I think this is really important. Stay-at-home parents want to get out, and free things are always welcome. Have daily reads + arts and crafts (simple coloring sheets is probably enough) with a small discount on the book-of-the-day is probably enough. I don't think it would even cost the store that much to run.
Michael's and Home Depot do weekly parent-child activities, and those you have to pay for, and I love taking my kids to them. Much easier than trying to figure out something to do at home.
A local theater had a "cheap kids movies" thing during the summer, where they showed older kids' movies for a dollar or two. My wife took our kids to those, and it's a lot of fun, even if those movies we could have seen on Netflix at home. The theater is just different, and it's refreshing to leave the house.
Parents like these things, and (IMO) it probably brings your utilization of the store up, since during the middle of the weekday you're not going to get a lot of traffic.
Plus, as far as children's books go, physical books are way, way better than ebooks. I might even go as far to say that ebooks will never replace children's books.
For me there is a log of nostalgia around going to Borders with my parents as a child. Regarding the eBook thing you may be correct, but for me they already have replaced real books. For 5 dollars a month through an app on iPad my kid gets access to thousands of children's books on-demand ranging from a direct page-for-page port to something more interactive with sound, interactions, and video. I, for one, welcome our e-book overlords.
(FWIW, you can get a "The Very Hungry Caterpillar" app, but it's a different experience, being an interactive toy. Not worse, not better, just different. It appears to nicely complement, not replace, the book.)
B&N needs to quit adding "new stuff" to failing stores, as it's just not enough to make people want to go vs shopping on Amazon, and shutter them instead. Maintain a smaller but better brand.
Malls are dying in the US, though. The only malls that remain successful these days feature more upscale products in affluent areas that people want to see in person before purchasing. For everything else, shoppers seem to prefer your outlet style strip malls where there's less crowding and inconvenience. Or if they can wait a day or two, just order it online.
Also, I've seen B&N stores in malls before.
No, but that's a point that a certain type of person likes to push. As this article [1] starts, "maybe it's that reporters don't like malls". You could add "and Hacker News commenters" after "reporters" there.
[1] http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/06/07/malls-aren-...
Yes, but for every Galleria or Woodlands Mall there's a number of malls like Greenspoint or Northwest, losing anchor stores and becoming very low quality. Even malls like Deerbrook, which while still containing mainstream stores and staying pretty busy, are very obviously becoming run down.
They are. See for example this article[0] from earlier this year and the HN comments[1] from about a month ago.
[0] http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/04/business/the-economics-and...
EDIT:
On the plus side, we still have some good book stores, like Brown Technical Book Shop (http://www.browntechnical.org/). :)
http://www.businessinsider.com/shopping-malls-are-going-exti...
> outlet style strip malls where there's less crowding and inconvenience
"Dying" problem and "crowding" problem seem to be mutually exclusive in a Yogi Berra kind of way.
I greatly enjoy books, and bookstores, and have shelves of books in my home. I guess I'm not the kind of customer B&N wants.
If physical bookstores are to have any hope of surviving then books need to be exactly that kind of product.
Physical books are exactly that kind of product, but there are precious few malls that meet that description, and the rents are very high. And the communities where they exist also tend to be communities where B&N has stores (though not always in the malls, though sometimes on the same lot and sharing foot traffic). I'd be very surprised if there's any real evidence that there is a profit opportunity for B&N being missed by tieing itself more to malls, there or anywhere else.
Maybe Barnes and Noble could do well over here. I mean, they can't really be any worse than Smith's in terms of quality, can they? I think they could do decently well in say, Lakeside or Bluewater.
B&N will linger on, since they have no real competition anymore with the demise of Borders. People still buy physical books, and book readers still like to visit bookstores. But the long term outlook is probably a 50% reduction in stores.
Oh, and they pay their employees like shit, though all retail does to some extent.
Isn't knowing exactly who customers are and what they want the priority of any business? (one might argue sometimes customers don't know what the want)
Of course, the current CEO presided over Toys R Us as they fell into oblivion and ended up purchased by Bain Capital. And Sears Canada, another example of failed "big box" retail shopping.
It was probably a Branded Solutions Food Service store (http://www.starbucks.com/business the Food Service option, not a Licensed Store or Starbuck Office Coffee delivery service) that served Starbucks brands from the "We Proudly Serve Starbucks Coffee" portfolio.
Or it may have been a real store (licensed); I can't say for certain.
The B&N I live near also has a "Starbucks" inside it, except it is actually one of the food service branded stores on closer inspection. It doesn't take the Starbucks app or giftcards, small signs with the prominent mermaid logo have the smaller "We Proudly Serve" print instead of "Starbucks", etc.
I think the Starbucks that are inside Target stores are also these sorts of arrangements.
Target stores have an actual 'licensed Starbucks store' where you can pay with the Starbucks app or giftcard.
> Not all Starbucks coffee shops are generic. Some of them
> have really nice layouts
It may just be one of the generics that you like - they have I think four different styles (not exact layouts, but upholstery themes).Quite a good idea IMO - allows them to better fit the area as you say, also make two nearby shops a bit different, while also keeping all the benefits of a common theme(s): bulk buying, easy and fast replacement, maintaining brand, etc.
