You may disagree with the author's reasons but at least read the whole article before saying that quite a long section is "entirely missing".
I agree, both the learning experience and the acquired skills matter. What's often overlooked is that every child develops at their own pace, and the skills progression taught in schools is based on both normative ideals and descriptive "modal" pace. Offering a child new material that they "should not be learning yet" is not a crime, nor an offense to the child, nor a criticism on other parenting methods (or other children, for that matter).
Not to mention that skills development doesn't occur across a single line. As an example, a child of a friend of mine is now almost two years old, and still vocalizes at most two syllables. Yet she's able to comprehend (and execute) very complicated sentences and commands, in two languages. Still, she's now officially labeled a "deficient" child, with all the counselling and monitoring that that entails...
Someone who are good a at multitude of things but very superficially does not make them more well rounded than one that practices on area more deeply. There are many many many areas that seem to be simple to learn because you can do them very quickly. But thats not what skills are about. Sure you can fake it, but unless you tried to dig deeper into something and learn what it means to learn then you aren't really going to be at a bigger advantage later on in life.
The very act of going deeper into a specific skill is teaching you something that just brushing over a wide area of skills isn't. In fact by going deeper into some of the typical things kids learn you are more likely to be able to also become better at others because you learn what it means to dig in rather than brush over.
Yes you can create a circumstance where literacy is gained through onerous means, but you can use that same hypothetical with pretty much any form of parental guidance till you get to the point where children are now only learning what they want to and not what is necssary.
Pretty big assumption there.
I'd think in context---a child taught how to read in a one-on-one interaction with a parent is more likely to have their difficulties noted and receive help from that same parent, than a child taught how to read in a one-on-fifteen classroom setting.
So I wonder: isn't reading a benefit in and of itself? If there's no direct harm, then it ought to be at worst a waste of time.
Again, that's a big assumption. Plausible problems:
1. developing language skills early stunts development of more visual skills
2. too much structured time has drawbacks
3. "it ought to be at worst a waste of time" ... and additional stress. Opportunity costs could also include relationship capital (pushing your kid to do unimportant things means you can't push as hard in other areas).
The author of the article went into detail as to what possible harm there could be, and why he thought they were avoided or null.
Your stance seems to be summarized as: 'what if parents are thoughtless, naive, and too forceful?'.
In this case, the author was none of that, and really shouldn't be compared to this hypothetical worst case scenario.
> developing language skills early stunts development of more visual skills
This seems incredibly unlikely. I'd in fact bet money that developing any skill young will not stunt the growth of another skill, so long as a normal amount of time is spent invested in that other skill comparative to normal children.
> too much structured time has drawbacks
Indeed, but according to the author all they did was read to the child before dinner, and have them sound out words as they pointed to them. Does 30 minutes to an hour of reading and pointing count as too much structured time?
> Opportunity costs could also include relationship capital (pushing your kid to do unimportant things means you can't push as hard in other areas).
This sounds like a problem of methodology, not of aims. If teaching a child anything causes alienation, then you are doing it wrong, especially if that thing is a basic skill that they must learn.
Sure there are many areas where reading is good, but it's not as simply as you want to present it here. Not by a longshot.
However, how do you know that "having more skills is good under virtually all circumstances" when toddlers are concerned? I have no reason to assume that learning to read at a very young age is harmful (which is why I'm not against it), but I can easily imagine ways that it could be harmful (or beneficial). But making a definitive ruling either way requires knowledge that neither I nor you possess. So I say "go ahead if that's what you want" just because I'd rather not recommend against something unless it is shown to be bad. But you seem to make a big assumption about developmental psychology that you have absolutely no basis to make.
Of course, that was thirty-odd years ago, before kindergarten-aged kids were expected to be familiar with English lit back to Chaucer and mathematics up to basic trigonometry. I can see how in the modern environment someone might react negatively to the suggestion that it doesn't hurt kids to know how to read when they're two, because letting on about it could well result in an environment where a kid who's three years old and can't yet read is either developmentally delayed or has bad parents, or of course possibly both.
Edited to add: It doesn't help at all that the author of the article under discussion couches his reasoning in terms of improved educational outcomes -- he's explicitly trying to turn his kids into highly performant overachievers, and that is super creepy. If that's your only available perspective on the matter, I can't blame you at all for being bothered by it, because I actually was taught to read at age two like he's advocating and it bothers me too. He sounds more like an education researcher than like a father, and that's disturbing.
But Mom didn't teach me to read early because she had some kind of n=1 eugenics experiment in mind. She did it because she loved me and thought I'd enjoy being able to read, and she didn't use the rather chilly and vaguely clinical-sounding methods this author describes. As she described it to me not long ago, she'd just read part of a story to me, showing me each word in turn and helping me sound it out and learn its meaning, and offer me as much help as I wanted in figuring the rest out for myself -- which I would, because I wanted to know how the story turned out. Evidently this method worked well enough, and as I said before, I've never regretted it. Make of that what you like, of course.
