News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by Alex3917 on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:00PM (#1062697)
My perception is that submission quality is roughly the same, but average comment quality has been dropping. Maybe the solution is to make comments work more like submissions, e.g. new top-level comments start out dead and need two upvotes before they go live. This is essentially how all new stories start out, and it seems to be working reasonably well.

Also, part of the issue with scaling is that there are some types of comments that are fine to post when the userbase is small, but that aren't ok to post as the userbase grows-- even if they add value in some way. So the problem isn't just coming from new users posting bad comments, it's coming from old users posting the same comments. So maybe some sort of radical experiment to try to refocus the discussions wouldn't be such a bad idea, at least to see how it goes.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by iamelgringo on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:26PM (#1062762)
I've noticed that my comments have been typically getting less points than they used to. What I've noticed is that when I don't get as much positive reinforcement (points) as I used to, I'm less inclined to take 30 minutes and writing and editing a thoughtful comment. It's a downward cycle.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by akkartik on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:52PM (#1062974)
Same here. The problem is not more upvotes, but upvotes spread out over a larger set of comments.

Perhaps we need a study of comments in the different percentiles now vs a year ago vs 2 years ago. Filter out comments that don't tell you something new. How does the remainder look?

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by robryan on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:49PM (#1063121)
This may be because there are more comments on each submission so your comment may be glanced over instead of being read properly like it would be if there were only a few comments on something.

The comment system is usually very good but for things like the Google/China post it is very hard to come back a few hours later and see what's new because of how things are ordered, I'm sure there would have been a lot of valid points in that thread which didn't get upvotes.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by Perceval on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:12PM (#1063192)
One of the great features of Scoop code (which runs kuro5hin and DailyKos among others) is that it can show you what comments are new since the last time you viewed a store, marking them with a red-colored '[new].' Makes coming back to an active thread much easier.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by robryan on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @07:22PM (#1063681)
I'd say that would be one feature useful here, I don't think it would over complicate the simplicity of things. Maybe it could be factored into the display order so things that are new since you last looked at a submission move to the top.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by JacobAldridge on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:22PM (#1063427)
Maybe the solution is to make comments work more like submissions, e.g. new top-level comments start out dead and need two upvotes before they go live.

Is that also related to the way comments are now weighted against time, as well as value? Every new comment is momentarily - or longer - placed at the top of the comments page, so something trite will live above a 32 point well-reasoned post for a period of time, depending on how old the 32 pointer happens to be.

When the new comments went straight to the pile of 1 point comments at the bottom, there was less incentive to contribute late in a discussion as your input could be overlooked; in fixing that problem, there's now an increased noise-to-signal ratio as low-value comments filter their way down, rather than build their way up.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:14PM (#1062733)
So the problem [is] old users posting the same comments.

Interesting hypothesis.

experiment to try to refocus the discussions

Expound?

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by tialys on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:26PM (#1062584)
The karma inflation says a lot I think. There seems to be a rash of new users posting less relevant 'link-bait' stories that get voted up for being edgy/funny, but have little interest to hackers. I've noticed that i've been far less interested in the front page of HN lately due to most of the links on the front page being non hacker news or links I already saw on Reddit(!). This is purely anecdotal however.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by grandalf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:53PM (#1062681)
I think the problem is that most HN readers don't bother flagging the link bait stories... many even vote them up.

I would be OK with a "no linkbait headlines" policy where any article that had a sensational headline such as "Why I will never use another Apple product again" or "Shocking lessons from my Google interview" should just be considered inappropriate for HN.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by electromagnetic on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:39PM (#1063098)
I'd second this, I personally don't hesitate flagging something I think is inappropriate. I've been around HN for a fair while, and lurked a lot in the beginning too, so I will often flag an article that may have been appropriate sans sensationalism.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by ubernostrum on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:46PM (#1062668)
There seems to be a rash of new users posting less relevant 'link-bait' stories that get voted up

When I first encountered HN, not long after its launch, it appeared to function largely as a syndicator of TechCrunch articles. So I find your characterization of a "rash" of new "link-bait" rather amusing...

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jaf656s on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:25PM (#1062759)
Did you wait a while before creating an account?

If you did, then you can ignore the rest of my comment.

If not, you could have joined during one of HN's "popularity peaks" when it was mentioned on another popular website, creating a wave of new users. Those peaks always seem to correspond with a rush of Techcrunch (and similar) articles.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by ubernostrum on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:49PM (#1062962)
HN was about a year and four months old when I created an account (finally figured it was worth posting a comment), but I'd been skimming headlines occasionally almost since it launched.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by seldo on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:44PM (#1062663)
I for one have got a lot more strict about flagging things that are interesting but off-topic.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by iamelgringo on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:59PM (#1062695)
I've tried to do that quite a bit, but since PG changed the rules for flagging last year, it hasn't been nearly as effective.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by grinich on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:05PM (#1062870)
How were the rules changed?
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by mbrubeck on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:40PM (#1062948)
Articles with a certain number of points (10 by default in news.arc) can no longer be removed automatically by flagging. There may have been other changes too; I don't know.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by btipling on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:29PM (#1062601)
The community will do as it will. If you want to keep something on topic you need moderators, like subreddit.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by pg on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:36PM (#1062626)
Here are the actual traffic stats as of today: http://ycombinator.com/images/hntraffic-19jan10.png
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:09PM (#1062722)
Paul, have you considered re-implementing the orange-names experiment as a gradient of gray-to-orange, to avoid a tribal sense of "grays versus oranges"? Or is that not-obviously-scalable?
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by smokinn on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:53PM (#1062833)
Any idea what caused that huge spike in late August/early September?
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by pg on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:55PM (#1062839)
The thread on _why.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by iamelgringo on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:16PM (#1062739)
Am I right in reading the graph, that when HN started, there were several thousand users?
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by pg on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:19PM (#1062747)
IIRC there were around 1500 uniques the first day.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by pg on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:45PM (#1062806)
Interesting is the start of the real growth roughly a year after the launch, coinciding with a broadening of the scope of HN.

