News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:02AM (#10751200)
Lets also not forget that if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, you also won't bother to invent any new ones. It seems to make people angry that greedy folks make money by saving lives, but lets remember that one likely alternative to this is greedy folks don't make money by not saving lives.

Putting my investor hat on, I generally believe that making rich people pretty is a far less risky investment than making sympathetic sick people healthy - I won't become public enemy #1 by charging a fortune for Botox 2.0.

(None of this is meant as commentary on the specifics of this guy - the media has decided he's a villain, prosecutors can boost their career by targeting him, and I have no way to determine the truth of the matter.)

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by coldtea on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:38AM (#10751667)
>Lets also not forget that if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, you also won't bother to invent any new ones.

Let's not forget that there are people who invent stuff and do research outside of monetary concerns too. Not to mention state funded research, which is how we got most of the foundations of the core science/technology we have now (either that or heavily subsidized "private" research, including pharmas).

And let's also not forget that by several accounts, the costs of research for most of those life saving drugs are dwarfed by the costs of marketing and other BS the companies spend their money on, and not even for them (as life saving drugs practically advertise themselves anyway) but for non life-saving drugs like Viagra and co...

>the media has decided he's a villain

And for one, in this particular case, nobody can blame them!

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by Brakenshire on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:44AM (#10752104)
Yes, although the cost bottleneck isn't the primary research to find drug candidates, but the clinical trials needed to see which of the hundred drug candidates i) works and ii) is safe. And public funding of medical research is nowhere near what would be necessary to fund current levels of clinical research, let alone expand to meet the enormous unmet demand. For instance, UK government medical research funding is significantly less than £1bn, and estimates are the the cost of clinical trials to demonstrate the safety and efficacy of just one drug costs £0.2-1bn. So the UK could divert all pure and early-stage research and develop only 1-5 drugs each year.

Agree about marketing, I think most people agree the purpose of the pharma industry is finding objective treatments for objective diseases, and not generating spurious demand. I think we could potentially optimize strongly for the first part if we heavily restricted the latter part.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:33AM (#10752019)
as life saving drugs practically advertise themselves anyway

Ummm.... no, they don't. I have a friend who works in the industry and you'd be surprised how cautious some physicians are. The decision to treat a patient with a new drug isn't "oh! it's better, let's use it!", it's much more complicated than that. Even great drugs need to be promoted.

Also, you can't compare the costs of marketing and R&D. You don't spend marketing dollars unless you think the return is greater than 1 (you make back more than you spent). If drug companies stopped marketing their drugs, they'd end up in a worse financial situation rather than a better one. That extra revenue means more R&D spend!

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by Brakenshire on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:51AM (#10752143)
For one thing, you're conflating marketing to consumers and marketing to physicians. There is no value in patients demanding a drug because of some contentless, sunshine-and-rainbows advert. The value in drug companies talking to doctors is arguable, but I think that doctors' very limited free time in general would also be more effectively spent talking to independent analysts, or reading independent comparative research. See the National Institute for Clinical Excellence in the UK, or the Cochrane Centre.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:18PM (#10752739)
There is no value in patients demanding a drug because of some contentless, sunshine-and-rainbows advert.

Really? I've talked to a handful of physicians that think advertising to patients is actually a good thing. They've talked about patients who haven't seen a doctor in years coming in to have their cholesterol checked because they saw an ad on TV.

I don't know about you, but I'd prefer it if patients were more proactive when it comes to their health, not less.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by jonknee on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:36AM (#10752048)
> Ummm.... no, they don't. I have a friend who works in the industry and you'd be surprised how cautious some physicians are. The decision to treat a patient with a new drug isn't "oh! it's better, let's use it!", it's much more complicated than that. Even great drugs need to be promoted.

And yet somehow the word on new drugs still gets to doctors in the rest of the world where public advertising of drugs is illegal. Any ideas on how this miracle occurs?

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by punee on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:49AM (#10752134)
Huh? The answer is in your question. Non-public advertising. Medical sales.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by DannoHung on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:06AM (#10752240)
> you'd be surprised how cautious some physicians are

I'd be a fuckton more surprised if there weren't hundreds of companies trying to sell drugs regardless of efficacy.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:17PM (#10752725)
The FDA won't approve a drug unless it's efficacious. Are you inferring that it's not?
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by roywiggins on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:28PM (#10753291)
So, so many companies have been caught promoting drugs "off-label", for uses that the FDA hasn't approved. So many. Johnson & Johnson paid $1.4 BILLION to settle a suit alleging that they heavily promoted the use of antipsychotics on dementia patients.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_off-label_promotion_ph...

