News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in... by DenisM on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:22PM (#1070289)
I was worried about the apparent onslaught of communism until I got to this:

San Francisco’s new policy requires city departments to consider open source software equally with commercial products when purchasing new software.

Seems like a reasonable policy. Although a better policy would be to consider all solutions on their fitness (open or closed) and demand open formats and protocols. Busting data lock-in would significantly improve competition and available choices.

Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in... by RyanMcGreal on Friday January 22, 2010 @03:14PM (#1070560)
>Busting data lock-in would significantly improve competition and available choices.

For various reasons, proprietary software is a lot more likely to employ proprietary data formats than open source software.

Of course, there are exceptions - e.g. the native GIMP format, which I understand to be a real hairball; but apparently the developers are working on a new open standard to replace it in future versions.

Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in... by rbanffy on Friday January 22, 2010 @10:14PM (#1071295)
"Of course, there are exceptions - e.g. the native GIMP format, which I understand to be a real hairball; but apparently the developers are working on a new open standard to replace it in future versions."

Doesn't having the source code of a reference implementation freely available make it non-proprietary?

I believe GIMP folks will be perfectly fine if you use their format for the pictures your paint program saves.

Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in... by almost on Saturday January 23, 2010 @05:17AM (#1071621)
Depends how hairy the code is really. Any format can be reverse engineered, but that doesn't make it open. Is it really open if the code is so hard to read it's not much easier than reverse engineering from a compiled program?

I don't actually know anything about The GIMP's format, just talking in general.

Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in... by rbanffy on Saturday January 23, 2010 @05:55AM (#1071654)
I have seen ISO standards (even pre-OOXML ones) that were more obscure than any code I ever saw.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in... by tvon on Friday January 22, 2010 @06:36PM (#1070992)
> For various reasons, proprietary software is a lot more likely to employ proprietary data formats than open source software.

That's kind of a moot point if you require open formats from the start.