armed.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:43PM (#10853110)
There is probably a better way to word this.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by kbenson on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:36PM (#10853559)
There is quite a difference between not faulting the police for shooting someone and saying that person should be shot. I do not think pointing a non-lethal weapon, much less a toy, should be automatic grounds for being shot. I do believe it may be the appropriate response in some situations though. That said, I suspect you don't really believe what you've said, and it's a case of poorly communicating your intent.

Unfortunately, on polarizing issues like this where clear communication is paramount to prevent people from wasting time arguing similar points, it seems people are more prone to comment without fully considering their wording (possibly due to high emotional investment).

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by mempko on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:38PM (#10853570)
Why? Likely from a distance the cop won't be shot if it is a real gun. The police should not be so trigger happy. What is more preferable to a society? A cop getting shot? Or a child with a toy gun?
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by CaptSpify on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:41PM (#10853595)
This seems like a case where they simplified the wording too much to be worthwhile. "Armed with a realistic-looking toy and pointing it at someone" is very different from "Playing with super-soakers and water-hoses on their lawn".
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by gohrt on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:03PM (#10853281)
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by rodgerd on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:01PM (#10853269)
There are regularly displays by men armed with AR-15s around cities in the US. Yet the police seem to be disinterested in shooting them. I wonder why?
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by 13thLetter on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:12PM (#10853372)
Simple: because they aren't pointing the AR-15s at anyone or breaking any laws. Hope that answers your question -- anything else you need help with?
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by drumdance on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:19PM (#10853419)
Look at this guy: http://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2015/11/25/laquan-mcdonald-chic....

He was walking away from the police when they shot him -- 16 times! Fortunately this was caught on camera, but a lot of shootings are not.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by rmxt on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:25PM (#10853466)
And people like these guys weren't pointing guns at other people or breaking the law?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundy_standoff#April_12_confro...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Springs_Planned_Paren...

I'm certainly not suggesting that we encourage violent responses from law enforcement. (I'm relieved injury and harm were minimized in both of the above instances.) But, it's disingenuous to think that all demographics get an equally fair shake/generous response from law enforcement when they are holding (or believed to be holding) a gun.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by 13thLetter on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:32PM (#10853516)
"But, it's disingenuous to think that all demographics get an equally fair shake/generous response from law enforcement when they are holding (or believed to be holding) a gun."

Maybe they do and maybe they don't, but that particular argument doesn't work at all. There's a huge difference between a protest (even with armed protesters) in broad daylight surrounded by cops and news media, and a split-second confrontation between a police officer and a suspect in the middle of the night. You cannot boil down both situations to "a person may have a gun."

(To be clear, that's not to make any moral judgements about the people involved in those two different situations, or what cops should or should not do. Just saying they are different, and it's dangerously simplistic to line them up next to each other and believe you've proved anything.)

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by rmxt on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:53PM (#10853670)
My main point is that it's not as simple as:

not("breaking law" or "pointing guns at other people") == not("get shot")

which is what you were snarkily making it out to be.

There are whole fields of study devoted to the issues at hand, neither you nor I will convince each other or make an airtight case in a single post regarding the full spectrum of input into all armed encounters with police that result in the output of either dying, or being arrested without incident, or anything in between.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by rodgerd on Thursday January 07, 2016 @12:26AM (#10856170)
So when someone tries to enter a property where firearms are banned, persists until the police are called, and then gets in the officers' faces while weilding a firearm, that doesn't seem like a problem to you, but gunning down children with toys is essential?

Interesting.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by 13thLetter on Thursday January 07, 2016 @01:56AM (#10856436)
If I were inclined to be rude, I might make a smartass remark in kind about how you seem to believe that the police should indiscriminately open fire on demonstrators the second they fail to cooperate in any way...

...but I won't, because I know the situations are more complicated than that and if we were speaking in person instead of over the Internet you'd probably agree with me on that, even if we didn't agree on the fundamentals of the issue.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by rayiner on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:11PM (#10852800)
Not a lot more: http://www.cnn.com/2015/10/02/us/oregon-shooting-terrorism-g.... About 30 terrorism-related deaths per year, not counting 9/11. If 9/11 is a once-every-50 year sort of event, that's another 60 per year on average.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by adam12 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:58PM (#10852702)
For me, this highlights how overblown the terrorist problem is.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by cryptoz on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:03PM (#10852748)
About 30,000 Americans die in car crashes every year. That's about ~400,000 Americans killed by other Americans in their cars since the 2001 terrorist attacks. It's pretty clear that the emotional appeal is what people seem to care about ("someone wants to kill us") and it has absolutely nothing to do at all with Americans dying.

