News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by mortenjorck on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:19AM (#1065030)
It's funny how some predictions that sound outlandish have come fairly close to the mark in less sexy ways. Kurzweil's defense of "computers commonly embedded in clothing and jewelry" as applying to iPod Nanos embedded in pockets is a bit of a stretch, but in practicality not far at all.

Though I think anyone with a sense for usability could have told you in 1999 that speech recognition, despite its eventual technological maturity, wouldn't be anywhere near the primary mode of text entry a decade later. Ultimately, I'd chalk that up to Kurzweil understanding technology somewhat better than he understands humans.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by Femur on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:28AM (#1065056)
I'd say for the most part nearly all of the technology Kurzweil predicts ends up being available, it is just the implementation of this technology that muddles the prediction.

In Kurzweil's talks he often expounds on the high predictability of technological progress (price and power of computing, etc). He does not so much cover how humans will use this tech.

Im sure that iPod Nano's (or equivalent) could easily have been embedded or sewn into clothing or hats for years now. Speech-to-text is available now and I use it in Google Voice all the time. It's a matter of choice in this case, not the technology.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by roc on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @12:04PM (#1065152)
There have been plenty of concept bluetooth rings and watches as well. Technologically they're quite doable and even offer some neat features. None have yet resonated with society enough to be common, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if these caught on in a more significant way much closer to 2009 than 2019; particularly as peripherals integrating wirelessly with a primary personal computer (phone).
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by Retric on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:06PM (#1065469)
The problem with wearable computing has always been how much it costs. People don't want to wear the same thing every day and washing machines and dryers are extremely harsh on electronics. Stepping outside the classics like wrist, ear, and eye is going to require a dramatic advantage. Cell phone watches are possible but holding your risk up to your ear is uncomfortable.

PS: IMO eyewear is the final external location for electronics, but it's going to need to be extreamly light, inexpensive and useful to make it there. Some sort of adaptive bifocal technology that watches your eyes and auto focuses might be the first winner.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by mpk on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @07:22PM (#1066221)
A mix of jewelry and electronics going mainstream is pretty unlikely.

Jewelry tends to be expensive and retain value over very long periods of time. Electronics tend to be pricey at first (but cheap relative to jewelry) but become obsolete and thrown in the trash very quickly.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by teej on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:32AM (#1066702)
I don't think that's right. Sure, there is jewelry that retains value, but that jewelry is composed of three things - gold, silver, and diamonds. It's the material that's retaining value, not the item.

We are already seeing a huge wave in the crossover between electronics and fashion accessories. The Motorola RAZR heralded the beginning of this wave - a phone that was "cool" to have. Apple is riding this wave with it's line of designer laptops, phones, and music devices.

Accessories, which includes cheap jewelry, follow the same value path as electronics: expensive and quickly depreciating. I don't know if I would have predicted it 10 years ago, but it's certainly happening now.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by roc on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:43PM (#1065569)
Wearables are destined as peripherals, precisely because it only makes sense to choose a wearable over the computer itself when the ergonomics and use cases are superior.

So a cell phone watch is a trivial non-starter. But a bluetooth watch, subservient to the phone, delivering accurate time, calendar information and message notification without having to reach into your pocket and enter your lock code, is a different thing.

Similarly, a necklace recording device would be ideal for hands-free audio/video recording to your primary device. Who wouldn't want a trip video they didn't even have to remember to record? Not to mention a necklace/earring combo that acted as a bluetooth headset.

Eyewear definitely has a lot of promise, but I'm not entirely sold on it needing to be inexpensive. People pay a lot for stylish eyewear. So I don't doubt people will pay quite a bit for eyewear with features. However, it also suggests that eyewear electronics are dead in the water until they're stylish.

