I have had snafus often enough that I no longer check bags, in any capacity. If I can't carry it myself, I mail it in advance.
Getting someone on the phone was impossible. Going to the local post office was not easy either (snow season) and when I finally did, it didn't seem like the package ever made it there. Apparently, if the USPS manages to get a package mishandled, they will send it all to a sorting facility near Atlanta, Georgia. I'd have to fill a form to start an investigation. Of course, the form is not available on the USPS website.
Thankfully, it wasn't something ridiculously valuable. However, if I ever have something of value it will stay with me. No, I will not check that carry on either.
I would always be worried that it gets delayed and I get there and its not there. Or that the hotel staff lose/steal it.
Permanently.
On the way to our honeymoon.
Ended up getting reimbursed a significant amount for the resulting loss.
The only bags we've checked, since, have been souvenirs, and that includes month-long trips overseas.
When it comes down to it, just like with airlines you have to pay for that guarantee
My checked baggage, on the other hand, is a strictly best-effort affair. If it doesn't fit on my plane, it becomes a "gets there when it gets there" problem. Once it's bumped once, the airline sees little reward in getting it to me faster or slower. There's good odds I will never see it again.
Comparing a $25 checked bag fee to a contracted cargo shipment is quite unfair.
--
edit: Here's another fun item. Technically, the conditions of carriage on your ticket don't require them to bump cargo for your baggage. And there's no incentive for them to do so.
http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-07-09/a-lawsuit-co...
“It costs United nothing to remove checked baggage, rather than cargo, in order to arrive at an acceptable aircraft weight because the checked baggage fee is purportedly nonrefundable, and United can simply transport the checked baggage on a later flight to the passenger’s destination.”