Realistically speaking, no amount of density housing would provide a 3000sqft house for 400k. Maybe a condo in a high rise, possibly skimping on "good school district". Density housing is not the path towards the 3000sqft SFH American dream, sorry.
That is the big problem with telecommuting for me - it seems hard to find companies which are willing to pay silicon valley level salaries to people living outside silicon valley, and if you take a pay cut, the savings in rent diminishes drastically.
I suppose it is different when you start in silicon valley and move elsewhere while staying in the same company, rather than just starting out elsewhere. But that is still an concern since your salary gets reset if you ever change companies without moving back to silicon valley.
> But that is still an concern since your salary gets reset if you ever change companies without moving back to silicon valley.
I'm not sure if this is true. If you're going to work for another SV company and remote, it's quite common for you to be able to quote a number higher than you got from your previous remote job and negotiate your way down to at or just above where you actually were in the previous job. The only time where I'd see you needing to adjust your salary down is if you took a job with a non-SV company in the interim. Just be aware that the salary data used by each company may be different.
But it is probably helpful to come to SV/SF at some point in the beginning and transition to remote work initially because hiring out here is somewhat incestuous and having a well-known SV employer on your CV will help with getting past HR filters and ensure you get the necessary LI touches.
With my current employer, I get paid the same regardless of where I live.
Density is necessary to build more supply in the same area. Unless you have a plan to level mountains and use the rock to fill the bay, they aren't making any more land area.
That's why density is the alternative to crazy impossible housing prices.
Do you mean to say:
1. That it's impossible to add 10,000 new housing units per year? That seems pretty unlikely.
2. If SF added 10,000 new housing units per year, housing prices wouldn't decline? Why not?
3. The politics of SF rule out the construction of 10,000 additional housing units per year? I agree, but think that needs to change; that's my whole argument.
4. That both politics and logistics would enable SF to add 10,000 additional new housing units per year, but that shouldn't happen because it would change the character of the city? That's an intellectually coherent argument, but one that I think a lot of people don't find compelling; I think if you're coming from a place of "save San Francisco's status as a postcard city", you should be up-front about that, rather than pretending that your argument is that fixing SF housing is somehow impossible.
(I took the "10,000" notion from your comment).
I also think this is part of the reason people in SF (rationally, in a purely self-interested sense) oppose building: the amount of increased housing on offer won't help them. So they bear the costs of living in a construction zone with zero benefits.
Building 200k homes over the next 5 years would help, but no-one is in any way contemplating that. And even beyond the housing fight itself, the infrastructure here can't handle it.
My friends who live in NYC metro area all have gorgeous estately 4bedroom 5 bathroom houses for between 500-700k in nice little commuter towns close to NYC like Rye and Stanford with simple commutes to NYC on the trains.
Whereas we make more than they do we are stuck scraping together 1.4 million for an ugly crack shack in redwood city. Seriously my wife and I looked at this piece of crap last weekend:
https://www.redfin.com/CA/Redwood-City/3452-Page-St-94063/ho...
Not only was it a mold filled fucking dump, it was located in the hood with no public transit nearby. meanwhile my friends who work in NYC are able to get something gorgeous like this for way less $$ and can walk to downtown and a train station:
https://www.redfin.com/CA/Norwalk/15203-Sylvanwood-Ave-90650...
or even if you want to get more expensive, this is still cheaper than the Redwood City dump, you get two stories, a deck and giant yard and you are right next to MetroNorth:
https://www.redfin.com/NY/Rye/200-Highland-Rd-10580/home/201...
The infrastructure in San Francisco (you mean, I assume, the roads and the public transit system) are abysmal, but they've been that way for a long time. It's possible that the Muni has actually improved since the second dot-com boom; when I lived there, it was a joke.
Much of the increase in supply is in condos costing $1.2k +/ft2, ie more than $1mm, which exacerbates the above effects. They also don't help for people who can't afford to spend the roughly $5.5k or so that a $1mm property costs (after $200k downpayment, inclusive of tax and hoa fees.)
If you want to bring down house prices in sf, you have to build enough to satisfy pent-up demand from the peninsula, and outrun continued population movement from the whole US into SF. Or force the peninsula to build housing.
5k or 10k homes isn't going to to outrun demand, particularly after years of building virtually no housing in sf.
2.) Unclear. It's fairly well-established that building more roads leads to more traffic, for example. So building more housing--up to a point, of course--may just lead to that much greater a population.
3/4.) Politics (i.e. the preference of voters) do seem to rule out a mass increase in housing units and associated infrastructure. I don't have any opinion on what SF should or shouldn't do. I don't live there, don't particularly want to live there, and think the character of SF is a matter primarily for the existing residents.
(3) and (4) aren't the same argument.
Argument (3) concedes that increasing housing supply in SF is a good thing, but that it can't happen because of political obstinacy. If you believe this, you're on the same page as I am, and we don't have much to debate.
