News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by JustSomeNobody on Friday December 04, 2015 @07:56AM (#10676031)
>> ... Invest in public transportation.

>> ... The US is a country where it's very difficult to live without a car, except in certain major cities.

In order to do this, we need to rethink how we design cities. Right now, unless, as you point out, you live in a major city, it just isn't well laid out for public transportation. No amount of retrofitting is going to help. City planners need to take public transportation into account when they issue new building permits, etc. They need to encourage business to build closer so people can use public transport. Here in the south, thought needs to be put into thunderstorms. We can have afternoon thunderstorms with 50MPH winds and deadly lightning pop up very quickly. You can't have people out waiting on public transport in that mess.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by wpietri on Friday December 04, 2015 @09:04AM (#10676331)
> You can't have people out waiting on public transport in that mess.

For the old sort of public transit, I think that's true. But our current notion of public transit is based on fixed schedules, fixed routes, and the high cost of human driver labor.

But think what a new public transit would mean. If everybody has a smartphone and vehicles are automated, then public transit could mean vans and small buses that dynamically route to come near you.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by akgerber on Friday December 04, 2015 @10:49AM (#10676943)
Such a system would still be much more inefficient than fixed-route transit because of the winding routes required and insufficient concentration of demand.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by wpietri on Friday December 04, 2015 @11:29PM (#10680867)
I would like to see the math on that. It's inefficient in terms of bus-miles driven, but assuming that we value people's time, it's not clear to me it would be inefficient in dollar terms.

Yes, insufficient concentration is a problem, which means that living in the suburbs would still be more expensive in transport costs. I still expect (or perhaps hope) that we'd see a contraction back to more dense urban cores. But automated transportation could provide a bridge between the suburban model and whatever comes after.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by jlebrech on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:19AM (#10676123)
the solution even though people won't like it is to put a tax on fuel and reinvest that into public transport, or give people 'miles' they can use with public transport so they don't feel robbed.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by noxToken on Friday December 04, 2015 @09:43AM (#10676549)
> the solution even though people won't like it is to put a tax on fuel

There already is an excise tax on fuel in a lot of places. I can't say what that revenue is specifically allocated towards, but the tax exists nonetheless.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by Zach_the_Lizard on Friday December 04, 2015 @01:39PM (#10678151)
In the US gas taxes are very low and don't even cover the costs of our highways. Local roads are paid for mostly with local taxes. It's hard to quantify exactly the subsidy per passenger mile while driving, whereas it's very easy to do the same for transit.

The system we have makes drivers feel as though they are paying their fair share while transit riders are not. They don't see the share of their local taxes going to roads.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by stanleydrew on Friday December 04, 2015 @10:16AM (#10676717)
The easiest thing that I can imagine working is elimination of most free parking.

That's effectively been a huge subsidy to drivers.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by panzagl on Friday December 04, 2015 @11:24AM (#10677194)
Where is there free parking? Either you have metered public spaces in a downtown area, or sections of private property set aside for parking use by the customers/employees of the owner of the property. Not really a subsidy in the way most people think.

Or you're playing Monopoly wrong and wondering why it takes 3 hours to finish...

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by teek on Friday December 04, 2015 @12:36PM (#10677687)
Free parking is kind of mislabeled. The correct term is minimum parking requirements. Most build standards now enforce having a minimum amount of parking for any new building or housing development, including for low income housing.

In order to have mass transit work, we need to be able to build housing and businesses that have very little to no parking allocated. Minimum parking (along with level of service for roads) makes every business and house foot print larger, decreases density, and decreases pedestrian accessibility.

It wouldn't even be that hard to naturally enforce/encourage this. All we would have to do is eliminate minimum parking requirements for developments within a quarter mile radius of a mass transit station.

One would argue that would do essentially nothing. For example a wealthy condo owner would naturally want a parking space and thus pressure the developer to build a space. But I argue there is demand and will be more demand for this parking-less space today in very crowded cities (think SF) or in the future when younger generations or immigrants decide to live in high density areas.

I actually think we have things backwards with minimum parking compared to other cities like Tokyo. Minimum parking acts as a hidden subsidy that increases the price of the property. In Tokyo, houses can be sold without parking. But in order to own a car in Tokyo, you have to prove you also own a parking space. So many housing communities will have parking lots or shared parking garages where nearby residents can rent a space. (There also exist houses that are sold with attached parking as well, but it isn't a requirement.) This is essentially a free market solution to the problem where as the American minimum parking solution is a government regulated solution.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by fixermark on Friday December 04, 2015 @11:44AM (#10677331)
Pittsburgh uses free parking as an incentive to draw people into commercial areas. Ironically, those commercial areas are well-served by the mass transit system generally, but Pittsburgh's suburbanization pattern doesn't align with how the mass-transit system is laid out (and, yes, plenty of suburanites appear anecdotally to think of the bus system as for "Those people").
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by tricolon on Friday December 04, 2015 @02:22PM (#10678444)
> Where is there free parking?

In New York, there's free street parking practically everywhere except Midtown and FiDi: https://smoothparking.com/

If all street parking were metered or for commercial use only, I think it would improve the city a lot.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by Zach_the_Lizard on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:26AM (#10676155)
>City planners need to take public transportation into account when they issue new building permits, etc. They need to encourage business to build closer so people can use public transport.

