News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by golemotron on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @08:14AM (#10783107)
Undoing hierarchy at every turn is in the zeitgeist. We need to take some time to appreciate when it is useful. My belief is that it is useful for quick action and inevitable when human systems scale.
Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by k__ on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @09:02AM (#10783270)
The problem doesn't seem to be hierarchy, but that it's expected to climb it.

Some people are good in management, some aren't.

But if you're long enough in a job, you have to take on a management position to get paid more or to make decisions in your favor.

Yes the payment thing isn't a big problem in the IT sector, senior engineers often get paid as much or even more than managers. But the decision part is still a problem. Often you end up with stupid ideas you have to execute and the only way to change them is to get rid of the manager, because he won't consider he failed...

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by laotzu on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @09:17AM (#10783356)
Success is as dangerous as failure. Hope is as hollow as fear.

What does it mean that success is as dangerous as failure? Whether you go up the ladder or down it, your position is shaky.

When you stand with your two feet on the ground, you will always keep your balance.

-Lao Tzu

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by eggie on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @09:23AM (#10783380)
Lovely. Are you a Lao Tzu quote bot ;) ?
Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by kabdib on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @09:24AM (#10783388)
Even in a flat organization, some people are good at organizing other folks and getting things done that way, while others are good at sitting down by themselves and cranking stuff out. I'd say the needle is much farther towards "communication and cooperation" (as opposed to "unopinionated worker drone") than in a hierarchy, but the spread of abilities is still there.

The nice thing about being truly flat is that there's no boss to get rid of if they're not working out. You just decide not to work with them.

[Flat isn't totally wonderful and there are still issues with it which I don't care to get into right now.]

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by pdkl95 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @09:44AM (#10783511)
> the decision part is still a problem.

"How s plan becomes policy"

http://ogun.stanford.edu/~bnayfeh/plan.html

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by erikpukinskis on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @01:55PM (#10784910)
> Undoing hierarchy at every turn is in the zeitgeist.

Question for folks: Do you really think this is happening or are people just talking about it? I've worked for people who talked a big collaboration/flat structure game, but when it comes down to important projects, all of the sudden, one guy is the decider, and he is only giving responsibility to his lieutenants, who have direct command over the people below. He can count on his hand the number of people who have true control over real resources, which makes it easy for him to reason about where costs are going.

Everyone tries to be nice about it, but my sense is that almost no one actually believes in giving serious responsibilities to a wide range of people. They have their go-to people, and everyone else has to prove themselves by following directions well and maybe they can get a position in that structure at some theoretical later date.

I haven't worked in very many different companies though, so I would love to hear if that's actually becoming a bigger thing in other places. I know Valve is different, but they seem more and more like an outlier to me.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by freshhawk on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @02:14PM (#10785026)
It's useful to make the distinction between structural hierarchies and social ones (and useful to be really skeptical of the zeitgeisty posts that don't differentiate between the two).

So flatten your company structure however you like, there will be a social hierarchy in place as well because these are Humans we are talking about. The people who have interesting things to say about this will talk about how this is the real power of a flat structure, that the social hierarchy is much more dynamic and re-arranges itself on demand and multiple context dependent hierarchies will exist all inter-relating. Your static and slow to adapt org-chart hierarchy just gets in the way.

Of course there are a lot of cons as well as the pros, you will get cliques, introverts, regardless of ability, will be disadvantaged, these subconscious social hierarchy building behaviours incorporate all those ugly human prejudices we know are maladaptive, etc.

But overall I find it a really interesting argument.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by TeMPOraL on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @02:42PM (#10785170)
This is what really happens, and generally what should be happening. But it's against the zeitgeist - it's undemocratic, it's not inclusive, etc. - that's why you mostly shut up about it and rely on leaders self-selecting themselves when a challenge arises. Humans understand this implicitly, therefore only complain when either a) the matter is insignificant to anything (e.g. things labeled as "just politics"), or b) they have a personal stake in breaking the existing hierarchy (e.g. they want to be leaders themselves).
Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by peteretep on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @11:50AM (#10784176)
I read something very interesting a while ago, which I'm not completely unable to find, about feminist movements rejecting, and then embracing, explicit hierachies.

The thrust of it was that without an explicit hierachy, informal hierachies in social structures always emerge. Those informal hierachies are much harder to navigate and much more likely to opress than explicit ones.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by Torgo on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @12:37PM (#10784445)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tyranny_of_Structurelessne...

From a feminist perspective some complaints are that lack of structure creates a vacuum in which sociopaths and bullies can run free. Also it doesn't have the capacity to enact top-down diagnostic and corrective action to combat institutional or otherwise widespread behavior deficits (for example discrminatory or sexist attitudes.)

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by schoen on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @12:36PM (#10784440)
The article you're thinking of is called "The Tyranny of Structurelessness".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tyranny_of_Structurelessne...

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by dsfsdfd on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @09:57AM (#10783579)
Hierarchical systems do NOT scale well. If you want to scale something it needs to be distributed and in human terms that means equality, action by consensus, local decision making. The properties of the system must emerge from the global rules.

It's in the Zeitgeist because people are coming to understand how monumentally stupid it is to continue operating in this horrific way - both in terms of overall efficiency and in terms of human suffering.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by sergiosgc on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @10:20AM (#10783697)
Hierarchical systems absolutely DO scale well. They are just not efficient in the task of adapting to a changing environment.

The proof that hierarchical systems do scale is in the military. They operate in absolute hierarchical fashion. In the past they did so with very limited communication, with headcounts unimaginable in today's organizations.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by dsfsdfd on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @10:32AM (#10783745)
No they don't.

Pointing in the vague direction of an exemplar system and describing it a positive argument does not constitute an argument.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by obstacle1 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @04:57PM (#10785927)
>Pointing in the vague direction of an exemplar system and describing it a positive argument does not constitute an argument.

Neither does saying "hierarchies do not scale well", or "no they don't", without providing any evidence. So at least you are both "arguing" on the same level: unsubstantiated opinion.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by jccooper on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @01:38PM (#10784821)
Pretty much every large business and government is also explicitly hierarchical. For a particular firm it's such a common choice one has to imagine it's a good one. For organizations or broader scope than a single firm (industries and economies, cities and nations) independent competition and cooperation seems to work quite well.
Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by TeMPOraL on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @02:58PM (#10785271)
Er... what? Hierarchical is the very definition of "scales well". That's what you want to do when you have many instances that all need to talk to each other. Distributed means combinatorial explosion. It's... like secondary-school-level graph theory/probability.

Distributed is what you want to have for a) robustness (because redundancy means the work can be redirected to agents that are still alive) and b) adaptability (because system can restructure itself locally without the need to coordinate with the entirety of it).

Of course you want to apply those two recursively, e.g. hierarchies that encompass many peers at each level, etc., but that doesn't change the point. Frankly, the whole field of distributed computing is one big proof that hierarchies are good and desirable.

Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation by rewqfdsa on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @11:54AM (#10784201)
> Hierarchical systems do NOT scale well.

Ahem. Ever hear of DNS?