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:44PM (#10753429)
Correct. It's illegal in the US to promote drugs for off-label uses. That doesn't mean the drugs don't work.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by roywiggins on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:52PM (#10753536)
If J&J thought their drugs worked, I'd naively think that they could just invest a (perhaps significant) fraction of the eventual settlement to prove as much to the FDA. It would boost sales and allow them to promote them indefinitely, out in the open.

Either they couldn't be bothered, or in fact they tried to prove it, and failed. If J&J can't prove a drug works, the odds that it does actually work seems... low, given the amount of resources J&J have.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by Malarkey73 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:16AM (#10751271)
Lets not forget too that Martin Shkreli took no risk inventing this drug. He bought a monopoly - a necessary lifesaving drug with no alternative - and jacked up the price by thousands.

Either a free market fundamentalist (ie no explotative patents) or a dyed in the wool regulator should be able to agree this is not how the market should work.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by rayiner on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:25AM (#10751569)
Daraprim is out of patent. He didn't buy a monopoly right, he just bought a drug that nobody else thought was worth making.

Anyway, the distinction between inventing the drug and buying the patent is an artificial one. If you're going to allow creating monopoly rights--and that you can debate--then making the rights tradable will make the market more efficient.

With drugs in particular, acquisition of promising drug candidates is a major input to the pipeline at the big drug companies. It enables separation of concerns: small startups to develop the drugs and big experienced companies to bring them to market. Creating an artificial distinction between inventors and acquirers precludes that efficient division of labor.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by dnautics on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:46PM (#10752967)
the FDA grants a de facto monopoly right to anyone bringing a drug that is unpatented but out-of-testing standard to updated fda safety standards, by preventing competitors from advertising.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by austinjp on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:08AM (#10751851)
Genuinely curious... does the world actually work like this? I strongly suspect not.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by rayiner on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:43AM (#10752096)
Yes, it does. For example, the recent Hep-C breakthrough drug was created by Pharmasset, Inc. Pharmasset was founded by the inventors of the drug--two professors at Emory University. It was purchased by Gilead, who commercialized it.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by twoodfin on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:59AM (#10752195)
I'm curious how you came to have strong suspicions that this kind of thing wouldn't work.

Google buys innovative startups all the time. Why should pharma be different?

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by austinjp on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @11:15AM (#10778511)
I just noticed this attracted some downvotes and comments. I should have been clearer. My curiosity was piqued by this:

> acquisition of promising drug candidates is a major input to the > pipeline at the big drug companies. It enables separation of > concerns: small startups to develop the drugs and big > experienced companies to bring them to market. Creating an > artificial distinction between inventors and acquirers precludes > that efficient division of labor.

I wonder how many small pharma startups are successful. Is this really "effective separation of concerns"? Seems more like standard capitalist market dynamics: allow small-fries to take all the risk -- those that sink disappear; those that succeed might get bought out.

Is this really the best way to drive innovation in pharma? But... that's a discussion about markets.

Also, without researching the history of every drug produced by any major pharma corp, I can't blithely accept whether acquisition of "promising drug candidates" is or is not a "major input" to their pipeline. I'm not denyingwhether this happens, just asking to what degree -- just saying "citation needed" for that particular point.

I'm certainly not denying that some small pharma companies are successful, and that some get bought up by large pharma companies. That wasn't my question, and I should have been clearer.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by simon_ on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:44AM (#10752102)
It does. Big pharma constantly acquires research-focused junior companies to input into its pipeline for regulatory approval / commercialization.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:26AM (#10751306)
But the existence of folks willing to buy up drugs/drug companies creates a liquid market. This makes creating new drugs more profitable and induces people to make more such drugs.

If we want to claim that folks buying up drugs don't help, do we also believe that tech startups getting exits doesn't promote the creation of more tech startups?

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by kedean on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:34AM (#10752033)
Well I mean yeah, that is an argument that floats around lately (one that I support). Namely, that the idea of every startup getting acquihired encourages low-quality startups with no purpose except getting eventually bought out. People need to be attached to their venture personally for it to get their full dedication, and if you just plan on selling it in the future anyway, that won't happen.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by mcherm on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:56AM (#10751432)
There are many people who have a philosophy of "Anything's Fair Within the Rules". There is no law against buying up the only manufacturer of a lifesaving drug and squeezing out as much profit as you are able, so there are many who would say it is fine to do.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by angdis on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:10AM (#10751502)
Obviously, that only works if you don't _ALSO_ create a public relations disaster by doing so.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:00AM (#10751798)
And end up in jail.

I'm still waiting for someone to explain to me the difference between a limited-oversight hands-off free market and a competitive criminal oligarchy.