Terrorism has never been a problem. The same number of people died in car accidents during September 2001 as they did in terrorist attacks. Where is our war on cars? Oh, nobody cares about that, cars are freedom, cars are what we went to war to protect.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by rayiner on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:24PM (#10852916)
What you call emotion, I call justice, and I think that matters.

Consider, without any emotion, the issue of murder versus suicide. What are the negative impacts of those acts? From the point of view of that person's friends and family and society at large, leaving aside emotion or notions of justice, the impact of the acts is the same: loss of that person, loss of their financial and emotional support. In fact, the impact on family and friends is often worse in cases of suicide because insurance policies often have an exemption for suicide.

Yet, almost nobody thinks murder should be legal while quite a few people think suicide should be legal. If we just mechanically consider "a death is a death" and count up the monetary impact of each case, we have no way to explain or justify why people feel this way.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:39PM (#10853073)
So you agree that the general lack of prosecutions for vehicle caused fatalities is a failure of justice?

The only difference between murder and suicide is if the person who dies chose to die.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:42PM (#10853099)
We don't prosecute people for "fatalities". We prosecute them for homicide and manslaughter, which are offenses in which the prosecution must prove intent to commit harm.

Meanwhile we do in fact prosecute car fatalities when they are caused by recklessness, and, of course, when they're caused intentionally.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:06PM (#10853314)
You engage me in a semantics debate in a condescending tone and then are wrong. Manslaughter does not require 'intent to commit harm'.

Yes, there are prosecutions of reckless/negligent drivers. However, the fact remains:

1) Most traffic fatalities are the result of human error.

2) Most traffic fatalities do not result in prosecution.

I can't find numbers to back up #2 but this semi-anecdotal evidence is telling:

http://www.wnyc.org/story/283394-killed-while-cycling-why-so...

This quote in particular makes my point:

> “We as a society have chosen to drive these big cars," said Joe McCormack, Assistant District Attorney for the Bronx. It’s his job to prosecute traffic crimes. "And we also as a society have chosen not to criminalize every single small mistake that just has a dramatic consequence because you're driving a car,” he said.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:47PM (#10853623)
I think it's actually you who have decided on the semantic debate, since the reason we don't charge lots of people with felonies for killing people with cars is pretty apparent from the comment I just wrote.

I also don't think you read my comment carefully.

As a reset: here's what the state must prove in a manslaughter case:

    First, the defendant unlawfully killed someone;

    Second, while in a sudden quarrel or heat of passion, caused by
    adequate provocation:

    a) the defendant intentionally killed someone; or

    b) the defendant killed name of victim recklessly with extreme
    disregard for human life; and

    Heat of passion may be provoked by fear, rage, anger or
    terror. Provocation, in order to be adequate, must be such as might
    arouse a reasonable and ordinary person to kill someone.
Maybe you'd rather look at a vehicular manslaughter statute? Here you go, California's:

    To prove that the defendant is guilty of this crime, the People must
    prove that:
    1. The defendant (drove under the influence of (an alcoholic
    beverage/ [or] a drug) [or under the combined influence of an
    alcoholic beverage and a drug]/drove while having a blood
    alcohol level of 0.08 or higher/drove under the influence of (an
    alcoholic beverage/ [or] a drug) [or under the combined influence
    of an alcoholic beverage and a drug] when under the age of 21/
    drove while having a blood alcohol level of 0.05 or higher when
    under the age of 21);
    2. While driving that vehicle under the influence of (an alcoholic
    beverage/ [or] a drug) [or under the combined influence of an
    alcoholic beverage and a drug], the defendant also committed
    (a/an) (misdemeanor[,]/ [or] infraction[,]/ [or] otherwise lawful
    act that might cause death);
    3. The defendant committed the (misdemeanor[,]/ [or] infraction[,]/
    [or] otherwise lawful act that might cause death) with gross
    negligence;
    AND
    4. The defendant’s grossly negligent conduct caused the death of
    another person.
This describes only a tiny percentage of vehicular fatalities.