The watch and jewelry really isn't that far out there. Particularly during years when chunky jewelry is in style.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by dagw on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @06:49PM (#1066141)
The technology is already here. The bluetooth watch you talk about is in the stores. As you and others have mentioned, it's not a tech problem, but style problem. We have to stop throwing engineers at the problem and start throwing fashion designers.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by dhume on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:32AM (#1065069)
Kurzweil's defense of "computers commonly embedded in clothing and jewelry" as applying to iPod Nanos embedded in pockets is a bit of a stretch, but in practicality not far at all. I'll accept this when the iPod is embedded with some degree of permanency and doesn't have to be taken out when I do laundry.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by ZachPruckowski on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @12:32PM (#1065229)
Do you honestly believe that it's not possible to waterproof/heatproof an iPod? The technology exists to do that, but it's not commercially practical, because no-one buys an iPod for every shirt they own.

I bet if I really wanted to, I could pull a shuffle out of it's case, use more expensive and denser flash memory, and shove all this in a tiny waterproof/heatproof baggie or small and thin container, swap the USB connector for mini-USB, insulate the wires, build caps for the external wiring ends, and sew the whole thing to the inside of my shirt behind my shoulderblade. It'd have exposed ports to connect mini-USB to my computer and earbuds to my ears, and if I wanted to wash it, I'd stick the port-caps in and seal it somehow. It'd take a fair few prototypes, but it could be done with today's tech.

Edit: I don't think this is commercial viable, but if one of you guys builds it and gets rich, I expect royalties :-)

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by scott_s on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @01:52PM (#1065432)
The technology exists to do that, but it's not commercially practical, because no-one buys an iPod for every shirt they own.

Clearly the implication of such a prediction is that the technology will be at a point where it is commercially practical.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by ZachPruckowski on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:57PM (#1065761)
So a prediction that we would have tiny computers that we carried everywhere in our clothes and bodies is wrong because instead of carrying them in our clothes, we carry them in our pockets? Kurzweil's predictions relate to the level of computational power for a given cost and what we can do with that power. Just because my turn-by-turn directions come from my phone instead of a wrist-strap doesn't make those predictions less wrong.

In the absence of iPods or cell phones, it's likely that sewn-in or wearable computers would be more attractive.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by scott_s on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @04:20PM (#1065812)
Kurzweil's predictions relate to the level of computational power for a given cost and what we can do with that power.

Indeed they do. And there's an order of magnitude separating the computational power and cost of iPods from what we can currently incorporate into reasonably priced clothing. A friend of mine does research in the area of wearable computing. We're not at the iPod-in-shirt level yet.

Further, if we don't hold predictions to what they actually said, then there's no point. We can always manufacture an interpretation in which the prediction is true.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by MaysonL on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:22PM (#1065676)
You hardly have to do all the heat/waterproofing and miniaturization: build it into a belt buckle. I wonder if anyone's done this yet? Google gives 10 pages of results: there are a lot of those out there. Kurzweil was right!
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by dhume on Monday January 25, 2010 @12:03PM (#1075490)
I don't consider that as satisfying the prediction of computers embedded in clothing any more than I consider predictions of flying cars fulfilled by ultralight aircraft.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by TrevorJ on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:52AM (#1065119)
I would agree here. The effect is ubiquitous computing in both cases, but rather than "a computer in everything" we have "Computers you can take everywhere".
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by SandB0x on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @12:49PM (#1065265)
I have an old Sony network walkman (nwz-e99) that went through a 40 degree wash and works just fine.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by axiom on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @12:49PM (#1065264)
It would be a lot more impressive if he made those predictions before PDAs were already commonplace, and WiFi was well established.

So basically his prediction was "there's gonna be the same stuff we have now, but it's gonna be all over the place!"

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by jerf on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:19PM (#1066430)
Many of his predictions boil down to "You know that weird fringe technology that's too expensive, bulky, and power consuming? In ten years, it'll be common place and cheap." After the fact they look like nothing.

But... despite over fifty years of this progression occurring in the electronics arena, the idea that what we have now is all we will ever have remains pervasive. Very few people have internalized the concept. And so he makes predictions, and they are not met with widespread apathy and people claiming they are trivial and obvious, they are met with disbelief and mockery from many people. So you can't say they are vacuously true from the vantage point of 2009. You need to have said it in 1998 when it was published, whereupon I assure you, you too would have been met with mockery and derision.