(Again, as in my other comment, I feel it worthwhile to point out that this isn't a purely theoretical discussion for me: I was myself taught to read at age two, and have never been other than glad of it.)
Not when you're two. When you're two you need to learn that asking questions is okay, how to ask questions, and how people answer questions.
During early years teaching it's apparently fairly trivial to identify the children who are recognizing shapes over the deconstruction technique, there's a test where they are shown lists of words with nonsense words thrown in, for those recognising shapes, when they see 'strom' they cannot help but unknowingly correct it to 'storm', their brain just fixes it for them, it's close enough and the word 'strom' has probably not been encountered, children implementing the deconstruction technique will have less of a problem.
Why teachers care is that it helps them identify children who may have issues identifying letter shapes but can pass other tests by recognising whole words, early diagnosis of dyslexia can have a very positive impact on a child's educational progress.
What I mean is that identifying the parts of the whole through de-construction is not the only way we recognize things.
To start the "compound interest" benefits as early as possible?
I regret I've lost the study (observational, not experimental) on students in North Rhine Westphalia on long term effects of early reading instruction but it showed children who learned to read later doing better at 16 or 17 than the ones who learned to read earlier. I think it was published in an economic of education journal but that's all I remember.
Edit:
The below study shows tiny differences between performance/school readiness of French and German children on entering primary school despite the French system being much more school like and placing a much greater emphasis on reading. Italics in abstract not in original.
French nursery schools and German kindergartens: effects of individual and contextual variables on early learning
Eur J Psychol Educ (2011) 26:199–213 DOI 10.1007/s10212-010-0043-4
The present article investigates the effects of individual and contextual variables on children’s early learning in French nursery schools and German kindergartens. Our study of 552 children at preschools in France (299 children from French nursery schools) and Germany (253 children from German kindergartens) measured skills that facilitate the learning of reading, writing and arithmetic at primary school. We also evaluated educational family practices and parents’ expectations of their children’s pre-school education. In order to take into account the hierarchical structure of our data, multilevel models were used in the analysis, which was carried out using MLwiN software version 2.02 (Rasbash et al.2005). Although French nursery schools emphasise academic learning, we did not find any significant differences in overall performances between the French and German samples. However, significant differences were obtained for some subscale results. In addition, our results indicate that individual and contextual variables have an impact on the differences observed between children from the two countries.
It's easy to forget, but 0-5 is, in terms of these advanced skills like "reading" (as opposed to "understanding what my body feels like"), not even 1/4th of a childhood. There's no way to stick a concrete number on it, but it's probably less than 10%.
We have a lot of evidence that depriving a child of the basics of life can affect them all their life, but I am not sure I've ever seen a study that has ever supported the idea that it is beneficial to accelerate education at the toddler phase. It's like trying to win a marathon by running really fast in the first 300 meters; unless you are going to be able to maintain that pace for the entire rest of the marathon, you probably haven't accomplished much.
And anecdotally I learnt to read at 4 and half and buy they time I was 11 I have a reading age several years higher than the adult population average.
A sample of 250 could be wrong but at least it's a study, and so much better than an anecdote.
It's also much better than the original article, which says, as justification for teaching children to read early, "I will wait for the results of empirical studies before insisting on definitive claims, but my guesses are as follows.... Again, I know this is just speculation, but it seems very reasonable to me, and in the absence of better evidence, I feel justified in acting on what seems very reasonable."
So, to sum up: the best evidence we have says this does not work.
I'm also not bullish on the positive effects of primary school on cognitive skills full stop. Unschooled children are only a year behind their counterparts in public schools on average. That's a really small effect for the difference between more than five hours a day of purposeful instruction versus none whatsoever. The same study does show children in structured homeschool doing one to five grade levels better depending on what's tested so there almost certainly are students who benefit from earlier more advanced reading instruction but the implications for mass schooling are unclear. If we can't even have children in different classes by ability level instead of age group I don't hold out much hope for sane educational policy.
The Impact of Schooling on Academic Achievement: Evidence From Homeschooled and Traditionally Schooled Students
The author somehow seems to implicitly assumes that being able to read as early as possible is good, period. Younger == better. He has a huge "why" chapter, where he debunks and defends all kinds of criticism he's gotten, but I haven't been able to at all find the section where he simply describes why it's a good idea. Not why it's not not a good idea, that's not good enough. Why would I teach my children to read already?
There might be good reasons, but this author is so consumed with the "it's possible! it's not harmful!" part of things that what should have been the central argument is nearly entirely missing.
I mean, seriously, it's possible and it's not harmful? I can think of a lot of things that are possible and not harmful but still wouldn't do with my kids.