News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tbrock on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:32AM (#10836469)
I'm glad we bailed them out so they could wildly speculate on tech startups.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tomasien on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:09PM (#10836754)
The bailout was massively profitable for the government and every penny has been repaid. Investing in innovation is exactly what a company like GM should be doing and our tax dollars are in no way involved in this.

Edit: didn't make money on GM http://www.reuters.com/article/us-autos-gm-treasury-idUSBREA... Made lots of money overall: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/20/business/us-signals-end-of...

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by mangeletti on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:16PM (#10836821)
This is entirely untrue, pertaining GM. We tax payers lost tremendous money on GM[1], and then GM restructured (think "good bank bad bank"[2] style nonsense) in a clever way to ensure that we would never reap the benefits of the future success of "GM".

1. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-autos-gm-treasury-idUSBREA...

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_bank

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by mrtron on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:30PM (#10837404)
Canada lost about 3.5B[1] on the bailouts to GM and Chrysler as well.

[1] http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/canadian-t...

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tomasien on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:30PM (#10836925)
Good point! Very good point - I still think investing in innovation is the only thing that makes sense for GM, the reason the auto bailout worked out is because Ford*, for example, did and is crushing it.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/20/business/us-signals-end-of...

Edit: Ford did not take bailout money so that logically does not hold like I thought it did. Point about innovating still holds fine.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by j2bax on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:24PM (#10837362)
I was under the impression that Ford was the only one that didn't take a bailout.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by wavefunction on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:34PM (#10837440)
You are correct.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by cgy1 on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:46PM (#10837985)
IIRC Ford actually got very lucky in that they were actually in huge trouble before the market crash and decided to mortgage the company right before the credit market seized up. So that was really why they didn't need to take the bailout.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by georgeecollins on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:28PM (#10839222)
I would argue they were also better run than GM during this period.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by maxerickson on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:10PM (#10839107)
Didn't the government take a 61% percent stake in the good bank part of the company?

Wikipedia links this WSJ article on the topic:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB124646098696280443

The second paragraph mentions the US government being the majority owner of the new company.

Am I misunderstanding which clever restructuring you are talking about?

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by bduerst on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:15PM (#10838677)
That's because in 2009, G.M. filed one of the biggest Ch. 11 bankruptcies in history, which the bailouts failed to prevent.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by acchow on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:32PM (#10836944)
> The bailout was massively profitable for the government and every penny has been repaid

I don't really have a stance on the GM bailout, but your statement here is missing something important - every company that a government gives billions to will do disproportionately well in their industry in the short term and give solid returns. But the role of taxpayer money isn't to select winners. The free market is supposed to weed out the chaff.

Edit: Want to add a PS - the government might "make profit" on the investment, but structurally the market and society has lost.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:59PM (#10837144)
The government didn't give money, they invested because the market wasn't in a position to do so when the industry needed it. The narrative that the company is only going to do good short-term because the government gave them a lot of money doesn't make sense when the government has since sold it's position in that company for a profit, meaning the market now viewed that company as a more favorable investment then they did when the government intervened.

> The free market is supposed to weed out the chaff.

The free market doesn't care about stability, but we as the people that deal with the market, should. An unconstrained free market will swing wildly, which is one of the ways it will identify the chaff to cull, or depending on how low the swing is, the not-quite-as-good wheat to cull. The US has long recognized the benefits of a steady economy though, so while there isn't as aggressive culling, allowing some mediocre companies to survive, the environment itself is more amenable to sustaining a population of people which is the whole point of the economy.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by RottenHuman on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:20PM (#10837323)
What you're completely ignoring is the consequences such bailouts have on the market dynamics[1]. It creates a massive morale hazard which can and will incentivize market actors to take part in risky behaviour. If you are seeking to stabilize the "free" market, you are not going to do it by rewarding the losers or picking the winners.