One example of where people are not thinking this way is in our discussions about the environment. The closest thing to innovation any mainstream debate discusses has to do with taking technologies that mostly work now but don't scale, and making them fail to scale marginally less, while assuming the same baseload of resource consumption will be in place. Yet technology marches ever onward, and one way it manifests is increased efficiency. A command of nanotechnology, even if it never quite reaches the dizzying heights described in the farthest-out singulatarian literature, will still have massive consequences for the efficiency of manufacturing, manufacturing of food resources, and numerous other issues as well. I find the idea of the Kyoto protocols utterly laughable, because built into the very concept is the idea that we can have meaningful discussions of what our resource consumption will look like in 50 years, an idea so absurd that it is remarkable that it passes without comment. What's the point of negotiating a binding treaty on a world that may literally be growing houses, just to take one incredibly small example?

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by axiom on Thursday January 21, 2010 @12:30AM (#1066696)
Except that the predictions that actually came true are the obvious ones (e.g. smaller faster computers everywhere predicted in 1999) while the ones that didn't come true (e.g. "Translating telephones allow people to speak to each other in different languages" ) were the ones that were derided - rightly so.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by jerf on Thursday January 21, 2010 @10:38AM (#1067467)
I accept Kurzweil's defense. He's off by two years, tops, for common use, and in terms of simple existence, he's not wrong at all. The software already exists: http://www.jibbigo.com/website/index.php . That's real. You can buy it. The only thing stopping me from linking straight into the app store is the app store won't let me. Even if you want to get anal about the year (which is not really appropriate), that was out in 2009. And I'm pretty sure that's not the only one, either.

Compared to the general rate of prediction failure he is in a league of his own.

And again, you just claimed his predictions were trivial as if I didn't mention that issue at all. I feel you may not have read my message, as you don't seem to have actually reacted to it. It's not about the triviality apparent in 2009. It's about whether the general public he was speaking to would have considered it a trivial prediction in 1998-ish. That's easy: No. I remember that time. Many technologically-aware people like me wouldn't have blinked at most of the predictions but they were not in the public's mind.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by ugh on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:08PM (#1065474)
WLAN well established? Really? Sure, some bigger institutions used it. But today you can be dropped pretty much anywhere in any city and have ten or more WLAN access points show up on your iPod touch. That you just pulled out of your pocket.

Everything seems obvious in hindsights.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by toby on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:21PM (#1065668)
To be fair, he says he made these predictions in 1996. The PalmPilot personal, which I would say was the first widely-used PDA didn't come out until 1997.

From what I remember, there weren't really any commercially available 802.11 devices until 1999.

So while these things were on the horizon, I wouldn't say they were commonplace just yet.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by varjag on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:29PM (#1065695)
There was already Apple Newton though, so the idea was clearly in the air.
Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by rictic on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @01:58PM (#1065446)
I think a parallel could be drawn to that Sci-fi and futurist favorite: the cyborg. Can we embed electronics into people today? Yeah, actually. But we only do it in extreme cases (cochlear implant, pacemaker, etc).

It's so much easier to just wear a pair of bluetooth headphones. It's far cheaper and lower risk, and it fits the rapid upgrade cycle of tech much better.

Re:Ray Kurzweil Responds to the Issue of Accuracy of His Pre... by Carlfish on Monday January 25, 2010 @12:40AM (#1074517)
"Kurzweil's defense of "computers commonly embedded in clothing and jewelry" as applying to iPod Nanos embedded in pockets is a bit of a stretch, but in practicality not far at all."

It's very far indeed. You're taking a specific prediction about how we are going to use technology and turning it into a prediction that technology will get smaller and more portable.

It's a technique shared by fabulists, fortune tellers and cold readers:

"I see a brown dog called eric..." "Well, we had a dog but he was a German Shepherd..." "Yes, that's it, I knew I saw a dog!"