Again: we don't prosecute people for errors. We prosecute them for doing things intentionally, or, as I said, for causing grave harm recklessly.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:14PM (#10854252)
I didn't intend to engage in a semantics debate and I did read your comment carefully. You might carefully re-read your comment to see how I got that impression.

> we don't prosecute people for errors. We prosecute them for doing things intentionally, or, as I said, for causing grave harm recklessly.

We usually don't prosecute for intentional errors. That is precisely the problem: we are far to lax with incompetent/reckless drivers. Do you think that if the costs associated with causing injury/death due to your own 'errors' were higher, we wouldn't see more careful drivers?

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:52PM (#10854528)
You asked why the lack of criminal prosecutions for automobile fatalities wasn't a "failure of justice". I answered, and answered again, and now answer yet again: because our system of justice generally avoids prosecuting people for things that aren't crimes.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:46PM (#10854859)
Your argument appears to be:

1) We don't prosecute people for things that aren't crimes.

2) Thus our system and standards for prosecuting people for things that are crimes is just.

I don't see the step from 1) to 2). I would guess you are making the following assumptions that I would disagree with:

a) We do a adequate job of enforcing the current laws. (Prosecutions tend to be fairly rare due to low priority and lack of investigative resources)

b) The current laws on the books are just. (The standards for recklessness are weighted toward DUIs and tend to exclude other types of intentional misconduct.)

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by tptacek on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:49PM (#10855148)
No. You've shifted the goalposts. You began the thread by trying to argue that a lack of prosecutions for vehicular fatalities was evidence of injustice. But it isn't: it's evidence for the fact that most traffic fatalities don't involve conduct we recognize as criminal.

Now you'd like to litigate whether we should pass laws that criminalize more kinds of driver error. I'm not interested in that discussion, and I don't have to be, because it's not germane to the argument you made up thread, except in a Calvinball kind of way.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @08:46PM (#10855400)
I'm not moving the goalposts, nor am I trying to litigate anyting. I'm simply trying to understand your argument and where we differ.

You think the current laws regarding driver culpability for errors are sufficient. Ok, fine. We've established a difference of opinion and don't need to argue it.

> You began the thread by trying to argue that a lack of prosecutions for vehicular fatalities was evidence of injustice. But it isn't: it's evidence for the fact that most traffic fatalities don't involve conduct we recognize as criminal.

From this I am going to assume that you also disagree that investigation and prosecution of traffic fatalities lack sufficient priority and resources.

If I am correct about this, then I now think the source of a disagreement is clear.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by jdmichal on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:10PM (#10853344)
I thought the whole purpose of manslaughter was that it does not require the intent to commit harm? Apparently, it's actually based on culpability. Involantary manslaughter matches my original ideal of there being no intent. But there's also voluntary manslaughter in which case intention is present but there's some other mitigating factor that reduces culpability.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by harryh on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:37PM (#10853049)
> Where is our war on cars?

We do have a war on car fatalities. It's been remarkably successful:

http://www.donerdesigns.org/_/rsrc/1376697199749/other-cause...

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:48PM (#10853161)
That graphic is rather misleading. Our success in reducing traffic fatalities is rather mixed and not nearly so dramatic:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:U.S._traffic_deaths_as_fr...

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by cbr on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:03PM (#10853282)
The first graph shows that we have made driving far less dangerous over time. The second graph shows that driving has become far more popular over time, popular enough to outweigh this effect until the early 70s.

The recent improvement in car accident rates is pretty impressive.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by Retric on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:13PM (#10853821)
If we force people to drive more by underfunding public transit then number of miles driven is going to go up due to public policy not personal choices.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:23PM (#10853448)
Yet it is misleading to support the claim of a "war on traffic fatalities" with a graph that measures something else.

The first graph show we have made driving far less dangerous per mile.

The second graph shows the likelihood that any given person will die due to traffic.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by jdmichal on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:41PM (#10853594)
I would make the reverse argument. Someone driving 100 miles today is far less likely to die doing it than, say, 30 years ago. The odds look about 3:1, eyeballing the chart. That, to me, seems like driving is far less dangerous than it was. The fact that people drive more miles today than before is an entire separate concern. One could even argue that making driving safer has also made it more popular, though I wouldn't bet on it being a large contributing factor.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:50PM (#10853643)
You seem to be missing the point. The graph was posted to show evidence for a 'war on car fatalities' not a 'war on the dangers of driving'.