Failing is just as important aspect of a self-regulated system as is the price, since the government voided that mechanism since forever we have an entirely disrupted market perfectly conditioned for too-big-to-fail participants.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:44PM (#10837969)
I think that depends entirely on whether you saw what happened as the government bailing out GM, or the government keeping an industry from collapsing, which just happened to by by taking the first major company of that industry to fail, and injecting capital. I don't think it would be wise to expect the government to bail GM or any other auto-maker out of a financial problem in all industry conditions and all market conditions. Investors that expect that will lose their money to investors that correctly assess all the preconditions required. I don't expect most investors to be so stupid as to think nothing bad can happen to their investment in a failing company because occasionally extreme measures are taken in extreme circumstances. At a bare minimum, they should recognize that even if a company is bailed out, that doesn't guarantee a positive return, just a theoretically less negative return than before.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by icelancer on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:08PM (#10837207)
> they invested because the market wasn't in a position to do so when the industry needed it

How is this different than "The industry planned poorly and deserves to have its assets liquidated?"

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:16PM (#10837286)
Because that industry employed two million people and a blow that large to the workforce with the economy how it was might have resulted in consequences that reached far beyond that industry.

Put another way, a free market will result in the best solution. Eventually. There's no reason we can't target what might end up being cascading failures to reduce the negative swings in the economy. I would hazard that this will result in a better economic outcome quicker, but even if it doesn't, I think it at least results in less human suffering, which is a fair trade in my eyes.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by bildung on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:44PM (#10837513)
As I understood it, the durable goods industries are the part of an economy that gets hit the most in a recession: Whether B2B or B2C, in the case of an uncertain economic outlook many customers will postpone investments in durable goods (e.g. cars, machining, housing upgrades like better heating/isolation systems etc.) more than they'll do with other products.

So: Many companies were similarly over-leveraged, but those in the durable goods industries were folding over it.

See IIRC Finland as an example: No banking or housing problems in 2007/8, but still in a recession because of the big role durable goods exports play in their economy.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tomasien on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:59PM (#10837145)
Whether or not the bailout was a good idea wasn't at issue. It's whether tax dollars are still tied up in the company or not and therefore whether the taxpayer has a right to judge the behavior of the company in that lens. At least that's how I read it.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by jegutman on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:40AM (#10836538)
This might be a bit technical, but the company that received a bailout went through bankruptcy and re-structuring.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_Chapter_11_reor...

So they didn't get a bailout that they are now using to "wildly speculate on tech startups" because all that capital has been restructured.

Many companies did get bailed out in a market where raising capital was near impossible and as a result recovered and are involved in investing in tech companies both equity and debt. Although I'm guessing your particular objection here is that they're a non-financial company and it doesn't seem to be part of their core business?

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:45AM (#10836580)
> I'm guessing your particular objection here is that they're a non-financial company and it doesn't seem to be part of their core business?

Although I'm pretty sure every major automaker is also a financial company, and has been for quite a while. All those special 0% down or cash back deals don't come from the dealer.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by adevine on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:53AM (#10836650)
GM's financial arm was GMAC, which, while bailed out during the financial crises, eventually rebranded and IPO'ed as Ally Financial.

The US Treasury made a ~ $2.4 billion profit on a $17.2 billion investment: https://www.treasury.gov/press-center/press-releases/Pages/j...

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by aaardvark on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:02PM (#10836699)
On a risk-adjusted basis, that's a pretty mediocre return.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:14PM (#10836805)
Considering the profit was at most a secondary goal of the investment, I wouldn't consider it bad at all.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:08PM (#10836746)
Sure (I was aware of most of that in general, but not the specifics), which only slightly alters my point, which is that major automakers have lots of experience in finance at certain levels. GM may have sold off a large portion of the division that handled this for them, but I would be surprised if there's not still a lot of people with quite a of of experience in finance embedded somewhere in their org.

My real objection is to thinking of automakers as not having finance as core to their business. The vast majority of new car purchases are financed in some manner[1], and many of those are through the financial divisions of the automakers[2]. To my eyes, finance incentives are core to their marketing, and marketing is core to their business.

1: http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2013/09/car-financin...

2: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-autos-financing-insight-id...

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tedmiston on Monday January 04, 2016 @09:32PM (#10840600)
I made some pretty unreasonable but convenient assumptions with the basic compound interest formula in back-of-the-envelope math to arrive at ~2.25% annual interest rate.

