News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by doctorpangloss on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:19PM (#10761012)
> "For computer software, patents together with copyright protection are the entire price of the product."

That doesn't ring true. Software is sold in far more complex ways that in no way benefit from the copyright regime. That could mean software consulting and support for open source projects, or it could mean advertising and IAP-supported free-to-play games. Both are extremely lucrative.

You might want to call in-app purchases something that corresponds to copyright. I think all that matters is what is enforceable (ask the movie and music industries). That game services have figured out how to make the enforceability of copyright irrelevant by centralizing hosting and matchmaking is the far bigger story.

Put another way, the researchers bring up removing patent regimes on drugs in order to save money and reduce rents. That's only because of the peculiar way that drugs work—it doesn't necessarily make sense. Jana Hunter, an indie musician, had this great phrase: "If technology provided loopholes for free food and shelter, that’s what we’d be arguing about." [0] But technology only provides loopholes for some free stuff, like music and drugs, and we can't just decide that property rights can be ignored when they're cheap to exploit (like copyright or patent infringement).

On the other hand, we will just, in a Darwinian way, end up in a world where the technological loopholes intrinsically don't exist. This happened in commercial video games, and it happened so quickly only because of enormous ingenuity, an extremely competitive market and a complete disconnect from the conventional political process (ever heard of a video game studio lobbyist?).

If you want to improve wealth distribution, messing with the mechanics of how things are bought and sold, as always, isn't going to get you very far. Maybe just raise taxes, you know?

[0] http://lowerdens.tumblr.com/post/34308869231/on-spotify-and-...

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:25PM (#10761053)
we can't just decide that property rights can be ignored when they're cheap to exploit (like copyright or patent infringement)

Copyrights and patents are state-granted exclusionary privileges, not property titles.

If you want to improve wealth distribution, messing with the mechanics of how things are bought and sold, as always, isn't going to get you very far.

What are you talking about? Abolishing and reforming institutions is one of the most powerful tools there is.

Maybe just raise taxes, you know?

The whole point of this paper is that simplistic fiscal shenanigans like this don't work.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:48PM (#10761209)
I used to argue against conflating property and immaterial rights along those lines. But it gets kind of interesting if you realize that all property titles are state-granted exclusionary privileges. So the distinction might not be that important.

When John Locke argued for the moral right of property as a result of labor, he also argued that it only applies when there are an abundance of resources. An extension of that though could be, why not look at all rent generating propert with suspicion. Property rents, as a result of exclusive rights to scarce resources, could be seen as an externality, as a result of everybody else accepting those exclusive rights without compensation for being excluded.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:59PM (#10761280)
But it gets kind of interesting if you realize that all property titles are state-granted exclusionary privileges.

Insofar as current arrangements of a state holding eminent domain, yes. Not intrinsically.

Property rents, as a result of exclusive rights to scarce resources, could be seen as an externality, as a result of everybody else accepting those exclusive rights without compensation for being excluded.

A property owner may extend easement or some other non-possessory right to usage, so to immediately classify all property as an "externality" is flat out wrong. If anything, private property rights are a necessary (if not the primary) precondition to resolving externalities.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:49PM (#10761516)
I meant rent as the externality, not the property as such.

Without the state taking the cost of enforcing the exclusivity the possessor would probably have to invest some cost in securing it. Either buying weapons or entering some kind of contractual agreements.

In either case the cost would probably correlate with the value of property. The rent, then, is the value the possessor can extract from the property as a result of not having to take those costs. In fact, it is the other way around, the cost is distributed among the non-possessors.

Assuming we would like to avoid a situation where possessors have to invest in violent means of exclusivity, I argue that the states role should be to enforce propery as, fair, contractual agreements between possessor and non-possessors.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:46PM (#10761801)
The rent, then, is the value the possessor can extract from the property as a result of not having to take those costs.

But the nature of uncertainty of action means that such a cost isn't really quantifiable. It seems like you're trying to say that the rent is the value derived during idling. But idling can serve a valid social purpose in conferring availability of something, or when land is converted for a purpose only on occasion but must necessarily remain available by idling.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:08PM (#10761899)
I think it is quantifiable. One way to quantify it is to determine exactly how much you are prepared to pay to keep the tile, (or some else is to get it).

A possibly fairer way might be to let you pay what the next highest bidder is prepared to pay. That means you unique addition remains your profit, while also quantifying the opportunity cost instead.

Regarding idling, I'm not arguing against that, only against the system by how it's scheduled and who pays and who gets paid for it

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by dragonwriter on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:12PM (#10761919)
> Insofar as current arrangements of a state holding eminent domain, yes. Not intrinsically.

No, property rights are intrinsically a creation of government through law, whether or not the government reserves something like the power of eminent domain.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by humanrebar on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:05PM (#10761314)
> So the distinction might not be that important.

If you take someone's home, they are homeless. If you copy someone's cat video, they still have their copy to enjoy. That's a huge distinction.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:54PM (#10761542)
But that really have nothing to do with the distinction between material an immaterial property. The distinction lies in the moral judgment of the consequences, and fairness, of those actions.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by humanrebar on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:29PM (#10761703)
No, it has everything to do with material and immaterial property. Because of the laws of conservation of mass, you cannot get new things for nothing. You can take things, and you can build new things. You can't out-and-out Star Trek style replicate things, at least not yet.

Information, because it isn't matter, can be copied very easily. It's actually quite tricky to make sure that only one person has a piece of information. This is why bitcoin and block chains are technically interesting.

All of this impacts the consequences and morality of the two kinds of "stealing". Stealing matter necessarily harms someone. They just lost something. Even if things can be easily replaced, the identity of matter is important. I could go out and buy another birthday card just like the one on my desk, but I'll never be able to truly replace it because my grandpa gave it to me just before he died. On the other hand, the identity of an instance of data generally isn't important. If I lose a video of my grandpa and then acquire a different copy, it isn't that important.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by humanrebar on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:04PM (#10761303)
> ...we can't just decide that property rights can be ignored when they're cheap to exploit (like copyright or patent infringement).

That's not the argument against IP. The argument is that IP isn't a thing as such. When you are copying ideas, the originator of the idea can eat his cake while you bake your own (literally). The crime (again, sometimes literally) is that you disrupted someone's monopoly, not that you took their car so they don't have a car anymore.

The whole concept of intellectual property is that it's supposed to be a win-win; limited monopolies are granted to encourage creation and innovation, and the public benefits from the innovations and the growing public domain. If, as proposed, rent seeking in the form of IP protection is causing wealth imbalances, then the bargain is probably a net good for the monopoly holder and a net bad for the public. If that is the case, the terms of the bargain should be revisited. The types of patents granted, how strict the process is, how soon things enter public domain, the terms of "fair use", and other things might need to be relaxed to make the deal fairer to the general public.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:23PM (#10761043)
Advertising and IAP-supported free-to-play games, if they did not have copyright protection, would be IMMEDIATELY hacked to not have advertising or IAP.