This isn't true. What you're seeing there is the usual holiday dropoff, followed by the huge bump that happened when Arrington outed us. Actually HN's growth rate has been pretty consistent throughout. A graph of x^n generally looks as if it's nearly flat initially and then takes off at some point, but this is an illusion.

It also isn't true that the change in focus happened then. We changed the site from "Startup News" to "Hacker News" after 6 months.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by electromagnetic on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:31PM (#1063078)
There appears to be a major dip every Mid-December to January. There also appears to be a moderate, but much longer, dip starting in May and ending in July.

I'm guessing this speaks more of the average age of users. I expect users with children tend to get less online-time around the summer holidays and especially the Christmas break. I know personally, without children, that I had much less time to access HN around Christmas.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by pchristensen on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:18PM (#1063216)
Plus college kids
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:06PM (#1062714)
I would love to see a kernel density plot of comments by point value, hypothesis being that there are a lot more low-point submissions than there were before. I see a lot of un-thought-out off-the-cuff comments lately: knee-jerk anti-Chinese sentiments, top comments with obvious flaws in reasoning, speculation, or just plain immaturity.

I know people have been saying this for years, but this is the first time I'll say it: I've been avoiding reading news.YC because I don't feel like I learn anything from the comments anymore. I'd really welcome a return of PG's orange-names experiment, but with a gradient instead of a binary grouping (to avoid tribal sentiment).

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jacquesm on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:35PM (#1062782)
Average karma is a meaningless metric.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @06:27PM (#1063586)
Meaningless how? In some absolute sense? It's a metric that, like any public metric, will guide behavior. The question to ask is "how will it guide behavior?"

The most quick/intuitive explanation is probably the best explanation - I think it'll make people think twice "is this more insightful than my average comment?" before hitting Submit. As the community grows, this is exactly what we need: incentives for commenting less, and reading more.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jacquesm on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @07:00PM (#1063638)
Average karma is meaningless because there are many modes of use of HN that are very useful and that will inherently lead to a very low average karma.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:38AM (#1065092)
there are many modes of use of HN that are very useful and that will inherently lead to a very low average karma

Such as?

Also, I'm claiming that as a community grows, it's vital for people to post less often - preferably only on topics regarding which they have something truly insightful to share. Your counter-claim would need to be stronger: you need to show that the "modes of use" you speak of are vital to the community, that there is harm in disincentivising them.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jacquesm on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:01PM (#1065458)
- ask HN threads

- discussions about hacking or start-up related items outside of the mainstream

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Thursday January 21, 2010 @10:48AM (#1067492)
you need to show that the 'modes of use' you speak of are vital to the community, that there is harm in disincentivising them

Stating them does not constitute an argument.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by mortenjorck on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:46PM (#1062667)
Any community that gains a critical mass of users will change. The interrogatory form of the headline isn't really necessary.

HN will change as it grows, just as did Slashdot, or Reddit, or Digg. It doesn't have to be a bad thing. YC can try to shape this growth by introducing features and changing algorithms, and the userbase can try to shape it through submissions and voting.

As with many things, it's all a question of balance. You don't want to tip things too far in favor of preserving the old culture lest you scare off newcomers and stagnate (perhaps Slashdot at some periods in its history), nor do you want to tip the other way and lose your core users (Digg).

Only time will tell how HN navigates these waters.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by blasdel on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:24PM (#1063240)
> Possibly it would be better to extend the length of the 'new' page because in practice once something moves to page 2 it is lost. It is very rare that something makes it to page 2 without enough upvotes and after that still collects enough votes to make it to the homepage, no matter how topical or interesting.

I don't think that's true at all. I'm not sure if pg logs enough data to test this, but I am quite sure that a lot of the popular stuff that makes it to the front page got there via multiple-submission, not off the new page. It's fucked if the first submitter is more than a day before the second, but the usual course is for multiple people to see something their feedreaders around the same time. This doesn't require fresh content, fresh references to old content work too.

Because of this, news.yc generally ignores any links that aren't presently being talked about elsewhere -- it's not the locus of discovery. Metafilter is the only site like this that manages to really handle it well.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by SamAtt on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:22PM (#1062579)
Nice data. I'd like to see it updated for a few months. I suspect if you do that you'll see the numbers are even higher than this shows. I think a lot of people go in and out of activity as their off-line life becomes more or less complicated.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:28PM (#1062595)
Nice. Good questions in this specific instance, as well as a good example of what everyone running a web site should be doing.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by franticromantic on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @11:29AM (#1062446)
Nice data collection. Conclusions make sense.