You can see this in wine tasting allot of the big name wines expensive wines do not score well in blind wine tastings however in non blind tastings when people are sold on the story they score remarkably well.
When you spend 200$ on a bottle of wine, 15$ on a bar of chocolate and 20$ on 8 oz. of coffee beans you'll be damn sure to like them even if they are nothing but average at best.
There is a reason why every "artisan" product comes with a nifty far fetched story tied to it as that's what you are buying at the end.
<anecdote> A few years ago I sent one of the first bottles of wine I ever made (a Barolo, still quite young) to a friend of mine with a comment to the effect that "it's not bad, but it has an aftertaste of asphalt. Probably needs to be aged more."
He replied with a link to a review of an expensive Barolo that indicated "hints of tar." But my major takeaway from that review was how it sounded exactly like the high-end audio reviews I used to read." Substitute the word "amplifier" for "wine" and you'd never know the difference. </anecdote>
BTW: I kept a few bottles of that batch and after five years, it was delicious. Five years was all the willpower I had :-(
Right...?
[1]: http://www.caltech.edu/news/wine-study-shows-price-influence...
It certainly seems to happen a lot in software; I cannot imagine it's any different in chocolate or coffee or anything else.
Unfortunately, because they buy and process relatively small batches of beans you might not be able to get more of a bar you really enjoy. Even if you see one with the same origin as a bar you've had before it might not be exactly the same since different batches may use different roasting parameters.
Your beliefs about what you consume can affect your taste and what pleasure you draw from consumption. Since the belief is part of what causes your positive experiences, why would you risk loosing that belief by asking people about things that may destroy it? Or is it already destroyed, those chocolates no longer taste that good, and you are hoping to regain the belief?
If latter is the case then, yes, I can assure you with my whole authority and complete independence from Dandelion in SF that their chocolate is the real deal.
Also while I'm sure that I am blind to lots of things as a consumer, I definitely still enjoy products with sketchy marketing but whose quality I like (Bulleit Rye is a great example).
Making chocolate in small batches doesn't have anything to do directly with making a better chocolate bar.
There are plenty of very large scale chocolate manufacturers that produce premium products and they have a much better process of ensuring the consistency and quality of their products than a small batch manufacturer, unlike small boutiques they also have the resources and the science to be able to tailor the taste to specific pallets much more consistently.
Going to a chocolate boutique however and buying expensive bars is an experience on it's own which most likely has just as much impact on the final tasting experience as the manufacturing process it self.
I agree with most of your points (both in this post and more generally elsewhere on the site), and even acknowledge that you might be right if you define "directly" in a particular way. But I'm almost certain you haven't made your own small-batch chocolate, and would guess you haven't personally compared products from the producers being discussed.
You are right that small batch doesn't matter much, but timing is crucial. Freshly made chocolate has a lot of volatile flavors that dissipate quickly. Large producers age their product to produce a consistent (and sometimes excellent) product. Some small producers achieve a much faster turn-around from roasting to consumption.
I've both made chocolate and done a lot of comparison, and I've never tasted a mass produced chocolate where the taste is comparable to a fresh batch made by an amateur using quality ingredients. I suppose that theoretically it could be done, but in practice, to my taste, freshness has always had the flavor advantage.
My usual comparison would be coffee: freshly roasted and freshly brewed coffee tastes significantly different than freeze dried. Both have their place, but you should doubt the taste of anyone who says there is no significant difference. Fresh versus canned tomatoes is another example I've considered. There are some excellent canned tomatoes, and some lousy fresh tomatoes, but no canned tomato is a decent substitute for an excellent fresh tomato.
Side note: Have we at a meta level concluded that self-identified "small batch" and "artisanal" products sold at farmers markets in hipsterish packaging are very highly correlated with "young people that don't really know what they are doing (are relatively inexperienced), but are good at marketing and charging a high price"?