News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by gloves on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:09AM (#10776481)
I love this type of thing - it shows those of us who spend their lives pontificating that Britain should be more British by halting immigration are arguing such a deeply contradictory argument (as if it wasn't obvious enough already)

Really, the best thing is to remember we're all just human beings, and should try our best to try and look after one another as best as possible.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by danieltillett on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:04AM (#10776631)
The rational argument about halting immigration has nothing to do with genetics, but if it makes the people already living there better off (assuming it is not a literal invasion and they have a choice). If it does help then it is a good idea and if it doesn’t then it is a bad idea.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by _delirium on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:19AM (#10776664)
A surprising proportion of the European populace really does think something like genetics, or maybe the slightly fuzzier "ethnicity", is at the core of the issue. Many people really think that they belong to a specific ethnicity that has existed in roughly its current form for hundreds or thousands of years, and that this is the glue holding together their nation-state and the reason for its success. That Europe's current ethnicities are the product of melting pots that emerged from waves of migration and intermingling and assimilation, is a common view among academics, but not so much the average person. I've had reasonably educated people specifically tell me that this is the thing Americans don't understand about Europe: that the American identity was created in the last 200 years from people of many backgrounds, while the European ethnic identities are 2000 years old and not the products of melting pots. Which is not really exactly right, but it's what many Europeans think. This is even true in Greece (I'm Greek-American), which is historically maybe one of the world's most "melting-pot" oriented ethnicities, almost evangelical in its desire to Hellenize people of any background.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by Swizec on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:38AM (#10776913)
The countries came into existence in the last 200 years. The ethnicities have been there for a while.

For instance, my country only started existing in 1991. But we have written records of people speaking our language and thinking of themselves as us going back to 800 AD. Germany can trace its origins straight back to The Holy Roman Empire, the ruling classes of which spoke German, thought of themselves as Germanic, had the same crest as Germany uses now, and started existing as a state in 962 AD.

And so on.

It's less about genetics and more about language.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by _delirium on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @08:24AM (#10777582)
Sure, the languages and aspects of the cultures do go back quite a ways. I mostly object to portraying it as a stable group of people directly descended with no immigration or adaptation. People changed languages, religions, etc. as borders and rulers changed, as they migrated, and for various other reasons. For example some of today's Greeks are descended from Hellenized Arabs, Persians, Turks, Italians, Romanians, Albanians, etc., while some of today's Italians are descended from Greeks, Visigoths, and others who became Italianized. And these migrations and assimilations also changed the cultures as well as adopting them, especially when they lived side-by-side in multicultural cities. That used to be common in Europe, especially in the big maritime cities and imperial capitals: cities like Vienna, Thessaloniki, Constantinople, Trieste, Rhodes, Gdańsk, Marseilles, and Vilnius were multicultural and multilingual up until they were turned monolingual (often violently) in the 19th and 20th centuries. So I don't really buy the idea that Europe is somehow inherently supposed to be made out of monocultural nation-states, and that a multicultural city like NYC is a uniquely American idea.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by CM30 on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @01:53PM (#10779526)
Or in other words, it's because of economic migration. Not the often quoted and disproven 'take advantage of welfare and services' stuff that certain papers seem to go on about, but the somewhat accurate concern that some of the people coming are being taken advantage of by unscrupulous employers who pay less than anyone born here would accept (but which is seen as a somewhat 'reasonable' wage in less well off countries).

So you get situations where 'low skilled' jobs pay peanuts, but end up being taken by people who send the money back abroad where the amount is more valuable than in the UK. It can sometimes lead to people from poorer backgrounds not getting these basic jobs because the employers know they'll want a wage they can actually live on.

That said, that's not really an issue with immigration specifically; anyone who immigrates to the area and knows about the minimum wage and decent working conditions will also find it more difficult to get a job.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by danieltillett on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @07:31PM (#10781304)
I have never understood the rational argument for granting refugee status for political persecution, but not fleeing an economic situation. If you flee a country because you have odious political views you are a refugee and are granted protection, if you flee a country because your children are starving then you are an economic refugee and sent home.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by im2w1l on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:59AM (#10776617)
Several of these "waves of immigration" were literal invasions.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by nova on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:09AM (#10776826)
It never stops to amaze me the doublethinking necessary to simultaneously believe that "colonization is bad and Africa is war-torn because of the arbitrarily drawn borders by Western powers" and "multiculturalism for the West is a great idea".
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:53AM (#10776961)
Why? The problem with colonization is that it disrupted the holistic growth of national communities like we experienced in XVIII to XIX century. We've "grown up" since then, recognising the competitive advantage of exploiting talents regardless of cultural provenance; but we couldn't do the latter without going through the former process and recognising its limits. Colonised countries were blocked from experiencing a similar process.

No doublethink involved, as long as you see history as a continuum, rather than believing in a fixed set of norms (typically your own, no offense) as an absolute ideal "best" transcending space and time.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by nova on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:57AM (#10776972)
> The problem with colonization is that it disrupted the holistic growth of national communities

The same with immigration, then. Psychologically is even worse maybe, because instead of an overtly foreign power coming to conquer your land it's your own very government selling your society.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @10:24AM (#10778229)
Mass-immigration in Europe didn't happen until late XX century, when national identities were entirely fully-formed and indeed brought upon us the disastrous World Wars. The cosmopolitan worldview that approves of melting-pots was born in response to the terrible failure of nationalism, which "we" experienced to the fullest.

> it's your own very government selling your society.

It's as much "your" government as it is mine, and I don't feel like they're selling anything, in this particular case.

