News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by CM30 on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:10PM (#10746463)
Probably a silly question, but is there a reason all these 'additions' are being snuck into bills and what not? Why does the system allow members of congress to add unrelated extras to bills in the first place?

Wouldn't a simple fix for things like this be 'only allow a new law proposal to be about a single topic and nothing else'?

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:38PM (#10746686)
> Wouldn't a simple fix for things like this be 'only allow a new law proposal to be about a single topic and nothing else'

Single-subject rules are adopted in many state, and they are neither complete solutions (viewing substantive subject-mixing as a problem), nor without their own potential problems. (And, anyway, to actually be mandatory, for Congress such a rule would have to be adopted through Constitutional amendment.)

Further, its quite arguable that substantive subject mixing is not a problem, poor representation is, and trying to limit substantive subject mixing just creates a new problem; where reps are effectively representing the interests of their district, why shouldn't they be able to effectively legislate based on considerations like:

1. X, considered alone, is better for those I represent, on balance, than not-X, and should be supported, and

2. Y, considered alone, is worse for those I represent, on balance, than not-Y, and should be opposed, but

3. X with Y, considered together, is better for those I represent than not-X with not-Y, thus, the combination of X and Y should be supported if X cannot be secured alone.

(While other representatives, with different constituents with different interests, see the same thing, but with X and Y reversed?)

If you could effectively prohibit subject mixing, that would prohibit compromises that are net gains for larger groups, even if smaller gains for the most-favored groups.

(Systems with parliamentary government with explicit coalition building essentially do massive subject mixing up-front in deciding the agenda of the coalition government when it is formed, and thus can avoid the need to do subject mixing when it comes to individual bills; the U.S. system works more on ad hoc coalition building, so the compromises are more on individual bills than anything analogous to the formation of a government in a parliamentary system.)

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by anonymfus on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:27PM (#10747484)
Then let's they first vote whether they want to mix X and Y, and then use ranked voting for deciding between 4 variants (X alone, Y alone, X and Y together, nothing).
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by shawn-furyan on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:41PM (#10747932)
Because you are opposed to the break neck pace at which congress currently operates? :P
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by makewavesnotwar on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:33AM (#10751633)
So I'm late to the party but I'd say this doesn't really apply to this or similar controversial situations that CM30 solution aims to fix.

On budgetary matters, sure. You want to combine efforts to get legislation through that benefits your constituency even if it's a lot more costly than it would be if you could get your measure approved by itself. An example would be Congressman A has a bunch of people complaining about the all the dangerous intersections in their state, Congressman B has a bunch of bridges that are falling apart, so the two get together and create a Federal Road Improvements Act or whatever to appropriate budget for what is now being considered a nation concern. This is a logical place for riders as it allows federal budgeting to have the greatest reach it can for helping the states.

There is substantially less logical argument when the riders concern law. From your example, if a law ever put a congressman's constituency worse off than they were before, there is no time when that representative should support it. Creating an environment of sweeping bad law into bills set to pass is inherently dangerous because once in place, laws are considered correct until properly invalidated.

But the nature of these riders is different still. This is law being thrown into budget. Just like the super controversial sections in the 2012 NDAA, these are mixing two very different types of bills. Having law riders is dangerous enough as it is, but allowing them to be thrown into budgetary bills that must pass is just insane.

The problem is there is currently no delineation in congress between the two types of bills. Everything they do whether budgetary or policy based is law and is generally "over the head of us simple minded folk" so they have leveraged a tremendous amount of freedom in the way that they can push things through regardless of how much sense anything they do ultimately makes.

I think the first-step solution would be to separate bill types and only allow appropriation riders on budgetary matters and no riders when it comes to new law/policy. If that is too complicated for them, they shouldn't be law makers.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by the_watcher on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:29PM (#10748218)
I actually prefer a solution that limits the length of individual bills. Want to pass a sweeping law change? Do it in parts, so no one can claim they missed it.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by davidw on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:22PM (#10748821)
That could be problematic unless you also implemented bill transactions in order to ensure that a group of things is passed together.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by spinlock on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:28PM (#10747494)
You know COBRA? That law that says you can buy insurance through your former employer after you leave the company. You know what COBRA stands for?

Combined Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act

Stuffing projects into the budget happens all the time. Basically, no one will negotiate in good faith on the merits of individual proposals so they play these tricks to get things passed into law.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by pjungwir on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:00PM (#10748056)
I like to think one of my better skills as a developer is asking a lot of dumb questions, and one rule in particular is to always ask what new acronyms stand for. Sounds like it wouldn't help me much in government. . . . :-)
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by LastZactionHero on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:21PM (#10747811)
Wow, thanks, I was thinking about COBRA yesterday and wondering what or stood for.

