Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by jbronn on Friday January 22, 2010 @12:55PM
(#1070206)
"The underlying source code is not copyrighted and therefore available free of charge to read, modify, and build upon."
This is a serious misconception as open source code is copyrighted -- it's just licensed to end users with terms that may allow modification and creation of derivative works. If you don't abide by terms of the particular open source license, then it's still copyright infringement.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by DenisM on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:22PM
(#1070289)
I was worried about the apparent onslaught of communism until I got to this:
San Francisco’s new policy requires city departments to consider open source software equally with commercial products when purchasing new software.
Seems like a reasonable policy. Although a better policy would be to consider all solutions on their fitness (open or closed) and demand open formats and protocols. Busting data lock-in would significantly improve competition and available choices.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by RyanMcGreal on Friday January 22, 2010 @03:14PM
(#1070560)
>Busting data lock-in would significantly improve competition and available choices.
For various reasons, proprietary software is a lot more likely to employ proprietary data formats than open source software.
Of course, there are exceptions - e.g. the native GIMP format, which I understand to be a real hairball; but apparently the developers are working on a new open standard to replace it in future versions.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by rbanffy on Friday January 22, 2010 @10:14PM
(#1071295)
"Of course, there are exceptions - e.g. the native GIMP format, which I understand to be a real hairball; but apparently the developers are working on a new open standard to replace it in future versions."
Doesn't having the source code of a reference implementation freely available make it non-proprietary?
I believe GIMP folks will be perfectly fine if you use their format for the pictures your paint program saves.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by almost on Saturday January 23, 2010 @05:17AM
(#1071621)
Depends how hairy the code is really. Any format can be reverse engineered, but that doesn't make it open. Is it really open if the code is so hard to read it's not much easier than reverse engineering from a compiled program?
I don't actually know anything about The GIMP's format, just talking in general.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by lmkg on Friday January 22, 2010 @12:46PM
(#1070177)
From the policy (linked from the article): Open source software means that the underlying source code is not copyrighted and therefore available free of charge to read, modify, and build upon. Isn't this factually incorrect? I thought that, say, GPL was technically a type of copyright.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by jcl on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:15PM
(#1070269)
GPL is not a "type of copyright"; it's a license that derives its power from copyright. The same is true of pretty much any license that tries to limit what you can do -- which includes most open source licenses (BSD, MIT, Apache).
There are also open source "licenses" that essentially place the code in the public domain. These are the only ones that fit the article's description.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by LogicHoleFlaw on Friday January 22, 2010 @02:38PM
(#1070477)
Unfortunately the public domain concept is not recognized in all countries. If you wish for your software to be truly available in these nations you will still need to apply some sort of copyright license, no matter how liberal.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by nzmsv on Friday January 22, 2010 @03:24PM
(#1070585)
Even open-source software has a potential problem in some countries. For example, while OSS is often received free of charge, the government can argue that the user still got an item of value. So they have to pay taxes on this "gift".
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by mattwdelong on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:02PM
(#1070226)
You can also charge for open source software.
Also, I believe if you find a free piece of open source software that is useful to you, one that comes free as in free beer, then you should be donating to the developer/s; even if its just enough to buy them a beer. Show the developer a little gratitude.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by shizcakes on Friday January 22, 2010 @02:13PM
(#1070414)
Ultimately, I feel like this is more of a "hey, it's free!" decision than a "we are going to use, and give back to the community" decision. Open Source is not a donation to City Government. They should give back to the community if they are going to have an explicit policy like this.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by pchristensen on Friday January 22, 2010 @02:38PM
(#1070478)
I think it's more of an explicit "just because it's free doesn't mean it sucks" policy. Most organizations need to learn that lesson and it's much quicker to have the head of the org communicate it than to wait for the IT people to convince everyone above them in the chain.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by hristov on Friday January 22, 2010 @07:22PM
(#1071072)
You do not remember that whole thing? Microsoft swooped in with their marketers and lobbyists and got the Mass government to change its mind. The ostensible reason was that open source software was less compatible with certain devices for blind people. So Microsoft won that particular round, and it will be interesting to see what will happen in SF.
However, MS cannot keep throwing millions of dollars at lobbyists and politicians every time a government decides to look at open source. If they keep doing it, some governments will go open source just for a slice of those MS lobbying money. So eventually something will give out.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by barnaby on Friday January 22, 2010 @03:29PM
(#1070601)
That whole thing was bogus, they mixed expenses from the County of San Francisco with the City of San Francisco (because the boundaries are the same). Factor for that, and it's actually well run for a city with a major port, an airport, a great public transit system, and an open source policy.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by defen on Friday January 22, 2010 @08:43PM
(#1071191)
Oakland handles all the container ships, SFO is in unincorporated San Mateo County, and the public transit is objectively bad - terrible compared to New York, Boston, or Chicago (and possible other cities I haven't been to).
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by nazgulnarsil on Friday January 22, 2010 @09:48PM
(#1071264)
is there any reason other than our collective stockholm syndrome not to expect a modern shipping hub and technological powerhouse city to be run at a hefty profit?
This is a serious misconception as open source code is copyrighted -- it's just licensed to end users with terms that may allow modification and creation of derivative works. If you don't abide by terms of the particular open source license, then it's still copyright infringement.
I also don't like how the article speaks about financial benefit. I mean, that's more the smaller part of the benefit you get. Oh well..
San Francisco’s new policy requires city departments to consider open source software equally with commercial products when purchasing new software.
Seems like a reasonable policy. Although a better policy would be to consider all solutions on their fitness (open or closed) and demand open formats and protocols. Busting data lock-in would significantly improve competition and available choices.
For various reasons, proprietary software is a lot more likely to employ proprietary data formats than open source software.
Of course, there are exceptions - e.g. the native GIMP format, which I understand to be a real hairball; but apparently the developers are working on a new open standard to replace it in future versions.
Doesn't having the source code of a reference implementation freely available make it non-proprietary?
I believe GIMP folks will be perfectly fine if you use their format for the pictures your paint program saves.
I don't actually know anything about The GIMP's format, just talking in general.
That's kind of a moot point if you require open formats from the start.
There are also open source "licenses" that essentially place the code in the public domain. These are the only ones that fit the article's description.
Also, I believe if you find a free piece of open source software that is useful to you, one that comes free as in free beer, then you should be donating to the developer/s; even if its just enough to buy them a beer. Show the developer a little gratitude.
But eventually I would expect them to make available apps, services, etc. that they use to run SF, so that other cities can use them and contribute.
http://news.zdnet.com/2100-3513_22-131911.html
However, MS cannot keep throwing millions of dollars at lobbyists and politicians every time a government decides to look at open source. If they keep doing it, some governments will go open source just for a slice of those MS lobbying money. So eventually something will give out.
My memory is coming back now :) I wonder if San Francisco will see anything similar.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=998554
Isn't this a good reason NOT to use open source? ;)
I'd say it's a good reason FOR using open source.