News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by Alex3917 on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:00PM (#1062697)
My perception is that submission quality is roughly the same, but average comment quality has been dropping. Maybe the solution is to make comments work more like submissions, e.g. new top-level comments start out dead and need two upvotes before they go live. This is essentially how all new stories start out, and it seems to be working reasonably well.

Also, part of the issue with scaling is that there are some types of comments that are fine to post when the userbase is small, but that aren't ok to post as the userbase grows-- even if they add value in some way. So the problem isn't just coming from new users posting bad comments, it's coming from old users posting the same comments. So maybe some sort of radical experiment to try to refocus the discussions wouldn't be such a bad idea, at least to see how it goes.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by iamelgringo on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:26PM (#1062762)
I've noticed that my comments have been typically getting less points than they used to. What I've noticed is that when I don't get as much positive reinforcement (points) as I used to, I'm less inclined to take 30 minutes and writing and editing a thoughtful comment. It's a downward cycle.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by akkartik on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:52PM (#1062974)
Same here. The problem is not more upvotes, but upvotes spread out over a larger set of comments.

Perhaps we need a study of comments in the different percentiles now vs a year ago vs 2 years ago. Filter out comments that don't tell you something new. How does the remainder look?

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by robryan on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:49PM (#1063121)
This may be because there are more comments on each submission so your comment may be glanced over instead of being read properly like it would be if there were only a few comments on something.

The comment system is usually very good but for things like the Google/China post it is very hard to come back a few hours later and see what's new because of how things are ordered, I'm sure there would have been a lot of valid points in that thread which didn't get upvotes.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by Perceval on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:12PM (#1063192)
One of the great features of Scoop code (which runs kuro5hin and DailyKos among others) is that it can show you what comments are new since the last time you viewed a store, marking them with a red-colored '[new].' Makes coming back to an active thread much easier.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by robryan on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @07:22PM (#1063681)
I'd say that would be one feature useful here, I don't think it would over complicate the simplicity of things. Maybe it could be factored into the display order so things that are new since you last looked at a submission move to the top.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by JacobAldridge on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:22PM (#1063427)
Maybe the solution is to make comments work more like submissions, e.g. new top-level comments start out dead and need two upvotes before they go live.

Is that also related to the way comments are now weighted against time, as well as value? Every new comment is momentarily - or longer - placed at the top of the comments page, so something trite will live above a 32 point well-reasoned post for a period of time, depending on how old the 32 pointer happens to be.

When the new comments went straight to the pile of 1 point comments at the bottom, there was less incentive to contribute late in a discussion as your input could be overlooked; in fixing that problem, there's now an increased noise-to-signal ratio as low-value comments filter their way down, rather than build their way up.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:14PM (#1062733)
So the problem [is] old users posting the same comments.

Interesting hypothesis.

experiment to try to refocus the discussions

Expound?