Argument (4) suggests instead that increasing the housing supply of SF is a bad thing, because it's more important to retain the character of San Francisco than it is to accommodate people who want to live there.
There may be some argument (5) that I missed as well.
We remain in a place where I still don't understand your objection to my argument that San Francisco should resolve its housing problems by drastically increasing the supply of housing units.
Put another way, I don't consider growth to be a universal positive. I would certainly tend to vote against zoning changes that created more development in my semi-rural town.
My theory is that prop 13 is the root of all evil. If it were repealed, and the old timers were forced to pay market rate taxes on their houses (and hence forced to sell out), it would change the voting demographics. Eventually, zoning rules and city plans would be relaxed to allow taller, higher density housing. This would gradually ease the supply side, and result in a larger supply, and hence lower prices. That's how it seems to work in many other markets.
So, force people to move out of the neighborhoods where they've lived all their lives. I'm by no means a general gentrification opponent but arguing that people should be forced to move out of their homes so that wealthy techies can move in?
It's surprising to me that people can look at the millionaire SF property owners as being deserving of public subsidy in perpetuity.
Where I live tax assessments are done regularly, tempered by a maximum 10% annual increase to prevent excessive shocks to the market. It seems like a reasonable compromise that puts all people on equal terms.
In the rest of the country, when somebody like Google or Facebook comes to town property values shoot up. Property tax assessments follow 1-5 years later. The higher assessments combined with lucrative offers from developers convince the existing owners who cannot afford to live there to move. They take their windfall and move someplace more affordable. Meanwhile, developers build higher density housing, which keeps prices, while high, from reaching insane levels. Everybody wins.
However, I have no sympathy for your argument. It is essentially, "I don't like the way people are voting so we should find a way to run them out of town."
Prop 13 correctly protects against such a situation. That is a good thing.
"It also prohibited reassessment of a new base year value except for in cases of (a) change in ownership, or (b) completion of new construction."
I live in Los Angeles and we have a similar problem being a popular location in California. Basically, there are people living in their homes paying the same taxes they paid in 1978, while anyone trying to buy a similar house will owe modern taxes. So you might be paying $15,000/yr. in taxes and your next door neighbor in a comparable house is literally paying $500/yr. That makes no sense. I've owned property in other states and assessments are done every 1-5 years.
The fallout is that certain areas pay significantly lower taxes, thus contributing significantly less to the community than other areas. It's made worse by the fact that if you inherit your house from your parents (or if they gift it to you before they die), you continue paying the 1978 taxes (or whatever year they bought or built the house). That's insane and it's unfair. It has nothing to do with how people vote. If they paid their fair share, you might have a point, but they don't, unless they decide to do construction on their house. It makes for a very uneven (and I would argue unfair) market.
I bought a home. It was a responsible purchase, in line with my earnings. 30 years later, I pay the home off. I retire on a fixed income which accounts for the roughly fixed costs of my home and its upkeep.
Now a big company builds a campus next door. Home prices skyrocket. What do I do? If my property tax is bounded, I'm fine. If not, then suddenly I lose my home because my fixed income did not account for my property taxes skyrocketing.
Sure, Prop 60 accounts for that by transferring basis, but maybe I'm 54 when this occurs so it doesn't apply. Or maybe I'm not retired, but have 3 kids in the local school district and having to uproot my family because I can't afford my home is extremely disruptive.
One of the points in buying a home, rather than renting, is to guarantee that stability.
I agree that there are problems with prop 13, but fairness is a two sided coin. It is certainly not fair for my home (which I own) to suddenly become unaffordable due to external circumstances. Likewise it's not fair for a neighbor to pay double for roughly the same consumption of public services.
I don't know the solution. Possibly decoupling property tax from home values might be the answer. It certainly isn't a very good tracker for public good consumption.
Also, I don't see why property tax increases for existing homes couldn't be capped in some way (say no more than inflation) to make this situation reasonable for people in the scenario you've laid out. But just saying, "Your taxes will never increase again as long as you stay in your home," hardly seems reasonable.
Second, I agree on the inheritance piece. That is a problem.
The argument is NOT to run them out of town. The argument is that them not feeling the pinch of high prices encourages them to vote for policies that drive housing supply down, to everyone else's detriment. This comment summarizes it better: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10822124
> have not been forced to sell due to real estate taxes
We're discussing why high real estate taxes forcing people to sell is "good thing"... That's pretty much running them out of town.
Like you, at the moment, I am not sure what a proper solution will come up to.
After living there for 2 years and paying insane rent (more than $5K/mo on a 1200sqft house), I now telecommute for a Bay Area company, and live in central VA in a 3000sqft house in a good school district with a community pool, etc, which cost less than $400K. I telecommute most of the time, and I fly to CA 5-6 times per year (on the company's dime). My quality of life is so much better. I mostly miss the weather and the food, but not the traffic & the crowds and the prices.
Not to mention that I'm using one of my 5 bedrooms as a private office, which is so, so, so much better than a low-walled cube in an open office environment.