It's the landlord who offers (within the limits of local law) the terms of the lease. I've never seen a lease agreement that allows subleasing without at least right of refusal on reasonable grounds by the landlord. The landlord is within its rights prohibit the tenant from entering into any kind of sub lease entirely. It could (again, within the limits of local law) evict the tenant for even advertising a possible sublease without its written permission.
But no, the landlord is very graciously offering to actively support subleasing via AirBnB. If the landlord executes properly, that's a win for the tenant, a win for the landlord, and a win for the neighbors.
Of course, you may not like that trade-off. You may, like me, have kids in those bedrooms, and enjoy having other families with kids around you who form lifelong friendships with your kids. You may not really want to see an investor buy the 3 bedroom apartment next to you and pay his or her own mortgage and profit by bringing a never ending stream of strangers into the house or apartment next door - even if these strangers are very well behaved.
In short, you may wish to trade your right to turn your house into a hotel in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that your neighbors won't do this either. Or, alternatively, you may be ok with it in a more limited way, that perhaps you don't really mind people doing this occasionally, when they are on vacation, say for a limited number of days a year.
If this is the case, then you would gain none of the benefits but experience all the negatives of disruption.
As you can probably tell from the way I set this up, I feel it is immensely reasonable to zone certain sections of a city as residential with strong restrictions on short term rentals, as a way of protecting residents from the externalities of short term rentals, as well as a way of protecting long term housing stock.
It's certainly true that if these things are done irresponsibly then bad things happen. And bad things do often happen, I'll give you that. But it's not necessarily true. How it's managed is what determines whether the outcome is good or bad and for whom.
When short term renters well behaved, then the neighbors aren't harmed at all. If any lease holder has the ability to sublet easily with support of the landlord then that is something of value. A landlord that gets involved like this is going to create an environment with incentives for good short term tenants.
I'd rather lease from a company that allows me to do that and also supports me in doing so. I'd rather lease from a company that actively manages subleases than one that sticks its head in the sand that pretends that isn't happening all the time.
Short term subleases are here to stay. Trying to stop them is like trying to stop piracy or illicit drug use. It's just not going to happen.
edit: also: To call what happens on airbnb an "unregulated hotel" is profoundly misguided. Have you ever lived for a significant period of time out of airbnb??
I'm not sure why I'm meant to care that there are people that use Airbnb for long-term living arrangements. The modal Airbnb renter does not do that.
What this landlord is doing is the equivalent of saying, "People are going to do drugs. OK. You can sell drugs and you can consume drugs, I'm not going to stop you. I only demand to test their purity first. And if you hurt unrelated parties I'm going to hold the guilty party accountable."
Now everyone has something to gain by playing by the rules. Sure, they have to give up something, but they get more than they give if they're honest. Once someone in a legal position of authority can get the parties to agree to play by the rules, that authority can do a lot to reduce, if not completely mitigate, the negative side effects.
But its funny how this free market thing works though, the hypocrisy is the same people who scream innovation and disruption when it comes to Uber are crying disgust and malpractice when it comes to Airbnb.
You can't have these selectively applied to what you like and dislike. If disrupting taxi unions and license issuers was fair, so is this.
Zilch. Nada. Absolutely nothing. They can accept it, or find somewhere else.
It's great that a landlord is saying, fine, you can sublease the place short term. But we have to regulate that, you have to pay us to do so, and if you can't hold up your end we have the right to put an end to it.
This is the only reasonable way I can see to solve the problem of short term rentals.
Not only do boilerplate leases include "quiet enjoyment" clauses that contractually bind landlords into ensuring that tenants aren't disruptive, but state laws also include implied covenants of quiet enjoyment, meaning that there are large areas where it doesn't even matter if you edit that out of your lease.
A landlord that fails to ensure quiet enjoyment can be sued by their tenants.
Even with the laws and implied covenants, it takes a significant amount of time to go through eviction proceedings in many states. In California it can take months (unless you stop paying rent altogether, in which case there's a fast-track procedure).
Yes, a tenant can sue their landlord as well. Again, however, that can take months and significant expense.
When considering these things, we must take into account the actual reality of how rights are exercised, not merely what rights exist in law.
In just about every other situation, there is a list of 16 reasons you can evict someone, and all of them can lead to a lengthy expensive trial, in which at the end the landlord has spent a significant amount of money and probably regrets every doing anything with their life.
Is that particularly worse than tenants having to deal with Section 8 tenants in their midst?
Your own comment some time ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10623102
Why do you think that short-term middle-to-upper-class renters are preferable neighbours to medium-to-long-term lower-class renters? I saw your comment elsethread about ease of punishment, which makes some sense, but in my experience small landlords simply don't care.
Living above a pair of end-stage alcoholics who importuned people on the sidewalk and called the ambulance for health care every few weeks was far, far more annoying than the flophouse a few doors down. Then there was the poor family with 9 people in a two-bedroom unit, with a couple of teenagers who vandalised and may have been thieves as well (not that upper-class teenagers aren't hoodlums, of course: many of them are too). Then there was the prostitute with the shady clientele.
You appear to be opposed to short-term renters, but appear to applaud Section 8. Why the difference?
Neither are short-term hotel guests, but tptacek wants to reduce those while welcoming Section 8, which is logically inconsistent.
They are both groups of people who some folks wish to exclude as neighbours, and others wish to include as neighbours, in both cases presumably based on desirability or undesirability qua neighbours.
I've explained my reasoning (which is that I think short-term renters are more likely to be of a similar social class as their neighbours than are those who qualify for housing vouchers, and that I view local class homogeneity as a social good); it's hardly illogical, although you are of course free to disagree with it.