Definitely not what I came up with...

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:32PM (#10747515)
Congress has broad authority to make the law the way they see fit. A lot of what we think of as the "normal" way to pass laws, are just traditions and rules that Congress sets for itself.

Those traditions and rules are good, which is why they exist in the first place. But they're not really binding or legally required.

Which, if you think about it, makes sense. Congress is the ultimate lawmaking authority in the land--who is going to tell Congress what they can't do? The only answers are the Constitution and the voters. The Constitution sets some limits on powers, but doesn't micromanage process. And the voters tend to care about issues, not process.

For CISA specifically, it had already passed both houses; adding it to the omnibus does not accomplish anything that was not already going to happen anyway. The text changes that tptacek details so thoroughly are the sorts of things that could easily happen in conference committee. Sticking it into the omnibus is mostly a matter of convenience at this point.

In the end, Congressional leaders negotiated the omnibus, will allow it on the floor, and the full Congress will vote on it. This is the same bar than any piece of legislation must get over on its own.

And there were nasty bills that did not make it into the omnibus, like de-funding Planned Parenthood.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by abannin on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:03PM (#10747691)
There is a significant difference between bundling a bill into a high stakes omnibus such as the budget and passing it individually. It's much easier to stand up and say "I voted against a single bill" then "I voted against the budget and shut down the government". It's a strong arm negotiation tactic to force members to vote against their position on a less important issue. This is the same reason that so much pork gets thrown into the large bills.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by oldmanjay on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:18PM (#10748523)
> Those traditions and rules are good, which is why they exist in the first place.

This is unsupported by evidence or reason.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by joering2 on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:21PM (#10748164)
I +1 you because it was educational to me, but I'm seriously asking: why you said "nasty" bills like de-funding PP ?

edit: tpacek, Im not asking him in terms of his own opinion, but rather what "nasty" he found in those bills.

His post was very informative that's why I asked. I couldn't care less what he thinks about the subject of PP.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:52PM (#10748957)
"Nasty" is just my personal opinion about the efforts to defund PP. And plenty of people here think CISA is nasty.

A more neutral word to make the same point would be "controversial." I probably should have written that instead.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by tptacek on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:24PM (#10748183)
Please not here.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by Kalium on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:49PM (#10746765)
> Wouldn't a simple fix for things like this be 'only allow a new law proposal to be about a single topic and nothing else'?

How do you define "a single topic"? Who gets to decide what is and isn't topical? Who gets to enforce it? Can you see how this definition might be abused for political gain?

Myself, I see it only making things worse.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by ars on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:30PM (#10748585)
> How do you define "a single topic"? Who gets to decide what is and isn't topical?

Easy. If 1/3 of Congress votes for something to be split, then it's split. (Kind of the opposite of the 2/3 super majority rule.)

As simple as that. Let the people actually voting decide if something is a single topic.

Yes, this could lead to nonsense where people split things to insane levels just to disrupt things, but I suspect it would not come to that because they would be ridiculed, and it would be just a waste of time for them since splitting something doesn't mean it doesn't get voted on in the end.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by Kalium on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:22PM (#10749525)
I hate to break it to you, but you have a bunch of people in Congress right now gaining politically by being disruptive. So your failure scenario is occurring now without your mechanism.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by filoeleven on Thursday December 17, 2015 @03:20PM (#10754218)
If the failure mode of this proposal (excessive splitting of bills) is less disruptive than the current situation (attaching bill-killing, shutdown-threatening riders), then it seems to me we would still be better off with this implemented than without.

In addition, as long as the votes for this are public, it seems like it would be harder to defend capricious action for political gain, since anyone could see that this group of senators all voted to split legislation that clearly should not have been split and then take them to task for it. It could even be mandatory that a proposal to split a bill must be accompanied by an explanation (also publicly available) of why it should be split that way. It's one thing in my opinion to put something controversial into an unrelated bill--there will always be people who are in favor of that, so it is politically defensible and can score points--but it is another thing entirely to try to (literally) rationalize the frivolous division of a cohesive bill.

It actually strikes me as quite an elegant solution to the problem of riders and sprawling legislation.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by Kalium on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:27PM (#10754680)
You believe that by increasing transparency and granularity, voters will punish or reward Congresscritters more effectively and efficiently.

I disagree strongly. I submit that most voters do not follow the legislative process very closely and vote accordingly. Rather, I submit that most voters make decisions emotionally using far less than the totality of the relevant information currently available to them. At this very moment, we have a batch of Congresscritters who gain the support of their constituents by obstructing their opposition by any means possible. Questions of frivolousness or caprice are not considered. This is the situation here, today, and now.

