Re:Plan to throw one away
by mcv on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @04:15AM
(#10736717)
I would like to know how the CTO responded to the idea of throwing away the code he'd been slaving on at the very last minute, and replacing it with something that someone cobbled together in two weeks (but worked).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Plan to throw one away
by tankenmate on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @04:32AM
(#10736767)
From the sound of the description the original CTO authored code was cobbled together and its replacement was properly engineered (for some value of properly).
Re:Plan to throw one away
by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @04:59AM
(#10736850)
And I'm sure if you said that to the CTO they wouldn't take offence and would react in a rational, measured way. Actually, I've worked with managers that would react OK to that, and ones that definitely wouldn't, but I wouldn't tell any of them their work wasn't "properly engineered". Stick to the objective facts: this version runs much faster (no need to even mention the 'several orders of magnitude' factor unless they really want to know).
Of course, but from the time invested, it would seem the other way around. It's often painful to accept that you wasted a lot of time and that it's better to start over (which is of course the entire point of the article), and even more so if the new hire has already done that and thrown the CTO's code away.
Ultimately it's a question of ego. Does the CTO welcome the new hire who knows more about this than he does, or does he insist he knows better? Does he feel threatened or slighted?
Re:Plan to throw one away
by ifdefdebug on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @06:31AM
(#10737176)
This is the "First class people hire first class people, second class people hire third class people" paradigm.
How would you respond if a new hire just told you he decided to do a complete rewrite 2 weeks before demo instead of fixing (what they considered to be) a few knows issues?
I best 9 out of 10 - this would of ended up badly.
I think it would have been fair to reject the idea given the timeline. Obviously some egos will allow it and some won't, but the short amount of time could skew those natural inclinations.