This is akin to announcing a 'war on cancer fatalities' but only caring about improving cancer treatments, not removing carcinogens on the environment.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by jdmichal on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:12PM (#10853810)
Here's a gedankenexperiment for you: I instantaneously and permanently disable every car and car manufactory, thereby reducing all traffic fatalities to zero. Did I make driving safer?

I'm not missing your point, and cbr's reply makes it obvious that he isn't either. The prevalence of driving is a separate variable from how dangerous it is. Driving is far less dangerous and far more prevalent.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:54PM (#10854109)
Obviously you have completely missed the point.

> Here's a gedankenexperiment for you: I instantaneously and permanently disable every car and car manufactory, thereby reducing all traffic fatalities to zero. Did I make driving safer?

You certainly would have done an effective job of executing a 'war on car fatalities' which is what the harryh was claiming was demonstrated by the chart he posted.

While I agree that driving is safer than it used to be, the chart harryh posted doesn't actually show that. it just shows that driving is safer per mile.

Analogous to the point that cbr made: Without changing any of the risks of driving, I could make driving safer per mile by hiring a million drivers to drive 10MPH on a closed track year round.

While the above point is rather tongue-in-cheek, I do suspect that a significant part of the drop indicated in harryh's chart is due to changing driving patterns, particularly the increase in freeway driving.

I don't think eliminating all driving would be a good way to reduce traffic deaths (because it all of the other consequences that would have). However, if we had spent more effort in trying to reduce unnecessary and high-risk driving we would see a larger reduction in traffic deaths. This includes solutions like walkable cities, adequate public transit, and higher penalties for drivers engaged in risky behavior that cause fatalities. Focusing purely on deaths per mile excludes those types of interventions. Thus you can't use that measure to claim a 'war on car fatalities'.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by jdmichal on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:24PM (#10854316)
So your entire argument is centered around the semantics of "war on car fatalities"? In that case, there's not really anything for me to add, other than that I think you are taking a very uncharitable [0] view of the original post.

[0] http://philosophy.lander.edu/oriental/charity.html

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:06PM (#10854636)
I noted that a set of statistics was being misused as evidence for the specific claim being made and added a source that supported that claim, abeit less strongly. That was 'uncharitable'?

You then 'charitably' missed my point twice, and argued against a strawman. You followed that up by 'charitably' accused me of only arguing semantics rather than responding to any of my actual points.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by jdmichal on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:57PM (#10854918)
I'm pretty sure I understand your argument fine. Allow me to attempt a summary:

The original graphic shows that driving is less dangerous now than ever before. However, it does not take into account the prevalence of driving, which is also higher. Therefore, the original graphic is "misleading", because "traffic fatalities" is the combination of the danger of driving and its prevalence.

Given this current understanding of your point, my only argument now is that I believe that is an uncharitable view of the original post. I argue this because the view is entirely based on that singular interpretation of "war on traffic fatalities". A charitable approach is entirely based on attempting to view an argument with suspension of your own beliefs and interpretations in order to understand the other party's. Through such, common understanding can be worked towards.

I'm also sorry that you feel that I have been uncharitable to you. I honestly do believe your argument is entirely centered around the semantics of "war on traffic fatalities". The information you provided in your graphic is very good, and the point you are making is not wrong. I didn't have any issues at all until your response to cbr's original post, which is where I feel you began arguing semantics over content. I feel this way because cbr was also not wrong, and if anything was an equally good summary as what I stated above. And yet you still seemed to take an issue with it.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @09:26PM (#10855554)
Your suggestion that I should have reinterpreted what harryh said, does not makes sense given the context of the post he was responding to:

> Terrorism has never been a problem. The same number of people died in car accidents during September 2001 as they did in terrorist attacks. Where is our war on cars?

My main point, and reason for making the distinction between metrics is explained here:

"However, if we had spent more effort in trying to reduce unnecessary and high-risk driving we would see a larger reduction in traffic deaths. This includes solutions like walkable cities, adequate public transit, and higher penalties for drivers engaged in risky behavior that cause fatalities. Focusing purely on deaths per mile excludes those types of interventions. Thus you can't use that measure to claim a 'war on car fatalities'."

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by cbr on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:57PM (#10853700)
It's as if we were successfully making cancer less deadly, but at the same time more people were living long enough to get cancer that there were more cancer deaths. We'd still be making the kind of progress we care about in working against cancer fatalities, even though there are more of them. And a suggestion that reduce longevity so that fewer people would die of cancer would be missing the point.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:31PM (#10853939)
Would a suggestion to stop contaminating the ground water and air with carcinogens also miss the point?