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=compound+interest&a=*C....

Assumptions:

- I know the amount was not dispersed all at once at the start

- I have no idea what compounding frequency seems appropriate

- Does not account for inflation

- Time frame: 12/29/2008–10/17/2014 per the linked pdf [1]

Aside: $17.2B 2008 dollars adjusted for inflation becomes $18.89B 2014 dollars.

https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=17%2C200%2C000%2C000+2...

That makes the return a bit less exciting.

I'd love to model this in a more accurate way if others know how that might be done.

1: https://www.treasury.gov/press-center/press-releases/Documen...

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by MajorLOL on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:09PM (#10836753)
>The US Treasury made a ~ $2.4 billion profit on a $17.2 billion investment

Factor in the interest USA would have saved by paying down the national debt instead. Additionally, consider what private investors would have returned with the same investment and what they would have paid in tax on personal income if they had never been taxed that $17.2b instead.

They won on this one, we can point at the various Solyndras the USA has bet on and lost while we are at it. This ignores the fact that we don't mail taxes in for government to act like a massive VC. We send the cash in so they can fix the 'crumbling roads and bridges', service debt and help the poor we are always hearing about.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by criley2 on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:21PM (#10836849)
>Factor in the interest USA would have saved by paying down the national debt instead.

The average interest rate on the debt is 2.43$, we have around $17 trillion debt, and you're talking about a $17 billion paydown (0.1%).

The amount of interest saved would be around $400 million per year. The profit on the GM bailout was $2400 million, so it would have taken 6 years for the decreased interest to total 2.4 billion.

>we can point at the various Solyndras the USA has bet on and lost while we are at it.

Can you point to the value of the hundreds or thousands of engineers and employees of failed new energy startups that received invaluable real world training and experience who are lending those talents to other companies.

Think about NASA and the 18 billion we "piss away" down that black hole every year, and the huge benefits that we derive from their work and the experience that those who work there gain.

Not every investment the government makes has a return in next-year-dollars.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by jegutman on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:32PM (#10837896)
Slightly technical point, but the average interest rate of outstanding debt is not particularly relevant, the relevant would be the average short term rates over the span of the investment. Would've been much lower than 2.4% over the life time of this investment.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by MajorLOL on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:32PM (#10836941)
Debt: 6 years to realize the savings on the interest? It nearly took GM that long to repay the debt they took on. It's sounding like a worse investment all the time.

OTJ Experience: I think it's less speculative and lines less wealthy billionaires pockets to invest directly into education and industry beyond private market money to provide great learning experiences for people.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by criley2 on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:19PM (#10838235)
>It's sounding like a worse investment all the time.

Until you realize the negative feedback loop of hundreds of thousands of GM employees hitting unemployment lines, and the secondary and tertiary companies that supply and contract for GM also shutting down. 200,000 employees * 1,000/mo unemployment * 100 weeks = $20 billion dollars. Obviously a terrible case, but not even a worst case as I examine only GM employees and not the subsequent losses in direct suppliers/contractors and community losses relying on those employees patronage.

Sure, the investment may not have great returns.

But are you calculating the billions in reduced welfare, or the billions in increased GDP, or the effect of stopping a negative feedback loop which spirals more deeply?

I mean, a GM level destruction isn't just GM. Isn't just suppliers. It's grocery stores. It's car mechanics. It's big box stores. It's fast food. It's everything in those communities that former employees patronized.

When you examine the decision more deeply than "net dollar returned" I think you'll develop a greater appreciation for the economic benefits of entire communities not being ruined.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by MajorLOL on Monday January 04, 2016 @06:21PM (#10839559)
So the core of it is; the ROI is irrelevant, it's value was the prevention of job loss and market failures.

Now you see why I'm not excited and jumping for joy when people spin it as a profitable investment. It never was a money making endeavor, if it turned out to be, it was by happenstance.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:26PM (#10836901)
Consider the loss in tax revenue and increased social program expenditure if the industry collapsed and some portion of the ~ 2 million US auto-workers lost their jobs. Consider the effect this could have had on the wider economy, and how that could have affected government finances, not to mention the average citizen.