Because variations on the criminal/sociopath thing keep happening so often when you get limited regulation and religious regard for profit at any social cost that they seem to be an inevitable outcome - a kind of moral Gresham's Law, where the crazy assholes always drive out more reasonable actors.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by morgante on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:23AM (#10752355)
I'm still waiting for someone to explain to me the difference between governments and stationary bandits.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by braythwayt on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:21AM (#10751552)

  > There are many people who...
Argumentum ad popularum. There are also many people who believe the Nazis passed good laws.

Yes, there are many people who are Lawful-Evil. That has no bearing on whether Evil is acceptable, provided it is Lawful.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by jdmichal on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:46PM (#10753453)
In order for it to be a fallacy, he has to be basing his argument off the fact that people believe this fact. I do not see him basing any argument on his first sentence. In fact, he mainly seems to be using it as an introduction mechanism. "Many people believe A. Proposition B about A." He states it as fact, and you may disagree with that fact, but that fact is in isolation from his actual argument.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by throwawaykf05 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:32AM (#10751326)
Except in this case the patents had long expired and there was no legal monopoly involved. This was pretty much free-market business wheeling and dealing.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by ansible on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:45AM (#10751382)
There was no monopoly per-se, but there is considerable cost getting a new pharmaceutical company's production spun up and FDA approved.

For limited application drugs (so annual sales smaller than Prozac... which is most of them), this effectively means there will only be one supplier.

I don't know a way to fix this that will satisfy most interested parties.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by paulmd on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:49AM (#10751727)
Another side note is that he was also impeding the FDA approval process.

In order to get your generic approved you have to prove that it's biologically equivalent to what's on the market. Shkreli's distributor would only sell directly to end-users and would refuse to sell it to anyone doing equivalence studies on it. Thus it was effectively impossible for anyone else to prove bioequivalence and bring a competing product to market.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by gohrt on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:54AM (#10752163)
Shkreli aside, it's ridiculous that the FDA would require such tests but not require that all approved drugs provide samples for further testing.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by logfromblammo on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:28AM (#10751988)
Also, any other company spending money to spin up production and get FDA approval would face its incumbent competitor suddenly dropping its price to cost. This lasts until the new entrant goes bankrupt or stops selling, and then the price jumps right back up to gouging territory.

The only way to eat the incumbent's lunch in a worthwhile way would be to start out larger, so you can absorb the startup costs, and find a way to produce at lower marginal cost.

The FDA approval process for generics is part of the problem there. It should be enough to do a chemical analysis showing that the molecules are the same. The current FDA requirements are akin to having to prove that your new vodka can get someone drunk just as well as vodka from other vodka makers. The active ingredient is ethanol. Ethanol made by you and ethanol made by AB InBev is chemically indistinguishable. As long as you can accurately report concentration, for the purposes of dosing, you shouldn't have to prove that ethanol still gets people drunk when you are the one making it. You should only need to prove that the amount of ethanol in your vodka matches the amount printed on the label.

So if your doctor prescribes 9.3 g ethanol, taken orally, once daily, your "compounding pharmacist" can give you a 1 oz. shot of any 80-proof beverage. It doesn't matter if it's name-brand top shelf or generic rail, so long as it's 40% alcohol by volume.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:35AM (#10752042)
I'm going to have to disagree that you shouldn't only need to show chemical equivalence. You need to show biological equivalence.

A few years back the FDA approved a generic version of Wellbutrin. They didn't ask for bioequivalence testing and as a result, the formulation dumped all the drug into the body, drug levels spiked and patients got sick. The FDA eventually made the company reformulate the drug so that it was truly interchangeable with the branded drug.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by logfromblammo on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:51PM (#10753521)
There's more to the buproprion HCl fiasco. The active ingredient produced by the generics manufacturers was the same. The delivery mechanism was different. The approval for the 300 mg XL version of the pills was extrapolated from 150 mg XL pill data, rather than compared with the Wellbutrin XL 300 mg. There wasn't even a check for chemical equivalence there.

You could have dropped the pills into an artificial stomach and measured concentrations at 20 minute intervals. That tests chemical equivalence. You don't need to test bioequivalence until after that. If your synthetic stomach setup does not show chemical equivalence, that's when you need to get the animal test subjects.

Part of the problem here is that the FDA bundles several different tests into one.

  - Does the molecule do harm to a human body?  What are the side effects?
  - Is the drug effective for a specific medical condition?
  - How does a higher or lower dosage affect the observed results?
  - How effective is a given delivery mechanism?
Those questions should really be answered separately, and in that order, for initial approval. Generics would then only need to re-answer question 4 if the delivery mechanism was different.

Take a look at this article about how manufacturers extend exclusivity by tweaking the delivery mechanism: http://www.pharmaceuticalcommerce.com/index.php?pg=manufactu...