If you think freedom of movement is bad, do you think capital should also be controlled? If not, why should money be free to flow, but not people? To artificially create "salary jails" to exploit? If you assume that money should move to maximize its potential, then the same should be allowed for people, surely?

Freedom of movement and freedom of enterprise are amongst the highest achievements of human civilization, which we paid for with millions of deaths in the XX and XIX century.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by nova on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @02:30PM (#10779775)
> The cosmopolitan worldview that approves of melting-pots was born in response to the terrible failure of nationalism, which "we" experienced to the fullest.

History hasn't ended up yet. I think we're going to see how far the string can be tensed, and whether that multi-culti "solution" isn't the genesis of new strife. Things aren't looking bright.

> If you think freedom of movement is bad, do you think capital should also be controlled?

Actually yes, in moderation. I used to lean libertarian, but not anymore. But that's another talk.

> then the same should be allowed for people, surely?

Why? Capital at least doesn't behead you, people do.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by pluma on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @06:40AM (#10777145)
> XVIII to XIX century

This is off topic, but what is up with the Roman numerals when referring to centuries?

I tried googling it but came up empty. I can't find any authoritative source for this being a thing in any particular dialect of English and at least one person I've seen using this was a native Russian speaker. Google results only indicate that this is common in Spanish and maybe Polish.

Am I missing something? Is this a thing in American or British academia? Is it part of some popular newspaper's house styles? As a non-native speaker I find this incredibly peculiar.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @10:16AM (#10778185)
I'm actually Italian; that's the standard way to refer to centuries in Italian academia, and I believe it's common across the EU. It's probably linked to traditional research usage by Catholic scholars writing in Latin. It's also much more concise: XIX would become "diciannovesimo" in Italian...
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by CM30 on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @01:42PM (#10779465)
Pretty much. Which makes me look at all the worries about native Americans and such and the complaints about their land being taken/their customes being ignored and wonder what the big deal even is. Every culture in history has conquered and been conquered. The UK has been conquered by tons of groups, yet we don't see people complaining about the actions of the Romans, or the Vikings, or the Anglo-Saxons, or the Normans, or anyone else. The hypocrisy about all this kind of confuses me.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by conceit on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:07AM (#10776822)
The Romans and the Norman, who else?
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by andrewmu on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:13AM (#10776838)
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by simonh on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:46AM (#10776936)
And before then the Saxons. And it's worth bearing in mind the Roman soldiers in Britain weren't all of Italian peninsular extraction. Many of them were levies from places all over the Empire, including the regions of the Middle East and North Africa from which many of the current wave of migrants also originate. It's hard to believe that absolutely none of them left a genetic legacy behind.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by pcardh0 on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:52AM (#10776596)
Very bizarre thinking. I guess the Irish should have welcomed Oliver Cromwell.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:55AM (#10776605)
Equating Cromwell with immigration is pretty fallacious. Overall, I think colonialism was nevertheless a net benefit to my home country, thanks.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by danieltillett on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:05AM (#10776634)
Did Oliver Cromwell ever personally travel to Ireland?
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:46AM (#10776741)
Yes, sure didn't he command and travel with the troops at e.g. the siege of Drogheda?
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by danieltillett on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:30AM (#10776893)
Yes you are right - very interesting.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by vixen99 on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:05AM (#10776814)
Do you write anodyne Christmas card mottos as a side project?

With price a consequence of demand, <all> Britons on average salary (about $38K pa) have given up any hope whatsoever of buying their own home thanks to demand exacerbated by an influx of immigrants unprecedented in any of the last two centuries. Indeed even professionals earning around $150K are very hard pushed. Of course planning permission & other factors have played a role in this but unquestionably, Britain is overcrowded and folk-in-the-street looking for jobs and accommodation are suffering thanks largely to a smug rich elite who accumulate moral brownie points opining on the value of immigration. I would have thought that enough is enough.

All this is redolent of vitamins: "If Y mg of vitamin X is good for you then Y*10 mg is ten times as good for you!". Really?

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by JetSetWilly on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:51AM (#10776952)
I must have hallucinated when I bought my 3 bedroom detached house for £145k.

Britain is not "overcrowded". If you don't want to live in expensive London, then move.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by toyg on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:45AM (#10776934)
I think you'll find that 1) the housing problem is strictly localized to London and surrounding areas, rather than Britain as a whole, and 2) it's mostly due to rich speculators keeping buildings empty, rather than everyday immigrants looking for cheap accomodation.
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by throwcc on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @06:12AM (#10777033)
apart from the very centre of london where there is an unavoidable shortage of space, the main cause is planning restrictions, with the refusal to expand on to "green field" sites the biggest barrier to more affordable housing. rich speculators cannot hold up the price of property all on their own without very strong supply side restrictions...
Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by simonh on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @06:44AM (#10777160)
Immigration has a tiny effect on housing demand. In part that's because immigrants are generally far more willing to share accommodation in order to save money. A far bigger effect is elderly people continuing to live in large family homes after their children have left, even on their own after the death of a partner. This is a much bigger drag on housing availability.

The main reason we need working age immigration is our ageing population. Our retiree population is set to massively inflate over the next few decades. Unless our otherwise shrinking working age population wants to be financially buried under the costs of supporting them, we need to support our working age population size and the only way to do that is through immigration.

Re:New genetic map of Britain shows waves of immigration goi... by gloves on Monday January 04, 2016 @07:40AM (#10835261)
I'm 23 and have just bought a house outside of Cambridge. I saved and saved and have managed. If people make the right choices and that is what they want to do, then they can. Outside of London, owning a house isn't a ridiculous idea.