Not the OP, but I think a lot more people nowadays should read (or re-read) Locke's "Two Treatises of Government". That book is famous mostly for the second part, where Locke actually intellectually imposes private property as a thing in the Western world, but I found the first part equally interesting, where Locke fights against a guy called Filmer, who was of the opinion (prevalent until then) that all property was rightfully owned by the King, transferred to him from generations past since Adam.
The thing I'm trying to say is that yes, private property is just a social construct, there's no divine nor moral thing about it, the concept came alive (so to speak) only because some guys in England didn't like that their possessions were in danger of being confiscated by the King's men.
In the end private property is indeed theft, more exactly the imposition of someone's moral values over the other's by intrinsic force (if you "steal" you might go to prison or worst). The sooner we realize this the better, there's no second-guessing about it.
Which, I think, is the central issue regarding property rights and inequality. We should question all rent generating property rights, just as Locke did, and try to find a system of propert rights where rent doesn't create inequality.
Taxation seems to be he popular approach, but why not try to redefine the rights all together? What if such property rights were time limited, and came with a fee equal to the rent potential?
I agree with your stance on component 1. The raw materials, the land, they do in fact manifestly belong to everyone.
On component 2, the labor or improvements, I don't think those do belong to everyone. They belong exclusively to the creator who can transfer title. In fact, society has no moral claim on this component at all in my estimation.
Here is my idea. Stop funding society by taxing labor. It's counterproductive. It's morally wrong. Tax material and land use. This is what society truly has a claim on and how society should fund itself.
What you're pointing out is a monopoly called "The Legal System": a single dispute resolution system everyone must adhere to without choice (Government/Mafia). This monopoly is often based on geolocation. Property will be inherently aggressive if one is forced to use a specific dispute resolution system.
Everyone withholds stuff from others: it is 100% universal. In this way, the notion of "property is theft" can not hold because everyone (even animals) do it: consciously or subconsciously.
There is then the system of dispute resolution. This defines if a particular act of withholding was an act of "theft".
The combination of withholding + dispute resolution results in what we call property.
Competing dispute resolution systems is really that free-market people hope for. Dispute resolution systems do not have to be based on geolocation. In fact, people form millions of these unique systems every day, freely, without resorting to monopolies or the lowest of low dispute resolution: killing one another.
> The sooner we realize this the better, there's no second-guessing about it.
So ya. Property in and of itself is not theft. Forcing others to use a specific dispute resolution could be viewed as the theft.
I'm curious how that follows? Many actions require force but are not theft (depriving someone of rightful resources). If your 'moral' values deprive someone of their own rightful resources you probably deserve to have some intrinsic force applied. In that way private property would seem to me to be close to a moral good.
Private property can't be "theft" if there is no private property.
If you don't believe in private property, you're sort of poisoning the well of any economic conversation, since it's the foundation of basically all of peaceful civilization.
Without private property there is only tribalism and, "might makes right."
http://io9.gizmodo.com/5872764/the-greatest-mystery-of-the-i...
That being said, many things are possible in groups with smaller populations, I've heard stories of large communes being fairly successful with up to several thousand people. However, at some point they tend to become too disorganized and break down, in one way or another.
In contrast, the concepts of private property and trade have enabled our human family to grow to 7 Billion, and population growth is barely even slowing down yet. Civilization allows things to work on an entirely different scale by providing a somewhat standardized framework for our territorial disputes.
This is also the most non-violent time in history by far, according to researchers, presumably due to the end of tribalism.
So, for me personally, there would have to be extremely compelling arguments to even begin to argue against the utility of private property as a social and economic system.
The disconnect here is that property rights are "more guidelines than actual rules", they are quite literally "made up". It used to be that keeping a black person out of your store was a "property right", until we decided it wasn't, and then we got rid of that one. It used to be that preventing airplanes from flying over your farm was a "property right" until it wasn't, and then we got rid of that one. You can only do that if "property rights" are artificial.
I mean just look around you. We live in a world where Smartflash has a "property right" to your in-app purchases, Apple has a "property right" to your iPad, JSTOR has a "property right" to publicly-funded research, etc. etc. That's because we made it that way; let's unmake it, and do it differently!
To a first approximation every single person on the planet had far less in the 1950s/1960s.
"Equality" sucks if it means that everyone is equally impoverished.
It seems like we probably benefit from an arrangement where we control the things in our immediate surroundings that we need in order to maintain reasonably stable and predictable lives. For instance it makes sense for me to control access to things like my glasses, bike, pajamas, etc. Property rights work pretty well for defining that arrangement.
At the other extreme, we have situations where property rights can be overridden, such as taxation and eminent domain, and entities whose value depends on a stable money system provided by the government -- I see no a priori reason why the workable way to manage those things is not through a system of limited property rights. In broad terms, one such limitation is an agreement that taxation is not a violation of a fundamental human right.
The more abstract and artificial "property" gets, the more reasonable that property rights are balanced against other things, such as redistribution.
This is the core of our system. And that system will always generate inequality.
Sure, and to the extent that it works, it's OK. When it doesn't work, then it seems reasonable to manage it in order to make it work better. Some broad-brush ideas are for the government to provide a functioning money system, and a way to redistribute wealth against the tide of inequality.