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by MoOmer on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:02AM (#10751462)
Huge costs related to creating a generic version of the drug, unless it gets fast tracked.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by cma on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:30AM (#10752001)
See my reply here for a possible approach: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10577132
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by CWuestefeld on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:30AM (#10751994)
This was pretty much free-market business

No, it wasn't free-market at all. Much of Shkreli's strategy relied on the barrier to entry created by FDA regulations. He priced the drug just low enough that it wouldn't be worthwhile for another manufacturer to get approved.

Nothing free market here. It's rent seeking, pure and simple.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by Killah911 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:48AM (#10751394)
There's a fundamental flaw in that thinking. Greed is far from the only motivating factor in humanity. As a matter of fact, I'd argue that it's precisely the belief in this status quo, that causes sociopathic a-holes to run sociopathic companies. The solution is not necessarily to make everything government run, but perhaps to simply not accept such behavior/thinking as having any place in our society.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by rayiner on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:31AM (#10751622)
Greed is not the most motivating factor, but it certainly is a key one. If you adopt the rule that greed has no place in "high minded" stuff like saving lives, then all the smart people who are nonetheless greedy will go into areas other than saving lives. There is no correlation between intelligence and selflessness. You give the best and brightest a choice between earning millions on Wall Street or never breaking $150k in science (after 7 years of low-paid doctoral and post-doctoral work) then you'll cut yourself off at the knees.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by gohrt on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:57AM (#10752179)
You are assuming that the greedy Wall Street folks are actually contributing some of their smarts to improve the product of the industry in some way, and not just sneaking in and extracting value from the medical industry as Shkreli does.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by rayiner on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:20AM (#10752338)
I'm not saying that the Wall Street folks are improving the products of the drug industry. I'm saying that a lot of very bright folks go to Wall Street instead of into science because of the opportunity to make a lot more money.

And they're not even really greedy people. We live in a country where even a PhD making $150k still has to stress about saving for college and faces potential bankruptcy from medical expenses. You don't have to be greedy to want to stave off that risk by getting a high-paying Wall Street job.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by JackFr on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:43AM (#10751703)
> if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, you also won't bother to invent any new ones.

Someone call NIH -- I think they believe that part of the annual $30 billion they hand out in extramural research grants is being used just for that.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by CWuestefeld on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:37AM (#10752052)
I think you're actually supporting the point. The people actually doing the research don't care whether they're being financed by VCs, or by NIH. As long as they're getting the money, they're happy.

Moreover, if you're advocating pushing private investment even farther out, there are undesirable side effects. It means that the decision about what to pursue stops being driven by what there's actual demand for, and becomes a matter of political policy.

We can already see the effects of this. Government investment in medical research is not proportional to the number of sufferers, or the expected gain in QALYs (Quality-Adjusted Life Years). It's clear that the investment is strongly slanted toward research on maladies that have distinct demographics - i.e., that are represented by organized voting blocs. Thus, you'll find far more money spent, proportionately, on research for HIV than for something that's pretty widely distributed like colon cancer. I believe it's wrong for politics to drive this so strongly.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by lhc- on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:34PM (#10753335)
Of course, in the other direction, private spending has it's own problems. Most of the money is spent on recurring conditions where you have to take the drug forever rather than one-time cures. Additionally, things like hair loss and impotence draw far greater funding than actual life-threatening illness, because the only motive is profit.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by bshanks on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:59PM (#10754886)
More than half of the costs of biomedical research ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_research#Privately_.28... ), and ~75% of clinical trials ( http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/who_pays ) is paid by industry (ironically it seems the public can't (easily, freely) read the original sources of those figures, as cited by the linked webpages, because they in for-profit journals).

My impression is that the cost of the final clinical trials account for a large part of the expense of bringing any single drug to market (but on the other hand a lot of other drugs fail before clinical trials) (some people think clinical trials are even 90%: https://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/stifling-new-cures-... ; see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10752639 for some disagreement with this figure). My impression is that the general tendency is for the government to focus more on funding the less expensive but more risky earlier stages of research, and for companies to focus more on funding the more expensive but less risky (but still rather risky) clinical trials.

So the conclusion is that in order to do without private funding for drug discovery, the government would have to either (a) massively increase government funding for this, or (b) greatly lower the standards for how much evidence is required before permitting a new drug to be sold to patients (that is, to be content with companies selling a drug to patients, and billing patients/insurance companies/the government, without solid evidence that the drug actually works). Imo either or both of those may be a good idea; but those would both be huge systemic reforms and hence are unlikely to occur, and in the meantime we do in fact rely a lot on industrial funding to bring new drugs to market.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:36AM (#10752049)
I'm curious which drugs the NIH has launched? Can you list them?
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by onli on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:55AM (#10751425)
The media has decided the is a villain? I do not think so. It is quite evident he made that decision himself, look at the interview linked in the top comment, or at his actions.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by angdis on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:01AM (#10751453)
Well, actually, this whole discussion IS about Shkreli and your comments are within the context of the discussion so don't disclaim that.