The US government has always invested in it's industries, either through broadly applicable programs like the patent office, or through more targeted items like specialized laws and grants for specific industries. Cash investment isn't really all that different, except they might actually expect some sort of monetary return on that investment, unlike grants.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by adevine on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:28PM (#10839221)
Just want to comment on the "Factor in the interest USA would have saved by paying down the national debt instead." statement. During the financial crisis paying down the national debt would have been pure folly. The US was borrowing at basically 0% at that point and purposefully trying to flood the economy with cash.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by whistlecrackers on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:00PM (#10836679)
You get it. Some times the automotive side takes a backseat to the financing.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tinkerrr on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:41AM (#10836545)
So you're saying a stagnant company in a stagnant industry that almost died should remain stagnant and not try anything risky at all?

It's not wild speculation for GM. They most likely have ways to work together. It's unlikely a completely passive investment.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by giarc on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:14PM (#10836800)
As the article states, GM is going to help Lyft set up rental centres across the states. I imagine this means GM vehicles therefore GM is not only investing in Lyft, they also get people driving their vehicles and passengers sitting in those vehicles. It's almost advertisement.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by bduerst on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:18PM (#10838700)
It's an awareness piece for investors about GM's market investment into Lyft's new rental fleet.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by tonyedgecombe on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:48AM (#10836608)
It should have been allowed to fail, propping it up is unfair competition against its stronger competitors.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by bendykstra on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:06PM (#10836730)
GM has good reason to make risky decisions, since the taxpayers will likely be asked to support the company a second time if it runs into trouble. As a taxpayer, I would like them to be as safe and stagnant as possible, but I have no say in the matter. This is the moral hazard created by the bailout.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by ssmoot on Monday January 04, 2016 @12:45PM (#10837031)
Ford was in bad shape in 2006.

Does anyone even remember the Ford of 2006? With their awful Focus when everyone was clamoring for the euro version? Or the Ford 500?

They didn't avoid a "bailout" because they were a strong company. Two years earlier they mortgaged everything (including the iconic blue-oval logo) while money was still cheap. It was pure luck. Not strength or some sort of moral superiority.

So by the time the crash rolled arounds and GM and Chrysler couldn't do the same, Ford had already secured over $25 billion in funding, with another $5 billion in government loans to refresh some factories to produce greener cars.

I'm not trying to argue GM or Chrysler did or didn't "deserve" a bailout. It's just a pet peeve of mine that there's this revisionist aura around Ford these days. They sold Jaguar and Land Rover to Tata for $2.3B, about half what they paid, and significantly less than they've made since. They sold Aston Martin for about $1B (well, that one was probably not a bad idea at least). They also sold Volvo for another $1.5B. They liquidated their stake in Mazda to the tune of about $500M dollars. Discounting the F-series, Ford easily had the worst portfolio, and were in trouble years before the others. They sold off several brands at a significant loss for some quick cash. Not all of those were smart moves in hindsight and they lost their shirts on most.

While Ford has taken government assistance, they've milked their amazing ability to avoid TARP by failing before everyone else for all it's worth. Will they be as lucky next time? What are they going to put into a $10B fire-sell next time? And will they be lucky enough next time to secure $25B in loans while the market money is still flowing? Will the government be handing out $5B loans to modernize factories?

I guess time will tell, but I felt like the conversation could use a little balance.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by kbenson on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:09PM (#10837220)
This all points towards i being a market problem that the government tried to mitigate (which fits their narrative), not a problem specifically with GM being so bad it needed a bailout. If the market wasn't in the disarray from the beginnings of a recession (and IMO what might have well been a depression without intervention), then it's entirely possible that GM would have found enough investment from other sources to pull itself out of the problem (as you point out, Ford was able to do it a few years prior, and GM was able to do it with the government investment).

