News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by amake on Thursday November 26, 2015 @06:59AM (#10632572)
What the Chinese think about pinyin is not relevant, nor is Chinese-language orthography. We are clearly communicating in English, and in English the correct orthography for the city in question is "Xi'an". This is important because "Xian" is an entirely unrelated, distinct syllable.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by kps on Thursday November 26, 2015 @11:09AM (#10633509)

  > in English the correct orthography for the city in question is "Xi'an"
Why? In English orthography, initial ‘x’ is /z/ an an apostrophe marks omission in a contraction. Neither seems to be the case here.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by amake on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:33PM (#10635324)
Because in Chinese morphology "xi'an" is two distinct syllables, while "xian" is a single syllable. In Hanyu Pinyin (the modern Chinese transliteration standard) this distinction is made with an apostrophe. What English "usually" does with the apostrophe is irrelevant.

"Xi'an" and "xian" must be able to be distinguished in English because they refer to separate things. If you have a problem with using an apostrophe for this, take it up with the standards body that decided on Hanyu Pinyin.

Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by thaumasiotes on Friday November 27, 2015 @03:07AM (#10636372)
> "Xi'an" and "xian" must be able to be distinguished in English because they refer to separate things.

What ridiculous nonsense. You mean like how Michael Jackson and Michael Jackson must be able to be distinguished in English because they refer to separate things? Oh, whoops.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_Walk_of_Fame#Names_i...

Maybe you mean how Springfield and Springfield must be able to be distinguished in English because they refer to separate things.

Maybe you mean that English must distinguish between strings of one syllable and strings of two. Unfortunately for you, that's still nonsense. Consider this variation on a classic example sentence: "I spent the evening evening out a ripple in the rug."

Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by kps on Friday November 27, 2015 @10:31AM (#10637657)
Well, OK; my question was based on your “pinyin is not relevant”; if it's pinyin or pseudo-pinyin then it has its own rules, just like any other non-English language that uses roman letters, and English orthography is irrelevant. Then writing ‘Xi'an’ is just an affectation like writing ‘Roma’ and ‘Wien’ in place of ‘Rome’ and ‘Vienna’.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by amake on Sunday November 29, 2015 @08:32PM (#10647093)
I said "What the Chinese think about pinyin is not relevant" in response to thaumasiotes's comment that "The chinese don't worry too much about pinyin." Clearly thaumasiotes is talking about your average Chinese-speaking man-on-the-street, and I think it's pretty clear that I meant that such a person's opinion is not relevant. Of course the Hanyu Pinyin standard is relevant.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by thaumasiotes on Monday November 30, 2015 @02:08AM (#10648197)
Why is the Hanyu Pinyin standard relevant? It is not the source of official English orthography for Chinese names (and hey, if it was, xi'an would be just as wrong as xian!). I'll ask you for the third time what you think of 陕西.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by lmm on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:12AM (#10632601)
Language is a tool for communication. In English "Xian" unambiguously refers to the city in question (e.g. searching for it will take you to the correct page), unless you're saying there's some other "Xian" it would be confused with?

(English orthography has always been ambiguous; accents are conventionally optional in English even when their absence is misleading regarding pronunciation, e.g. "cafe")

Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by Symbiote on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:48AM (#10632720)
There's a Xian County [1].

I don't think anyone would accept "Newyork", even though a Google search goes to the correct place ­— hardly a good measure of ambiguity. The pronunciation is different, so it could be confused with "Newark" with some accents.

English has enough ambiguity without introducing more, especially from carelessness or laziness.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xian_County

Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by lmm on Thursday November 26, 2015 @08:01AM (#10632759)
Spaces are much less optional than accents. Very few object to "Montreal" or "San Jose" (indeed those have become the accepted English spellings at this point).
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by germanier on Thursday November 26, 2015 @08:20AM (#10632834)
To add a counterpoint: The German cities Münster and Munster are distinct. Just leaving the diacritics away confuses everybody (the correct way of spelling the former when there is no "ü" available is Muenster).
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday November 26, 2015 @10:58AM (#10633458)
An apostrophe is not an "accent".
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by lmm on Thursday November 26, 2015 @11:11AM (#10633520)
The "'" in "Xi'an" is not an English apostrophe (it doesn't indicate an omitted letter or a possessive); it's an accent-like diacritic.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by thaumasiotes on Friday November 27, 2015 @02:58AM (#10636351)
Technically it's not a diacritic, either; it doesn't attach to any letter. It's a syllable boundary, like the hyphens in Wade-Giles transcription ("Hsi-an" or "Tse-tung").
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by amake on Thursday November 26, 2015 @09:08AM (#10633009)
> In English "Xian" unambiguously refers to the city in question

That's just the thing: It does not.

Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by brent_maxwell on Thursday November 26, 2015 @10:44AM (#10633398)
It was pretty unambiguous to me.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by amake on Thursday November 26, 2015 @07:34PM (#10635328)
That is because you happen to be ignorant of all but the most notable thing that could be either "xi'an" or "xian". Others are not limited by the extent of your knowledge.
Re:Ways to Design the Letter 'M' by thaumasiotes on Friday November 27, 2015 @03:01AM (#10636359)
Virtually 100% of English speakers are (in fact, I'd go so far as to say nearly 100% of english speakers are ignorant of all the notable things that might be xian or xi'an). Of the remainder, none will be confused (your worry is ambiguity, right?) by the sort of reference we see here.

I asked your opinion of 陕西 for a reason.