News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by JaggedJax on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:10PM (#10623932)
I was very surprised to learn there's no check for Chip and Pin requirements beyond what the magstripe requests. I naively assumed if the card had that feature the terminal could force it to be used. What would happen with the other fields he mentions, like whether or not you can withdraw cash with the card?
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by halviti on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:33PM (#10625043)
The problem of tricking the reader will be solved in the US the same way the rest of the world solved the problem. You stop using magnetic stripes.

For the longest time, chip-and-pin readers in most european countries would let you just swipe the magnetic card if you didn't have a chip.. this allowed americans (and whoever else still uses this technology) to be able to shop when they travel.

Unfortunately a disproportionate amount of theft occurs by bypassing the chip-and-pin system. Many european countries and banks finally had enough and said "no more loopholes, chip-and-pin only" and set a date.

Lo and behold this spurred the US banks to finally start releasing chip-and-pin enabled cards, otherwise their clients would find themselves unable to buy things overseas.

The deadlines have come and went in my country, and today it is literally impossible to buy anything with just a magnetic stripe.

I imagine the US will solve the problem the same way.. by no longer allowing magnetic stripes to be used.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by rconti on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @02:59AM (#10625991)
I can't claim to spend a ton of time in a huge variety of countries, but in the past year I've been to Iceland, England, Wales, Scotland, Italy, France, and New Zealand, and I can't remember anywhere I had to use the EMV chip in my credit cards except places like parking garages that didn't have the physical facility for a mag stripe swipe. Every retailer terminal could read a magstripe.

More annoyingly, whether I swiped or dipped, a signature was required. Except, again, where there was no way to sign (parking garages). Then, magically, my PIN was "good enough".

I went out of my way to get EMV cards last year due to upcoming trips, because I had only been overseas sporadically over the past decade and assumed that the magstripe was gone. It was not. If anything, merchants seemed more able to deal with them than 10 years ago, where I occasionally had a clerk who couldn't figure out whether to swipe extremely slowly, or quickly enough to set fire to the equipment.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by pjc50 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:41AM (#10626306)
You're a US resident with a US card?

As a UK resident with a UK card it's been a long time since I swiped or signed. I think you must have the "require signature always" bit set on your cards because someone in the issuing chain doesn't trust EMV.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by dylz on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:58AM (#10626358)
IIRC, US uses chip and signature 99% of the time, not chip and pin.

I don't think I have a single card that supports pin.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by rconti on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @06:36PM (#10700665)
Correct. I HAVE a PIN for purchasing, but the card is set to prefer signature so I end up having to sign unless I'm purchasing somewhere without signature capability (eg, an automated kiosk). And yeah, US resident, US card.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by Slump on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:32AM (#10627317)
You're correct. From my understanding, most issuers have determined that Chip and Signature is secure enough for the US market provided they support DDA. Both of my EMV cards do not even provide a way to create a PIN for them. It will most like be this way for a year or two.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by halviti on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:21AM (#10626444)
I live in Iceland, and it is not possible for me to buy anything with a magnetic stripe.

Here is the campaign that was ran by the largest payment processor letting everyone know the old system was going away. It was heavily advertised all over the country.

http://www.valitor.is/fyrirtaekjalausnir/pinnid-a-minnid/

Perhaps there is somehow an exception for foreign cards? But this is news to me, and seems like it defeats the entire purpose.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by pjc50 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:11AM (#10626781)
There usually is an exception for foreign cards because otherwise visiting American tourists can't buy anything. Your local card may not even have a magstripe any more, but until the US upgrades most places will keep their magstripe readers.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by Symbiote on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:34AM (#10626661)
Perhaps your card marks the use of EMV as optional.

A European-issued card would deny use of the magstripe on an EMV reader. This could possibly by overridden by the cashier, but most won't have the authority to do this. (The merchant takes responsibility for fraud in this case.)

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by celticninja on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:31AM (#10626844)
not sure where in the UK you were spending/shopping but I live in the UK and all card readers require chip and pin and there is no signature required. Whilst the readers have a swipe facility if your card has a chip you are required to use it. Perhaps because you were using an international card it allowed you to use the swipe facility although I have no idea why you would choose that as it is significantly slower.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by rconti on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @06:37PM (#10700672)
It's the signature that's the slow part. The swipe takes, what, 1/4 second vs perhaps 2 seconds for the dip?
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by chrisfosterelli on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:04PM (#10624225)
The terminal has no method to determine if the card is Chip and Pin enabled aside from the magstripe.

Sure it could check for the actual chip, but credit card fraudsters aren't creating fake cards that include the chip so that wouldn't help either.