Shkreli has foolishly attracted attention to himself by comically absurd price-gouging. Whether it is illegal or not, it was dick move and in the end probably not even likely to net much profit. It also has understandably destroyed the good-will of anyone other than Ayn-randian maniacs.

Now he's been arrested for what sounds like illegal and extremely irresponsible financial shenanigans that happened before all this stuff. Greedy, amoral business people that break the law are usually able to maneuver themselves around getting jail-time. Shkreli's going to have a much harder time with that (because as you noted the media has decided he's a villain) and its his own dumb fault.

Personality defects have consequences.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by vdaniuk on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:14AM (#10751262)
>Lets also not forget that if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, you also won't bother to invent any new ones

Citation needed. Extremely needed.

Counter-anecdote: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonas_Salk

edit: wording

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by Malarkey73 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:18AM (#10751277)
If you can make exploitative profits from old drugs why risk your money making new ones?
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:23AM (#10751295)
Are you saying I'm wrong, and that that pharma companies and others will donate hundreds of billions of dollars to drug development purely out of altruism?

Or are you simply claiming that a small number of examples exist, therefore my claim doesn't follow as a hard and fast rule but merely as a trend?

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by jacquesm on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:28AM (#10751313)
It's not exactly a fine line between altruism and price gouging, there is a huge scala of options in between. I find your comments in this thread hard to rhyme with your recent post about medical tourism. After all, if not for generics and your ability to move temporarily to a country where medical care is affordable you'd be out a very large amount of money over and beyond what you paid for your treatment. Clearly - for you - medication and care where you live is too expensive and you too would have benefited from more affordable medication and care.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:22AM (#10751560)
I'm not sure why you find my comments hard to rhyme.

In this thread I'm claiming that if you make it harder to make a profit off lifesaving drugs, people will probably invest their money elsewhere and produce fewer such drugs. Reduced demand (or price ceilings) lower quantity produced.

In the other thread I claimed that if you consider alternate sellers of medical labor, you can get a lower price. Increased supply lowers price and increases quantity provided.

Both of these claims are just classic Econ 101.

If medical tourism was not an option for me I'd have paid full price in the US and considered myself extremely lucky to have the option to trade money for the ability to do sex positions besides "girl on top, me not moving". I hardly think I'm alone - how many people would be willing to give up all medical procedures invented since 1970 in return for lower prices?

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by jacquesm on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:27AM (#10751589)
But the problem lies in the fact that for 'medical tourism' to be an option at all you first have to achieve a certain amount of wealth and your social situation has to be one where you can just pack-up-and-leave for an x amount of time without your life ending up in disarray upon your return. For many people these are not options because of money in the first place so they would not be able to pay the full price in the US to begin with.

It's just another wealth-begets-more-wealth story, your jump off point is already one of considerable privilege, one that relatively few people in the US have.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:54AM (#10752165)
If I bought a round trip US->India->US ticket (I didn't, I stayed in India), that would have been about $1000 at most. Hotel + food another $1000. Surgery $2000. Lets round up to $5k.

$5k is not a lot of money even for lower middle class USians. (Lower class USians have medicaid.)

It's true that many Americans live up to the limit of (or beyond) their means. Even if someone earning $25k cuts his consumption down to $20k, he'll still be living a vastly better life than almost everyone in India. It's true that being born in the US, and being able to trade 20% of your income one year for the ability to walk again, is a massive privilege.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by acgourley on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:18PM (#10753213)
Wealth inequality may be a problem broadly but it doesn't invalidate his argument about incentives in drug production.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by abawany on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:23PM (#10752775)
I don't agree with this false choice, re. "how many people...since 1970 in return for lower prices". To extend the ridiculous analogy to you and medical tourism, by not supporting the medical industry in the US and paying exorbitant prices, you are choosing to give up all US medical advances since 1995.

It can't be this drastic. Remember, the medicines are being invented by people who I believe to some significant extent are motivated by the desire for research and to improve the human condition. Witness all of the smart doctors who join, voluntarily, organizations such as Doctors Without Borders and go to the harshest places in this world to provide medical treatment for all.

I am not attacking you or your enjoyable write-up earlier but I had to comment on this false choice. I observe this same dogmatic behavior when people compare agile vs "waterfall" - it just makes no sense to me because I just don't think the world is ever this black and white.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:53PM (#10753018)
The point I'm making is that prices are high but we are getting valuable things in return for high prices. I.e., we pay 5x the cost for 10x the value. Prices are high not due to inflation or someone getting ripped off, but because we want to buy awesome yet expensive things.