The problem we have today is too much planning, from the smallest rural town to the biggest metropolis. Planning has gone from the simple but noble goals of ensuring public safety and efficient flow of goods and services to dictating lifestyle and trying to preserve things exactly as they are.

The typical suburb or sprawling city, for instance, doesn't merely not take into account public transit in zoning and approval processes, it actively allows only sprawling designs. Minimum setbacks, floor area ratio limits, side, front, and back yard requirements, minimum parking requirements, and height limits all act to make it so nothing but sprawl is even legally possible.

I can point to numerous examples of these sorts of regulation from all over the United States in cities big and small, from New York to Nome. Yes, this includes places like Houston where it is claimed that there is no zoning but land use control is still Stalnist.

This is all based on a 1950s utopian vision where all people everywhere would have cars, cars would just be extensions of people, and we'd all be able to live in a comfortable middle class suburb the next state over because modern planning would ensure no traffic could ever happen.

It would also ensure those pesky apartments full of those 'others' would have limited density, so they'd be packed away in some ungodly corner of the world where everyone else wouldn't have to see them.

This power is still used today as a de facto tool of modern segregationists who are concerned not merely with race, but also class and even taste and lifestyle.

Reducing the power of these local regulators so that urban planning once again becomes a boring profession concerned with public safety and the movement of people, goods, and services and not a way to enforce a very specific 1950s utopian lifestyle would go a huge way to fixing sprawl in America.

>You can't have people out waiting on public transport in that mess.

Until about the 1950s, people in the South did wait on public transportation. Look up the timetables and maps of the old railroads, interurbans, and streetcars. You'd be amazed how far reaching public transportation in the US was. Many of the cities of consequence in the South sprung up around the railroads.

Atlanta, for instance, used to be known as 'Terminus' as it was the end of the line for a railroad with nothing else nearby. The city was built around it, grew rapidly, and eventually the state capital was moved there. Streetcars further fueled growth. This is a story repeated all throughout the South and the rest of the US.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by nitrogen on Friday December 04, 2015 @11:29AM (#10677240)
Minimum setbacks, yard size requirements, etc. -- these are all things that people want and continue to pay for. This is Hacker News; instead of getting self-righteous with city dweller indignation, figure out how to make what people want.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by Zach_the_Lizard on Friday December 04, 2015 @03:48PM (#10679031)
>Minimum setbacks, yard size requirements, etc. -- these are all things that people want and continue to pay for

If these are what people want, this regulation wouldn't be required, now would it? Anyone who built anything else would go bankrupt.

Unfortunately for the theory that this is what people want, cities are still full of people and have the most expensive real estate. Walkable areas generally command a premium over car only areas. Locations near transit tend to be more expensive than those not near transit.

Funny how in places where we stop mandating sprawl, the sprawl goes away. Compare Arlington, VA in the 1970s vs. 2010s; it had all of these regulations near the Metro lines before it was built (and kept them not near Metro) but relaxed them after the Metro was built. It's night and day. I can point to dozens of places where once these rules go away, the sprawl goes away.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by nitrogen on Friday December 04, 2015 @10:11PM (#10680630)
Look at it from the other side. Space is a thing that has to be protected. If you don't protect open space, builders race to profits and residents just have to put up with the resulting density. If unprotected, space is consumed kind of like the tragedy of the commons or prisoners' dilemma.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by JustSomeNobody on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:39AM (#10676212)
Ok, then we need the right kind of planning, not more.

>> >You can't have people out waiting on public transport in that mess.

>>Until about the 1950s, people in the South did wait on public transportation. Look up the timetables and maps of the old railroads, interurbans, and streetcars. You'd be amazed how far reaching public transportation in the US was. Many of the cities of consequence in the South sprung up around the railroads.

Fair enough, but surely we can do better 60 years later.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by Zach_the_Lizard on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:54AM (#10676283)
> Ok, then we need the right kind of planning, not more.

It's not just the right kind; there is no right kind of parking minimum. We are good at things like ensuring we don't build toxic waste dumps next to schools or that maybe coal firing power plants should be away from people. These are the kinds of things we should keep doing.

What we need to do is to stop dictating lifestyle. I might want to drive everywhere, but that shouldn't mean that I use the law to force everyone to provide free parking for me (as is the case in much of America). I might want a large yard, but I shouldn't be able to use the law to force everyone else to have a large yard because that's just what I like.

There are rational restrictions you can come up with, such as regarding shadows, but there are rational laws you can come up with in response to those beyond 'ban all things over X height'.

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by astazangasta on Friday December 04, 2015 @02:28PM (#10678488)
>We are good at things like ensuring we don't build toxic waste dumps next to schools

FYI: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Love_Canal

Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by Retric on Friday December 04, 2015 @09:51AM (#10676585)
A small shelter at each buss stop is fairly cheap to build. However, with a bus tracking app you don't need to spend much time waiting outside at most stops. Just where you transfer from bus A to bus B which makes this even cheaper.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by kwhitefoot on Friday December 04, 2015 @04:35PM (#10679326)
Where I live you might be waiting for a bus at -30C in heavy snow, it doesn't stop people using buses. Where more than one or two people habitually wait the authorities normally build a shelter that at least keeps most of the rain, snow, and wind at bay.
Re:Car turns driver in for hit-and-run by panglott on Friday December 04, 2015 @08:41AM (#10676220)
We got where we are now with nearly a century of poorly-considered planning and infrastructure spending. It will take another century of better design to get us out of this hole.