"'I have discovered something else,' I continued. 'By flipping the pages at random, and putting my finger in and reading the sentences on that page, I can show you what’s the matter – how it’s not science, but memorizing, in every circumstance. Therefore I am brave enough to flip through the pages now, in front of this audience, to put my finger in, to read, and to show you.'"
I am myself mixed about the benefits of learning to code. I am currently leaning towards it being equal to the other activities you list, but not greater than.
These days, it's a whole new game. We can give our kids a more holistic education around coding because we have things like Arduino, Raspberry Pi, Lego Mindstorms, etc. We can teach code as one among many tools to get a job done or otherwise affect the world, rather than teaching coding as an abstract end in itself.
As an example, my daughter wants to build a garden with me in the near future. Part of that project might include some Arduino-based sensors. If she's interested, I can teach her all about it. But either way, there's a lot to learn.
All of this is to say I agree with you, that code is perhaps an equal, but not superior, among many other ways to help teach a kid how to think.
At 40, I'm well on my way to becoming a gray beard, just the same this shouldn't be required. Maybe somewhere around 10-12yo, an rPI or similar would make sense to tinker with in school... but that should only be to introduce kids to these things.
Kids are naturally creative and curious... let them know something is possible, and let them choose to explore. I wish there were more schools that offered elective coursework earlier on the junior high school... it would let kids explore more in a semi-structured way.
We do teach coding principles by pattern recognition (big for literacy) and to problem solve. Heck we even do engineering with a problem, come up with a plan and then a creation. The kids always blow me away with what they come up with.
You can teach the great parts of coding outside with your kids (I do) and then see where their interest lie. My daughter who is 9 wants a Robot she can program and we will go the Arduino route. My two older kids never touched a computer growing up and no real desire except to play a game or watch Netflix (They didn't become a part of our family till they were 11 and 15). My 4 year old LOVE playing programming board games (the Turtle Game? and Robo Rally) Teaching kids how to think is a lost art and we have many things we can use to help us. Learning to CODE is code to me to help children learn to think and to learn it early which is good to me. CODE for CODE sake is dumb.
But isn't that how every skill begins? With doing very simple things, by the book?
Like in your examples:
building things - cutting out preprinted paper models and gluing the pieces
playing music - playing scales over and over again
reading & writing - reading and writing simple sentences over and over
I don't know any skill where you just "jump" to creativity. It all takes time and effort, during which you actually learn the patterns.
I think coding is worth learning for a simple reason - computers are pervasive and universal tools, therefore to know how to talk to them is a part of universal literacy, just like reading, writing and arithmetic.
Kids should definately learn how to think algorithmically and understand mathematics/physics concepts (as opposed to repeating some pattern recognition which is to often the case) and if some type of coding facilitates engraining this knowledge I think that'd be great, but as of yet I haven't read a study that showed this to be the case.
As a programmer, when I have kids I'm not going to teach them how to code. I'd much rather they spent time playing outside, building things with their hands, acting in plays, playing music, reading books, writing papers, doing science experiments etc. Computers are nice tools to help you do these things but they are not ends in themselves.
this all IMHO of course :)