I.e., what I'm disagreeing with is the contention that "medication and care where you live is too expensive".

(Jacquesm is also assuming I lived in the US last year when I had my surgery, but in fact I was homeless and spent most of my time overseas.)

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by jacquesm on Thursday December 17, 2015 @02:17PM (#10753707)
That assumption was based on the data in your article.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by mhb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:19AM (#10751282)
vdaniuk wrote and then deleted: "'Lets also not forget that if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, you also won't bother to invent any new ones' Citation needed. Extremely needed. Counterfact: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonas_Salk"

Here: http://www.investopedia.com/university/economics/economics3....

NB: the higher the price, the higher the quantity supplied

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by bmelton on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:01PM (#10752618)
Not sure why you're seeing it as deleted. It was edited

s/counterfact/counter-anecdote/

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10751262

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by throwawaykf05 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:26AM (#10751302)
You mean "counter-anecdote"?
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by sillyhealthcare on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:28PM (#10755466)
Yes...and...no

One of the biggest costs is getting a drug approved and then sold

The FDA will prioritize Orphan drugs and other high priority drugs, and the US government will help pay for drugs that haven't even gotten full clearance through the FDA if they are considered high priority.

Sovaldi (the Hep C drug that cures 90% of cases at over $1000/dose) and Harvoni (94%) you can apply your argument to. And there is a reason why the FDA and US government supports the pricing even over patients screams.

Meanwhile, while the FDA did approve Zaltrap, it was not considered a priority drug, and they did not say a thing when Memorial Sloan Ketterring publicly announced they would refuse to perscribe because the clinical data made Zaltrap out to be as effective as many other off patent drugs, and at $11000/month, Zaltrap would bankrupt patients. In the end, Zaltrap's maker, Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc., brought down the price.

(http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/15/opinion/a-hospital-says-no... , https://www.advisory.com/research/oncology-roundtable/oncolo... )

if Tomorrow you were to invent a new antibiotic that would work against drug resistant bacteria (this is considered to be a high priority research area and any drug that is ready for approval will be fasttracked), you could charge whatever you want, no complaints, and the media will not consider you a villian as much as part of the spectacle of medicine.

If you re-invented botox for no reason, or stop others from being a provider in the market, then you get to be a villian

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by maxerickson on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:51AM (#10751412)
This particular rights purchase and price hike was just foolish. A compounding pharmacy responded to it by offering the same medicine for ~$1 per pill.

http://bigstory.ap.org/article/c1264e78de574d869519f169d5a1a...

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by realusername on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:32AM (#10751626)
This is only if you believe in a private market which works for drugs which I believe is not possible unless for really simple basic meds. I beleive the research should be public on this case, no legal incentive can really fix the drug market. This is one of those markets where the interests of both parties will likely never align.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by refurb on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:37AM (#10752057)
Keep in mind that most new drugs are discovered and developed in the US. If you take a look at the countries with strict price controls, you'll see a lot fewer new drugs being discovered.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by littletimmy on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:29AM (#10751318)
Why can't we have the government fund pharmaceutical research?
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by rayiner on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:28AM (#10751596)
The question is: what's cheaper in the end? Having the government develop these drugs, soup to nuts, or giving private industry do it and having medicare/medicaid pay for those who can't afford it? If private industry is more efficient at bringing these drugs to market, then the latter option might be cheaper, even if it creates "unseemly" profits for private companies.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:33AM (#10751630)
In theory this might work. In practice, the US is truly terrible at running big projects.

Consider the 2nd avenue subway in NYC. We've been building it since 1972. It's still under construction and is the most expensive subway ever. Compare to the Delhi metro: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delhi_Metro#/media/File:Delhi_...

What big projects of any sort have we done a good job with lately? The closest we've had to a success might have been our second attempt at building an ebay for health insurance.

When we run our current crop of big projects well, I'd think about expanding into more. Until then, lets not take chances with something as important as pharmaceutical research.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by dalke on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:40PM (#10753394)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_megaprojects#North_Ame... suggests: CityCenter in Las Vegas, Brickell Key in Miami, and Battery Park City in NYC as recently completed megaprojects in the US. (The last has been in development for a long time.)

It also lists the Hudson Yards Redevelopment Project as an on-going $20 billion megaproject, which broke ground in December 2012 and appears to be doing well. It's the largest real estate development in U.S. history.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by mseebach on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:11AM (#10751873)
Because you'd ultimately have politicians direct research, based on what makes the best photo-ops up to the next election as well as the inevitable old-boys-club/revolving-doors "corruption-light" that quickly infects expensive government programs.