I think your notion fails because it adds extra information that voters will disregard. Because this information will be disregarded, it will not significantly impact the behavior of voters. The net result is likely to be an increased legislative overhead, more procedural tools to be wielded as partisan weapons, and voter behavior not shifting significantly. As a result, the failure mode of this proposal is everything wrong with the current (attaching bill-killing, shutdown-threatening riders) PLUS excessive bill-splitting for the sake of obstruction.

Might I suggest that your solutions should not hinge on sudden and dramatic shifts of voter behavior at a scale of many millions?

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by woah on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:20PM (#10748813)
Sounds very easily DOS-able
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by mjevans on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @07:34PM (#10748605)
I think that a 'bill' should have a statement (which is not actual 'law') that clearly records the intended effects of the 'bill'. This could be seen as an executive summary.

The contents of the bill that are actually the changes to the code of law would prescribe how that effect is to occur. I would also like to see bills define, in law, how they are funded (even if that is, 'this is funded from a general fund').

I think that the above should be true for every level of governance. The bill should be rejected (patch refused), in it's entirety, if any material not 'directly' related to the intended purpose of the bill is within it, or if it conflicts with existing law in a way that is not corrected by the bill's application to the law. This is what the legal system in a given jurisdiction should do. All law would automatically be reviewed for correctness and compatibility.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by Kalium on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @11:23PM (#10749528)
How do you define "directly"? Who gets to judge? Who enforces?

You haven't really answered these questions. You've just postulated that someone will, implicitly assuming that nobody involved will ever be partisan.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by ionforce on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @08:09PM (#10748748)
There's no way a provision as "nice" as this would go through. Of course lawmakers want ways to sneak things in.

Oh, what are those last few pages you added? Never you mind, those are tertiary. This is all in the name of protecting the environment, and its citizens, and their metadata...

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by SapphireSun on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:57PM (#10746832)
Seems like it would fall to the judicial branch to decide if something is topical or not if it was that contested. However, that would lead to accusations of the judiciary being involved in making the law, though their power would be limited to splitting bills into smaller bills.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by Someone1234 on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:50PM (#10747234)
> Myself, I see it only making things worse.

How?

Unless you can show how it could make the situation actually worse, your argument doesn't hold.

It would at least be "as bad as now" or better.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by Kalium on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:17PM (#10747789)
It adds complexity and creates another procedural weapon to kill bills without discussing their contents. I see both of those as strictly worse.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by mhurron on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:55PM (#10746816)
> How do you define "a single topic"?

The original bill. As in, no riders at all.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:58PM (#10746843)
So, you'd prohibit all amendments, but allow unlimited mixing of unrelated subjects as long as they were incorporated in the original bill as proposed, so instead of adding riders to existing bills, politicians would let one measure die, and introduce a new one with the all the various mix of subjects (including the central focus of the old one) that would have been in the first measure with added riders.

Aside from moving part of the action from formal amendment processes to informal processes, I don't see what change that gets you.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by brianwawok on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:58PM (#10746835)
But does that change anything?

"Party X votes no in favor of bill Z, but we will vote again if you introduce bill Y which is the exact same as bill Z except with a new section funding for building a shipyard in the congressional district of a popular guy in Party X"

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by EvanAnderson on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:44PM (#10746732)
The "fix" for riders, in the past, has been the line-item veto (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line-item_veto_in_the_United_S...), which allows the president to veto parts of legislation.

It was passed in 1996, challenged, then struck down as unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in 1998.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:02PM (#10746873)
The line item veto, which purported to allow a kind-of, sort-of veto on spending items in budget bills was never (even had it been Constitutional) a solution to policy riders (whether on budget bills or otherwise.)
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by WildUtah on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:44PM (#10748315)
Before the 1974 Congressional Budget Act [0], it had been the law for 185 years that the president could simply refuse to spend money Congress had appropriated. He could hold back the cash even if he did spend other funds appropriated in the same law. That was the original line item veto.

Then Nixon tried to exercise his power to target specific projects and congressmen with an aggressive rescission project and Congress changed the system.

The current federal budget process was instituted in that law where Congress first authorizes all plausible spending and then appropriates only a smaller amount dedicated to specific programs and the president must spend that exact amount by law.

Congress tried to compromise between the two systems with a line item veto managed by Congress in 1996. The courts weren't ready to let the executive and legislature share spending power, especially when they were likely to be the referees and the post-1974 system persists.

Or, it persisted until about 1996. In recent years -- including all of the Obama presidency and the latter Bush years -- the Congressional budget process hasn't produced regular appropriations bills and has delivered only irregular authorizations. The process is supposed to produce at least twelve openly debated appropriations bills every year with participation by all of Congress. Instead a new system of continuing resolutions that limit all spending power to the president and the Senate majority leader and the House speaker in secret conferences has taken hold.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congressional_Budget_and_Impou...