As a useful legal fiction subject to the same limitations as others of its genus, sure.
As a natural moral right? Not in the slightest, because there ain't no such thing. The history of "ownership" of any given thing today is basically a history of force, fraud and the occasional lucky break. Who should own a piece of land? What moral claim do they have to it? The very best that can be said today is that they can trace a chain of transfers back to the person who most recently was able to stay on that land without being forcibly put underneath it by someone else. What kind of grounding for a supposed moral good is that?
So I believe in Thomas Hobbes' conception of the state of nature -- namely, that there are no rights, no virtues, no morals, nothing but all-out war for resources, where what is "yours" is what you can take and keep by violence -- and in his conception of government as what we introduce when we get tired of that, and that this arrangement is better than the "war of all against all" even though it comes at the expense of sometimes having the government decide that "my" property could be put to a better use.
Now, do you want to try engaging with the actual argument (property is a useful legal fiction, not an inherent moral right)?
If you accept his arguments, you're basically advocating a dictatorship (or his era's equivalent, a king ruling by "divine right").
For another, his notion that humans are motivated purely by ego and self-aggrandizement is demonstrably wrong.
Posit a "desert island" scenario in which an adult is marooned with a small child. Assume that rescue is impossible (or at least wildly unlikely). No legal repercussions to worry about.
The child has collected some fruit, clams, or whatnot.
The adult is hungry.
In this situation, a Hobbes person would simply take the food from the child.
While there certainly are some real people who would do that, most of us would not. They would prefer to collect their own fruit and clams rather than take them from the child by force.
Even if there weren't enough food to go around, many would give the food to the child and choose to go without themselves.
As with many political theories, the Hobbes model says rather more about its originator than it does about people in general.
Many of these philosophers, including John Locke (who Jefferson cribbed heavily from when writing the US Declaration of Independence), wrote as if the morals of Enlightenment-era westerners would magically naturally exist in people living in such a "state of nature", and simply took them for granted.
Hobbes pointed out that this was balderdash. Our entire conception of propriety, of right and wrong, of what is or isn't acceptable, comes not from some natural moral law engraved into our hearts or deduced in an ideal pre-society state of pure reason, but rather is inculcated into us by the culture in which we live. So Hobbes dismissed the idea that people would be respectful and helpful in the "state of nature" and pointed out that, since that stuff only comes into being later with organized society, none of it would exist at that point. Hence the war of all against all.
Which is where your desert-island analogy, and most other attempts to tear down Hobbes' state of nature, fall apart: your stranded people come in with experience of an organized culture which taught a particular set of morals and norms. One of those norms is that the adult should go hungry to let the child eat, but there is no guarantee that some natural moral law written in the adult's heart would have produced the same outcome absent years of indoctrination in a particular culture's moral system (and in fact, in actual nature we can find examples of animal species where adults will kill and even eat young of their own species).
The first two are complicated, because they are extremely political. To own geographic space is entirely divisive from owning just the dirt under a house, or the physical material that composes it. To own an idea, a trademark or a patent, is to assign exclusivity to thoughts. Its much easier to say "we have scarce goods, so those that create them can sell them, and the buyer owns it". Its why I think goods property is a good thing, but our attempts to strong arm real estate and IP into the same formula is a cause of constant economic tension because they aren't a good fit.
Just in this context for reference, I'm an IP abolitionist and think we should adopt homesteading of property again. Both forms of state granted monopoly to space and idea are being rampantly exploited by market forces and were conceived of in an age when technology did not enable the information exchange we have today. It would have been much more complicated to verify usage of a plot of land a hundred years ago than it would now, to know who previously owned it and for how long it has been unused before you could claim it as your own.
That individuals believe government should be directed at investors who risk their property to create wealth in order to take by force that property to redistribute it is perhaps the most offensive sentiment.
> There is no reason why the bulk of the billions taken-in by WalMart should go to the Walton family while their employees live on food-stamps - that is just a legal arrangement. And there is no reason why the Walton family should continue to be allowed to use offshore corporations to loan themselves money to run all their WalMart stores - that is just a legal arrangement which allows them to avoid taxes and hide their billions offshore
No one is arguing the value of the social safety net. The comment goes above and beyond the safety net suggesting it shouldn't be needed and the remedy is redistribution. A safety net is one thing but arbitrarily inflating wages is another.
I don't believe the suggested remedy would be proposed by someone who believes in property rights. Further, as a person who believes in property rights I do find the sentiment of theft of property for redistribution offensive.
(The concept didn't work out so well for Marie Antoinette)
If a revolution comes and you find yourself thrown up against a wall somewhere, remember your comment this evening.
If a violent revolution comes, I'd be thinking more about those pervasive comments touting a belief that theft of private property is somehow justified. I'd suspect those making such comments would be a little more regretful to see their rhetoric fulfilled.
Truly terrifying.
That we are debating the goodness of property rights in this day is a mystery to me.
Having a legal/police system to catch people who forcebly take property?
Using trade to exchange property?
This is the core of our system. And that system will always generate inequality.
Not necessarily a bad thing.
You can have laws to take the edge off inequality generated, but at the core of the system you can't really avoid it.