News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:06PM (#1062714)
I would love to see a kernel density plot of comments by point value, hypothesis being that there are a lot more low-point submissions than there were before. I see a lot of un-thought-out off-the-cuff comments lately: knee-jerk anti-Chinese sentiments, top comments with obvious flaws in reasoning, speculation, or just plain immaturity.

I know people have been saying this for years, but this is the first time I'll say it: I've been avoiding reading news.YC because I don't feel like I learn anything from the comments anymore. I'd really welcome a return of PG's orange-names experiment, but with a gradient instead of a binary grouping (to avoid tribal sentiment).

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jacquesm on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:35PM (#1062782)
Average karma is a meaningless metric.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @06:27PM (#1063586)
Meaningless how? In some absolute sense? It's a metric that, like any public metric, will guide behavior. The question to ask is "how will it guide behavior?"

The most quick/intuitive explanation is probably the best explanation - I think it'll make people think twice "is this more insightful than my average comment?" before hitting Submit. As the community grows, this is exactly what we need: incentives for commenting less, and reading more.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jacquesm on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @07:00PM (#1063638)
Average karma is meaningless because there are many modes of use of HN that are very useful and that will inherently lead to a very low average karma.
Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:38AM (#1065092)
there are many modes of use of HN that are very useful and that will inherently lead to a very low average karma

Such as?

Also, I'm claiming that as a community grows, it's vital for people to post less often - preferably only on topics regarding which they have something truly insightful to share. Your counter-claim would need to be stronger: you need to show that the "modes of use" you speak of are vital to the community, that there is harm in disincentivising them.

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by jacquesm on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @02:01PM (#1065458)
- ask HN threads

- discussions about hacking or start-up related items outside of the mainstream

Re:Is HN Changing? - Growth by andreyf on Thursday January 21, 2010 @10:48AM (#1067492)
you need to show that the 'modes of use' you speak of are vital to the community, that there is harm in disincentivising them

Stating them does not constitute an argument.