Whatever the aesthetics of people getting rich from treating sick people, on the evidence, it's actually very effective.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by littletimmy on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:15AM (#10751894)
Well, we do have an example of a governmental agency that is free from political control, i.e. the federal reserve. We could have something like that for research, can't we? After the appointment of a governor, the organization could function on its own without politics. Other examples include supreme court of the United States, BBC in the UK etc.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by logfromblammo on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:19AM (#10752329)
The problem is that the price system is the best resource allocation scheme that humans have ever attempted at scale.

When you sever the external link between the product going out, and the money coming in, you destroy some of the positive or negative feedback loops that take into account what people actually want and what they can do.

There has to be a hard external link between the outputs and the inputs, or you end up with a situation where rent-seekers charge in and gum up the works, absorbing resources without doing anything economically useful in exchange. The instant you guarantee a cash flow independent of actual results, you create sinecures, and those offices fill up and never go vacant again.

You could end up with situations where the agency cures a disease, but spends 100 times more doing that than it would cost to develop an acceptably effective treatment and also create a foundation that could pay to produce and distribute that treatment to everyone who gets it any time within the next 5 billion years.

Yay, woo, we cured it. But our inability to effectively prioritize resources meant that 99% of that cure budget was not spent on researching diseases that have a far greater economic impact. Oops.

Someone has to decide whether the money is well spent. And if that someone isn't everyone, then there is an agency problem, and rent-seekers scramble over each other to be the someone, so they can easily profit from that decision-making power.

Now, before anyone goes shaking their pompoms for the free market, I should mention that we haven't actually had one in medicine for a long time, thanks to the godawful market distortions that currently exist in the healthcare sector of markets where most treatments are researched. But at least that market-side link in the feedback loop still exists to some tiny extent, no matter how weak or tenuous it may be now.

So an independent research agency would be great for about 15 years. After that, it will start to become a gigantic black hole of waste and inefficiency.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by CWuestefeld on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:41AM (#10752085)
a governmental agency that is free from political control, i.e. the federal reserve

I'm not sure how much it affects the argument, but the Fed is not a governmental agency. It's a stand-alone corporation whose officers are appointed by the government.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve_System

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by dalke on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:19PM (#10753221)
The NIH and NSF funding doesn't appear to have that much in the way of low-level decision making by politicians looking for election day limelight.

Of course there is some, such as disparaging attacks on why we should put shrimps on treadmills, to the other extreme where the government, following public demand, funded a lot of HIV/AIDS research.

Also, as counter-example, the US government funds research in tropical diseases, not because it's a great photo-op for the next election, but also not completely altruistically - the military wants to be able to go into tropics and not have many of its soldiers die.

So the evidence so far says that your supposition isn't the whole picture by far.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by jcranmer on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:06AM (#10751831)
The cost of research and development per approved drug comes out to around $1-2 billion, while the cost of developing a single drug if it's successful is about $300 million. The vast disparity in prices here is the cost of pursuing failed drugs.

It's really not clear that government could develop drugs more cheaply. If you want to bring down the price of drug development, the primary thing you need to do is to discover which of your candidates is not promising and kill them much earlier in the pipeline. This sort of task is not one of government's core competencies (particularly if the legislature decides it wants a say in things).

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by vezzy-fnord on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:31AM (#10751620)
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by bshanks on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:06PM (#10754932)
Yes, but often the government research money doesn't pay for the goverment-mandated clinial trials. See my comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10754886 for details. So the parent's proposal to have the government entirely fund bringing drugs to market, including paying for 100% of clinical trials, would indeed be a (large) change to (and possibly an improvement upon) the status quo.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by EliRivers on Thursday December 17, 2015 @12:04PM (#10752639)
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by bshanks on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:09PM (#10754950)
In any case, the government would have to increase funding by some amount in order to fund 100% of the costs of bringing drugs to market, including all clinical trials, so as to remove the need for any private investment. If the study cited by the Slate article is correct, then this proposed increase would not have to be as large as some people expect. My person approach when evaluating the cost of proposals for the government to do something new, however, is to be pessimistic and lean towards the larger cost estimates.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by lentil_soup on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:45AM (#10751380)
Don't know why you're getting down voted, it seems like the best way to go about it. Share the cost of this research among all of us, just like we (in some countries) do with education, healthcare, police, etc.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by pjc50 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:04AM (#10751467)
He's getting downvoted because, as the adjacent wall-of-text reminds us, there are only two countries in the world: the US and the USSR. Since they have diametrically opposed ways of doing things, any change to the US system would instantly turn it into the USSR.

/s

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by briandear on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:58AM (#10751440)
TLDR; No. See Soviet Union.

Why should it? The free market is the most powerful incentive there is. Government control of the pharmaceutical industry has been tried before, in the Soviet Union and it was a mess.

