Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by lmkg on Friday January 22, 2010 @12:46PM
(#1070177)
From the policy (linked from the article): Open source software means that the underlying source code is not copyrighted and therefore available free of charge to read, modify, and build upon. Isn't this factually incorrect? I thought that, say, GPL was technically a type of copyright.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by jcl on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:15PM
(#1070269)
GPL is not a "type of copyright"; it's a license that derives its power from copyright. The same is true of pretty much any license that tries to limit what you can do -- which includes most open source licenses (BSD, MIT, Apache).
There are also open source "licenses" that essentially place the code in the public domain. These are the only ones that fit the article's description.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by LogicHoleFlaw on Friday January 22, 2010 @02:38PM
(#1070477)
Unfortunately the public domain concept is not recognized in all countries. If you wish for your software to be truly available in these nations you will still need to apply some sort of copyright license, no matter how liberal.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by nzmsv on Friday January 22, 2010 @03:24PM
(#1070585)
Even open-source software has a potential problem in some countries. For example, while OSS is often received free of charge, the government can argue that the user still got an item of value. So they have to pay taxes on this "gift".
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by jpwatts on Friday January 22, 2010 @12:54PM
(#1070200)
That's most definitely incorrect. And it's not just a technicality; copyright law is the legal foundation of free/open source software.
Re:SF Mayor on why open source is the new software policy in...
by mattwdelong on Friday January 22, 2010 @01:02PM
(#1070226)
You can also charge for open source software.
Also, I believe if you find a free piece of open source software that is useful to you, one that comes free as in free beer, then you should be donating to the developer/s; even if its just enough to buy them a beer. Show the developer a little gratitude.