I would argue the way they should implement it is such that the bank itself rejects the transaction if it knows the card is chip enabled and the terminal is as well.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by Strilanc on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:20PM (#10624563)
I always assumed that chip/pin being used was at least checked by the credit card company. The machine should be telling them if it supports chip/pin, and the cc company independently knows all the information about your card, so... urrrrgh.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by seanp2k2 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:30PM (#10624838)
What's also interesting about our chip readers here in the US is that they only do chip + signature for credit cards, so they're not adding anything if someone physically has your card (I've had the ones they auto-reissue, which Chase claims they cannot stop in their system, stolen from my mailbox).
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by dfox on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @12:34AM (#10625517)
The card company checks whether the card and terminal are EMV capable. But, the whole card system is not built on absolute security but on risk-management and fraud detection, that is somehow balanced with customer convenience. In effects this means that only thing that is absolutely needed for transaction to be authorized is card number, what other data have to be provided and what checks have to pass is function of trustworthiness of various parties involved (mainly of the merchant).

(for example, the EMV standard explicitly handles various failure modes like "PIN-pad is broken", "card holder does not remember PIN" and so on, and allows configurations that accept such transactions)

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by JaggedJax on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:10PM (#10624250)
Agreed. I think for it to truly work it would require support from the terminal in the form of letting the processor know if the terminal does or doesn't support chip & pin.

If the terminal doesn't support it the processor always lets it through. If the terminal does support it the processor only lets it through if using chip and pin. Then again, maybe there won't be non chip and pin terminal much longer so that won't matter.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by leni536 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @02:56AM (#10625976)
It's easy. Make card number ranges that must have chip and pin.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by nailer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:36PM (#10624372)
> Sure it could check for the actual chip, but credit card fraudsters aren't creating fake cards that include the chip so that wouldn't help either.

Should that read 'credit card fraudsters are creating fake cards that include the chip' ?

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by alanfalcon on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:51PM (#10624450)
No, what he wrote makes sense as written in this context.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by q3k on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:26PM (#10624009)
IIRC from some resarch I did, a decent card provider will reject a magstripe transaction from a terminal with EMV capability if a card is known to also be EMV capable... At least, it could in theory.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by stanmancan on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:46PM (#10624120)
I live in Canada and that's what happens with all of my visa/debit chip cards. If you attempt to swipe your card and it, as well as the terminal, are chip enabled then it gives you an error and asks you to insert your card into the terminal.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by JaggedJax on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:49PM (#10624134)
That is triggered by the magstripe though. The point here is you can trick the reader by turning off that feature on the magstripe and the reader doesn't do any additional check on whether EMV should be required.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by noddingham on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:25PM (#10624317)
Based upon my knowledge of EMV liability, the merchant would still be clear from fraudulent charges if they had an EMV reader. If the device tells the reader it can't do chip & pin, then the buyer is the least secure part of the transaction.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by TeMPOraL on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:41PM (#10625204)
Not in all cases, I believe. For instance, to use my debit card in China, where a lot of payments is still done via magstripe, I have to call my bank and ask them to enable magstripe transactions for me in their system. Otherwise, the bank will keep rejecting transaction attempts.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by the_mitsuhiko on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:58AM (#10626557)
> IIRC from some resarch I did, a decent card provider will reject a magstripe transaction from a terminal with EMV capability if a card is known to also be EMV capable... At least, it could in theory.

That's how it works for all countries other than the US. In the US EMV capable terminals are not common so transactions in the US are typically permitted no matter if magstripe or EMV. This is why starting with October this year the US are finally making the switch to EMV and once that roll-out is complete, magstripe transactions could (theoretically) be either disabled or severely limited. For instance you might have to confirm a magstripe transaction with a text message.

Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by JaggedJax on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:52PM (#10624155)
They could definitely do this, but I don't think any of them do (or will for quite a while). It's perfectly acceptable for a business to continue sending magstripe transactions if they want. The business just takes the responsibility for chargebacks. This would just look like a transaction where either the reader didn't have the functionality or the merchant decided not to use it.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by sliverstorm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:41PM (#10624392)
The business has an interest in using chip & PIN. I forget the details of the contracts they have with the banks, but the chip adds extra protection to the credit card company, and the PIN adds extra protection to the business. Which is why people are annoyed that the credit card companies want to stop at chip & signature.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by sliverstorm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:39PM (#10624379)
Pretty sure this has already happened to me in the USA. Though, I was scattered at the time and don't remember for certain.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by Slump on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:27AM (#10627294)
This would only be an issue for those that don't authorize with the issuer immediately when the card is read. The issuer would know the service code read by the pin pad and should be able to determine that it is incorrect based on the PAN read by the pin pad and the fact that the merchant is certified to support EMV. They could choose to decline the authorization at that point. Most payment processors that I'm aware of in the US do this.
Re:MagSpoof – wireless credit card/magstripe spoofer by JimmaDaRustla on Thursday November 26, 2015 @11:53AM (#10633710)
There is a sentinel character on the mag stripe which identifies the card as chip and pin. As mentioned in the README of this repo, it can be disabled - for the purposes of backwards compatibility, this is a necessary evil.

Fortunately, it is easy to detect! The terminal will send the magstripe data online when authorizing the transaction, and the backend systems will identify the corruption in magstripe data and identify it as fraud.