It's not really a Starbucks in the same sense as the standalone coffee shops of that name (nor is it specific to a particular local store); they've licensed the branding and beverage product line from Starbucks on a chain-wide basis (their food products are not Starbucks lines, but from other sources.)
They used to. From 1987 to 2010, B&N owned a mall bookstore chain called B. Dalton. There were in every mall, but then B&N decided they didn't need that market anymore, so they liquidated the stores and killed the Dalton brand.
There actually are a few full-size B&N stores in some malls, but only a few malls have them, and they're typically positioned as anchors.
B Dalton was (as were other mall located bookstores at the same time) in decline when B&N bought them; the format was visibly on the way out even before online competition.
There's slight confirmation bias as before 2011 it was Borders who would follow the Starbucks strategy for real estate - sign a lease on the place with the most foot traffic (in US it was typical to see Borders shops close to train stations, major urban shopping centers, malls, etc.)
Borders went bankrupt, and B&N is not that flush with cash to overtake their leases (which makes me wonder if expensive leases combined with relatively fixed margins on books are sustainable), but that was likely the reason B&N would not compete for prime real estate.
> They place them poorly. B&N is perfect for foot traffic. But B&Ns are typically located as drive-up "out of town" shopping. Somewhere you need to go to intentionally. They need to be in malls.
The smaller, mall-located brick and mortar bookstores were unsupportable even when B&N was doing well -- B&N even bought several of them and continued to operate them under their old names for a while, attempting to leverage connections to B&N's loyalty programs, online presence, and other relevant strengths to make them viable.
I think the theory here has been fairly well tested and proven false.
> The children's area is really nice, but poorly leveraged. No classes, no reading groups, no reason to come in. Stay at home parents WANT a reason to get out of the house, you offer a free reading group for small kids, the parents will buy the books after the group.
Most B&N's I've seen have events in the children's section; I just checked one of my local stores, and they have children's storytime weekly.
> Atmosphere in the coffee shop is bad. Waterstones feels like a nice little swanky coffee shop, somewhere you'd go and work on your novel, B&N's coffee shop feels like a generic coffee shop at the airport.
IME, "coffee shop atmosphere" varies considerably among B&Ns (for those that even have coffee shops).
> B&Ns has no brand, and keeps making it worse. 3D printers, toys, Nooks, what is it that B&Ns is? They're all over the place, and now when you go into a B&N store you'll never know what they'll be pushing this week.
I think B&N, like many stores, has decided that focusing on a narrow product range is less viable than targeting interests of a particular demographic. This is not a completely insane idea, but do I think Waterstones' strategy of keeping the book focus and letting each store target locally is better.
Only if we assume that store size and location at the ONLY metrics used to determine success. Not atmosphere, product selection, store layout, consumer demand, competition, and price.
You cannot say for sure why that specific attempt failed. Nor can I.
Our local B&N is the size of Toys R Us (same plot), and while Toys R Us makes good use of their floor space, it feels like half of the B&N is populated (e.g. fiction section) while the other half is a desert wasteland (reference, Nook showcase, etc).
And considering how much rent costs around here, I can only imagine how much B&N could save by re-designing the stores into a smaller plot. Or heck move it into a plot with more foot traffic, and the same popular selection.
That was the same with Waterstones. They just decided to kill all that stuff. None of the stores stocks any references or similar things.
I think Waterstones just generally benefits from having really good locations and tailoring them to the audience. But that requires good stores in the first place. Not every company has that luxury.
It's not for lack of trying, but publishers have to play ball. They've had a few programs where you could buy a physical book and pay $x extra for the ebook, but the process has been cumbersome and the publisher-set additional cost too high.
It could lead by example by doing that for the titles B&N itself publishes.
I've spent a lot of time in both B&N and Waterstones. B&N has a lot of problems Waterstones never had even ahead of bankruptcy:
- The stores are too big. 1/2 of a B&N store is tat, reference books, niche stock, a Nook display area, and other nonsense. You could cut almost all B&N stores in half and not notice as a customer.
- They place them poorly. B&N is perfect for foot traffic. But B&Ns are typically located as drive-up "out of town" shopping. Somewhere you need to go to intentionally. They need to be in malls.
- No good Nook tie-in for the stores. My SO often goes into B&N and looks at books, and then says "I'll buy it on my Nook later." They should have made an agreement with the publishers YEARS ago: When you buy a physical book, you get the Nook book included.
- The children's area is really nice, but poorly leveraged. No classes, no reading groups, no reason to come in. Stay at home parents WANT a reason to get out of the house, you offer a free reading group for small kids, the parents will buy the books after the group.
- Atmosphere in the coffee shop is bad. Waterstones feels like a nice little swanky coffee shop, somewhere you'd go and work on your novel, B&N's coffee shop feels like a generic coffee shop at the airport.
- B&Ns has no brand, and keeps making it worse. 3D printers, toys, Nooks, what is it that B&Ns is? They're all over the place, and now when you go into a B&N store you'll never know what they'll be pushing this week.
I think B&N will go under. I just don't think the management is very good, and every attempt they make to right the ship makes it worse. The whole business needs to be restructured.