Obviously, it is a bad idea to maximize the wrong metric. In the case of cancer, just measuring survival rates is a bad metric, but so is measuring cancer deaths per capita. A better metric is to measure the per-capita deaths due to cancer within specific age groups.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by spikels on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @07:11PM (#10854985)
This a very dishonest argument. Fatalities per km travelled is the standard metric of safety for a good reason.

Are you against hospitals too? Deaths in hospitals have skyrocketed since they were invented.

You are being a pedantic jerk. Read this:

http://paulgraham.com/disagree.html

Here are some more reasonable discussions of the issue:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_safety_in_the...

http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/02/a-m...

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @09:01PM (#10855476)
> You are being a pedantic jerk

"DH0. Name-calling. This is the lowest form of disagreement"

> Are you against hospitals too? Deaths in hospitals have skyrocketed since they were invented.

"DH1. Ad Hominem."

Good job, you've hit the bottom of the disagreement heirarchy. In my mind my responses are all on the level of DH4 and DH5. If I have failed to do that, please provide specific examples because I strive to disagree well and wish to improve.

> Here are some more reasonable discussions of the issue:

Neither of those are discussions of the issue at hand, which is the number of deaths due to cars. Nowhere, except in replies that attack a strawman argument, was the safety of driving a point of debate. I have even stated elsewhere that I agree that driving has gotten safer (though I do dispute that fatalities per distance is an ideal metric for measuring that since it is also affected by usage patterns in addition to safety).

I have made solid, non-pedantic points about the effect of using different metrics and what types of interventions will show up in those metrics.

If you are talking about traffic safety (say vs air travel or between countries), fatalities per distance is one of several applicable metrics (fatalities per trip being another).

If you are talking about traffic deaths, as a overall source of risk (say vs terrorism) then fatalities per capita is a more correct metric.

This is not a pedantic point, this is a very important point that is key to the discussion that you seem to be avoiding.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by harryh on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @05:07PM (#10854203)
The 60% drop since 1972 looks pretty good to me.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:27PM (#10854757)
It looks less good when you compare our numbers vs. those of other countries:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...

We have higher traffic related death rates per capita than any other 'first world' country, including coutries with similar geograhpy such as Canada and Australia.

We have higher traffic related death rates per distance than any other 'first world' country (other than New Zealand, but still including Canada and Australia)

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by harryh on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:55PM (#10854905)
Interesting! I wonder why that is? I don't have a good hypothesis.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by shkkmo on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @09:21PM (#10855535)
I don't know. If I were to guess, I would blame some combination of the large number of urban areas in the US that are pedestrian-unfriendly and the US's relatively lax punishment of DUIs. In Canada for example, a DUI is a felony. As a non canadian citizen, you will be bared from entering Canada for 5-10 years after receiving a DUI anywhere.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:42PM (#10853095)
> The same number of people died in car accidents during September 2001 as they did in terrorist attacks.

I was interested if this is true, and on the face of it it is. 2996 people died in 9/11, in 2001 (the entire year) 37,795 people died in car accidents (source: NHTSA), or an average of 3149/deaths per month.

Injuries are also higher from accidents than 9/11 for the month of Sept. 2001.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by 13thLetter on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:21PM (#10853437)
This is an argument that gets wheeled out a lot, and I'm afraid I don't see the logic in it at all. More Americans died in car crashes in December, 1941 than were killed at Pearl Harbor, too; are you going to assert that, therefore, Japan bombing Pearl Harbor was not a problem?
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by soheil on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:15PM (#10852836)
> it has absolutely nothing to do at all with Americans dying

I think it does, it's just that people are simply not aware of the numbers.

Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by jrlocke on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:37PM (#10853051)
In arguments over the relative safeness of the world it is often pointed out that relatively few people have died recently in terrorist attacks, but as N. N. Taleb points out, the distribution of deaths by terrorist attacks is a fat tailed one: the current average does not preclude much higher future numbers.
Re:Investigation: Police Shootings by spikels on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:35PM (#10853548)
I though the same thing until 9/11.

The 3,000 people killed were 20% of the 16,000 murders that year. It was by far the biggest mass murder in US history. Next biggest was 44 in the 1927 Bath School disaster.

And of course terrorism is a much bigger problem in some countries.