News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barnes and Noble is dying, Waterstones in the U.K. is thr... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @12:45PM (#10745864)
> The stores are too big. 1/2 of a B&N store is tat, reference books, niche stock, a Nook display area, and other nonsense. You could cut almost all B&N stores in half and not notice as a customer.

> They place them poorly. B&N is perfect for foot traffic. But B&Ns are typically located as drive-up "out of town" shopping. Somewhere you need to go to intentionally. They need to be in malls.

The smaller, mall-located brick and mortar bookstores were unsupportable even when B&N was doing well -- B&N even bought several of them and continued to operate them under their old names for a while, attempting to leverage connections to B&N's loyalty programs, online presence, and other relevant strengths to make them viable.

I think the theory here has been fairly well tested and proven false.

> The children's area is really nice, but poorly leveraged. No classes, no reading groups, no reason to come in. Stay at home parents WANT a reason to get out of the house, you offer a free reading group for small kids, the parents will buy the books after the group.

Most B&N's I've seen have events in the children's section; I just checked one of my local stores, and they have children's storytime weekly.

> Atmosphere in the coffee shop is bad. Waterstones feels like a nice little swanky coffee shop, somewhere you'd go and work on your novel, B&N's coffee shop feels like a generic coffee shop at the airport.

IME, "coffee shop atmosphere" varies considerably among B&Ns (for those that even have coffee shops).

> B&Ns has no brand, and keeps making it worse. 3D printers, toys, Nooks, what is it that B&Ns is? They're all over the place, and now when you go into a B&N store you'll never know what they'll be pushing this week.

I think B&N, like many stores, has decided that focusing on a narrow product range is less viable than targeting interests of a particular demographic. This is not a completely insane idea, but do I think Waterstones' strategy of keeping the book focus and letting each store target locally is better.

Re:Barnes and Noble is dying, Waterstones in the U.K. is thr... by Someone1234 on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @12:51PM (#10745901)
> I think the theory here has been fairly well tested and proven false.

Only if we assume that store size and location at the ONLY metrics used to determine success. Not atmosphere, product selection, store layout, consumer demand, competition, and price.

You cannot say for sure why that specific attempt failed. Nor can I.

Our local B&N is the size of Toys R Us (same plot), and while Toys R Us makes good use of their floor space, it feels like half of the B&N is populated (e.g. fiction section) while the other half is a desert wasteland (reference, Nook showcase, etc).

And considering how much rent costs around here, I can only imagine how much B&N could save by re-designing the stores into a smaller plot. Or heck move it into a plot with more foot traffic, and the same popular selection.