Here's an excerpt from Michael Binyon's "Life in Russia" (1983)

"How often are foreigners asked by Russian friends to bring back drugs for sick relatives, and how often does the press complain that cheap, effective Soviet drugs are simply unobtainable! Take the case of a researcher who discovered an efficient drug to stimulate growth and spent fifteen years trying to get it on the market. In spite of repeated clinical tests, scientific endorsement and an urgent demand from people with deficiencies in growth hormones, the drug was unavailable. Instead manufacturers were producing a less effective foreign product which first came on the market twenty-two years ago.

What is on sale in the shops or in special kiosks is so outdated or so general in its effects that few people buy the product. Packets of good pills are so valuable that they are sold at special foreign currency counters in tourist hotels. Doctors issue prescriptions even if the hospitals have no supplies, leaving it to hapless patients to use their wits in trying to get hold of what they need. There are plenty of stories of dentists working without adequate supplies of anaesthetic, of polyclinics unable to supply a full course of treatment, of chronically sick people living from month to month, never sure whether their prescriptions can be renewed.

The drug industry suffers from none of the failings its Western counterpart is accused of: there is no risk of profit-taking at the expense of safety, no aggressive marketing of unnecessary drugs, no costly duplication of research laboratories. Instead, research, development, testing, approval, manufacture and promotion are organized as a public service. But the links between each stage are so weak that the time lag between research and retailing may be up to seven years. Responsibility for pharmaceuticals is divided between the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Medication Industry. Everything used to come under a subdivision of the Ministry of Health, but because of poor results a separate ministry was created in 1967. The Health Ministry is still responsible for resarch, testing and licensing of new drugs. The new ministry deals with production and quality control. Most research is carried out in state laboratories, and if an effective product is discovered it is sent to the Ministry of Medication Industry which finds a suitable factory to try it out. Test batches go back to the Ministry of Health for clinical trials, and often, if approved, to another plant for mass production. A separate agency handles distribution and marketing, and quality control is the responsibility of an independent state inspectorate.

Theoretically each stage leads to the next with no waste or duplication. In practice the chain becomes a bureaucratic nightmare. The institutional separation means that each body operates according to its own terms with little concern for the total process. By the time the product gets to the chemists' shelves, it has often been rendered obsolete. Research institutes have no real leverage to press factories to put their results into production, and have little incentive to do so. As for the manufacturers, they cannot get back their initial production costs because of a rigid pricing system, and find it cheaper and easier to stick to the older and tested lines for which there is already a market.

The lack of advertising means that doctors are often unaware of what is available. Sometimes they prescribe drugs that have long been withdrawn from the market. Similarly, since brand-names play little part in the pharmaceutical industry, a factory manager is not too concerned about the name and reputation of his plant, and this breeds indifference.

The Russians have tried various remedies. The simplest is to import drugs."

Gilead spends almost a billion dollars PER QUARTER on R&D expenses. Amgen spends over a billion per quarter, Celgene spends 1.3 billion per quarter. Most of those discoveries that come from those expenditures will never see the light of day. So how else are they to recoup their costs? If the government started funding pharmaceutical development at the tune of 25 billion per year, how would that infrastructure suddenly be created? Would they also need to get into the manufacturing side as well? Manufacturing many drugs is not a trivial process. Then there's the marketing expense -- doctors would need to be aware of the new drugs. There's distribution involved. Getting the government into the pharmaceutical business would be a massive, massive expenditure and still result in lower quality than the private sector could produce because the competitive forces would be eliminated. See the success of pretty much any Iron Curtain industry compared to the US and Japan for examples of how this goes bad and ultimately results in lower quality. Can you name a single Russian electronics manufacturer that you can buy in the Frankfurt Duty Free shop?

Of course the argument would be "we can do it more efficiently than the Soviets" -- sure. That's the same argument Communists use to suggest that "this time it'll work." I'd rather trust my life to someone that will profit from my survival than to a government that is influenced by whatever political forces are at play. Then you have the issue of what drugs deserve public funding and what drugs do not. That becomes a political decision and not a market decision. That's very dangerous.

Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by myth_buster on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:07AM (#10751837)

  Lets also not forget that if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, 
  you also won't bother to invent any new ones. 
This is not true.
Re:Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges by such_a_casual on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:18AM (#10752318)
> Lets also not forget that if you can't make money off lifesaving drugs, you also won't bother to invent any new ones.

Well this is the smartest thing I'll hear today. Context, context, context. The story goes that the drug was already around, already invented, already profitable. Some rich people came along and bought the product for billions of dollars because they realized they could resell it at a much higher price. So yes, let's not forget that if you can't make money reselling AIDS medications at an inhumane price, you won't bother to. And let's also not forget how easy it is to come across as capitalist sheep when we ignore the basic facts of the story in order to support our own ideals.