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:51PM (#10748368)
> In recent years -- including all of the Obama presidency and the latter Bush years -- the Congressional budget process hasn't produced regular appropriations bills and has delivered only irregular authorizations.

This uses an unusual distinction between "appropriation" and "authorization" (usually, policy language is "authorization", and then actual dedication of money to be spent on an authorized purpose is "appropriation"; CRs are appropriations, not authorizations.)

> The process is supposed to produce at least twelve openly debated appropriations bills every year with participation by all of Congress. Instead a new system of continuing resolutions that limit all spending power to the president and the Senate majority leader and the House speaker in secret conferences has taken hold.

CRs are appropriations. Congress votes on the rules by which CRs are considered, and on the CRs themselves. The negotiations for CRs, as those for regular budgets, often involve the White House and leadership from both Houses of Congress in various configurations, but if Congress chooses not to debate them thoroughly, that's a choice Congress makes. The power is still with the whole body of Congress, even if that body (by a majority in each House) chooses to defer to the leadership in each House.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by JoshTriplett on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @05:09PM (#10747738)
The most obvious problem with the line-item veto is that some things should stay together, such as a new program and the funding to pay for that program, or the repeal of one tax and the institution of another tax to replace it.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by chishaku on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:35PM (#10746656)
What passes as a "single topic?"

Often, "additions" are included in these last-second, "must sign" bills because they face resistance and are unlikely to pass on their own. No representative, nor the president want to be responsible for a "government shutdown" so anything that makes it into the last version of the bill is likely to become law.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by nargella on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:35PM (#10746658)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation)

Riders are a terrible idea. This wiki does a good job at describing them and illustrating that other countries don't like the idea either.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by lukeschlather on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:30PM (#10746606)
What you're suggesting is essentially banning formal expressions of compromise. Compromise is essential for legislation to get made.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by EvanAnderson on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:37PM (#10746670)
Compromise is essential for legislation to happen, but I also don't think riders really are a form of compromise. It's an underhanded tactic.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by lukeschlather on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:32PM (#10747088)
How do you suggest a formally agreed-upon compromise without merging two separate topics into one bill?
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by jessriedel on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @03:51PM (#10747240)
It was my vague understanding that there is some very low bar for attaching riders, so that members can kill a bill they don't like by attaching a poison pill. If so, the answer would be "make the amendment process require more votes" or something like that.

I'd very much like an clear explanation of how the amendment process works.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:27PM (#10747486)
> It was my vague understanding that there is some very low bar for attaching riders, so that members can kill a bill they don't like by attaching a poison pill.

Floor amendments are voted on just like bills, and require a majority vote to pass. The way that it can be relatively "easy" for certain members to get amendments attached to a bill is in committee, since the committee to which a bill is assigned can either let the original bill languish (though if the rest of the House wants the bill out of committee, it can be pulled out) and adopt and report out an entirely new bill, on the same subject, with amendments, or report out the original bill with committee amendments as a package which are voted on together (this would be part of the rule for the bill, and this rule is, itself, subject to vote.)

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by jessriedel on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:41AM (#10752084)
Thanks very much. That was useful.

It still seems like there's a possibility that a large minority, who will vote against the bill no matter what, can attach a rider that appeals to a subset of the majority that's in favor of the bill but which will make the bill unpalatable to the rest of the supporting majority. But those kind of hypotheticals quickly devolve into complicated strategies, and it's not clear there's a better mechanism than the majority vote.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by bsder on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @04:50PM (#10747628)
The "simple fix" is the line-item veto.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by the_watcher on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @06:28PM (#10748213)
Yes, that would be a simple fix. Unfortunately, this is such an effective way to sneak favors into bills (things like funding for a local initiative in the home district for a politician who voted for a previous bill) that lawmakers love it, so it's here to stay.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by uremog on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:27PM (#10746586)
It's common because politics often works like that and nothing disallows it. "I'll vote for your [x] if you vote for my [y]". I definitely dislike it but just saying, sometimes that's why.
Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by ashark on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:37PM (#10746669)
> Wouldn't a simple fix for things like this be 'only allow a new law proposal to be about a single topic and nothing else'?

Define "topic" in a way that still lets legislators write useful laws while unequivocally disallowing the kind of thing you want to try to ban, and you can probably get published in a major poli-sci or philosophy journal.

Re:Congress has added CISA to the federal budget bill by harshreality on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:52PM (#10746792)
The perfect is the enemy of the good.

We can start with this HN thread's subject, which is a budget bill. Can we at least agree that budgets should not touch the U.S. Code? That they should be simply allocating money from the treasury to various programs and agencies previously specified by law?