On this note I've been thinking about whether there's anything actually offensive about capturing video in a public location. You're just capturing photons thrown at you. If someone doesn't want to be captured, too bad, they shouldn't be throwing photons at you (read: if they want privacy, they shouldn't be in a public location).
The human eye is a camera; the only real difference between your eye and your Canon is in material composition. One is made of organic material, another made of silicon and glass. In the future, I see this boundary blurring, whether in the form of digital prosthetic eyes for the blind (which inevitably would possess the hardware ability to capture video to a file) or in being able to understand, capture, and save neural signals out of our biological eyes directly. It will happen and is just a matter of time. So we might as well create a unified ethical framework now, built around the fact that the human eye is a camera; the act of seeing is videography; the act of remembering is data storage.
There's a huge difference: With a camera, you can record the photons and share them. The barrier to entry for privacy violation and harassment has via "captured photons" has never been lower.
Would it be acceptable for a person in public to wear one of these, but not one of the others?
My sense is that if you want privacy in public, you should wear the matte black mask.
It's very well done and wonderfully dystopic. Soon™
That is true when it comes to merely being seen, but not being recorded. Being in a public location naturally implies consent to be seen, but it does not imply consent to be recorded artificially. (This includes any augmentations to human abilities from future technology, as someone mentioned this in a later comment)
I think that another important difference is that Canon-recorded images can be stored, archived, and consulted indefinitely, and by anyone, whereas human-recorded images cannot.
I beg your pardon?
If one doesn't want that the fact they've been at some public location, doing something, they shouldn't be there. Forcing bystanding observers to not remember or not disclose the facts they have observed is somewhat odd idea.
But love it or hate it, but it seems that we're grasping wearable computing. And that includes stuff like hearing, vision, memory or navigational aids, and such things depend on recording what's going on around the wearer. So, while today there's a clear distinction we're just bound to hit the issue some years in the future. And given that some tech is already there, said future doesn't seem to be too far away. Then the difference would be much smaller. Probably even non-existent if we'd get anywhere close to what transhumanistic sci-fi pictures ;)
And this means a war between concepts - freedom to absorb and process information, and freedom to control your personal information.
I'm not sure there is any objective approach for ethical problems, so, I guess, it would be just a matter of taste, chance and circumstances.
I think that this is especially pertinent for children who are not able to make the decision to grant these rights, the permission for a photograph or video cannot be rescinded on majority, but the person could make different decisions about where they go, what they wear and how they behave, with limited responsibility for the prior decision to do something else.
I am aware of tourist photos and photos by friends. It is reasonable to expect that I'll be in occasional photographs where I am not the subject. I know that. It is reasonable to expect that I won't be the subject of photos without my knowledge or included in detailed photographic records just because I went to a public place. Detailed imagery of your whereabouts and activities should never be expected and should only be legal with a warrant.
That would be a perfectly reasonable position if there weren't laws against blocking photons. (Mask bans)
This idea is shifting though, we've steadily been leaving behind a place of having cameras predominantly being used to prevent theft, towards a situation of mass government surveillance on the street level (think license plate scanners etc). To me personally, that is more offensive at this point.
Not to mention the battery pack and heat generation issues from such a hat would make it rather cumbersome to wear anyway.
It would do nothing to stop your image being recorded. It may well just improve the quality of your image on the recording.
Until you walk into that elevator with a mirror mounted inside.
Or until you bump into other people.
Lastly, just because you could use lasers to neutralize cameras doesn't mean you can. In trying to to make a point about the ubiquity of cameras, the author reveals a challenge in fighting them:
> Video cameras the size of postage stamps can be procured for under $100, and will certainly become even smaller and cheaper.
Blocking cameras is one thing; finding them is another!