Investors that think the government will bail out GM again just because they have in the past are betting money in a way that they're likely to lose. The important factor of the GM bailout wasn't GM, it was how the industry as a whole was doing, and how the financial markets were acting at the time. GM would have been the first of a set of dominoes that included most if not all the auto-makers due to their shared dependencies on the parts companies that would have went out of business (which Ford testified to at the time). The important thing here is the dominoes, not GM. They just happened to be the first one in line.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by rifung on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:50PM (#10837568)
I apologize if this is incorrect as the only bits I know are from my interest in cars and not finance, but I don't think it was completely luck that Ford decided to try to get money. From what I understand, they did all this because Alan Mullaly just took over as CEO and he wanted to cushion a potential unexpected event.

At least that's what it says here: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/09/business/09ford.html?scp=5...

As far as I can tell, Alan Mullaly is a very good CEO who many consider to be responsible for the comeback of both Ford and Boeing. I remember there were rumors he was even considered for the position of CEO of Microsoft. That being said, I don't think you could say it was completely luck.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by csours on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:40PM (#10837945)
I just finished reading American Icon by Bryce Hoffman.

Ford realized they needed to change long before this; around 2001 (around the same time that Bob Lutz was preaching to GM). Bill Ford and Mark Fields were already planning to do many of the things that Mulally wound up doing.

What Alan Mulally did was still incredibly amazing - he restructured the reporting structure at the top of the company, increased accountability, increased transparency, increased trust and made people deliver on the plans. He got people to surface their problems at the executive level, where before everyone hid the issues for fear it would be used as ammunition against them by fellow executives.

Mulally emphasised the core brands, and in fact wanted to ditch ALL the brands except for Ford. He got Ford to bring over the European models that were far superior to their equivalents in the USA. He brought the Mazda product development model to Ford, where the engineers and designers sit in the same room. He sped up implementation of Global Ford Production System, patterned in large part on the Toyota Production System. He worked with the UAW to decrease legacy costs by funding the VEBA (UAW run healthcare fund) and trading worker concessions for promises to keep production in the USA. He worked with suppliers to decrease costs and increase supplier satisfaction. He reduced the number of dealers.

When I say "he" did these things above, I mean he pushed for them. In almost all instances they were accomplished by other executives and team members.

The discipline and planning were not luck; the timing was very lucky indeed.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by ssmoot on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:34PM (#10837904)
It's always a mix. And is it luck or preparedness and foresight? Either way, there's a strong argument to be made that Ford was in very bad shape, and their timing in 2006 was amazing. Had they held out much longer there might very well not be a Ford today.

This is an interesting article I just ran across, and suggests the fundraising actually predated Mullally: http://fortune.com/2011/05/25/fords-forgotten-man/

I dunno. Ford is looking a bit 90's Apple right now IMO. Product (outside of the F-series) seems a week point.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by matthewmacleod on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:50AM (#10836625)
This is not a valuable contribution to any discussion.

GM should be developing their business, in part to ensure they don't end up in a situation where they are stagnant and need bailed out again. Investment in startups in the same industry is a sensible approach to this.

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by pc86 on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:39AM (#10836528)
Well they've paid back the money already (as of 2010 or so?) so I'm not sure that's totally relevant to what they're doing now.
Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by spoiledtechie on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:48AM (#10836611)
Not really, what your speaking of isn't entirely accurate.

http://business.time.com/2013/12/17/gm-ceo-were-not-paying-a...

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by pc86 on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:28PM (#10837388)
You're talking about the delta in share value. The money they took was paid back.[0] They are two completely different things.

> Q: Did General Motors repay its TARP loan from the Treasury with other TARP money? > A: Yes. GM repaid the loan portion of the automaker bailout ahead of schedule, with interest.

The article you cite seems to suggest that the government should have had some sort of guarantee from GM that the gov't would be able to sell shares back for no less than what they paid for them. I don't think any such promise was ever made.

> taxpayers are still stuck with GM stock that isn’t worth what was paid for it.

[0] http://www.factcheck.org/2010/05/general-motors-debt/

Re:G.M. Invests $500M in Lyft by mmanfrin on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:53AM (#10836647)
Yep because bailing out a capstone company buttressing up an enormous cottage industry of parts makers was such a bad idea.